You are on page 1of 5

Guidance Note

Protective treatment of fasteners No. 8.02


Scope
This note covers the various metal coatings Extreme caution is therefore necessary when
that are applied to bolts used in bridgework, dealing with any bolted connections made
and the practical aspects to be considered. before 1995, as cadmium may be present
even if the original specification suggests
Why apply metal coatings to bolts? otherwise.
With the exception of structures of weather
resistant steel (WRS), the long-term corro- Zinc coatings used in bolt manufacture
sion protection to bolt groups in bridge There are three methods of applying zinc
structures is given by the full coating sys- coatings to fasteners:
tem. (For WRS steel structures the bolts,  Electroplating
nuts and washers should be of WRS material
and are not given any protective treatment,  Sherardizing
unless the steelwork is painted for some  Hot dip galvanizing
reason.)
BS EN 14399 does not specify a standard
for electroplating or sherardizing and leaves
Threaded components are very difficult to
the coatings to be negotiated with the manu-
blast clean effectively, and even more diffi-
facturer.
cult to metal spray effectively. The normal
and recommended approach is therefore to
(1) Electroplated zinc coatings
procure bolts that are protected by metal
The coating of zinc is applied by the elec-
coatings during manufacture in order to
trolysis of an aqueous solution of a zinc salt.
avoid blasting and metal spraying of bolted
The minimum local thickness typically used
joints in the assembled steelwork.
in bridge construction is 8 μm.
The metal coating provides primary protec-
As a precautionary measure, the Specifica-
tion during construction until the rest of the
tion for Highway Works (SHW) (Ref 1) re-
coating system is applied. (For a major
quires that any electroplated bolts are heat
structure, this may involve a long period of
treated to drive out any possible entrapped
exposure for the metal coating.) Thereafter,
hydrogen, because of the danger of hydro-
the metal coating provides additional protec-
gen embrittlement‡ during the plating proc-
tion, depending on its thickness, in the event
ess. Current practice is to follow BS 7371-3
that the paint system suffers local break-
(Ref 2), which states that bolts of property
down in the long term; it also offers continu-
class 8.8 do not need to be de-embrittled,
ing protection to the concealed surfaces of
but property classes where the tensile
the bolts.
strength exceeds 1040 N/mm2 must be de-
embrittled (this may require a formal Depar-
Beware of cadmium coatings
ture from Standard). Bolts of grades higher
Cadmium plating was frequently specified
than 8.8 are not normally electroplated.
and used up to the early 1990s. It is now
prohibited for health and safety reasons.
Chromate passivation is essential for all zinc
Cadmium is highly toxic if vaporised; this
electroplated components. It is a process by
could happen if a cutting flame or welding
which the surface of the zinc coating is
arc came into contact with a cadmium-
coated surface.

Hydrogen embrittlement results from the absorp-
On earlier structures, even when zinc elec- tion of monatomic hydrogen during the plating
troplated coatings were specified, it was process. After installation, and under load,
common for fabricators to seek and be hydrogen atoms can migrate to dislocations in the
granted a concession to use zinc-plated bolts crystal structure of the metal where they can
gather to form gaseous hydrogen, which gener-
with cadmium plated nuts, it being well
ates very high levels of internal stress. This can
known that such a combination gave lower lead to a catastrophic failure of the fastener.
thread friction and reduced tightening prob- Such breakages can occur hours or even weeks
lems. after tightening.
SCI P185 Guidance notes on best practice in steel bridge construction 8.02/1
GN802R2.doc Revision 2
Guidance Note

No. 8.02

converted to extend its life. There are four (2) Sherardized coatings
levels of passivation. If no passivation is Sherardizing is a diffusion process in which
applied, zinc salts of a powdery appearance the components are heated in close contact
will form on the surface very quickly. This is with zinc dust. The process is normally
known as white rusting. The use of chro- carried out in a slowly rotating and closed
mate is frowned upon for environmental and container at a temperature in the region of
safety reasons. 385oC.

