Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Politics at MoMA 112 The Ethics of Incarceration 134 Server Overload 102
Saturday, 7 p.m.
the corner of Atlantic & Flatbush
BIM
®
BIM IQ
Like smartphones have revolutionized how people communicate, BIM IQ® will revolutionize the way
buildings are designed. How does it differ from BIM? Change the glass option or mullion design—only
BIM IQ® will show you that change from any view of your project, interior or exterior, in its precise
location, on any day of the year! That’s right, and you not only see what it looks like, BIM IQ® calculates the
energy data based on your selections—no waiting. To learn more, call 1-866-OLDCASTLE (653-2278),
see us at Greenbuild Conference, booth #3457N or visit BIMIQ.com to take a tour.
→
ONLINE
FRESH
ARCHITECTURE,
EVERY DAY
Want more news, projects,
products, arts and
culture, technology, and
business coverage? We
are so darn productive
that it’s impossible to fit
every word and image
into the monthly print
edition of ARCHITECT. If
you like the magazine,
then you’ll find even
156 PIERRESVIVES
about changing your
address, ordering back
Zaha Hadid adds to the urban renaissance of Montpellier, France, drawing issues, uploading your
projects to our website,
together three public agencies under a concrete, glass, and gold roof. and more. If we feel your
correspondence would
W W W. S A FT I . CO M
mySAFTI App 888.653.3333 Proudly made in USA
Circle no. 515 or http://architect.hotims.com
11.12
4
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
FRONT
12 DIALOGUE
How much more proof does America need to
motivate real action on climate change?
23 FRONT
Toronto by Gehry, Sterling Prize winners, over
the fiscal cliff, the Clinton Global Initiative, a
chat with Eisenman about Palladio, and more …
45 PRODUCTS
The right plants for your green roof, virtual
reality, a dramatic wood-clad cantilever, the
success of EPDs, and lots of new products.
63 AIARCHITECT
Preservation: restoration, the gaps in education,
and deciding what to defend and preserve.
CENTER
74 ON THE INSIDE LOOKING OUT
Johnston Marklee is part of a new wave of Los
Angeles architects whose influences extend
well beyond Southern California.
88 MAPPING MOTOWN
Detroit Works is unveiling a long-term
strategic vision to combat the city’s ills. Two
local architects were given the difficult task of
getting residents and officials to buy in.
BACK
THE FUTURE FOR DETROIT 200 PAST PROGRESSIVES
Thomas Phifer updated the early modern ideal
88 of a pure volume in a Hudson Valley retreat.
CEILINGS
RECYCLE THE CEILING PANELS FROM YOUR NEXT RENOVATION PROJECT
Where do ceiling panels go at the end of their useful life? 61,500 tons of panels have been diverted from landfill,
thanks to specifiers of the Armstrong Ceiling Recycling Program. Those 123 million lbs. of old ceiling panels are used
to manufacture new “Ceiling-2-Ceiling™” panels. So, close the loop – include Ceiling-2-Ceiling panels and Ceiling
Recycling in your next specification.
Recycling contributes to LEED® credits. Visit armstrong.com/savetheceilings and find out how you can “Save the
Ceilings” from becoming landfill on your very next project.
1 877 ARMSTRONG
LEED® is a registered trademark of the U.S. Green Building Council.
Circle no. 533 or http://architect.hotims.com
CONTACT
Want to get in touch with an Continuing Education
editor or sales representative? We have more than 200 free courses to
Order a back issue? Change the help you stay current with your learning
address for your subscription? requirements: To register, please
Find all of the information you visit architectmagazine.com and click
need on this and the following “Continuing Ed” at the top of the page.
pages. Or, if you’d rather, go to
architectmagazine.com and click Newsletters
“Contact” at the top of the page. ARCHITECT produces two free
email newsletters: the ARCHITECT
Submissions NEWSWIRE, which is a daily
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR compilation of our top stories, and the
Send us an email. You can reach us at ARCHITECT WEEKLY, which keeps you
letters@architectmagazine.com. Letters current on all of the top stories from
may be edited for length, content, and ARCHITECT and its Hanley Wood sister
style, and published in a future issue. publications. Subscribe to one or both
at architectmagazine.com by clicking
PROJECTS “Newsletter” at the top of the page.
If you have a building project that you
think would be of interest to our readers, Digital Edition
please go to architectmagazine.com, click You can read any issue of ARCHITECT on
“Projects,” select “Add a Project,” and your computer. Read it while online, or
upload images, project credits, and a download the PDF of the issue to read
description directly to our website. Our offline. Go to architectmagazine.com
design editors review every submission and click on “Magazine” at the top of
for possible publication in print and for the page.
promotion online.
ARCHITECT on Mobile
ARTICLES In addition to visting our website,
ARCHITECT does not accept unsolicited architectmagazine.com, there are two
articles. If you have an idea for a story, ways that you can read ARCHITECT
please email a brief description and on your iPad or iPhone. With our
writing samples to senior editor Eric ARCHITECT MAGAZINE READER app,
Wills at ewills@hanleywood.com. download the digital version of our
latest print edition or go back through
PRODUCTS our archives to find an issue you missed.
To submit a product for consideration for With our ARCHITECT NEWS app, keep
publication, please email a press release up with all of the news, products, and
and at least one image of the product to projects as they go live on our website.
products@architectmagazine.com.
Reprints
Edit Calendar & Media Kit Call the YGS Group at 717.505.9701,
Please visit architectmediakit.com. ext. 128, or email brad.hairhoger@
theygsgroup.com.
Subscriptions, Customer
Service, and Back Issues Newsstand
Email arch@omeda.com or call ARCHITECT is available at Barnes & Noble
888.269.8410 (toll-free in USA) and other booksellers across the country
or 847.291.5221. You can also visit for $9.95 per issue. Contact your local
WHERE VINTAGE AND MODERN COLLIDE® architectmagazine.com and click on bookstore to check for availability.
“Subscribe” (subscriptions only). Allow
six to eight weeks for the first issue. Address Changes
AIA MEMBERS
ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION RATES Call 800.242.3837, and press 2
Efficient fans
DESIGN AND TECHNOLOGY COLUMNS AND FEATURES ONLINE
Stylish fans SENIOR EDITOR, DESIGN
Katie Gerfen
SENIOR EDITOR, FEATURES
Eric Wills
SENIOR EDITOR,
ONLINE
kgerfen@hanleywood.com ewills@hanleywood.com Kriston Capps
ASSOCIATE EDITOR,
wlau@hanleywood.com Michael Todaro CULTURE AND COMMUNITY
Powerful fans ASSISTANT EDITOR, DESIGN
mtodaro@hanleywood.com Lindsey M. Roberts
lmroberts@hanleywood.com
Deane Madsen, Assoc. AIA COPY AND RESEARCH
dmadsen@hanleywood.com SENIOR WEB PRODUCER
QA/COPY EDITOR Armando Manzanares
Alexandra Rice amanzanares@hanleywood.com
arice@hanleywood.com
We’ve designed the right
fan for your project.
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS CONTRIBUTING ARTISTS
The selection and quality of Ernest Beck; Aaron Betsky; Blaine Brownell, AIA; Ian Allen, Peter Arkle, Catalogtree,
Elizabeth Evitts Dickinson; John Morris Dixon, FAIA; Jason Fulford, Noah Kalina
Big Ass Fans® is unparalleled and Thomas Fisher, Assoc. AIA; Joseph Giovannini;
so is our exceptional service. Our Cathy Lang Ho; Margot Carmichael Lester;
Vernon Mays; Mimi Zeiger
experts will work with you to specify
the appropriate fans for your project
and certified installers make sure your EDITORIAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE
clients receive perfect fans, every time. Fredric M. Bell, FAIA; Renee Cheng, AIA; Ned Cramer, Assoc. AIA; Yolande Daniels, Assoc. AIA; Sarah Dunn;
Andrew Freear; George H. Miller, FAIA; Randy Peterson, FAIA; James Timberlake, FAIA
The Big Ass Fans project consultant
team offers free design support and
assistance, while LEED® Accredited COMMERCIAL DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION
Professionals can tell you how Big Ass Fans GROUP PRESIDENT
Patrick J. Carroll
contribute to your building’s LEED credits. pcarroll@hanleywood.com 773.824.2411
EDITORIAL AND ADVERTISING OFFICES Copyright 2012 by Hanley Wood, LLC. Reproduction
MANUFACTURED IN LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY One Thomas Circle, NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC in whole or in part prohibited without written
20005. Phone: 202.452.0800. Fax: 202.785.1974. authorization. All rights reserved. Printed in the USA.
More.
One of the only products on the market to combine superior thermal
performance with a larger, more versatile span, Kawneer’s newest
Trifab® 601 Series Framing System is built with a 6" frame – that’s an
inch and a half more than a traditional storefront. Available in standard,
thermally broken and ultra thermally broken, the new Trifab® 3-in-1 platform
offers more flexibility, more drama, more options for you to design bigger,
better buildings. An extra inch and a half makes a world of difference.
VICE CHAIRMAN
Frank Anton
CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER CHIEF CUSTOMER OFFICER
Matthew Flynn David Colford
OFFICERS: Jeffery Potter, FAIA, President; Mickey EXECUTIVE TEAM: Robert A. Ivy, FAIA, EVP/Chief
Jacob, FAIA, First Vice President/President-elect; Executive Officer; Richard James, Chief Operating
Dennis A. Andrejko, FAIA, Vice President; Russell A. Officer; Kathron Compton, Vice President, Marketing
Davidson, FAIA, Vice President; Debra S. Kunce, FAIA, & Communications; Lisa Green, Vice President,
Vice President; John A. Padilla, AIA, Vice President; Finance and Accounting; Susan McDaid, Hon. AIA,
Helene Combs Dreiling, FAIA, Secretary; Gabriel Vice President, Member & Component Resources;
Durand-Hollis, FAIA, Treasurer; William R. Turner Paul T. Mendelsohn, Vice President, Government and
Jr., Assoc. AIA, Senior Associate Director; Michael Community Relations; Kevin Novak, Vice President,
Waldinger, Hon. AIA, CACE Representative to the New Business Development and Digital Strategies; Ken
Executive Committee; Robert A. Ivy, FAIA, EVP/Chief L. Ross Jr., FAIA, Vice President, Design and Practice; Jay
Executive Officer. A. Stephens, Esq., Vice President and General Counsel.
DIRECTORS: T. Gregory Ames Jr., AIA; William J. Bates, MANAGEMENT TEAM: Marlene Bohn, SPHR, GPHR,
AIA; William J. Carpenter, PhD, FAIA; Susan Chin, Managing Director, Human Resources; Paula Clements,
FAIA; Ashley W. Clark, Assoc. AIA, LEED AP; Stuart L. Hon. TSA, CAE, Managing Director, Component
Coppedge, AIA; Mary P. Cox, FAIA, LEED AP; Thomas Resources and Collaboration; Kenneth Cobleigh, Esq.,
R. Cox, AIA, LEED AP; Nicholas Docous, AIA, LEED AP; Managing Director & Counsel, Contract Documents
Jerome L. Eben, AIA; Mohamad Farzan, AIA, RIBA; Content; Pam Day, Hon. AIA, Corporate Secretary
Kevin J. Flynn, FAIA, IES; John P. Grounds, AIA, LEED & Managing Director, Governance Administration;
AP; Steve Jernigan, FAIA, LEED AP BD+C; Thad R. Andrew Goldberg, Assoc. AIA, Managing Director,
Kelly III, AIA; Gregory A. Kessler, AIA; Glen S. LeRoy, Government Relations & Outreach; Christopher Gribbs,
FAIA; Vivien Li; Vicki Long, CAE; Michael Malinowski, Assoc. AIA, Managing Director, Convention; Maan
AIA; Nick Mancusi, Assoc. AIA; Christopher Morrison, Hashem, PMP, CAE, Managing Director, Software &
AIA, LEED AP; John V. Nyfeler, FAIA, LEED AP; Wendy Products Services; Suzanna Wight Kelley, AIA, LEED AP
Ornelas, FAIA; Francis Murdock Pitts, FAIA, FACHA, BD+C, Managing Director, Organizational Strategy &
OAA; Beverly J. Prior, FAIA, LEED AP; Larry C. Quenette, Alliances; Molly Lindblom, Managing Director, Contract
AIA; James Easton Rains, Jr., FAIA; Elizabeth Chu Documents Operations; Kyle McAdams, AIA, Managing
Richter, FAIA; Anthony P. Schirripa, FAIA, IIDA; Charles Director, Marketing & Business Development; Philip
L. Schreckenberger, AIA; William D. Seider, AIA; O’Neal, Managing Director, Information Technology;
Steven Spurlock, FAIA, LEED AP; J. Cyril Stewart, AIA; Jeffrey Raymond, Managing Director, New Business
Walter D. Street III, AIA; Mark G. Swenson, FAIA, LEED Development Technology; Cedric Rush, Managing
AP; Martha R. Tarrant, AIA, LEED AP BD+C; Edward A. Director, Member Resources; Phil Simon, CAE,
Vance, AIA; Thomas V. Vonier, FAIA; Bill T. Wilson II, Managing Director, Communications and Publishing;
FAIA; Donald T. Yoshino, FAIA; David Zach. Carolyn Snowbarger, Managing Director, Professional
Development & Resources; Terri Stewart, CAE,
Circle no. 60 or http://architect.hotims.com Managing Director, Practice & Knowledge Resources.
PEFC Certified
This product is
from sustainably
managed forests and
controlled sources
PEFC/29-31-75 www.pefc.org
Ani
A n mal
ni mal al Care
Care
Ca re & Protrro
rotec
ot
ote
ecccttiv
ect ivve
iveeSSe ervices
rvviice
rvi
rv ces
ces
es - JaJac
Jac
Jackso
ackso
kso
ksson
nvi
nv vviille
illle
lle
e, FL
Arrc
Arc
A rchit
hiiit
h itect
tect
ect:
ec
ct: Ebe
ct Eb
E be
bertrt Nor
Nor
o man
ma Br
ma B ady
addy ArArch
cchi
hi
hitec
hitec
te
te
tect
ects
ts
Pan
Pa
Pan nel
el Conontra
tracto
tr
tra cto
tor:
r: Th
r: hororn
ornrne Meta tal SSyst
ys
yyst
sttems
m
P ofil
Pr
Pro file:
file:
e 7 7.2”
2” R Rib
ib & P Pe
Per
erfor
er ffo
ora
oraate
te
ed Pane
Panane
aneells
s
Fin
Fini
nis
iish
sh: Car
sh Ca
C arrd
diin
din
inaall Re
Red
Red d, Int
Inte
ntte
n terrst
rs
s
sttate
a Bl
at
ate Bllue
ue
u e & Wea ea
eat
eath
atthe
her
h erred
e d Zin
Zincc
NO DENYING
ARCHITECTS STAND ON THE FRONT LINE IN THE WAR
AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE AND EXTREME WEATHER.
