You are on page 1of 6

1

IoT Architecture and Routing for MV and LV


Smart Grid
S. A. Alharthi and P. Johnson, Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool, UK and M. A. Alharthi,
Saudi Electricity Company, Makkah, Saudi Arabia

 The traditional electric power system design is not efficient


Abstract— Wireless sensor networks (WSNs) are cost for current market needs or addressing up-to-date issues due to
effective for numerous applications including smart cities, the state-of-the art technology used at that time. Recent years
environmental monitoring, industry process control, etc. have witnessed a rapid growth in smart wireless devices which
Hence, WSNs form the major hardware infrastructure for can communicate with each other or to access the Internet.
the Internet of Things (IoT). Nowadays, homes and cities Internet of things (IoT) is a network of these connected smart
become smarter by installing sensors and actuators to devices to the Internet. Thus, the IoT can be integrated to
manage energy consumption through WSNs and IoT monitor and control the electric power system which allows
integration. According to the demand, loads are shut off or immediate response to power outage and efficient resource
can be shifted to off-peak times. The 2030 and 2050 visions management. Hence, the electric power system across the
of Electrical power system are not only to deliver energy world would greatly benefit from adopting the transition from
from suppliers to consumers but also to integrate the traditional design towards the Smart Grid (SG).
information and communication technology (ICT) into the An example of this transition is the advanced metering
electrical power system to reduce the cost, optimize the infrastructure (AMI) where the two-way communication is
energy and increase the reliability. Though Supervisory established between IP enabled smart devices and electric
Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) is used to monitor utility companies. The AMI has been the foundation of the SG
high power transmission, low and medium voltages are less [1]. The 2030 and 2050 visions of SG are to utilize the data
monitored and controlled. This paper proposes an from multiple ICT infrastructure and use the IoT solutions in
architecture for IoT smart grid (SG) to monitor and the design and development of SG to manage the utility
control low and medium voltage networks. Since WSNs is companies’ assets and to improve their services.
being incorporated, careful designing of energy efficient The IoT has evolved from its conception stage and a new
routing protocol is critical due to limited power of sensor era of the Internet called Web 3.0 or semantic web has started.
nodes (SNs) and the spread of information in WSNs. This This revolution will change the way business is being handled.
motivates our research to propose an IPv6 compatible Several studies, surveys and reports anticipate that the number
hierarchical routing protocol based on clustering for IoT of smart devices connected to the Internet will be more than 20
SG. The simulation results of the proposed IPv6 routing billion by 2020 [2]. The IoT market is huge which requires
protocol achieves extended network lifetime for WSNs and huge investments. International data Corporation surveyed
shorter delay compared to standardized RPL. 2300 executives from different organizations in 15 countries
about their business strategies towards IoT. Around 50 %
Index Terms-- Smart Grid (SG); IPv6/LowPAN; Collection
respondents said that they have already deployed IoT solutions
Tree Protocol (CTP); RPL; LOADng; IETF; information and
communication technology (ICT); and around 60 % said that IoT is strategic to their business [3].
Electric utility companies are among the largest businesses,
I.INTRODUCTION which should go forward on strategic plans for IoT SG. The

N EXT generation electrical power systems will benefit decision is made by calculating the payback period by dividing
from the explosive advancements in the information and the investment amount by the annual profit of the investment.
communication technology (ICT) to operate, manage and The initiative towards the IoT SG offers multidimensional
deliver the electric power economically, safely and reliably. ways to solve several problems such as power outages,
resource management, emission, energy waste, etc. with the
new emerging applications and services of the SG and IoT.
Mr. Alharthi’s research studies is sponsored by the Royal Saudi Embassy Open connectivity foundation (OCF) is a group of major
at London.
Corresponding Saad A. Alharthi is with the Department of Electronics and
players in communication, electronics and IT industries whose
Electrical Engineering, Liverpool John Moores University, Byrom Street, goal is to develop an open connectivity standard models for
Liverpool, L3 3AF, UK, (e-mail: s.a.alharthi@2014.ljmu.ac.uk). IoT. This group is led by Microsoft, Cisco, GE Digital, Intel,
Princy L. Johnson, is with the Department of Electronics and Electrical ARRIS, Samsung, CableLabs, Qualcomm and Electrolux [4].
Engineering, Liverpool John Moores University, Byrom Street, Liverpool L3
3AF, UK, (e-mail: P.Johnson@ljmu.ac.uk).
OCF ensures interoperability of the connected devices in the
Mohammed A. Alharthi is the Head of the Department of Distribution IoT settings. This guarantees remarkable enhancements of the
Substation Maintenance, Makkah Branch, Saudi Electricity Company, smart world and customer satisfaction from their endeavor.
Makkah 386-25460, Saudi Arabia, (e-mail: 78742@se.com.sa)
2