The SHW, Series 1900, states that chromate The resulting coating has a matt grey ap-
passivation shall not be applied to electro- pearance. Orange staining may become
plated bolts which are to be painted. The apparent on sherardized coatings early in
reason behind this is that many commonly their exposure, but this is not detrimental to
used paint systems will not adhere to zinc- their performance.
coated surfaces without some form of etch-
ing to that surface. The higher levels of Sherardizing tends to be used mostly to
chromate passivation can resist such an protect higher tensile steels (greater than
etching process. Current practice is to apply 1000 N/mm2), to avoid the risk of hydrogen
a basic passivation (designation A, Table 3 embrittlement (which can occur with electro-
of BS 7371-3) to ensure that the bolt arrives plating). It is also the normal treatment for
on site in a reasonable condition. Class A is direct tension indicators‡. Note that sherard-
the lowest level of passivation, which will izing is only suitable for protecting higher
not resist a subsequent etching process and tensile steels if the method of cleaning the
which should therefore be deemed to be bolts prior to sherardizing is mechanical. (For
compliant with the SHW. grades 10.9 and above, if the method of
cleaning is acid pickling, there is a risk of
The thickness of the coating is such that no hydrogen embrittlement.)
special measures are required with respect to
thread clearance. Sherardized assemblies for preloading must
be passivated to remove loose dust from the
The SHW calls for all zinc plating of bolts up threads of bolt the bolt and nut; dust could
to 36 mm diameter to be carried out in cause problems when tightening to achieve
accordance with BS 3382 (Ref 3). The the preload.
maximum bolt size covered by that standard
is ¾ inch and therefore the maximum stan- The thickness of the coating requires the nut
dard metric bolt size covered is M16. The to be over tapped to create sufficient thread
majority of bolts used in bridgework are of clearance. (See Section 7 of BS 7371-8 for
larger diameter. Despite the wording of the details.)
SHW, the common approach for bolts over
20 mm diameter is to supply to For bridgework, Class S1 coatings to
BS 1706:1960 (Ref 4). Note that the 1990 BS 7371-8 (Ref 6) are normally specified.
revision to BS 1706 cannot be used as it This gives a coating of minimum thickness
was converted from a specification to a 30 μm.
method of specifying.
(3) Hot dip galvanized coatings
Specifying zinc electroplated bolts to Bolts and nuts are dipped in molten zinc and
BS 7371-3, grade Zn8A, or to BS EN then centrifuged to remove excess zinc.
ISO 4042 (Ref 5), grade Fe/Zn 8c1A, would Such products are commonly referred to as
avoid the use of obsolescent codes. spun galvanized.
BS 7371-3 was published in 1993 and BS
EN ISO 4042 in 2000; both cover bolt Hot dip galvanizing provides the highest level
diameters up to 64 mm, which comfortably of corrosion protection as it gives a consid-
covers the range of sizes normally used in
bridge construction. ‡
DTIs can also be ‘mechanically galvanized’, with
a coating thickness of 55 m.
8.02/2 © 2009 The Steel Construction Institute
GN802R2.doc Printed 17/03/10
Guidance Note

No. 8.02

erably thicker coating than either sherardizing fied for assemblies to other national stan-
or electroplating dards. The main difference between
BS EN ISO 10684 and BS 7371-6 is the
The galvanizing process does not cause degree of over-tapping to accommodate the
hydrogen embrittlement, but embrittlement zinc coating; whichever standard is used, the
can be caused by acid pickling, which is corresponding requirements for over-tapping
used to clean the bolts prior to galvanizing. should be observed. The minimum local
There is no problem for bolts up to and thickness specified by these standards is
including grade 8.8, but for higher grade 40 μm and 43 μm respectively.
bolts only mechanical cleaning can be used.
Tightening zinc-coated preload bolts
High temperature galvanizing is now avail- The tightening of zinc coated preloaded
able from some manufacturers. The normal fasteners (nuts and bolts to BS EN 14399)
galvanizing bath has a temperature of ap- requires special care. Zinc coated surfaces
proximately 450C. However, it has been tend to bind under high interface pressure;
found that if the temperature is raised to this phenomenon is known as galling. Lubri-
approximately 550C, a more even coating cation is essential to avoid a high proportion
of zinc is achieved. By careful choice of of bolt breakages in the latter stages of
suitable material and processing, manufac- tightening.
turers can ensure that the high temperature
galvanizing process does not have any sig- In the UK, all bolts manufactured to
nificant retempering effect on the bolt. This BS EN 14399 are supplied in a lubricated
process is covered by BS EN ISO 10684 condition K0. Furthermore, HRC assemblies
(Ref 7). to BS EN 14399-10 (TC bolts) must not have
their lubrication modified in any way. Simi-
Currently, grades up to and including 10.9 can larly, any assemblies supplied for use in
be obtained in a high temperature galvanized either of the K-class conditions K1 or K2
finish, and in sizes up to 24 mm diameter. must not have their lubrication modified.

The major fastener manufacturers have made The most effective and economic lubricant is
considerable investments in developing tallow which for the best results should be
improved methods of galvanizing. However, sparingly applied to the leading threads
extreme caution should always be exercised within the nut and the face of the nut that
if galvanized bolts are procured through contacts the washer.
stockists, especially if the galvanizing is
being arranged by the stockist; the process Over-application of tallow, for example dip-
used must be identified reliably. ping complete assemblies in molten tallow,
gives no advantage and can create additional
Passivation is not necessary on a galvanized problems in cleaning prior to painting.
finish.
Some specialist bolt suppliers whose prod-
Bolts are galvanized after threading. Nuts are ucts require consistent torque / tension
over-tapped to create thread clearance. This relationships during tightening apply wax-
is achieved by galvanizing the nuts as blanks based lubricants to plated nuts under factory
and then tapping them over size after galva- conditions. These are often water-soluble
nizing. Although this approach results in an and can be readily washed off after installa-
uncoated female thread, this will be pro- tion. Some manufacturers add a dye to the
tected by the coating on the male thread wax coating to distinguish such bolts from
when the fastener is assembled. untreated items.