COMPAP RISONS TO KAT A RINA were inevitable matters straight. Meanwhile, the U.S. spent
as Hurricane Sandy tore across the Eastern an estimated $7.8 trillion on defense and
Seaboard. Eyewitnesses documented the homeland security in the decade following 9/11,
storm’s effects via Twitter and Instagram, including on the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
LETTERS
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
→
at trebling? Isn’t infinity a state we should
seek? DAVID SMITH
In our October issue, we asked two seasoned
Tabitha Ponte
political writers to argue for which presidential I think that many of us older architects who @tcpg: Funny
candidate would most benefit architects and other lived through the end of Reaganomics, and reading
design and construction professionals— Philip now are witnessing the end of Bushonomics @architectmag
Klein of The Washington Examiner defended the have little desire to see the economy return to yesterday … Stanley
Tigerman’s interview
Republican ticket of Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan the slash-and-burn policies of those previous
with the new IIT
and Jamelle Bouie of The American Prospect administrations. It seems to me that the Arch Dean. Using the
defended the Democratic ticket of Barack Obama economy is becoming more stable under the word “integrative.”
and Joseph Biden. Readers continued the debate present administration and that the policies PshHa!
online in the story’s comments section as well as are working. ANONYMOUS
HONBLUE
on ARCHITECT’s LinkedIn page. At press time, we @HONBLUE:
didn’t know who would hold the 45th presidency, Voting for Romney could be ruin for architects? Stupid politicians. RT
but we did know that you were as eager to find The majority voting for Obama four years ago @architectmag: AIA
out as we were. has already brought me ruin. Why would the says the impending
fiscal cliff could be
majority vote for even more ruin from Obama
Contact Us: devastating to archs
Letters, c/o ARCHITECT You are all wet. Obama is killing us with his again? No thanks, I’ve had enough. I’ll take my and engineers.
Hanley Wood policies. Have you noticed how many architects chances on Romney. HAPPYCUSTOMER62409
One Thomas Circle N.W. are out of work? K. ANTHONY HAYEK, AIA, Mark Hogan
Ste. 600 The most telling comment that can be made @markasaurus:
YOUNGSTOWN, OHIO
Washington, D.C., 20005 I’m unclear on what
on the difference between Romney/Ryan and A. Betsky thinks tall
letters@ My vote will be to enable the Democrats to Obama/Biden is that Osama is dead and GM is bldgs should look
architectmagazine.com actually run things, rather than fight a handful alive thanks to Obama. BURTON ROSLYN, FAIA, like, not boxy but
of programs through an obstructive opposition NEW YORK CITY not sculptural?
whose signature aim has been to oust the
Randy Deutsch
president rather than work together to run Supporting a platform that demonizes hard @randydeutsch:
the country. PHIL KABZA work and success should not be one that Will the day arrive
architects support. RAY CUDNEYRAYC when there aren’t
Try this. Go out and spend up your credit 50 firms to make up
the @architectmag
cards to their limit. Then, ask for a credit Obama or Romney? Incur the infantile wrath ARCHITECT 50
line increase. Spend that to the limit. Go out of the moneyed class, or worship a few Ranking?
and buy a car, a new house, and a new color shriveled dollars by sacrificing everything else?
laser-jet printer—a good one. When the bills ARCHBART_DAN Elevator View
@ElevatorView:
do come in, ignore them. Buy some more stuff.
I think
After a couple of months, print some money “The budget should be balanced, the Treasury @barclayscenter
up on your laser printer to pay for all of those should be refilled, public debt should be reduced, interacts well
bills. Oh, that’s criminal? Yes, you’re right! It is the arrogance of officialdom should be tempered w/street, and
criminal! TR DESIGN GROUP ARCHITECTURE, and controlled, and the assistance to foreign transit focus may
set standard for
RIVERSIDE, CALIF. lands should be curtailed lest Rome become future arenas.
bankrupt. People must again learn to work,
The only plan to create jobs I’ve seen from instead of living on public assistance.” —Cicero, DavidZach
Gov. Romney is to cut taxes for individuals and 55 BC —Romney/Ryan, 2012 CE GERALD MARTIN @DavidZach:
@architectmag
businesses. The only way I see to create jobs Agreed. Access
is to create demand. The only way to create Philip Klein, you are correct in one statement: to #education is
demand is for some entity (the government!) Broader growth in the private sector is a human right.
to purchase large quantities of products and paramount. But you are mistaken that cutting Knowing what to do
services across a large spectrum of industries. taxes will lead to this goal. STEVEN JONES with it is a human
responsibility.
ANDREW V VANHOOSER, STUART, FLA.
The working poor do not pay income taxes, Amanda Kolson
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
As long as we tolerate a government that but when the Bush tax cuts expire, the lowest Hurley
confiscates our earnings in increasing income tax bracket of 10 percent will be @amandakhurley:
Yep, & next gen of
amounts, our incomes will be diminished as increased to 15, a 34 percent increase—the
firm leaders is thin
well as our quality of life. What rational and highest percent increase when the cuts expire on the ground RT @
thoughtful person can believe that increasing of all the tax brackets. WATSON architectmag Baker:
our nation’s debt burden will increase our 14% architects >
prosperity and happiness? If this were the I am a sole proprietor in my architecture (small 60yrs old. Addt’l 30%
btw 51 and 60yrs
case, we could triple our debt and thereby business) firm. No one like me earns over #AR50
greatly increase our well-being. But why stop $250K! Get real! ELIZABETH BOUGART-SHARKOV
FRONT 17
Project: Velti
Photographer: David Azevedo Manufacturers of woven wire fabrics for partitions,
Location: San Francisco, CA window treatments, GuardianCoil blast mitigation
Architect: AECOM, Los Angeles screening, and other ornamental metal applications.
&LUFOHQRRUKWWSDUFKLWHFWKRWLPVFRP
18
CONTRIBUTORS
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
WANDA LAU
WANDA LAU is the associate editor for has served as a civil
i engineering intern with
technology at ARCHITECT. SmithGroupJJR and as an engineer at Simpson
Lau receiv
i ed her bachelor’s degree in civil
i Gumpertz and Heger. Her work in journalism
engineering at Michigan State Univ i ersity,
y includes internships with both Men’s Health
→ READ LAU’S DETAIL where she graduated with high honors. She and Boston Review w magazines. She has
STORY ON AN UNDULATING went on to study
d building technology at the freelanced for The Post Standard (Syracuse, N.Y
.Y.)
WOODEN FAÇADE AT Massachusetts Institute of Technology, y where and worked as the communications director at
KILDEN PERFORMING she earned a Master’s degree and was named KSS Architects in Princeton, N.J.
ARTS CENTER ON PAGE
a Presidential Fellow. Not content with two In her spare time, Lau runs a stationery
56 AND THE COLUMN ON
THE RAPID RISE OF DATA degrees, Lau also earned a Master’s degree in design and letterpress studio, Aptly
l Noted, from
CENTERS, WHICH SHE journalism from Syracuse Univ i ersity. Washington, D.C.’s Capitol Hill neighborhood,
EDITED, ON PAGE 102. When not pursuing academic honors, Lau where she liv
i es with her husband.
Th key
The key toto our
our
Garrden
de Ro of® iss our
Roof ou
Mon
onoli
olithi
thicc Memb
Membra rane
6125
612 5®, a seamless
se
rubber
rub berrize
iz d asphalt
membra
mem brane with a 45 5+
yearr track
yea t recoord for
critic
critical water-r-pproofin fing
g
a roofing
and
an g applica
a catitions
ns
world
wor ld-wid
wide.
Americann H
Hyd
ydro
rote
tech
tech, Inc. | 303 Eas
astt Ohio | C
Chhica
cago
go, IL 606111 | 80
8 0.877.6125 | www.hydrotechusa.com
© 20122 Garde
Gardenn R
Rooff is a registered trademark
rk of American Hyd
ydrotech, nc.
h Inc
19
UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh is not just a world-class health trim are coated with PPG PURE PERFORMANCE®, among the world’s
care facility and LEED® silver certified. It’s also a vivid example of how first premium-quality zero-VOC* latex paint, in shades designed to
designers, architects, and contractors can use color to create a physical promote healing. SUNGATE® 500 glass allows high levels of natural
and emotional transformation. After extensive research with children sunlight, while our Atlantica glass supplies the spectacular emerald-green
and their families, the hospital’s architect chose PPG CORAFLON® hue. With more than 100,000 custom-created Duranarr colors and a wide
and DURANAR® fluoropolymer coatings for the exterior colors, to array of energy-saving tinted glass, no company offers more color choices
communicate a facility that is dynamic and alive. Interior walls and for your next project. So visit ppg.com
m to contact an architectural specialist.
TRENDS TO WATCH:
Spanish Ceramic Tile
Tile today is anything but flat or square, it’s all about adding depth and
interest to environments. Tile of Spain manufacturers are constantly
presenting materials and solutions that empower and inspire their clients
to use tiles in creative ways. Here’s a look at what’s trending now.
thought I knew. I am ready d for another shot, not another tombstone to the
COURTESY DBOX / FOSTER + PARTNERS
MY POSITION IS GUIDED BY THE BELIEF THAT WE SHOULD CONSTANTLY STRIVE TO BUILD A BETTER FUTURE. AS WE HAVE THROUGHOUT OUR HISTORY, EVERY
TIME CHICAGO REBUILDS, WE BUILD A STRONGER, MORE GLOBAL CITY. IT IS CLEAR THAT THE CURRENT [PRENTICE WOMEN’S HOSPITAL] BUILDING CANNOT
ACCOMMODATE THE GROUNDBREAKING RESEARCH FACILITY THAT NORTHWESTERN NEEDS TO BUILD, AND I SUPPORT THE DECISION TO REBUILD ON THE SITE.
—CHICAGO MAYOR RAHM EMANUEL
24
FRONT
51.6 48.4
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
September 2012
Architecture Billings Index
65
To most critics, the architecture of Frank Gehry, y FAIA,
F is inseparablyl Inquiries
60
linked to a free-thinking, artsy milieu in Southern California. But if you
ask the man himself, it was during his childhood in Toronto, Canada, 55
Mirvish spoke of the scheme as a work of art. “I am not building into a design epicenter,
condos,” he said. “I am building three sculptures for people to liv i e in.” while also shifting female-
His motiv i ations are to work with Gehry and to do a transformativ i e dominated crafts into a
more gender-neutral and
piece of city-building. “I love architecture because it tells us who we
desirable pursuit. Through
are as a people,” he said. “A “ nd on that basis, I’ve been talking to Frank Jan. 6, 2013. • mocad.org
Gehry for years.” ALEX BOZIKOVIC ALEXANDRA RICE
Defiantly different carpet? Naturally.
MAKE YOUR DESIGNS STAND OUT with the newest, most innovative carpet fiber in over 20 years —
DuPont™ Sorona.® And you don’t have to sacrifice performance or your commitment to the planet.
OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE: Resilience and crush resistance that withstand the test of time.
Permanent natural stain, fade and bleach resistance keeps carpet clean and beautiful.
Carpet with DuPont™ Sorona® contributes to LEED® points and lets you rock the design world.
To learn more, visit sorona.dupont.com or call 1-866-4-Sorona.
*Sorona contains 37% annually renewable plant-based ingredients by weight. **Based on peer-reviewed ISO Life Cycle Analysis. © 2011 DuPont. All rights reserved. The DuPont Oval Logo,
DuPont™, and Sorona® are registered trademarks or trademarks of E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company or its affiliates. LEED® is a registered trademark of the U.S. Green Building Council.
Circle no. 195 or http://architect.hotims.com
26
FRONT
WOOD
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
-6.8%
Adds Ciecko, “Innovative wood materials and building systems
such as post-frame, cross-laminated timber, mid-ply shear walls, post-
tensioned and braced-frame timber structures and LifeCycle Towers
are reducing the carbon footprint of the built environment while U.S. Wood Paneling
Morris Arboretum’s Tree Adventure allowing wood to reach new heights, create safe havens in seismic Industry Growth, 2012
by Metcalfe Architecture and Design zones and maximize energy efficiency.” MARGOT CARMICHAEL LESTER SOURCE: IBISWORLD
SANAA DESIGNS ‘RIVER’ BUILDING The winner of the 2010 Pritzker Prize, Sanaa
(the Tokyo-based practice of Kazuyo Sejima and
Mindy Fullilove, a research psychiatrist at New York State University Psychiatric Institute, sees a connection between the ways our cities are de-
signed and the health of their inhabitants. Fullilove, 62, also a professor of clinical psychiatry and public health at Columbia University, first saw it
COURTESY SANAA AND OLIN
when doing research on AIDS in 1989: she was surprised by a proposal that the urban policies of the ’70s—including planned city shrinkage—had
been instrumental in spreading the disease. “At first, I thought about AIDS as a personal behavior,” she says, “but this [paper] was saying that there
are also larger contexts.” Since then, Fullilove has kept her research focused on the relationship between the collapse of communities and the
decline in health. Her most recent book, Urban Alchemy: Restoring Joy in America’s Fractured Cities, which will be published in March, profiles three
architects—Dan Rothschild and Ken Doyno of Pittsburgh's Rothschild Doyno Collaborative and Michel Cantal-Dupart of France's Atelier Cantal-
Dupart—who are creating urban interventions that knit communities back together, and in turn, encourage healthier citizens. Fullilove will be public
director for the AIA through 2015. “I think that there’s a huge amount that architects and planners can do to help us,” she says. LINDSEY M. ROBERTS
Circle no. 571 or http://architect.hotims.com
28
FRONT
—PHILIP NOBEL
↑ Reynold Levy
President, Lincoln Center
↑
Karen Roch
Associate principal,
↑ Braulio Agnese
Firmwide marketing
manager, community
sector, Gensler
→ MORE DAILY NEWS AT ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM Moody•Nolan
SUPPORTING SUSTAINABLE
INSPIRATION.