Cisco proposed a reference model for IoT in the 2013 IoT computing are key technologies in the IoT revolution of the
World Forum [5]. This model consists of seven layers or levels. digital age. Hence, communication network architecture needs
The first level is the physical layer where all types of smart to be modified to meet the future requirements. Cloud and Big
wireless devices or sensor nodes (SNs) collect data and send data platforms are the center of next generation internet
them to the upper layers. Due to the resource constraint nature architecture.
of the SNs and the spread of information in wireless sensor IPv6 routing protocols for IoT is a hot research topic due to
networks (WSNs), the design of routing protocol needs to be fast growing IoT applications. There are several important
more energy efficient as communication consumes most of the challenges related to security and QoS that must be
energy. investigated to make IoT applications viable, which are beyond
There are various IPv6 protocols which have been proposed the scope of this study.
for IoT routing. Some examples include collection tree CTP was the initiative towards designing energy efficient
protocol (CTP), the routing protocol for low-power and lossy routing protocol for WSNs which takes into consideration the
networks; LLN, (RPL) and its different versions, the challenges facing existing protocols. CTP employs three
Lightweight On-demand Ad hoc Distance-vector routing strategies to quickly adapt to the rapid topology changes
protocol - next generation (LOADng) and Least Path (network agility) and to reliably deliver data in bursty and
Interference Beaconing Protocol (LIBP). CTP and RPL are the dynamic wireless networks. The strategies are: four-bit link
benchmarks to evaluate the performance of new IoT routing estimator, datapath validation and adaptive beaconing [7].
protocols. The successor to the CTP is RPL where CTP has laid the
We propose an architecture for IoT SG to monitor and basis for RPL. Both CTP and RPL are distance vector routing
control the medium and low voltage (MV and LV) electric protocols relying on the Trickle algorithm. They use a
networks. In this paper, we also discuss an IPv6 compatible proactive mechanism where routes are established even though
zone based energy aware hierarchical clustering routing they may not be used, which causes significant energy
protocol for IoT SG, to extend the lifetime of WSNs through consumption accompanied with control packet overheads.
individual SNs' energy conservation. If the sink is within the RPL has been proposed by the Internet Engineering Task
range of the SNs, they can forward their data directly. The Force/Routing over low-power and lossy links working group
farthest are elected as cluster parents (CPs) for other SNs. The (IETF/ROLL) for IPv6/LowPAN. RFC 6550 defines RPL
SNs are grouped into clusters. The cluster members or orphans where the term RFC stands for "request for comments" and it
build routing trees rooted at CPs. The CPs in lower level zones has been approved as an IETF standard since 2012 [8]. The
estimate the cost for each path and choose the least cost design of RPL is based on directed acyclic graph (DAG) where
multihop paths to forward their data to the sink. all edges terminate at one or more roots with no cycles or loops
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Section exist in the paths.
II presents the related work. In Section III, the IoT SG DAG roots and Destination-Oriented DAG (DODAG) or
architecture for medium and low voltage networks is proposed. sometimes called a single DAG root do not have outgoing
In Section IV, heterogeneous network and radio model are edges. The DODAG root is the DAG root of the DODAG. The
defined. Section V provides the details of our proposed IPv6 way the DODAG tree is built depends on the DAG's objective
routing for IoT SG. Section VI presents the performance function (OF). The instances of RPL compute the rank of each
evaluation and analysis of the proposed routing protocol node using the OF to construct the DODAG. The patters of
compared to known RPL and CTP. The conclusion of this traffic supported by RPL are Multipoint-to-Point (MP2P),
research is presented in Section VII Point-to-Point (P2P) and Point-to-Multipoint (P2MP).
The packet information in RPL has control packets and data
II. RELATED WORK packets. The main control messages used in RPL are DODAG
IEEE has more than 100 active and proposed standards to Information Object (DIO), DODAG Information Solicitation
help in the transformation from traditional electric power (DIS), Destination Advertisement Object (DAO), DAO-
system to the SG. The National Institute of Standards and Acknowledgement (DAO-ACK) and consistency check (CC).
Technology (NIST) has published its Framework and In P2P and MP2P traffic patterns, DIO and DIS are necessary;
Roadmap for SG Release 1.0 which included more than 20 of however, DAO is required only for MP2P.
the IEEE standards for SG [6]. The NIST's report has The Objective function zero (OF0) is defined in RFC 6552
envisaged IP-based networks to be used as communication as the default OF for RPL. RFC 6550 does not provide
networks in SG.
definitions for the OF because the OFs may differ according to
The current Internet infrastructure cannot accommodate the
the applications. The OF0 is used to calculate the rank of a
explosive growth of IP-enabled device-to-device (D2D)
node. The child rank is equal to the rank of the best parent plus
communication and the emerging applications where the
Volume of data generated from the Variety of sources in the an increment. The OF0 chooses the best parent based on the
IoT is unprecedented. The Value of information mined from following criteria: DAG is grounded, DAG preferred metric
the gathered data and the Velocity to retrieve data with and the rank of the DAG [9].
Veracity in the IoT is important for decision making. Volume, LOADng is an IETF draft to adapt Ad hoc On-demand
Variety, Value, Velocity and Veracity are the key components Distance-Vector (AODV) specified in RFC 3651 as routing
that make up Big Data complex to handle. Big data and Cloud protocol for LLNs. Like CTP and RPL, LOADng is a distance
3

