Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Brad Gradwell
Managing Director/Executive Engineer
Brad.Gradwell@HudsonMckay.com.au
0419515223
Copyright & Disclaimers ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
This paper contains content from IEEE P1585/D6 July 2018. IEEE draft and approved standards are copyrighted by IEEE under U.S. and international copyright laws.
A copy of IEEE P1585/D6 July 2018 is available at: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8403238/
IEEE does not warrant or represent the accuracy or content of the material contained in its standards, and expressly disclaims all warranties (express, implied and statutory) not
included in this or any other document relating to the standard, including, but not limited to, the warranties of:
• merchantability;
• fitness for a particular purpose;
• non-infringement; and
• quality, accuracy, effectiveness, currency, or completeness of material.
In addition, IEEE disclaims any and all conditions relating to: results; and workmanlike effort. IEEE standards documents are supplied “AS IS” and “WITH ALL FAULTS. Use of an IEEE
standard is wholly voluntary. The existence of an IEEE standard does not imply that there are no other ways to produce, test, measure, purchase, market, or provide other goods and
services related to the scope of the IEEE standard. Furthermore, the viewpoint expressed at the time a standard is approved and issued is subject to change brought about through
developments in the state of the art and comments received from users of the standard.
Hudson McKay has used its best endeavours to procure, analyse and provide information in this document which is accurate and reliable based on information available to Hudson
McKay or third parties at the time of document creation. Notwithstanding these best endeavours Hudson McKay is not liable for any inaccuracy or incompleteness of the information
obtained, or provided any third party. Any use of this document must consider that it may include qualified assumptions and provides a ‘point in time’ based assessment and may
require to be updated. That is, these assumptions and/or the information relied upon to produce this document may become outdated as new information or more accurate data
becomes available.
All background material, copyright, confidential information, patents, design rights and all other intellectual property rights of whatsoever nature contained herein are and shall
remain the sole and exclusive property of Hudson McKay Group Pty Ltd and its related entities. All third party intellectual property rights shall remain vested in their respective
owners. The Hudson McKay Group names and Hudson McKay Group logos are trademarks or registered trademarks of Hudson McKay Group Pty Ltd. All other trademarks are the
property of their respective owners.
Historical Context ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Stokes & Sweeting – IEEE1584-2002 Criticism ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
• Electrode Orientation;
• Personal exposed to ejected arc are exposed to the plasma jet rather than radiated heat calculated by the
IEEE1584 -2002.
• Electrode orientations found within electrical switchgear produce 260-330% more incident energy due to
“ejected arc”/”contained arc” mechanism.
• In the case of the horizontal case the arcing current is significantly lower than the bolted fault current.
• Arc Voltage Influence;
• The voltage across an arc is approximately 10V\cm. The arc voltage is less than the nominal operating
voltage, Voc. Therefore in low voltage systems arcing currents can be 30-70% lower than the maximum
bolted fault current, Is/c
• Arc Conditions
• At low voltages less than 480V, during the initiation phase of the fault, it is possible that all three phases
of arc current may remain near zero for several cycles until the insulation fails again, restrike, which could
cause a reset on electronic protection modules.
IEEE 1584:2018 – The Journey to a New
Guide ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IEEE 1584:2018 – Empirical Model Range ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IEEE 1584:2018 – Empirical Model Integrity ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
600V < Model 600V > Model < 15kV Human Hazard Model
IEEE 1584:2018 - The Process Summary ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Step 2 - Calculate Interpolation Arcing Current Step 11 - Calculate Iarc_min Correction Factor
Step 3 - Determine the Final Arcing Current Step 12 - Adjust the Intermediate Arcing Currents
Step 4 - Determine Arc Duration Step 13 - Calculate Interpolation Arcing Currents
Step 5 - Calculate Enclosure Size Correction Factor Step 14 - Determine the Final Arcing Currents
Step 6 - Calculate the Intermediate Incident Step 15 - Determine Arc Duration
Energy Step 16 - Calculate the Intermediate Incident Energy
Step 7 - Calculate Interpolation Incident Energy Step 17 - Calculate Interpolation Incident Energy
Step 8 - Calculate the Intermediate Arc Flash Step 18 - Calculate the Intermediate Arc Flash
Boundary Boundary
Step 9 - Calculate Interpolation Arc Flash Step 19 - Calculate Interpolation Arc Flash Boundary
Boundary Step 20 - Calculate the Final IE & AFB
Step 10 - Calculate the Final Incident Energy & Arc
Flash Boundary
IEEE 1584:2018 – Electrode Case - VCB ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
+85%
+55%
+32%
+34%
+36%
-10%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V AFH Iarc ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc_ave
Iarc(2002)
Iarc_min Iarc(2002)x85%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc_ave (VCBB)
Iarc_ave (HCB)
Iarc_ave (VCB)
Iarc(2002)
IE = 8 cal\cm2
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ENA NENS09
IE IEEE-2002
IE IEEE-2018
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V AFH ↨ Cell Size ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ↓@500mm IE ↑@203.2mm
IEEE 1584:2018 – 1000V AFH Iarc & IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
-9%
+105%
-12% +31%
-13%
-3%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 1000V AFH IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ENA NENS09
IE IEEE-2002
IE IEEE-2018
IEEE 1584:2018 – 1000V AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc(2002)
Iarc_ave (VCBB)
Iarc_ave (HCB)
-7% +93%
+27%
-11%
-9%
-11%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 3.3kV AFH IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ENA NENS09
IE IEEE-2002
IE IEEE-2018
IEEE 1584:2018 – 3.3kV AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc(2002)
Iarc_ave (VCBB)
Iarc_ave (HCB)
Iarc_ave (VCB)
IE = 8 cal\cm2
IEEE 1584:2018 – 11kV AFH Iarc & IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
-3% +94%
+44%
-6%
-8%
-10%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 11kV AFH IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ENA NENS09
IE IEEE-2002
IE IEEE-2018
IEEE 1584:2018 – 11kV AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc(2002)
Iarc_ave (VCBB)
Iarc_ave (VCB)
Iarc_ave (HCB)
IE = 8 cal\cm2
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V_AIR Iarc & IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
+42% +105%
+16%
0%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V_Air AFH IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ENA NENS09
IE IEEE-2002
IE IEEE-2018
IEEE 1584:2018 – 415V AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc_ave (VOA)
Iarc_ave (HOA)
Iarc(2002)
IE = 8 cal\cm2
IEEE 1584:2018 – 11kV_AIR Iarc & IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
+415%
-10%
+81%
-13%
IEEE 1584:2018 – 11kV_Air AFH IE ↨ Ibf ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
IE ENA NENS09
IE IEEE-2002
IE IEEE-2018
IEEE 1584:2018 – 11kV AFH IE ↨ Time ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Iarc(2002)
Iarc_ave (HOA)
ELECTRODE Iarc IE
VCB ≈IEEE1584:2002 ≈IEEE1584:2002
VCBB IEEE1584:2002 20-50% x IEEE:2002
HCB 85% x IEEE:2002 100% x IEEE:2002
VOA ≈IEEE1584:2002 ≈IEEE1584:2002
HOA IEEE:2002 100-400% x IEEE:2002
IEEE 1584:2018 – AF Risk Management
Impact ESTABLISH | ENGINEER | EXECUTE
Thank you