Truly inspired designs call for performance
solutions that are every bit as remarkable.
You can count on the support you need to
bring your vision to life with the architectural
wood door possibilities of VT. VT doors are
available FSC® certified and manufactured in
highly efficient facilities using low-emitting
and recycled materials, and they can assist
in achieving LEED® credits. When inspiration
hits, VT is there with a sustainable solution.
A MAJOR SFMOMA SHOW OPENING IN 2013. On-site graywater treatment systems offer an efficient solution for
water conservation, if designers are willing to invest the time and
effort. Despite the science behind the design of wastewater treatment
systems, some designers, building officials, and occupants still view
them with skepticism. The solution to water scarcity ultimately does
not lie in codebooks or technical drawings. (1 AIA HSW/SD)
65%
debt-ceiling standoff ff last summerr, and its impact on the architecture and engineering jobs.
design and construction industry ry. That act, the byproduct Furthermore, the AIA’ A s report only covers the
of tense negotiations, stipulated $1.2 trillion in nearly effects of cuts to direct spending on building design and
across-the-board budget cuts, which would go into construction, not those that also allocate building-
effect in lieu of a compromise bill tasked to a bipartisan related funds, such as energy efficiency. y “If these other Small businesses who reported being
“supercommittee.” (That committee adjourned a few accounts were included,” the report’s authors write, “the “very concerned” about fiscal cliff
days before Thanksgiving of last year with no plan, impact on the build [sic] environment would likely be SOURCE: SURVEY, U.S. CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
and so the cuts detailed in the Budget Control Act are significantly higher.” In addition, there are a host of tax
48
scheduled to go forward on Jan. 2, 2013.) credits for Congress to take up before the end of the year
According to its press release, the AIA looked at an that have either expired already, y such as the research
Office of Management and Budget report and identified and experimentation tax credit, or are scheduled to be
48 accounts that currently fund federal construction, and concurrent with the sequestration going into effect.
Number of accounts that currently fund federal
from there analyzed the effects of the scheduled cuts to The full report, with charts detailing the amount
construction projects
those budgets. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, and of money currently allocated to the 48 budget lines and
SOURCE: U.S. CENSUS BUREAU
cited by the AIA in its report, federal agencies accounted how much will be cut through sequestration, can be
for a seasonally adjusted annual rate of construction found on the ARCHITECT website. GREIG O’BRIEN → MORE NUMBERS AT ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
TWITTER
TYPO
TY POLO
LOGY
@PAULGOLDBERGER:
THE NYT EDITORIAL PAGE SAYS
REVERSE CO
ORPORATE CREEP
P
AS THE
T HE
H IIR
R WOR
W ORKF K ORCE FLOCKS BACK TO CITY CENTERS,
WHAT NEEDED TO BE SAID: SUBURB
SU RBANANN O FFFFICC E PARKS NO LONGER PROVE THE
ICE
IC
A BIG STORM REQUIRES ULLTI
U T IIMA
M ATTEE D IG
MA I G S FFO
O R CCO
O RP
ORP
RPOOR
R AT
AT IONS
IIO
ONNSS .
BIG GOVERNMENT.
@MARKLAMSTER:
SO WHEN DO WE START
IMPLEMENTING THE ARO/
DLAND & LTL RISING
CURRENTS PLAN?
@LIFESANSBLDGS:
The suburban offi ffice park phenomenon got its start in the post-war 1940s, when white-collar workers traded city
HURRICANE AFTERMATH. life for the ’burbs and companies such as A AT&T and General Electric followed suit in seeking the “pastoral ideal,”
STRANDED IN CONNECTICUT. according to Louise Mozingo, author of Pastoral Capitalism: A History of Suburban Corporate Landscapes. She writes,
COURTESY FOSTER + PARTNERS, ARUP, KIER & WRIGHT, APPLE
“Corporations heralded the verdant pleasures of their new locations as substitutes for urban enticements.” In their
SHAKEUP AT APPLE. LEBBEUS new parks, these corporations gained both privacy and prestige while widening the gap between management and
manufacturing.
WOODS DIES. DISNEY But the grass is not always greener. Though suburban office parks—which range in program from plush
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
corporate headquarters to sprawling research campuses—constitute over half of America’s office space today, y they are
BUYS LUCAS. EPISODE 7 suffering higher vacancy rates than their urban counterparts. Companies are choosing to move downtown once again,
NOW. from San Francisco that covers more miles than the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system. MURRYE BERNARD
Search: Construction Specialties
We’ve changed Architects asked us to develop new flooring options for their entrances.
Floorometry® 201 entrance flooring features four high-tech stainless steel and
the rules architectural bronze mesh designs that effectively remove water and debris from
shoes, while providing a stunning accent for any entranceway. To see all of our
Floorometry products, call 888-621-3344 or visit www.c-sgroup.com/floorometry.
See us at Greenbuild, booth #2001S.
PROJECTS
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
CSI D.C.
THE NEW DEPARTMENT OF FORENSIC
SCIENCES WILL SHARE A HIGH-TECH,
GREEN FACILITY WITH THE OFFICE
OF THE CHIEF MEDICAL EXAMINER
AND THE METROPOLITAN POLICE
DEPARTMENT’S CRIME SCENE UNITS
IN WASHINGTON, D.C.
Interior
UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
C.S. MOTT CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL
ANN ARBOR, MI
ARCHITECT: HKS
GUARDIAN
SELECT FABRICATOR:
Trulite Glass & Aluminum Solutions
GUARDIAN GLAZIER
CONNECTION MEMBER:
CGI
SUNGUARD GLASS:
Neutral 40 on clear and
SuperNeutral 68 on clear
FRONT
36
Z»
104
'"
,., THE HOUSE THAT WRIGHT BUILT
:z:
:; IN OCTOBER 19S3, A FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT SHOW OPENED ONTHE
m
,., SITE THE THEN-FUTURE SOLOMON R. GUGG ENHEIM MUSEUM.
...
--<
::c
m
'!::
l> Age of esteemed
:;: Brazilian architect, Oscar
l>
C'l
l>
Niemeyer, upon his
N release from Hospital
Z
m Samaritano in Brazil. The
Z renowned modernist,
o
<
m
who shaped Brasilia
:;: and much of RIO, was
OJ
m
'"
hospitalized in mid
N October for dehydration.
S He was released after
N
a two-week stay.
Previously, Niemeyer was
hospitalized for another
two weeks in May for
pneumonia and In 2011
for a urinary infection
) M Q R. GOG' G· E . N H E- 'I M M U S E U M but for now, he's
'" 1-\ 1 e. r T I 0 J..I O F O R.. 0 A. N 1 C A. R. C H I holding strong.
T E M P O R. A. R:. Y ') T R.. U C T U "- E
"- " N ""- C o y D w '- I G, H T 'I-. P-. C. H I T E
SOURCE: THE HUFFINGTON POST
THE [BARCLAYS CENTER] ARENA CONSTITUTES ONLY THE FIRST PART OF MR. RATNER'S 22-ACRE, $4.9 BILLION
ATLANTIC YARDS DEVELOPMENT. SO WHAT WE SEE TODAY IS LIKE SEEING A NAKED MAN WITH JUST HIS SOCKS
ON-NICE SOCKS, BUT WE STILL CAN'T BE SURE WHAT HE'S GOING TO LOOK LIKE WHEN HE GETS DRESSED.
Not only does India have three of the world's While there, the architects met with
largest cities, it also has three of the world's public and private sector developers to
fastest growing cities. (To be clear, those are six discuss growing and updating the country's
disparate cities.) And while economic growth is infrastructure as part of a $299,139 Commerce
rarely frowned upon, it can be disconcerting for grant, according to Engineering News-Record.
the city's sustainability record when it happens "This trade mission aims to help build
at such an intense pace, a new report states. America's competitiveness by raising the
The AlA, in an effort to help the profile of u.s. innovative design in worldwide
architecture profession grow alongside India's markets," AlA first vice president/president
expanding economy, is conducting its first elect Mickey Jacob, FAIA, said in a statement.
ever trade mission in the country, connecting Jacob also visited Chennai, Kolkata, and
U.s. architectural firms with state and local Bangalore along with representatives of U.S.
::;: government officials as well as potential clients firms to discuss work opportunities. India is
::;:
:;: across various sectors, including healthcare particularly keen to develop its infrastructure,
l>
'"
n and transportation. and the government planning commission
::c
� SKETCH, FILTER, AND FORGET Backed by the u.s. Department of has launched an effort to spend $1 trillion on
n
--< Design studios are filled with digital devices, but Commerce, the AlA sent representatives infrastructure over the next five years.
:;:
l> when architects congregate for a pin-up or desk
C"1 from some 20 firms overseas for a five-day In addition to infrastructure, the trade
l> critique, someone is bound to unfurl a roll of trace. The
�
Z
networking trip starting on Oct. 15, according to mission focused on master planning, mixed
m
Morpholio Project hopes to bridge the digital-physical
n divide with Trace (mymorpholio.com), a free iPad app Loni Crowley, a Commerce Department public use development, healthcare, airports, and
o
:;: that essentially digitizes its namesake. WANDA LAU affairs specialist. educational institutions. A.R.
Specifies in seconds,
Installs in minutes.
The Strong Frame® ordinary moment frame provides high lateral-force resistance
for limited wall space, large openings and soft-story retrofit applications. And since
it’s pre-engineered and fabricated, designers can choose the exact frame size in
seconds with columns from 8 feet to 35 feet tall and beams from 6 feet to 24 feet
wide, as well as two-story solutions. The Strong Frame moment frame is the only
frame that’s bolted together, eliminating on-site welding. It also installs in less than
an hour and can be delivered to jobsites in just a few days.
For steel and wood construction, the Strong Frame moment
frame is the time-saving choice. Learn more and view a copy of
the Strong Frame Ordinary Moment Frame catalog by visiting
www.strongtie.com/strongframe or calling (800) 999-5099.
GLOBAL INITIATIVE
THE CLINTON GLOBAL INITIATIVE 2012 ANNUAL MEETING
ACKNOWLEDGED THE ROLE OF ARCHITECTURE IN GUIDING THE WORLD’S
LONG-TERM DEVELOPMENT. YEMEN IS JUST ONE EXAMPLE.
When an international community that longer esteemed or readily l understood. With
includes heads of state, business leaders, and no municipal authority to enforce codes and
foundation directors conv n enes to discuss the protect the 500-year-old urban fabric, there
most challenging issues we face as a planet, has been a rapid disintegration of the cultural
150
and they invn oke the word “design” as a practices inherent in ancient, vertical living.
i
potential solution, it’s a seminal moment for For Damluji,
u the fear that this tradition
the design profession. In late September, the will be forever lost is palatable. “Since we
Number of new commitments generated at the Clinton Global Initiativi e (CGI) opened its annual started losing our Islamic cities, quarters
Clinton Global Initiative 2012 Annual Meeting meeting on the topic “Designing for Impact” and edifices early l on in the 1960s and 1970s,
$2 billion
with this question: How are we designing our it was important as an architect to fight for
liv
i es, our environmen
n ts, and the global systems the continuation of the urban culture, the
we employ to impact the challenges at hand? vernacular architecture in towns and cities that
Total value of new commitments Throughout the CGI conference, in are built of earth,” she says.
a
sessions on topics ranging from “Influencing For its commitment to CGI, the Daw’an
2,300
a ors and Attitudes” to “Turning
Behavi Mud Brick Architecture Foundation is activ i ely
l
Inspiration Into Action,” architects were named facilitating the architectural rehabilitation
as integral play
a ers in re-imagining both spaces of local mud building traditions by working
Number of total commitments garnered by the and systems. With an international focus on directly
l with Y Yemeni and Hadrami building
Clinton Global Initiative “Designing for Impact,” it would be tempting to disciplines. The foundation pledges to restore
400 million
simplyl view this as reason to insert ourselv l es this unique cultural tradition and the urban
center stage after a tough downturn. culture associated with it.
Globally
ly, however, architects are already d In this wayay, the foundation hopes to
Estimated number of people reached by Clinton leading that conv n ersation. For more than regenerate substantial social and economic
Global Initiative commitments 3 billion people living
i in poverty around the resources that will allow the Daw’an
180
world, architecture means access: access to community to safeguard its unique cultural
schools, access to safe water and sanitation, and history. “It is about engaging the communities
access to the economic and physical
h security i ating their urban culture, by creating
in cultiv
Number of countries reached by Clinton Global that comes with effectiv i e education. tangible results and projects that serve
Initiative commitments One case in point: the Daw’an Mud Brick as landmarks for future inspiration and
Architecture Foundation, located in Y Yemen. development,” Damluji u saays.
Founded by Salma Samar Damluji, u an Iraqi The question at hand at CGI—how are we
with the surrounding climate and geographic design—making its principles essential to any n
Yemen Estimated Total Value: context. Daw’an acts as an original archetype conv
n ersation about change.
$1.5 million over 2 years for sustainable architecture. Architects such as Damluji u are
Both artform and building technology, y the demonstrating their willingness to proactiv i ely
l
HOW LONG HOW MANY ancient methods used to create these structures create more sustainable environmen
n ts—
Project Start: Dec. 1 As many as 43,000 are rapidly
l disappearing; the architecture that initiativ
i es recognized by the Clinton Global
residents
remains is in immediate need of rehabilitation. Initiativ
i e in this year’s annual assembly l . They
Abandonment and modernization hav a e created are leading by design, building for impact, and
SOURCE: CLINTON GLOBAL INITIATIVE a condition in which the old methods are no not waiting for instructions. ERINN MCGURN
Circle no. 406 or http://architect.hotims.com
40
FRONT
PUBLISH YOURSELF AT
ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM/PROJECTS
After a decade of research on Andrea Palladio, Peter Eisenman,
FAIA, presents a new take on the 16th-century master.
How did your research turn into the recent Yale University exhibit?