vector routing but it uses a reactive mechanism instead of kV switchgears and ends at the consumers as shown in Fig. 1.
proactive where routes are established only on demand. In Residential, commercial, industrial and farming units are the
[10], the performance of LOADng and RPL are compared in types of consumers for SEC.
smart home application. Their results show that RPL performs
better than LOADng.
LIBP [11] implements a routing algorithm known as the
Least Path Interference Beaconing Algorithm (LIBA) to
construct the routing spanning tree rooted at the sink. Like
CTP and RPL, the sink initiates a beaconing process which is
repeated by the SNs within on hop distance from the sink and
their neighbors thereafter to discover routes or paths. LIBP
selects paths that have least traffic or weights where children
select parents which have less number of children.
Cluster-based RPL (CRPL) was proposed in [12]. CRPL
outperforms RPL and opportunistic RPL (ORPL). Wang et. al
[13] proposed RPL based routing for AMI which gives another
glimpse that AODV fails to achieve better performance due to
flooding strategy which was validated through simulation.
One drawback of RPL is its implementation complexity
Figure 1: Single line diagram for MV and LV Electric network
which makes interoperability between devices a hard task.
Although simplicity and flexibility are features of LOADng, To help with the new trend towards SG, an IoT SG
flooding and route recovery strategies used in the current architecture to monitor and control the electric distribution of
version cause its performance less comparable to RPL. The MV and LV networks is proposed by the authors as shown in
linked list in LIBP at each SN with its neighbors is the major Fig. 2. This will enable SEC with a completely innovative
source of energy consumption and control packet overhead. solution to reduce the losses, which in turn will increase the
The main goal of this paper is to propose an architecture for reliability of the distribution network. This will empower the
IoT SG to monitor and control MV and LV electric network. SEC to efficiently plan, design, operate, and manage its
Besides, we propose an IPv6 compatible zone based energy electric distribution network.
aware hierarchical clustering and multi hop routing protocol Our proposed architecture for IoT SG assumes that the
for IoT SG to improve the performance of routing algorithms apparatus of MV and LV electric networks are equipped with
and to extend the lifetime of WSNs as will be discussed in the smart electronic devices. Furthermore, it is also assumed that
subsequent sections. the network infrastructure for communication exists. The main
point to emphasize here is that both SEC and consumers have
III. PROPOSED IOT SG ARCHITECTURE FOR ELECTRIC opportunities to benefit from IoT integration with SG.
DISTRIBUTION MV AND LV NETWORKS On the consumer side, they can control homes, offices and
buildings remotely where phone or iPad applications
Generation, transmission and distribution are three main empowered with ZigBee sensors and IoT gateway. Their bills
strategic business units (SBU) in electric power system. In can be managed by shifting loads to off-peak times and lower
some countries, the transmission and distribution are joined to rate tariffs. Green energy sources such as solar panels or wind
connect electric power suppliers and consumers. For instance, turbines are other alternatives to them.
the national grid (NG) in Great Britain connects England, On the SEC side, the switchgears monitoring and control
Scotland and Wales, hence, the electric power supply in one can be part of the IoT SG architecture. The underground and
region can be carried to feed the demand in any region. Control overhead MV feeders are provided with fault detector and
centers are responsible for monitoring and controlling the locator. The remote terminal unit (RTU) and motorized ring
generation and transmission through state-of-the-art main unit (RMU) substations or transformers are provided
technology and sophisticated SCADA systems. with access point to communicate through the internet. The
Saudi Electricity Company (SEC) is the largest electric maximum demand MDI and earth fault EFI indications and
utility company in the Middle East and North Africa. The monitoring against thefts can be reported instantaneously to
vision of SEC towards SG coincides with the government's the control centers. The load management module (LMM) can
2030 vision and the world's 2030 and 2050 visions for SG. coordinate load shedding through the collected smart meter
SEC has sponsored many conferences for SG and it is the readings from consumers and the substations in the area. The
sponsor of SASG 2017 conference. Several renewable energy backhaul communication infrastructure can be fiber optics,
projects have been launched by SEC to supply the high wireless, or power line communication (PLC).
demands from consumers. Their initiatives towards green The control center monitors and controls the electric
energy and SG have helped them remain competitive both at distribution MV and LV networks through distribution or
regional and global level. energy management systems DMS or EMS. Finally, it is worth
The scope of this research is limited to the MV and LV pointing out that distribution automation system (DAS) has
electric distribution network in SEC due to less monitoring and been successfully implemented in SEC Makkah to provide real
control of the network, which begins at 13.8 kV, 33kV or 69 time supervision on its distribution substations.
4