Hot dip galvanizing to BS EN ISO 10684 is Oils and greases should not be used for the
specified for assemblies to BS EN 14399 lubrication of preloaded assemblies, as there
(Ref 8); BS 7371-6 (Ref 9) is currently speci- is a high risk of contaminating faying sur-
faces and significantly reducing slip factors.
SCI P185 Guidance notes on best practice in steel bridge construction 8.02/3
GN802R2.doc Revision 2
Guidance Note

No. 8.02

Painting zinc-coated fasteners should be undertaken before using one of


Most paint primers will not satisfactorily these materials.
adhere directly to zinc-coated surfaces.
Bolts are generally supplied with a lubricant
Two approaches are commonly used to on the threads of the nut. The use of T-
provide a key for paint systems. The first is wash prior to assembly will remove/destroy
to fix the bolts in the structure, as supplied, the lubricant. Therefore, tightening methods
and then utilise a paint system for the bolted that rely on torque should not be used, as
joints that includes, as a first coat, an etch the friction in the threads will be different
primer. The second is to T-wash the bolts from that assumed by the manufacturer and
before fixing. the suitability test for preloading
(BS EN 14399-2).
T-wash is a solution containing phosphoric
acid and copper carbonate. The phosphoric The part-turn method of tightening (which is
acid etches the surface of the zinc and the added as an acceptable method of tightening
copper carbonate produces a blue/black in the MPS, Ref 10) is a predominantly
surface colouration showing that the surface strain-control method that takes the bolt
reaction is complete. This discolouration is beyond its yield point. Consequently the final
not absolutely uniform and it is not neces- preload developed is not sensitive to a
sary to try to achieve absolute change in lubricant such as that caused by T-
blue/blackness, as long as it is clear that the washing or by the application of tallow.
solution has been applied over the whole Similarly the use of direct tension indicators
area. Further application will only remove (in accordance with BS EN 14399-9) does
more zinc than is necessary. not rely on controlled lubrication.

T-wash should not be applied after installa- Treatment of plated bolts after installation
tion as contamination of adjacent surfaces is Normally the specification of the protective
inevitable and the acid content may damage system for slip-resistant bolted joints requires
them. surface preparation of the joint contact sur-
faces (faying surfaces) by abrasive blast
The data sheets from most paint manufac- cleaning. This should not be taken to include
turers state that T-wash should be brushed the bolts, nuts and washers, as they are not
on, but this is impractical for fasteners; the ‘joint material’. It is less satisfactory to blast
normal approach is to batch dip. However, off the fasteners’ coating and then reapply
care should be taken to remove the items coatings than simply to degrease the fasten-
from the solution as soon as they discolour. ers and apply the remainder of the coating
If the items are left in the solution for too system. However, if the fasteners have only
long, the zinc will be stripped. It is also very thin plating and there has been lengthy expo-
important to rinse clean and dry the bolts sure that results in corrosion, then blast
thoroughly. cleaning of the fasteners may be required.

Some primers, other than etching materials, Recommendations


are now available that will give satisfactory The following table gives an indication of the
adhesion directly on zinc plated surfaces. costs of the various types of zinc coating
These provide an attractive alternative to relative to that of the untreated fastener:
T-wash, the use of which now creates many
problems under environmental and health and Coating Cost
safety legislation. However, it is strongly Zinc electroplated 20%
advised that adhesion tests are carried out to
Spun galvanized 30%
verify the performance of such primers prior
Sherardized 35%
to their use.
Note: The total cost of bolts is usually less than
1% of the cost of the structural steelwork.
Alternative pre-treatments to replace T-Wash
are also becoming available. Proper testing
8.02/4 © 2009 The Steel Construction Institute
GN802R2.doc Printed 17/03/10
Guidance Note

No. 8.02

Of the three processes, the most effective in 4. BS 1706:1960, Specification for electro-
terms of corrosion protection is spun galva- plated coatings of cadmium and zinc on
nized. iron and steel (Withdrawn)
5. BS EN ISO 4042:2000, Fasteners. Elec-
It is recommended that spun galvanized bolts troplated coatings
be specified (in accordance with BS EN ISO 6. BS 7371-8:1998 Coatings on metal
10684 or BS 7371-6) wherever possible. fasteners. Specification for sherardized
coatings.
References 7. BS EN ISO 10684:2004. Fasteners. Hot
1. Manual of Contract Documents for High- dip galvanized coatings
way Works, Volume 1: Specification for 8. BS EN 14399, High-strength structural
Highway Works, Series 1900, Protection bolting assemblies for preloading (in 10
of steelwork against corrosion, 2005. Parts)
2. BS 7371-3:1993, Coatings on metal 9. BS 7371-6: 1998, Coatings on metal
fasteners. Specification for electroplated fasteners. Specification for hot dipped
zinc and cadmium coatings. (Replaced by galvanized coatings.
BS EN ISO 4042:2000 but remains cur- 10. Steel Bridge Group: Model Project Speci-
rent.) fication for the execution of steelwork in
3. BS 3382: Parts 1 and 2:1961 Specifica- bridges (P382), SCI, 2009.
tion for electroplated coatings on
threaded components. Cadmium on steel
components. Zinc on steel components.
(Withdrawn)

SCI P185 Guidance notes on best practice in steel bridge construction 8.02/5
GN802R2.doc Revision 2

You might also like