In addition to practicing architecture, I teach and write. I’ve been work-
ing on research on Palladio for maybe 10 years, and making analytic
drawings. I have over 700 analytical drawings that we made. At a certain
point, [Ya
Y le architecture school] dean Robert Stern asked me to prepare
an exhibition, which we did do. And I think it’s a very lovely exhibition,
and we’re finally finalizing a book coming out next year.
Daegu Gosan Public Library
Studio Ghirardelli
How did Palladio’s forms evolve over his career?
The buildings evolve from merely isolated buildings to buildings that
reach out into a landscape. The compositions are much more complex
and intricate and deal more with the idea of the urban in a pastoral set-
ting. There’s nothing ideal about what he did.
Do you think your conclusions will change the way architects and archi-
tectural historians look at these villas?
It’s bound to. They can’t ignore the work we’ve done. They have to look
at it and respond to it. There’ll be controversy, surely. But whether they
Ballard High School
agree or not, they can’t ignore it. Ask me in six months what people
HAILA Architecture|Structure|Planning
thought, especially when we get the book out.
Are you done with Palladio? David L. Kurtz Center for the
Performing Arts
→ FULL INTERVIEW AT I’m tired of it. I don’t want to even think of it. In the end, it’s done. Good
ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM or bad. L.M.R. Voith & Mactavish
ESTO EDITIONS
Famed architectural
photo house Esto,
founded by Ezra Stoller,
will display a sampling
of its works at the
new Boston Society of
Architects (BSA) Space
gallery in Boston. Esto
Editions features the R. B. Akins Company
works of photographers
Elliott + Associates Architects
Francis Dzikowski,
Jeff Goldberg, Anton
Grassl, Peter Mauss,
David Sundberg, and
Albert Vecerka as part
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Perfecting Progress™
REDUCE waste
Every plastic buccket in a landfill
Ev
aam mounts to 3 lbss. (1,36 kg) of oil-
bbaased raw materials that can never
bbee reused.
d
RECYCLE packaging
Ultrabond ECO Refills are provided
iinn 100%-recyclabble boxes.
Contact your local sales representative to learn how you can make a difference!
OGASSIAN TILES
With expertise in glazing technology, artist and designer Daniel
Ogassian created a collection of ceramic and concrete tiles for Ann Sacks
that features bold geometries, deep relief, and glazed finishes. Available
in many patterns, colors, and sizes (12" Japanese Geo in metallic antique
gold shown), the tiles are suitable for vertical installation indoors. Flat
designs may be used for flooring. annsacks.com Circle 100
→ FOR MANUFACTURER INFORMATION ABOUT ANY OF THE PRODUCTS SHOWN HERE, GO TO ARCHITECT.HOTIMS.COM
46
PRODUCTS
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
POLYWHEY
Vermont Natural Coatings uses recycled whey protein
in this wood finish to eliminate the need for heavy
metal driers. Available in several tints, the nontoxic,
nonflammable waterborne finish dries in under two
hours, seals and protects against water and chemicals, and
contains no VOCs. vermontnaturalcoatings.com Circle 102
DOUGLAS FIR
TABLETOPS
Decommissioned
decades- and centuries-
old warehouses, docks,
and gymnasiums are just
some of the buildings
from which Viridian
Reclaimed Wood recovers
beams for these tabletops.
HEXAGON ACOUSTIC TILE
The structural beams’
When looking for a material to dampen its workspace
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
DESIGN CATALOG
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
WHITE STONECROP (SEDUM ALBUM) (OPUNTIA HUMIFUSA) NODDING ONION (ALLIUM CERNUUM)
Good for: Year-round color Zone: 5 to 8 Good for: Color and low maintenance Good for: Year-round color Zone: 4 to 8
Height: 2 to 6 inches Sun: Full Blooms: Varies Zone: 2 to 10 Height: 8 inches Sun: Full Height: 1 to 3 feet Sun: Full
Tolerant of shallow planting media and Blooms: May to July Blooms: June to August
intense sunlight, sedums are frequently No “plant it and forget it” species exists, For use in milder climates, this evergreen
used on green roofs. The hardy, low-growing Bousselot says, but the prickly pear comes plant adds height and interest to roof gardens,
plants come in many varieties, says Jennifer close. Its drawbacks include pedestrian- Bousselot says. “It has grasslike but thick leaves
Bousselot, a former researcher at Iowa State unfriendly spines and slow growth, but it can with a beautiful flower. Its flower head dries
and Colorado State universities. “Depending endure frigid climates. Native and widespread and creates excellent winter interest.” Once
on the cultivar, the winter colors are endless— in the eastern U.S., it produces waxy yellow abundant on the Chicago River banks, the plant
$10–$24
ranging from orange to pink to yellow.” flowers that are followed by edible fruit. features edible leaves, bulbs, and bulblets.
Zone: 7 to 10 Height: 3 to 6 inches Sun: Full Height: 3 to 6 inches Sun: Full without irrigation Zone: 3 to 9 Height: 8 to
Blooms: June to September This plant lives up to its Latin name 10 inches Sun: Full Blooms: Summer
Though it requires a well-drained substrate, sempervivum, which means to live forever. Well suited for roofs with limited additional
this fast-growing plant has succulent foliage Though hens and chicks can take longer to load capacity, this colorful sedum tolerates
that turns purple in the winter, Bousselot says. establish than sedums, the payoff is worth soil depths as shallow as 1 to 3 inches, says
Suitable as a ground cover, it produces fuchsia it once the plants take root. Not only are the Kristin Getter, a floriculture outreach specialist
flowers from late spring until the first frost. evergreen succulents drought resistant and at Michigan State University (MSU). White
However, as a native of Southern Africa, it is low-maintenance, but they also provide color, Stonecrop is another option, but it does not
not reliably winter hardy north of zone 7. producing purple-red flowers in midsummer. withstand hot summers, Getter says. →
But th
Bu thehe po
pow
owe
wer of of Met
Met etlSpa
lS
Spa
pan n’’s HHP PCI
CI Barrri rieerr In
nssul ulat
lated
atted
ed Metetall Pananelel iis
s
undedernrnea
eath
ea th.. De
th Delililive
veri
vering
ring g con
onti
tiinu
nuououss ai
ou a r,
r wa ater
er, th
er, ther
erma
er m l an
ma andd vaapo
p rp prrot
otec
e ti
ec tion
tion
in
n a sinsin
ngl
gle-
gle-
e pa
panenell co
ne ompon
mp po
onnen
entt ththat
that
at’s
’ss eas
asysy too insnsta
tallllll, th
ta the
he HPCI
HPPCI
CI BBar
arri
ar rier
rier
e wal all
pane
pa nell ma
ne maxixim
xi miz
miizze
es en ener
ergy
er g effic
gy cieienc
iency
nc y.. Bec
y cau
aussse it ca
cann be use used
se
ed with any ttyp ype
yp e of
faça
fa çade
çade,, th
de thee HPCl Bar Bar
arri
r er is a po
ri poweweerrfful
u insnsuullat
u a in
i g ba
base s ffor
se orr a
o an
n en
e dl
d es
esss vvaari
riet
etty
of mat
of atereria
ials
ls. Th
ls. This is iiss in
inno
innonovvaati
tion
on n. Th
This is is H HPPCII Bar arrriierer.
er.
IN THE ZONE
Plant selection depends
on a few factors. First,
a project team should
determine what type of
green roof is best suited
to its project: intensive
or extensive. Intensive
green roofs have deeper
planting media depths and
are similar to traditional
landscaping. Extensive green
roofs, designed to boost
building performance and
environmental sustainability,
use shallower depths and
PRAIRIE DROPSEED (SPOROBOLUS CREEPING PHLOX (PHLOX
O SUBULATA
TA) STONECROP (SEDUM
U KA
K MTSCHA
H TICUM
U M)
require less maintenance.
HETEROLEPIS)
S Good for: Kid-friendly, high- Good for: Kid-friendly, high-traffic areas Good for: Storing carbon Zone: 4 to 9
Next, teams should
traffic areas Zone: 3 to 9 Height: 2 to 3 feet Zone: 3 to 9 Height: 6 feet Sun: Full sun to Height: 6 to 12 inches Sun: Full sun to partial
consider their roof’s
Sun: Full Blooms: August to October partial shade shade Blooms: Early summer microclimate, which is
This plant, native to Chicago, produces pink The Chicago Botanic Garden is examining the All plants store carbon, but some are more determined by several
flowers with brown tints in the late summer.
fl durability of this semi-evergreen ground cover, effffective than others, says MSU horticulture factors, including average
Its foliage turns gold and orange in the which grows into a dense mat, Shelton says. “It professor Brad Rowe. Carbon storage potential temperatures, wind levels,
fall and fades to light bronze in the winter. can handle some foot traffi ffic and is a carpet of is directly related to biomass—for example, sun intensity, and rainfall.
blooms in the spring”—good news for a plant a tree will store more than a perennial. The U.S. Department of
“The grass … has a strong fragrance in late
Stonecrop, Rowe says, is a larger rooftop plant Agriculture publishes its
summer into early fall that has been likened that must withstand frigid winters, frequent
Plant Hardiness Zone Map
to popcorn,” says Chicago Botanic Garden handling by students, and up to 1 million that can be planted in shallow soil. It produces
(planthardiness.ars.usda.
horticulturist Emily Shelton. annual visitors to the garden’s Daniel F. and Ada long-lasting, half-inch yellow flowers.
fl
gov) based on the average
L. Rice Plant Conservation Science Center. annual minimum winter
temperatures, divided into
10-degree zones; lower-
numbered zones are colder.
TOP, LEFT TO RIGHT: ROBIN CARLSON / CHICAGO BOTANIC GARDEN; ROBIN CARLSON / CHICAGO BOTANIC GARDEN; STAN SHEBS
However, depending on
roof height, the conditions
on top of buildings may
be very different from
conditions on grade.
Rooftops may require
plants suited to a different
zone than the landscaping
planted several stories
below on ground level does.
Green Roofs for Healthy
Cities offers a database of
green-roof professionals
(greenroofs.org/index.php/
BOTTOM, LEFT TO RIGHT: ADAMANTIOS; AMIT BANSAL; ROB HILLE
find-greenroofprofessional),
who can help sort out the
ORNAMENTAL ONION (A ( LLIUM
U MINT (M
( ENTHA
H A) TWO-ROW STONECROP (SEDUM U technicalities of selecting
SENESCENS)
S Good for: High-salinity Good for: Bulk food source Zone: 3 to 10 SPURIUM
UM) Good for: Storing carbon plants for rooftops.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
environments Zone: 4 to 8 Height: 6 to Height: 1 to 4 feet Sun: Full sun to partial shade Zone: 4 to 9 Height: 2 to 6 inches
8 inches Sun: Full sun to partial shade For the Ledge Kitchen & Drinks restaurant Sun: Full sun to partial shade
Blooms: Mid to late summer in Dorchester, Mass., Recover Green Roofs Blooms: Summer
In coastal applications and on roofs in which worked with Green City Growers to create a Rowe also pointed to this sedum variety as
de-icers are used, plants that can tolerate rooftop kitchen garden, whose abundance of another excellent carbon-storage plant that
high salinity are a must. In his research, Rowe produce includes mint—traditional, chocolate, can grow in shallow planting soils. The semi-
has found ornamental onions to be very salt pineapple, spearmint, and peppermint. The evergreen sedum produces white or purplish
tolerant. With blue-green leaves that smell like fast-growing, continually harvestable plant is star-shaped flowers in the summer. Its foliage
onion when bruised, the plant grows in clumps “easy to apply to a menu,” said Recover project turns burgundy in the fall. Like Stonecrop, the
and produces lilac-pink flflowers. manager Brendan Shea. plant also provides good ground cover.
NFPA 285 COMPLIANCE
IS NOW IN THE PALM OF YOUR HAND.
1RZ WKHUH·V D SRZHUIXO \HW VLPSOH DSS WKDW JLYHV GHVLJQ SURIHVVLRQDOV D FRPSUHKHQVLYH UDQJH RI RSWLRQV WR HQVXUH
1)3$FRPSOLDQFHZKHQVSHFLQJZDOODVVHPEOLHV
3-step, touch screen simplicity
7KLVXQLTXHHDV\WRXVHDSSKDVEHHQGHVLJQHGE\+XQWHU3DQHOV·+XQWHU;FLGLYLVLRQIRUVHDPOHVVXVHRQDOO'URLG
L3DGDQGL3KRQHGHYLFHV$ZHEEDVHGYHUVLRQLVDOVRDYDLODEOH7KHQHZDSSKHOSVFRQÀJXUHDOOFRPSRQHQWVRIDZDOO
DVVHPEO\IURPLQWHULRUÀQLVKWRH[WHULRUFODGGLQJ6HHIRU\RXUVHOIKRZHDV\LWLVWRXVHWKLVQHZJURXQGEUHDNLQJDSS,WFDQ
EHGRZQORDGHGIUHHDWKXQWHU[FLFRP
NFPA 285 compliance is easy as 1, 2, 3
Step 1 Select Wall Type. Step 2 Select Hunter Xci Step 3 Select exterior
Choose from CMU, product. Choose Xci CG, cladding systems. Choose
Concrete or Steel Stud. Xci Ply, Xci Class A, Xci Foil options based on wall
and Xci product type
TREMOLO
For this vinyl wallcovering in his eponymous collection
for Maya Romanoff, interior designer Roger Thomas
was inspired by a scrap of industrial material covered in
18-karat gold. Layers of metallic pigment are hand applied
to the embossed base. Custom colors and lengths are
offered. mayaromanoff.com Circle 106
ENGUARD
INSULATION
Manu ctured
Manufa ed by Vit
Vitaa
No
N onwovwovensens,, EnGu
EnGuardard
is a hypoypoall
al erg
ergeni
enicc
altternatiative
ve to gla
gl sss fiber
ber
inssula
in latio
tion
n made
made entir tirely
ely
from
fro mp poly
olyest
ester—
er—namnamelye ,
recycl
rec ycleded plastic
pla bott
ttles
les
and
nd fiber
fiber
b rss ffrom
rom
om p pre-
con nsum mer ccon nten
tent.
te t The
T
hydro
hyd rop
ophob
hob
o ic materi
materiial
mat a
willl not
not abs
absorborb mo
moistist
s ure e
and
an d can
ccan be hand
han
anddle
led
d
wittho
hououtt prot
protectect
ec
ctive
ive gear.
arr
eng
en gua
uarardin
dinsul
sulati
sul ation.
ati
tion.
on.com
com
Cirrcle
Ci e 10
05
PLAY OF LIGHT
The Mohawk Group
combined light and dark
motifs with geometric
patterns in this modular
collection, inspired by
the “rurban” trend in
which urban cultures are
embracing rural values.