Figure 2: An architecture for IoT SG to monitor and control the electric distribution MV and LV networks

IV. HETEROGENEOUS NETWORK AND ENERGY MODELS ℰamp is the energy dissipation in power amplifier and it depends
This section defines the network model for IoT based on power loss in the channel model used. For example, d 2
heterogeneous WSNs used in our simulation and the radio power loss in free space ℰfs and d 4 power loss in multipath
energy model which is used to compute the energy dissipated fading ℰmp or sometimes called two-ray model.
by the SNs.

A. Heterogeneous Network Model


A heterogeneous WSN having N=20 SNs are randomly
distributed in a 50x50 square sensor field as shown in Fig.3. do (4)
The sink or base station (BS) is static and located at the center The energy consumption in the receiver circuit is due to
with no limited energy. The SNs are unaware about their running radio electronics only. Hence, ERx (B) is given by
location and fixed after deployment and each has a unique ID ERx (B) = Eelec * B (5)
which is IP address in this case.
V. PROPOSED PROTOCOLS
Our proposed IPv6 is based on hierarchical clustering
routing for energy optimization and less control overhead. The
minimum rank with hysteresis objective function RPL-
MRHOF is modified based on the low-cost ETX (expected
transmission time) rank computation method in [12].
A. Initial Phase
The initial phase begins with hello message from the sink
which sets time to live (TTL) timer and time slots schedule to
all SNs to advertise themselves. Based on the TTL and the
information among the SNs, the sink divides the sensor field
into logical smaller zones. The SNs within a threshold distance
d1 ≤ range communicate directly with the sink and will be in
zone-0. The SNs within the threshold distance d2= 2* d1 will
Figure 3: The N heterogeneous SNs distributed in a squqre area
be in zone-1 and so on.
The heterogeneous WSN assumes m fraction of N total SNs B. Network Configuration
are advanced, that is, N*m are advanced each with a factor α
The network configuration phase consists of two stages; i.e.,
additional energy Eadv = (1+α) * Eo and N*(1-m) are normal
cluster parent selection and clusters formation.
each with an initial energy Enrm = Eo. The total initial energy of
the network Et is given by: Cluster Parent (CP) selection
Et = N*(1-m)*Eo+N*m(1+ α) Eo=N*(1+ α) Eo (1) The sink selects the preferred CPs based on zone ID,
residual energy and the weights of supported children or SNs.
B. Radio Energy Model
If the threshold energy of CP is reached, ECP-Threshold, the sink
The model for radio energy consumption in [14] is used. elects other SNs as CPs the same way and this process
The energy consumptions in the transmitter circuit ETx are due continues. Each CP computes the routing cost to the sink and
to running radio electronics and transmitter amplifier chooses the route with the minimum ETX.
ETx (B,d) = Eelec * B + ℰamp * B (2)
5