It is manufactured with
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
SmartStrand Contract
with DuPont Sorona,
a recyclable, rapidly
BENCHMARK FAÇADES renewable, biobased fiber
Kingspan Insulated Panels recently released this high- that requires 30% less
performance, universal barrier wall system, which energy to manufacture
features multiple cladding options, including glass, than does nylon. Nine
ceramics, wood, cementitious boards, and metals. The colorways and three
wall assembly comprises a rail substructure, insulated patterns are available.
panels, and a rainscreen. Kingspan plans to add other mohawkgroup.com
materials and finishes. kingspanpanels.us Circle 107 Circle 108
PROOF THAT PRODUCTS ARE AS GREEN AS THEY CLAIM
UL Environment empowers purchasers to identify environmentally-preferable products
with ease and confidence. We provide lifecycle-based, multi-attribute product certifications,
environmental product declarations, claim validations, and indoor air quality certifications to
help manufacturers create better products in a more environmentally-responsible way. Trust
UL Environment to help you find and specify greener products. Visit www.ul.com/environment.
PIECES OF FLAIR
Labels, seals, and
certifications may offer
at-a-glance environmental
approval, but they track
INDUSTTRY NOTES varying criteria, and some
Green Cleansing
are only single-attribute
claims. Here is a sample of
the ecolabel programs and
sustainability standards that
are offered today.
The International Living
EVERY PRODUCT SEEMS TO HAVE A SUSTAINABLE STORY THESE Future Institute’s Declare
DAYS. ENVIRONMENTAL PRODUCT DECLARATIONS WERE CREATED TO database—and label—
lists a building product’s
VET MANUFACTURERS’ CLAIMS. HAVE THEY BEEN SUCCESSFUL? composition, source, and
manufacturing locations and
Text by KJ Fields
color codes potential hazards.
Illustration by Lauren Nassef The Pharos database
identifies a product’s VOCs,
IN A MARKET WHERE manu n facturers tout all EPDs, and the latest draft f of LEED v4 rewards toxicity, renewable material
kinds of envn ironmental claims, it’s hard to de- the use of products that hav a e EPDs. content, energy sources,
cipher whw at
a ’s really
l green. In 2006, the Interna- UL Env
n ironment, a business unit of Under- and reflectance.
Greenguard certifies
tional Organizat a ion for Standardizat a ion (ISO) writers Laborata ories based in Marietta, Ga., and
low-emissions materials and
published standards for Env n ironmental Prod- one of the few program operat a ors in the U.S., interior products to promote
uct Declarata ions (EPDs)—scientific, third-party has registered approximat a ely
l 30 EPDs in four indoor air quality (IAQ) and
validata ed reports thata disclose a product’s life industries to data e. Strat
a egic development and reduce chemical exposure.
Scientific Certification
cycle assessment (LCA); carbon footprint; land, innovata ion group lead Heat a her Gadonniex has
Systems independently
wat
a er, and air impacts; and ozone depletion po- seen a surge of interest and growt w h in the pro- verifies items such as life
tential. Now fairlyl common in Europe and parts gram in the past two years.“A “ lt
l hough the U.S. is cycle assessment, forestry
of Asia, EPDs are relata iv
i ely
l new in the U.S., but a just getting started, we are working with a large management, and furniture
groundswell toward certificat a ion is under wayay. n mber of manu
nu n facturers and industry associa- and flooring emissions.
Green Seal develops life
Certification alone does not make a prod- tions to address demand for EPDs,” she say a s.
cycle–based sustainability
uct eco-friendly ly. Rather, EPDs track and report Cost and complexity are among the rea- standards and offers third-
a product’s progression from cradle to grav a e (or sons whwhy U.S. manu n facturers hav a e been slow party certification.
back to cradle). EPDs are based on the product’s to report EPDs. Certificata ion costs vary depend- To receive the Energy Star
label, products must meet
LCA, whw ich is guided by specific Product Cate- ing on the program operat a or’s role, but the real
specific energy efficiency
gory Rules (PCRs) that describe the LCA param- cost lies in conducting the LCA. EPD educat a ion requirements and be certified
eters for scope, data collection, methodology, y remains a challenge. No single entity oversees by an EPA-recognized
and presentation format. Independent agen- EPDs or their approval process, so it’s important certification body.
cies, or program operators, help manufacturers to delv
l e into wh
w ich PCRs were followed to en- MBDC Cradle to Cradle
Certification evaluates
nav
a igate the certification process and comply l sure consistency whw en comparing products.
products based on their
with ISO standards. Because standardization is Carpet manufacturer Interface has at- use of materials with
critical for comparing products worldwide, EPD tained EPDs for 90 percent of its product lines closed-loop life cycles. It
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
DETAIL
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
55,438
The number of
seat cuts made
in the glulam
beams to ensure
the continuity
of the gaps
between the
finished oak
planks
Text by Wanda Lau TURNING A BUILDING TYPOLOGY on its heels spaces, which align in a row behind the lobby,y
can take a lot of convicti
n on. Luckily
ly, an unin- is delineated by the undulating 3,500-square-
The geometric, dark- corporated team of architecture students and meter (37,700-square-feet) wooden façade,
gray aluminum panels recent graduates had no shortage of convicti
n on which spans from the lobby floor to the 22-
cladding the building’s
rear and side elevations
when they entered an international competi- meter-tall cantilevered roof. The curves draw
juxtapose the warmth tion to design a performance hall for a sym- visitors into the performance halls, as if they
and curves of the Kilden phony
n orchestra, regional theater group, and were being “sucked into a cav
a e,” Woo
W lston says.
a
Performing Arts Center’s opera in Kristiansand, Norway a . As it turns out, The dyn
d amic surface is deriv i ed from two
main façade, which
the group’s idea to manifest the div i erse pro- lines: the curved one that outlines the audi-
emulates a rippling stage
curtain or the wooden gram for the Kilden Performing Arts Center toriums at its base and the austere, 95-meter-
hulls of ships pulling on the building façade was selected, leading to long straight edge of the roof. Creating the
into harbor. the foundation of ALA Architects in Helsinki. double-curved form between the lines—with
Theaters often emphasize a “blank tower the curved line nearly
l twice the length of the
on the building that nobody d will recognize,” straight one—tested the limits of modeling,
says
a Samuli WooW lston, a partner at ALA. “We W fabrication, and construction.
TUOMAS UUSHEIMO / COURTESY ALA ARCHITECTS
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
wanted to bring out … the bellies of the actual The challenge fell to Zurich-based archi-
shapes of the auditoriums, and how the seats tectural and technology consultant Designto-
rise and become visible on the surface.” production, which Norwegian timber contrac-
Designed in collaboration with local tor Trebyggeriet brought onboard, along with
firm SMS Arkitekter, the 24,600-square-meter a Norwegian shipbuilder, Risør Trebåtbyggeri.
(265,000-square-feet) structure hosts a 1,200- Steel framing, hu
h ng from the building’s
seat concert hall, a 700-seat theater and opera concrete structure, supports the curved wood
hall, a 150-seat experimental theater hall,
and a 235-seat multipurpose hall. The suite of →
1FSGPSNBODFBOE8FBUIFS3FTJTUBODFBU
'FFU
>ÃiÀÊ*>À>VÊ >À]Ê-iÀv>ÕÃÊÕÃÌÀ>
>>7> Ê ÕÕÊÀ>i`Ê/iÀ> ÞÊ ÀiÊ `}Ê-ÞÃÌiÊ-ÇäÊÜÌÊÌÀ« iÊ} >â}
iÛ>ÌÊn]äÎnÊviiÌÊÊÊÊ
/BOB8BMMZFBSTPGFOHJOFFSJOHFYDFMMFODFXJUI
PWFSBNJMMJPOQBOFMTJOTUBMMFE
r#FOFñUGSPNBTJOHMFTPVSDFQSPEVDUCVJMUBTBDPNQMFUF
TZTUFNPGVOQBSBMMFMFERVBMJUZXJUITVQFSJPSMPOHUFSN
XFBUIFSQFSGPSNBODF
r$IPPTFGSPNPWFSEJíFSFOUTZTUFNTXJUIIVOESFETPG
PQUJPOTGPSDPOñHVSBUJPOT
JOXBSEPSPVUXBSEPQFOJOHT
NBUFSJBMT
HMB[JOHBOEñOJTIFT
r$POUBDUUIF/BOB8BMM%FEJDBUFE"SDIJUFDUVSBM4VQQPSUUFBN
GPSDPODFQUUPDPNQMFUJPOFWBMVBUJPOTBOEEFTJHOHVJEBODF
5IF-FBEFSJO0QFOJOH(MBTT8BMMT
OBOBXBMMDPN
4IPXSPPNT/BUJPOXJEF
Circle no. 211 or http://architect.hotims.com
58
PRODUCTS
→
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
Steel framing
Glulam header
beam
Glulam
m curved
beams
Oak planks
wall structurally. To create the furring system between the be easily transported on barges to Kilden’s waterfront site
steel framing and the finished oak planks, Designtoproduction 100 kilometers away. If all went as planned, the assemblies
proposed using 10-meter-long glue-laminated spruce beams, would “snap into place, just like an Ikea building kit for 126
which could be milled by CNC fabrication machines to within façade elements,” Scheurer says.
a 1/2-millimeter tolerance, says partner Fabian Scheurer. To mitigate the difference between the 15-millimeter
Digitally fabricating the 1,803 glulam beams and 12,248 tolerance in the steel-frame construction and the 2-milli-
oak finished boards, which together comprise the wooden meter tolerance allowed in the finished ceiling gaps, Design-
façade, required the consultants to model every aspect of toproduction fabricated each furring element with eight
the wall “down to the last screw hole,” Scheurer says. The connection points that allowed for some play during the wall
team divided the furring system into 126 decklike elements, installation. “Unfortunately, the human eye is pretty good
each comprising two straight header beams with nine to 13 at seeing non-straight lines,” Scheurer says. In the end, the
curved beams in between. Seat cuts to align the oak planks team’s meticulous planning and assembly paid off: Only one
were milled into the glulam beams, which average 120- of the 126 elements required a slight modification.
millimeters-by-280-millimeters in section. Fabricated in While the wooden façade appears to run continuously
Switzerland by timber consultant Blumer-Lehmann, the from the building interior to exterior, the glass curtainwall
curved beams were transported to a shipyard in Norway, actually truncates the oak planks, creating a clean break
where they joined the Trebyggeriet-fabricated header beams between inside and outside members. The curtainwall
and the Risør Trebåtbyggeri–fabricated oak planks. stops shortly once it disappears above the finished wood
The 21-millimeter-thick, 3-meter-long planks made from surface to avoid interfering with the steel framing. The
Norwegian oak—a reference to Kristiansand’s founding in curtainwall is supported on grade, allowing the wooden
the 17th century as a harbor to export wood to Europe for façade to move freely, not only to accommodate thermal
shipbuilding—were milled in sets of four on a five-axis loads but also loads from “heavy winds blowing down from
CNC machine. To compensate for the differences in length the fjord,” Woolston says.
between the wall’s defining curved and straight lines, the The intersection of the glazed and wooden façades at
planks taper in width between 120 millimeters and 55 milli- the outside corners of the building also proved to be one of
meters, but maintain the 10-millimeter gap between boards. the design’s greatest fabrication challenges. The return of
“At some point, the boards would become too small,” Scheurer the curtainwall into the cantilevered wooden façade creates
says. Once the planks taper to 55 millimeters, a new 120-mil- a diagonal intersection that runs the height of the glazing.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
limeter board picks up where two planks left off. “In those corners, you have double-curved elements” where
The long edges of the oak planks were also angled to the furring elements are no longer planar curves, but spatial
accommodate the surface’s inward and outward curves. As curves that bend in two directions, Scheurer says.
many as 180 planks fit on each furring element. Each plank The graceful movement and materiality of the wave
was slightly bleached and then re-dyed to help preserve its wall, which took about 18 months to complete, belies its com-
DESIGNTOPRODUCTION
rich, uniform color from fading due to exposure to the sun plexity. Downplaying the wall as a “huge eaves structure,”
and Norwegian winters, Woolston says. Woolston says that “the most interesting part was the collab-
Risør Trebåtbyggeri then preassembled the elements oration with Designtoproduction and the way of using two
in its shipyard, where the prefabricated assemblies could very simple lines to create a big surface.”
SOME
TALK THE TALK.
OTHERS
WALK THE
WALK.
3USTAINABILITY¬HAS¬BECOME¬A¬MAJOR¬
FACTOR¬IN¬THE¬¬CONSTRUCTION¬MARKET¬
!ND¬ THE¬ DOMESTIC¬ STRUCTURAL¬
STEEL¬ INDUSTRY¬ HAS¬ BEEN¬ MAKING¬
ENVIRONMENTAL¬ IMPROVEMENTS¬ FOR¬
DECADES¬BY
s¬#UTTING¬ITS¬CARBON¬FOOTPRINT¬
NEARLY¬BY¬¬SINCE¬¬
s¬2EDUCING¬ITS¬ENERGY¬USE¬BY¬
¬SINCE¬¬
s¬2EDUCING¬GREENHOUSE¬GAS¬
EMISSIONS¬BY¬¬SINCE¬¬
s¬"ECOMING¬RECOGNIZED¬AS¬ONE¬
OF¬THE¬BEST
PERFORMING¬53¬
MANUFACTURING¬INDUSTRIES¬BY¬
the EPA.
!ND¬STEELS¬ENVIRONMENTAL¬
IMPACT¬CONTINUES¬TO¬DROP
WWWAISCORGSUSTAINABILITY
Circle no. 22 or http://architect.hotims.com
60
PRODUCTS
Virtual Design
FOR REAL
The University of
Minnesota Virtual Reality
Design Lab (VRDL) recently
installed a VR system in
Rapson Hall, where the
schools of architecture and
landscape architecture
reside. The brainchild of
architecture associate
professor Lee Anderson,
the VRDL platform
Using a mobile device’s allows multiple users to
camera feature, Urbasee experience immersive,
Project superimposes stereoscopic VR while
virtual models—in this roaming about Rapson
case, HWKN’s Wendy— Courtyard with wireless
onto the camera image. headsets. The platform
offers more than 900
square feet of tracked area
with room to grow. “We’re
pushing the boundaries
in several areas, including
REMEMBER THE HYPE around virtual reality? design meetings. Meanwh w ile, Urbasee Future the size of the space that
The movement to create digitally l constructed superimposes virtual building models to scale we’re using, which is really
environmen
n ts that stand in for real experi- onto their proposed sites. Both programs require big for a virtual reality
ences took off in the 1990s with the develop- KMZ-format a georeferenced files, such as those system,” Anderson told the
Minnesota Daily.
ment of computing technologies and gaming produced by SketchUp. Otherwise, the tools are
software. For architects looking to communi- d to go—no headset or cables required.
ready
cate their designs with greater realism, an im- These aperture-styl y e VR tools do not pro-
mersiv i e, stereoscopic visualization technique vide stereoscopic immersion, but the develop-
1968
holds much appeal. However, virtual reality ment of wireless technologies that a can delivi er
(VR) has been cumbersome to implement; VR large amounts of real-time data has enabled the
labs often rely l on the Cava e Automatic Virtual first generata ion of full-immersion VR systems in
n
Environmen t model—a small enclosure that a semi-mobile format. At the Univ i ersity of Min-
limits the experience to one person at a time. nesota, wh
w ere I teach, facult l y in the College of
Consequently ly, not many
n people hav a e been seen Design and the Digital Design Consortium hav a e The year in which
wearing VR headsets lately l . developed such a tool (see “For Real,” at a right).
Ivan Sutherland
But VR is far from extinct—in fact, it’s Despite their capabilities, the tablet and
finallyl gaining traction, garnering increased in- wireless VR-based tools hav a e their limitations,
created
terest from Hollywood
l as well as the military,
y including seamless tracking. In my m experience, the “head-
aerospace, medical, and gaming industries. the smoothness of Urbasee’s operation varies mounted three
The proliferation of mobile computing, wire- with the strength of the GPS signal. The Univ i er- dimensional
less, and GPS technologies has enabled VR to sity of Minnesota VR tool also has time-delays a display.” The
escape the lab. Now, architects can use VR as a in its deliv
i ery of wireless data—a problem that heavy forerunner
productiv i e, on-the-go tool, untethered from the the team is currently l troubleshooting.
of virtual reality
cumbersome hardware of the past. Economics is another challenge. While
GPS-enabled mobile electronic platforms the visualization of one project is free, Urbasee
headsets had to
on tablet computers or smartphones can simu- charges more than $1,000 per year for addition- be suspended
from the ceiling.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
alternate world. The most compelling VR appli- for educational purposes, non-univ i ersity enti- PROCESSING
simulated data onto the visible world. Nevertheless, these approaches demon-
The French company n Urbasee has released strate the extent to which VR—now freed from
two such architectural applicat a ions. Urbasee the dark recesses of the cav a e—is becoming sig-
Text by Blaine Brownell Project brings 2D drawings to life, tethering nificantlyl more accessible and publicly l visible. → MORE PRODUCTS AT
Illustration by Peter Arkle virtual models to tabletop plans for enhanced Soon, we may a all be stepping into our designs. ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Want to Build Your Business by Building Your Team?
Get to Class...and Get Your Credits!
www.BlueBookUniversity.com
Introducing BlueBookUniversity.com – the construction industry’s newest The Blue Boo ookk Un
U iv
i er
e si
sity
tyy Cam
ampu
p s Bo
Bookk Sto
tore
re pr
provid
i es a broad inventory of
source for online continuing education. Now you annd yo
your team have direc
ectt refe
refeereenc
ncee manuals, cododee boookoks,
s DVDs and downloadable content to help
access to one complete, comprehensive online education sol
olution. keep you up-to-d -datee an
andd in formed of industry best practices. Plus, Blue Book
i fo
Premier NeNetwworkk Me
M mbmbers are eligible for discounts on all educ
u at
atio
ionn co
cour
urse
sess
BlueBookUniversity.com offers an ag a gregat a ed
e sel e ection of CE courses, and book store ppururch
chases!
programs and publications targeted to thhe co
commmmere cial
a cconstruction industry.
Powered by three of the nation’s leading onllin i e ed
e uc
u ation providers, Want to build your businesss? Dev
e el
e op yyou a an
ourr team
am a d do iitt wi
with
th edu
duca
catition
onn.
BlueBookUniversity.com provides the specifiic coourrse con ontent necessary to
meet your license requirements and developopp yyou
our team
ou
our t m.
te Gett to cla
Ge lass and vis he new Bl
isitit the B ue
ueBo
B ok
BookUn
Univ
i er
iversi
sity
ty.c
.com
o to
om toda
daay.
y
Visit us at
november 2012
photo: dana hoff
AIA VOICES
history buff | preservation and place in charleston
Glenn Keyes, AIA, is a preservation architect based in Charleston, S.C., gave it a concrete-and-steel-framed structure (recessed into the
who has consulted with communities affected by hurricanes, including 32-inch-thick masonry walls) to comply with the county’s request.
Hugo in 1989 and Katrina in 2005. He is a former staff architect for the We then reconstructed a period interior based on research and the
South Carolina Department of Archives and History and a current adviser investigation of the existing physical conditions.
to the National Trust for Historic Preservation. Since 1986, he has restored There is always a desire to put things back to the way they were
more than 150 churches, commercial buildings, museums, and houses as quickly as possible after a disaster, and I think that’s done to
in Charleston. the detriment of buildings sometimes. Scrambling to replace a roof
quickly isn’t always the best idea until you’ve had a chance to assess
charleston underwent a major change in its approach to the situation. The roofs needed to be dried in quickly, but people
preservation after Hurricane Hugo in 1989. The requirements for often hired the first roofer that knocked on the door. Since that
buildings, reflected in the codes, reinterpreted preservation in time, we have replaced many expensive slate and metal roofs that
the way we treat windows, roofing, and seismic retrofits. Codes were installed improperly after Hugo hit. So a measured approach
required us to tie down roof structures when possible in historic is always best in a disaster recovery situation. Charleston’s Board of
rehabilitations and to protect window openings. The earthquake of Architecture Review was great about material requirements after the
1886 was also a pivotal moment—and the subsequent reconstruction hurricane. It was tempting for the city to say, “OK, you can put on
gave us a lot of the buildings we seek to protect today—but we’re still an asphalt shingle roof.” Instead, it said, “If you had a slate roof,
on a fault line and continue to have tremors. So, with our historic you have to put a slate roof back on,” thus protecting the historic
buildings, we do what we can. integrity of the city’s architecture.
Take the Charleston County Courthouse, completed in 1792, There is a future for architects trained in preservation. There has
which had been gutted seven times in its history. After Hugo, been so much research on historic materials and methods done on so
the county asked us to seismically retrofit the building as part of many successful preservation projects completed over the last 30 years.
a major restoration. Of course, by that time the interior was not As architects, it’s a great time to be involved in a growing field.
considered historic—having been gutted so many times—so we —As told to William Richards
Unusual items froom extraordinary places—a collection
of boutique items curated foor those who appreciate good design.
For your home or office, for you, the architect in your life,
or your young architeect-to-be, the AIA Store offers special
gifts,
if jewelry,
j l books,
b k greeting cards, and toys and games.
T H R E E W A Y S T O S H O P
Store
www.aia.org/store
65
AIA NOW
across the institute
Compiled by William Richards
5
1. Style Profile. Call it arbitrary or call it
fundamental, but style—the design rules a
building follows or breaks—is a calculation
in the process of creating architecture. But
how does style contribute to the definition
november 2012
of design excellence? After the taxonomies
of the 19th and 20th centuries, does style
even matter anymore? If sustainability is the
measure of excellent design these days, can 2
we consider it a style unto itself? Join the AIA
Committee on Design and the AIA Historic
Resources Committee to investigate these
questions and others in Seville, Spain,
from Nov. 11 to 17.
n Learn more at network.aia.org/committeeondesign.
Field Survey
Where are the gaps
in preservation
education?
november 2012
AIAFEATURE
as being guided solely by emotion and “A love of place and historic buildings tends to be the gateway
sentiment. Daniel Bluestone, direc- drug that gets young people interested in architecture in the first
tor of the University of Virginia School place,” Wilson says.
of Architecture’s historic preservation Typically, 25 percent of applicants to the Clemson program were
certificate program, argues that the what Wilson calls “frustrated architecture students.” These students
advent of New Urbanism and sus- had formal architecture training, and, after earning their preservation
tainability has brought preservation degrees, they usually went on to work in architecture firms, she says.
november 2012
closer to the center of architectural “Yet they had lost their opportunity to become licensed architects
production and challenged the idea because they weren’t receiving a Master of Architecture.”
that “preservation architect” is an Without architects in leadership roles in historic preservation,
oxymoron. Designing and working buildings suffer and education suffers, according to Hugh C. Miller,
within a historic context, he says, are FAIA, a former chief historical architect for the National Park Service
not mutually exclusive processes. and a professor and thesis director for Goucher College’s Master
More than a decade later, that is of Arts in Historic Preservation program (of which this author is a
still often the case. Architects inter- graduate). “The profession is complicated, and the whole building
ested in preservation often have to industry is very complicated,” he says. “The trend in preservation
choose between going for a Master education is that we’re really training generalists. They get a pretty
of Architecture degree or a Master good immersion in the preservation process, but they don’t get very
of Historic Preservation. Rarely much in terms of its application to the practice of architecture.”
can they get both without a major The concepts of preservation related to culture and context are
outlay of time and money. The multi- inherent in most theory, history, and design studios already, Wilson
disciplinary nature of historic preser- adds. “It probably isn’t presented as preservation, but it is there.”
vation (some might call it fragmented) Without preservation training, architects naturally have less
also means that preservation pro- appreciation for character-defining features of historic buildings,
grams are housed not only in archi- or their historic context, says Bruce D. Judd, FAIA, principal of the
tecture schools, but also in history Bruce Judd Consulting Group in Seaside, Fla., and an adjunct assistant
or urban planning departments, professor in the Goucher program. “Many people think that, if you’re
museum studies majors, or as stand- a ‘real’ architect, you can design something that is magnificent
alone programs. and put your ego into it; and if you’re a preservation architect, you
“Within undergraduate architec- subvert your ego in many ways,” he says. “It may be that you need
tural education, preservation is almost both those elements to work on historic buildings successfully.”
nonexistent,” Sandmeier says. “That “Preservation education gives you a much better understanding
is a puzzle to me. Most architectural when you have to interface with an existing building,” Judd says.
schools are looking to train architects, “Many people do a terrible job—they overwhelm the original building
but they’re giving the students only with large unsympathetic additions, or don’t understand the
studio topics that deal with creating importance of character-defining features.”
something new on a blank site with Architecture schools also provide a fertile environment in which
no context, or in a fake environment. to explore a deeper understanding of the intersection between
There’s certainly a place for think- preservation and sustainability. As architects chase after LEED
ing outside the box, but 95 points, architecture and preservation students are increasingly being
percent of graduates challenged to consider alternative definitions of sustainability that
will be working on take cultural issues, building and material life cycles, and economics
projects that have to into account. “When people talk about green buildings and existing
do with existing struc- buildings, my sense is there is a lot of mythology,” Miller says. “Is the
tures, with context greenest building the one that’s already built? It depends. How do
in an urban environ- you improve the envelope performance? Are there outdated systems
ment, or in a historic landscape. that need to be replaced?”
Students aren’t getting the whole picture. Several architecture schools and stand-alone preservation
I’m trying to change that within our school, programs are adding a sustainability element in the form of a course
because what we do is not preservation as a treatment or an additional certificate. The Goucher’s program, for example,
approach but rehabilitation, which is a much more interesting has a two-semester course on preservation and sustainability that
concept to architects.” requires students to produce a publishable, vetted white paper on
“The architecture profession is inclusive—we work in teams some aspect of the field.
comprising many specialties, and the schools should reflect this “I think there’s increasing interest in this world, due to
reality,” says Ashley R. Wilson, AIA, currently the Graham Gund environmental and resource issues and contextual issues,” says U.Va.’s
Architect for the National Trust for Historic Preservation and a Daniel Bluestone. “As society is becoming increasingly global and
professor in the Clemson University/College of Charleston master’s homogenous, we are more intensely interested in feeling rooted in
program in preservation. place, and that means tapping into the heritage of particular localities.”
68
AIAFEATURE
The down economy, ironically, has been a boon to preservation Tulane University, Preservation University of Minnesota, Architec-
architects as well. “When the economy is not doing very well, people Studies, New Orleans, La. ture—Heritage, Conservation and
have a tendency to go back and work on their existing buildings,” University of Colorado, Denver, Preservation, Minneapolis, Minn.
Judd says. Historic Preservation, Denver, Colo. University of Oregon,
That may be true, but if current trends in preservation education University of Delaware, Historic Historic Preservation, Eugene, Ore.
persist, will architects know what to do with them? Next year, the Preservation, Newark, Del. University of Pennsylvania, Historic
AIA, the National Architectural Accreditation Board, the Association University of Florida, Historic Preservation, Philadelphia, Pa.
november 2012
of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, the American Institute of Preservation, Gainesville, Fla. University of Southern California,
Architecture Students, and the National Council of Architectural University of Georgia, Historic Preservation,
Registration Boards, among others, will participate in the quinquen- Historic Preservation, Athens, Ga. Los Angeles, Calif.
nial Accreditation Review Conference. Already, the AIA is soliciting University of Kentucky, Historic University of Texas,
input from members about what the conference should cover and how Preservation, Lexington, Ky. Historic Preservation, Austin, Texas
architectural education should evolve. Where historic preservation University of Maryland, Historic University of Vermont, Historic
will fit in remains to be seen. Preservation, College Park, Md. Preservation, Burlington, Vt.