The ratio Ei(r)/Ea(r) is used to select SNs with highest


energy as CPs. The Ei(r) is the residual energy and Ea(r) is the
average energy for the current round given by

Clusters formation
Once k CPs are elected, they broadcast DIO messages to
other SNs. Except SNs closest to the sink, SNs add the DIO
sender to their parent list and make CP with highest received
signal strength indicator RSSI as default parents. Each CP sets
up time slots and sends them to its children or members. After
that all the SNs within the cluster turn off their radio (sleep
state) except during their transmission time slot.
Figure 4: The screenshot for Border IoT Gateway
C. Steady State phase
The SNs have limited power and capabilities which requires
If n denotes the SNs closest to the sink, the energy as little power consumption as possible in communication to
dissipated by each CP, ECP, is the energy due to receiving data conserve their power which extend their lifetime. This will in
from [(N-n/k)-1] SNs, aggregation of the received data and turn extend the overall network lifetime for WSNs. The
transmission of the aggregated data to the sink average power consumption in our proposed IPv6 routing is
less as compared to the standards RPL-OF0 and RPL-MRHOF
The energy dissipated in k cluster Ek-cluster is given by as shown in Fig. 5. This is due to the low-cost ETX rank
computation but power consumption is trade-off with PDR.
Ek-cluster = k*ECP + ETx-NCP (8)
where ETx-NCP is the energy due to transmission of data from
(N-n) SNs. The total energy dissipated per round (Eround) is
calculated as
Eround = k * ECP + B [ (N-k) * (Eelec + ɛfs * d 2 toCP)] (9)

VI. PERFORMANCE SIMULATION


Instant Contiki-3.0 and VMware workstation 12 player
virtual machine which has Ubuntu 14.2 are used to make
COOJA network simulator for Contiki OS works. The
simulation setup and the parameters for emulated Sky Tmotes
are given in Table 1.
Table 1: Simulation Parameters
Figure 5: The average power consumption in standardized RPL and Proposed
Description Value
The minimum hop (Min-Hop) is an important metric to
Emulated motes Tmote Sky evaluate end-to-end delay. Thus, minimum distance between
Simulation time 1000 s SNs and roots (CPs and sink) gives less delay. Critical
applications require short delay, td (0.2 < td < 0.5 s). RPL is a
Radio Channel UDGM model proactive routing which gives it advantage over on-demand
Communication range 10 m routing. The end-to-end delay for the proposed routing and
standardized RPL is shown in Fig. 6 with Min-Hop is set to 3.
Network size 50*50 m2
Transmission power 0 dBm
Packet size 512 bytes
Transmission rate 1, 10 pkt/min

First, a screenshot for simulation scenario for the border IoT


gateway is shown in Fig. 4. Second, to evaluate the proposed
IPv6 routing, it is compared with standards RPL OF0 and
MRHOF. The performance metrics used are: average power
consumption, packet delay and packet delivery ratio PDR.
Finally, the simulation is repeated ten times and the average
values are plotted for each metric. Figure 6: The packet delay in standardized RPL and Proposed protocols
6

Link quality indicator (LQI) is the metric used to measure [8] T. Winter et al., "RPL: IPv6 Routing Protocol for Low Power and Lossy
Networks," IETF, RFC 6650, April 2012.
the PDR. If the link is reliable, in other words LQI is high, the
[9] P. Thubert, "Objective Function Zero for Routing Protocol for Low
probability of packet reception increases and vice versa. It is Power and Lossy Networks," IETF, RFC 6652, March 2012.
known fact that RPL suffers in terms of PDR. The comparison [10]T. Clausen et al., “The Lightweight On-demand Ad hoc Distance-vector
between our proposed IPv6 routing and the standardized RPL Routing Protocol - Next Generation (LOADng),” IETF, Draft, Oct 2012.
protocols is shown in Fig. 7 with LQI is set to 0.5. [11]L. Ngqakaza and A. Bagula, "Least Path Interference Beaconing Protocol
(LIBP):A Frugal Routing Protocol for IoT," Wired/Wireless Internet
Communication: 12th International Conference, WWIC, 2014. pp 1-14.
[12]Ming Zhao, Hnin Yu Shwe and P. H. J. Chong, "Cluster-parent based
RPL for Low-Power and Lossy Networks in building environment," 2015
12th Annual IEEE Consumer Communications and Networking
Conference (CCNC), Las Vegas, NV, 2015, pp. 779-784
[13]Wang, Z. Tao, J. Zhang and A. A. Abouzeid, "RPL Based Routing for
Advanced Metering Infrastructure in Smart Grid," 2010 IEEE
International Conference on Communications Workshops, Capetown,
2010, pp. 1-6
[14]S. A. Alharthi and P. A. Johnson, "Threshold sensitive heterogeneous
LEACH protocol for wireless sensor networks," 2016 24th
Telecommunications Forum (TELFOR), Belgrade, 2016, pp. 1-4..