“The preservation field is thriving,” Wilson says. “It is the architec- University of Massachusetts, Ursuline College, Historic
ture programs that are losing out by not taking ownership of the dis- Historic Preservation, Amherst, Mass. Preservation, Pepper Pike, Ohio
cipline. The preservationist and the architect share the ultimate belief:
that we are serving something bigger than ourselves—that we create Graduate programs with a historic preservation option
places where people can flourish.” If that is true, then the academy is California State Polytechnic University, University of Illinois, at Urbana–
perfectly poised to help those two professions to coexist. Architecture, Pomona, Calif. Champaign, Architecture,
Colorado State University, Public Champaign, Ill.
History, Fort Collins, Colo. University of North Carolina at
n To learn more about preservation issues, including education, visit aia.org/hrc.
George Washington University, Greensboro, Several Programs
American Studies, Washington, D.C. Greensboro, N.C.
Undergraduate programs in historic preservation Middle Tennessee State University, University of Texas, several
American College of the Building Salve Regina University, Cultural and Public History, Murfreesboro, Tenn. programs, Austin, Texas
Arts, Applied Science in the Building Historic Preservation, Newport, R.I. University of Delaware, Urban
Arts, Charleston, S.C. Savannah College of Art & Design, Affairs & Public Policy, Newark, Del.
Boston Architectural College, Historic Preservation, Savannah, Ga.
Design Studies, Boston, Mass. S.E. Missouri State University, Certificate programs in historic preservation
Belmont College, Historic Preservation,
Bucks County Community College, University of Southern California,
Building Preservation and Cape Girardeau, Mo.
Historic Preservation, Newtown, Pa. Historic Preservation,
Restoration, St. Clairsville, Ohio University of Mary Washington,
National Center for Preservation Los Angeles, Calif.
College of Charleston, Historic Historic Preservation,
Technology and Training, Materials University of Arizona, Heritage
Preservation, Charleston, S.C. Fredericksburg, Va.
Science, New York, N.Y. Conservation, Tucson, Ariz.
Roger Williams University, Ursuline College, Historic
Historic Preservation, Bristol, R.I. Preservation, Pepper Pike, Ohio RESTORE, Materials Science, University of Cincinnati, Historic
New York, N.Y. Preservation, Cincinnati, Ohio
Graduate programs in historic preservation Rutgers University, Historic University of Florida, Historic
Preservation, New Brunswick, N.J. Preservation, Gainesville, Fla.
Ball State University, Georgia State University, Savannah College of Art & Design, University of Hawaii, Manoa,
Historic Preservation, Muncie, Ind. Heritage Preservation, Atlanta, Ga. Historic Preservation, Historic Preservation,
Boston Architectural College, Goucher College, Historic Savannah, Ga. Honolulu, Hawaii
Design Studies, Boston, Mass. Preservation, Baltimore, Md. School of the Art Institute of University of New Mexico, Historic
Boston University, Plymouth State University, Chicago, Historic Preservation, Preservation and Regionalism,
Preservation Studies, Boston, Mass. Heritage Studies, Plymouth, N.H. Chicago, Ill. Albuquerque, N.M.
Clemson University & College of Pratt Institute, Historic Texas A&M University, Historic University of North Carolina
Charleston, Historic Preservation Preservation, New York, N.Y. Preservation, College Station, Texas at Greensboro, Historic Preservation,
Charleston, S.C. Roger Williams University, Tulane University, Preservation Greensboro, N.C.
Columbia University, Historic Historic Preservation, Bristol, R.I. Studies, New Orleans, La. University of Texas at San Antonio,
Preservation, New York, N.Y. Rutgers University, Cultural University of Colorado, Historic Historic Preservation,
Cornell University, Historic Heritage and Preservation, Preservation, Denver, Colo. San Antonio, Texas
Preservation Planning, Ithaca, N.Y. New Brunswick, N.J. University of Georgia, Historic University of Utah, Historic
Delaware State University, Historic Savannah College of Art & Design Preservation, Athens, Ga. Preservation, Salt Lake City, Utah
Preservation, Dover, Del. Historic Preservation, Savannah, Ga. University of Maryland, Historic University of Virginia, Historic
Eastern Michigan University, School of the Art Institute of Preservation, College Park, Md. Preservation, Charlottesville, Va.
Historic Preservation, Chicago, Historic Preservation, University of Pennsylvania, Historic University of Washington, Historic
Ypsilanti, Mich. Chicago, Ill. Preservation, Philadelphia, Pa. Preservation, Seattle, Wash.
Member Since 2010
Joseph Mayo, Assoc.
A soc. AIA
ne, AIA
R. Corey Clayborne,
Member Since 2004
Virginia E. Marquardt, AIA
Virgi
Member Since 2004
Membe
Engage. colleagues—a valuable professional resource to draw upon, and a powerful, collective voice
to advocate for a stronger economic climate for architects nationwide. Join today and make
an investment in your future.
*Some restrictions apply. Learn more, and review contest terms and conditions at www.aia.org/joinnow.
70
AIA PERSPECTIVE
frozen music
november 2012
]Ê >`
`Ê ÌiÊ onlyÊ
iÊ ÜÌÊ >Ê Ü>Ã>LiÊ «ÀiwÌiÀÊ v
ÀÊ Ài>LiÊ
«iÀv
À>ViÊ >`Ê iÝÌi`i
i`Ê wÌiÀÊ vi°Ê 8
,/",Ê ÜÌÊ
*Ê ÃiÌÌiÃÊ ÌiÊ `iL>ÌiÊ
>L
ÕÌÊ >`Ê `ÀÞiÀÊ Þ}iiÊ LÞÊ `iÛiÀ}Ê Vi>]Ê wÌiÀi`]Ê «ÕÀwi`Ê >ÀÊ >ÃÊ
ÞÊ
`ÊivwViÌÞ°Ê/iÊ
*ÊwÌÀ>Ì
ÊÃÞÃÌiÊÃÊ
ÜÊ>Û>>LiÊ
8
,/",ÊV>ÊqÊv>ÃÌÊ>`
>ÃÊ>Ê
«Ì
>Ê8
,/",
,Êvi>ÌÕÀi]Ê
ÀÊV>Êi>ÃÞÊLiÊÀiÌÀ
wÌÌi`ÊÌ
ÊiÝÃÌ}ÊÕÌð
Ciirc
rcle no. 1
19
96 or http://arc
chi
hite
tect.hotims.com
m
#
!!
#
®
"
"
!
"!"!
!
"
!
"
| STYLISH | MODERN
CLASSIC
Copyright © 2012 Sargent Manufacturing Company, an ASSA ABLOY Group company. All rights reserved.
Circle no. 405 or http://architect.hotims.com
CENTER
73
in “Study of Perspective—
Tiananmen Square” (detail,
this page). The photograph
appears in the Museum of
Modern Art exhibition 9+1
Ways of Being Political: 50
Years of Political Stances
in Architecture and Urban
Design, reviewed on page 112.
74
CENTER
PROFILE
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
Mark Lee and Sharon JOHNSTON MARKLEE IS HAVING A BREAKOUT YEAR. BUT UNLIKE THE PREVIOUS
Johnston, AIA, in a GENERATION OF OUTSPOKEN LOS ANGELES ARCHITECTS, THE FIRM’S INFLUENCES
conference room in their
firm’s Los Angeles office.
EXTEND WELL BEYOND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
The two architects just
secured the commission Text by Christopher Hawthorne obsessions: a mock-up of the cover of their book
for the Drawing Institute House Is a House Is a House Is a House, wh
w ich
on the legendary Menil will be published next year by Springer Vienna,
Collection campus in
Houston, beating out
OF ALL THE QUESTIONS I posed to the Los and a model of a preliminary design for the
an impressive list of Angeles architects Sharon Johnston, AIA, and Drawing Institute at the Menil Collection in
contenders. Mark Lee, wh
w o run an increasingly l busy practice Houston.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
together under the name Johnston Marklee & Johnston Marklee won the Drawing
Associates, the one that elicited wh
w at I found Institute commission last summer, giv i ing the
to be the most telling response had to do with two partners by far the biggest break of their
PREVIOUS PAGE: AI WEIWEI;
their relationship with other emerging firms in 14-year career together. They prevailed in a
THIS PAGE: JOE PUGLIESE
Southern California. We
W were sitting in a long, competition that produced one of the most
all-wh
w ite conference room in their office, wh
w ich intriguing architectural shortlists of recent
is located just north of Wilshire Boulevard in memory; the other finalists were Tokyo’s
W st Los Angeles. On a table in the middle of
We Sanaa, London’s Dava id Chipperfield Architects
the room were totems of the firm’s current (who had alreadyd produced a larger master
Circle no. 504 or http://architect.hotims.com
76
CENTER
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
The Hill House in plan for the Menil campus), and the Mexico more opportunity for that kind of engagement
Pacific Palisades, Calif., City architect Tatiana Bilbao. across continents because of publications,
a 3,600-square-foot As Johnston clicked through a series of because of technology—all the things that
single family residence
completed in 2004, was
images of the firm’s recent work—a mixture make the marketplace bigger.”
designed for an irregularly of houses, small pavilions, competition entries, Lee added, “We always feel a bit like
shaped hillside lot. The and installation designs in the U.S., Europe, and outsiders in L.A., but not complete outliers.
program sought to South America—it quickly became apparent We find more of a community outside the
maximize the allowable
that the pair, married since 1998, is in some U.S. In Europe or Latin America, it’s more
volume permitted by
zoning regulations while ways more closely associated with a group of possible for very open dialogue than with
minimizing the house’s well-traveled youngish architects from around our L.A. colleagues.”
foundations and footprint. the world than with its home city of L.A. Lee, who is 45, grew up in Hong Kong
Again and again, she’d introduce a and moved with his sister to Claremont, a
project—Ordos in Mongolia, the Solo Houses tree-lined college town about 30 miles east
in Spain, the post-earthquake META pavilions of downtown Los Angeles, near the end of
in southern Chile—in which Johnston Marklee high school. He studied architecture at the
contributed a design along with a small group University of Southern California. He met
of other firms. And the same names kept Johnston—who is 47, grew up in Malibu,
coming up: Office, the firm run by Kersten and graduated from Stanford University—
Geers and David Van Severen in Belgium. when both were earning master’s degrees
Bilbao, their competitor at the Menil. Studio at Harvard University’s Graduate School of
Mumbai of India. Sou Fujimoto, from Tokyo. Design. The pair opened their office in 1998,
Given their membership in this multinational after Johnston moved back to Los Angeles. Lee
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
group, I asked Lee and Johnston, did they feel had been living in Switzerland, teaching at the
any similar connection or sense of kinship Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH)
with L.A. architects around their age? in Zurich. That set the tone for a practice that
Johnston’s response was immediate. “Not continues to have one foot in California and
really,” she said with a shrug. the other somewhere else.
ERIC STAUDENMAIER
www.bentley.com/Architect
© 2012 Bentley Systems, Incorporated. Bentley, the “B” Bentley logo and ProjectWise are either registered or unregistered trademarks or service marks of Bentley Systems, Incorporated or one of its direct or indirect wholly owned subsidiaries.
Other brands and product names are trademarks of their respective owners.
Circle no. 199 or http://architect.hotims.com
CENTER
INSPIRED BY
PASSION.
DESIGNED FOR
PERFORMANCE.
WELCOME TO
THE WORLD
OF SPANISH
CERAMIC TILE.
The 2004 Sale House in before them: the so-called L.A. School, made
Venice, Calif., a single- up of Frank Gehry, Eric Owen Moss, Franklin
family residence, was Israel, and Thom Mayne and Michael Rotondi
commissioned after the
of Morphosis, among others. This group
previous house on the site
was destroyed in a fire. An of architects not only emerged together
adjacent garage and studio from the same place—the west side of Los
designed by California- Angeles, specifically Santa Monica, Venice,
based Morphosis
and Culver City—in the 1980s, but their work
Architects in 1978 survived
the blaze and helped shared a number of formal and conceptual
inform Johnston Marklee’s preoccupations.
design. One should be careful not to overstate the
collegiality of the L.A School. Its architects were
fiercely competitive with one another and often
conflicted, as self-styled rebels, about accepting
membership in any movement or collective.
Be inspired by texture, be surprised by (“The first time I heard of Frank Gehry I was 38
years old,” Mayne once said.) Still, at least as
dimension. Rethink the possibilities.
viewed from the outside—from New York, say,
For innovative design and boundless or Tokyo—the L.A. School made up a coherent
group that took American architecture in a
inspiration visit the single
specific and barbed direction. And in the days
source for over 200 Spanish before the Internet arrived to distribute images
ceramic tile manufacturers. of new architecture instantly around the world,
the L.A School architects worked in relative
Tile of Spain - Trade Commission of Spain geographic isolation. Their primary audience
FIND 305.446.4387 miami@mcx.es was one another.
INSPIRATION! Nothing similar could be said about the
current crop of L.A. architects now in their 40s
and 50s, who make up a diffuse group. There
are the sunny, effortlessly savvy houses of
Barbara Bestor, deeply connected to place and
ERIC STAUDENMAIER
www.taktl-llc.com
Circle no. 584 or http://architect.hotims.com
CENTER
INSPIRING
POSSIBILITIES
with 3D models for Revit®
and Google™ SketchUp
Walden Wilson in Culver City, Calif., an 800-square-foot studio and garage completed in 2003, features a baffled
skylight and an exterior clad in cement fiber board panels.
Palisades section of Los Angeles, it is evident in of interior space into a building that seems to
the building’s dramatic rhomboid form. touch the steep hillside not with work boots but
The house, completed in 2004 and widely with ballet slippers.
published since, was a spec project. Though the “We tried to see the hillside ordinance
owners of the lot appreciated contemporary not as a policing device, but as a design
architecture and sought out Johnston Marklee, opportunity,” Lee said matter-of-factly.
they also wanted to maximize their square The Hill House is also very much an
footage. At the same time, the new house had L.A. design. The waterproof cement finish
to meet L.A.’s rigorous, even oppressive, hillside that wraps the exterior is tinted a very faint
Ultra Series Folding Doors building ordinance, which mandates significant lavender to pick up the colors of the Eucalyptus
setbacks from the lot line and strict height trunks that rise around it. And the use of the
limits. The setbacks are measured from where stucco-like material itself, and the rather banal
the house comes out of the ground, not from way it sheathes this otherwise otherworldly
Download at how far it hangs over the hillside. As a result, architectural shape, is a nod to all kinds of local
www.kolbe-kolbe.com/architectlibrary Lee and Johnston pushed the main floor out as precedents, most notably Gehry’s deadpan early
far as they could, then pinched the lower level buildings (the Danziger Studio, say) and the L.A.
back toward the hill. streetscape photography of the artist Ed Ruscha.