X. BIOGRAPHIES
Figure 7: The PDR in standardized RPL and Proposed protocols
Saad Alharthi received BSc degree in Electrical
VII. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK and Computers Engineering from Umm Al-Qura
Universit, Makkah, Saudi Arabia, in 1999. From
In our research, an architecture for IoT SG to monitor and 1999 to 2006, he worked in private sector. Funded
control the electric distribution MV and LV networks has been through Albaha University, he received a ME in
proposed. The architecture utilizes the advances in the ICT and Computers Engineering from Old Dominion
University, VA, USA in 2009 where he returned to
emerging technologies and integrate them to the SG. Also, Albaha until 2014. He is currently working towards
IPv6 routing protocol is proposed where IoT gateway connect his PhD in Electronics and Electrical Engineering
IP-enabled smart devices to the internet. We evaluate the at Liverpool John Moores University, UK.
performance of our proposed IPv6 routing against standards
RPL-OF0 and RPL-MRHOF in terms of the average power Princy Johnson received BE followed by a ME in
Electronics from GCT, Coimbatore and Guindy
consumption, packet delay and PDR using COOJA network Engineering College, Madras, India, respectively,
simulator for Contiki OS. The simulation results show that the both with distinction. Through Commonwealth
proposed protocol performed better than the standardized RPL Scholarship, she received her Ph.D. from King’s
protocols. Our proposed IoT SG architecture and IPv6 routing College London. From 2000 to 2002, she worked at
Nortel Networks UK Ltd during which she had a
protocol can be part of DAS which will be our future work.
patent. She is at Liverpool John Moores University
and her research interests include energy-efficient
VIII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT protocols for mobile, wireless and sensor networks.
The authors would gratefully thank the Royal Saudi Embassy
Mohammed Alharthi received BSc degree in
at London for sponsoring Mr. Saad Alharthi’s research studies. Electrical and Computers Engineering from Umm
Al-Qura Universit, Makkah, Saudi Arabia, in 2008
with distinction. From 2008 to present, he is
IX. REFERENCES working with Saudi Electricity Company, Makkah
Branch, Distribution network maintenance during
[1] S. Karnouskos, O. Terzidis and P. Karnouskos, "An Advanced Metering which he has Rewards, Medals and certificates. He
Infrastructure for Future Energy Networks", IFIP/IEEE 1st International is the head of the Department of Distribution
Conference on New Technologies, Mobility and Security, May. 2007. Substation Maintenance. His research interests are
[2] A. Nordrum. (2016, Aug 18) IEEE Spectrum [Online]. Available: work safety, smart grid and leadership development
http://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/telecom/internet/popular-internet-of-
things-forecast-of-50-billion-devices-by-2020-is-outdated
[3] Cisco. Internet of Things (IoT) [Online]. Available:
https://www.cisco.com/c/dam/en/us/products/collateral/se/internet-of-
things/at-a-glance-c45-731471.pdf
[4] Open Connectivity Foundation (OCF) [Online]. Available:
https://openconnectivity.org/
[5] Cisco. IoT World Forum Reference Model [Online]. Available:
http://cdn.iotwf.com/resources/72/IoT_Reference_Model_04_June_2014.
pdf
[6] NIST. Framework and Roadmap for SG (R. 1.0) [Online]. Available:
https://www.nist.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_affairs/releases
/smartgrid_interoperability_final.pdf
[7] O. Gnawali et al., "Collection Tree Potocol", In Proc. of 7th ACM
conference (SenSys'09), Berkeley, CA/USA, Nov. 2009. pp. 1-14.

You might also like