The pinching both produced the house’s Similarly flexible in both its materials
most memorable moment—when you stand and its relationship to Los Angeles is Johnston
at the corner of the living room, looking out Marklee’s retail outlet, on Santa Monica
over the canyon, with a tiny sliver of Pacific Boulevard in Beverly Hills, created for the
ERIC STAUDENMEIR
Ocean visible above the treetops to the west, Belgian designer Martin Margiela. The shop,
you feel that you’re on the prow of a ship, which opened in 2007, features a faÇade
with no architectural mass beneath you—and covered with shimmering white plastic discs.
allowed the architects to pack 3,600 square feet The choice was inspired by the architects’
Circle no. 40 or http://architect.hotims.com
This is the Next Revolution in LED Outdoor Lighting.
This is Kim Lighting.
www.kimlighting.com/products/altitude
Circle no. 445 or http://architect.hotims.com
Weaver™ BLOCK ©2010 modularArts, Inc.
CENTER
PPATE
PAT ENDI
NDI
ATEENTT PEEND
ND
EN
N D NG
DIIN G
View House in Rosario, Argentina, completed in 2009, makes use of natural light and
passive ventilation to minimize the need for mechanical systems. The 3,000-square-
foot, torus-shaped structure also has expansive views of the surrounding landscape.
immersion in Margiela’s archive, where they roughly 20,000 square feet, wrapped in gray
discovered dresses covered in plastic sequins. brick and snaking around three courtyards,
The discs Johnston Marklee specified are made each containing a large existing live oak tree.
in Germany and used as reflectors on road Like Renzo Piano’s Menil galleries and the other
signs, embedding in the design a sly nod to buildings that make up the museum campus,
L.A. car culture. such as the Rothko Chapel by Philip Johnson
Taken together, these projects and others and Houston architects Howard Barnstone and
like them—including a chiseled concrete house Eugene Aubry, the design has a frankness and
finished in Rosario, Argentina, in 2009, and a a domestic character, and it takes advantage of
series of buildings in Marfa, Texas—suggest the parklike setting. Though the scale is small,
a firm, like many of Johnston Marklee’s the program incorporates not just exhibition
generation, that is picking up momentum but space for works on paper but studios and
still finding its voice. That’s one reason the conservation rooms.
Menil commission came as such a surprise. According to Helfenstein, the clarity of
“They are young, and they haven’t built Johnston Marklee’s competition entry made
that many things,” said Josef Helfenstein, the the firm a good fit for that context: “There
Menil’s director. “There is a tendency in these was a minimalism and efficiency in their
Clark™ BLOCK ©2012 modularArts, Inc.
commissions to choose a big name. I think it proposal, very much serving the cause and
took some courage on the part of our trustees not advertising itself or pointing out itself. I
not to do that.” thought that was encouraging and refreshing.
GUSTAVO FRITTEGOTTO
The plans for the Drawing Institute And very much in the spirit of this institution.”
remain preliminary and have not yet been I know what Helfenstein means when he
released to the public. Johnston Marklee has says that, but it wouldn’t be entirely accurate to
proposed a single-story building, encompassing call Johnston and Lee simply minimalists, as if
86
CENTER
IN PERSON AND IN THEIR ARCHITECTURE, JOHNSTON AND LEE AIM FOR A KIND OF ACCESSIBLE
MYSTERY; THE WORK IS VEILED, BUT THE VEIL IS LIGHT AND EASILY REMOVED.
Enhanced
nhanced Per
Performance
erforma conceptual complexity to their work—subtle,
but present all the same. It’s visible in the
R Hatches
hes
firm’s proposal for the huge Grand Traiano Art
Complex just southeast of Rome—a hillside stack
of big boxes—and in its design, still awaiting
funding, for new University of California at
for Green Building Los Angeles graduate art studios in Culver City,
which call for a vaulted polycarbonate roof
Applications covering a kind of interior city.
I’m also not sure I’d agree with the Houston
Chronicle, which in a headline announcing the
results of the Drawing Institute competition
described Johnston and Lee as “glam L.A.
architects.” Their connections in the fashion
and art worlds and their own sense of style
might lead one to that conclusion. (Lee was
Our Most wearing suspenders over a black T-shirt the day
Energy-Efficient we talked at the office, and both architects are
Model Yet! prominently bespectacled even by the standards
of the profession.) But in person and in their
architecture, Johnston and Lee aim for a kind of
accessible mystery; the work is veiled, but the
LEED is a reegistered veil is light and easily removed.
trademark of the U.S. Available in a number
Green Build ding Council As Lee put it, “We do strive for a certain
of standard sizes
reticence, but it’s not an aloofness. It’s not
being elitist. I think in a way it’s an aura we use
as a kind of protection. But if people want to
t Energy efficiency exceeds standard hatches by more than 48% penetrate it they can.”
t Meets LEED® standards for recycled content To get a final reading, I emailed Kersten
t High solar reflective index (SRI) Geers of Office, which has often worked
t Ozone-friendly polyisocyanurate insulation side-by-side with Johnston Marklee on group
projects. He described their architecture as “part
t EPDM gasketing with enhanced weather-resistance
pragmatism, part show, part tongue in cheek,
but most of all very intelligent.”
For more information call 800-366-6530 Geers knows Southern California well; he
and his Office partner, Van Severen, met while
or log on to www.bilco.com
living in Southern California in their 20s. As a
result, he zeroed right in on the complicated
relationship Johnston and Lee enjoy with Los
Angeles and the L.A. firms that came before
them. In their work, he wrote, “It is possible that
there are some connections with [older] L.A.
architects—Owen Moss, perhaps, Gehry—but
always without the forced exuberance. More
dry, less outspoken.”
He added, “L.A. has always been a strange
place, a kind of Western Eden, as much artificial
as it is aware of it. Mark and Sharon are a
perfect product of that ambivalent scene.”
We’re primed to
make your job
worry-free.
PPG Architectural Coatings knows
you have more than paint to worry
about — that’s our job. So, count on
our 100 years of experience, full range
of quality products and services,
color expertise, and on-site support to
get the job done right from the start.
ppgpro.com
THE CITY
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
MAPPING MOTOWN
DETROIT WORKS IS UNVEILING A LONG-TERM STRATEGIC VISION TO
COMBAT THE CITY’S ILLS. TWO LOCAL ARCHITECTS WERE GIVEN THE
DIFFICULT TASK OF GETTING RESIDENTS AND OFFICIALS TO BUY IN.
7,000
The number
of new jobs
projected in
the city of
Detroit by
2030.
300,000
Dan Kinkead (left) of IT’S IMPOSSIBLE to talk about Detroit without residents live in the city’s 139 square miles.
Hamilton Anderson talking about poverty. What relevance does But most haven’t yet benefited from the
Associates and Dan design have in neighborhoods lined by miles revival of investment in downtown and
Pitera of the Detroit
of abandoned bungalows, where families Midtown—where companies such as
The number
Collaborative Design
Center stand amid navigate patchy streetlighting and unreliable Chrysler, Quicken Loans, and Twitter are of new jobs
newly planted trees in a bus service? In April, the city government’s relocating thousands of jobs. Southeastern
stormwater-infiltration ongoing fiscal crisis led to a brokered consent A host of neighborhood groups,
forest at Detroit’s agreement with the state, a last stop before nonprofits, and other organizations are trying Michigan is
Latham Park. The two
projected to
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
architects helped
emergency management and bankruptcy. to alleviate the city’s ills, but without the
With the usual systems of power cracked benefit of a strategic framework. Enter Detroit
manage the long-term gain during
arm of Detroit Works. at the core, numerous artists, entrepreneurs, Works, an exceptionally comprehensive—and
and urban thinkers are experimenting in controversial—planning effort unveiled in the same
Detroit, infusing the streets with a slow-burn 2010 by Mayor Dave Bing and supported period.
creativity. But it’s naive—and offensive—to by funding from the Kresge Foundation,
pretend that Detroit is a “blank canvas,” a $3.1 billion philanthropic organization
as many newcomers and reporters have headquartered in Troy, Mich. The project’s
suggested. It’s not. More than 700,000 initial launch was inept and acrimonious,
Circle no. 413 or http://architect.hotims.com
90
CENTER
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
needs of each neighborhood. other hand, are often close to current environmental creating surface lakes that capture stormwater in
hazards or contaminated land and closed schools. But, high-vacancy areas to creating forested buffers around
“You have to identify those neighborhoods in many cases, they are also close to some of the city’s industrial zones. The buffers would serve as visual and
where you want to concentrate your best assets. The Detroit Works framework suggests sound barriers and would help lessen the impact of
population,” Chris Brown, Detroit’s chief ways to maximize land-use and assets in each of the pollutants on adjacent neighborhoods.
Outsulation offers a wide variety of finishes to suit the aesthetic needs of your next project.
Who would Whatever your answer, you’re correct. An Outsulation® system by Dryvit is as much a
love Outsulation practical solution as it is an aesthetic one. Practically speaking, it solves the challenge
more, Picasso of providing exterior continuous insulation in one simple step. And because that’s
or Einstein? the most energy-efficient way to insulate a building, it meets the energy code, too.
In fact, by October 18, 2013, exterior continuous insulation will be required for most
Yes. commercial buildings. And when it comes to aesthetics, Outsulation has a wide
palette of finishes ranging from granite to limestone to brick and more. So, no
matter which side of the brain guides you, Outsulation is sure to inspire.
operating officer, told a Bloomberg BusinessWeek working class black people, he’s viewed as an
reporter in May. “We’re not going to light outsider telling locals what to do. His personal
distressed areas like we light other areas.” In asides are meant to communicate an alliance
other words, with the declining tax base, the city with residents as he presents data that emerged
simply cannot afford to provide the same level from nearly three years of planning work.
of services to every block, requiring decisions Kinkead is an architect with Hamilton
that will have a clear effect on residents in Anderson Associates (HAA), a firm founded
“distressed” areas. in Detroit in 1994 with a holistic approach to
Meanwhile, a team of planners is focusing architecture, landscape, and planning. HAA
not on the city’s day-to-day, but on its future. was chosen to help lead the technical team
The long-term planning arm of Detroit Works of Detroit Works’ long-term arm by Kresge,
is crafting a strategic framework for decision which is bankrolling the effort with $2.7
making—not a master plan—that assumes the million. (The Ford and W.K. Kellogg foundations
need to “raise the quality of life for all,” as the added $3 million to aid the technical team and
program’s leaders defined its primary goal. community outreach.) Kresge officials have
Detroit Works could be a game-changer. already pledged support for initiatives that
It could help residents chart a course for their arise from the project’s research.
own neighborhoods, become a guide for HAA’s office is in Detroit’s Harmonie
businesses looking to expand in the city, and Park, a part of town with a charged history of
help city officials (members of the planning urban planning failure. Locals are cultivating
commission and development departments are the revival of the area’s legendary Paradise
on the long-term arm’s steering committee) Valley arts district, adjacent to the Black Bottom
come up with strategic approaches for the neighborhood (named for its rich soil) where
investment of scant resources. much of Detroit’s black community lived prior
www.hanoverpavers.com
Or Detroit Works could sit prettily on a to World War II. In Black Bottom, boxer Joe
800.426.4242 shelf, largely unused. With the final results Louis grew up, trained, and, as reigning world
soon to be released, we’re about to find out champion, sponsored the Brown Bombers
whether City Hall will buy in to the long-term softball team. Jazz and blues clubs thrived, as
vision. The project’s effectiveness depends on did theaters and speakeasies.
the quality of conversations that its champions But, in the name of “urban renewal,” the
have with city officials, as well as with business city began demolishing swaths of Paradise
owners, nonprofit leaders, investors, activists, Valley and Black Bottom in the 1940s and ’50s.
and, of course, the hundreds of thousands of In their stead came the I-75 and I-375 freeways
residents who, as one east-sider put it, have “the and the 78-acre Lafayette Park complex,
brilliance of lived experience.” How calibrated designed by Ludwig Mies van der Rohe as a
Detroit Works is to that brilliance will define its model neighborhood (and is home to, more
future as rhetoric, or reality. recently, Comerica Park and Ford Field). With
no relocation plan, many displaced residents
We Are You, You Are Us moved into housing projects. The community’s
Dan Kinkead makes a point of mentioning that decimation is a charged memory that fuels
he lives in Detroit when he meets with city suspicion about Detroit Works. Hence the need
residents. He’s raising a daughter here. His stake for Kinkead to send the message to residents:
in the city’s future as a member of the Detroit We are you, you are us.
Works planning team is not just professional, Kinkead reports to Toni Griffin, who
it’s also personal. This is an important point. As heads long-term planning and, like HAA, was
a young white planner in a city dominated by handpicked by Kresge. Griffin also directs the
Our engineers have taken air movement to a new art form. From the sleek NASA-design airfoil blade to the
precision drive system, MacroAir fans are among the most efficient air movement products on earth. Using the
perfect 6ixBlade™ design to move large quantities of air with the least energy required, our fans employ high volume
and low speed to reduce energy use by 20% or more. One 24’ AirVolution fan can lower the effective temperature
of a 2,500 sq. ft. space by 5˚ to 15˚, dramatically lowering energy costs and improving circulation and comfort. Now
that’s a beautiful thing.
See a demonstration at macroairfans.com/demo
DOORS
MANUFACTURED
MA
M ANU
NU UFA
FACT
FACTUR
URED BY
RED
ED BY
AND ENTRANCE
SYSTEMS
tentative findings at community meetings,
where he starts conversations with a 50-minute
presentation. At a recent meeting, the piles of
information proved overwhelming to some
C.R.
R.. LAURENCE
C..R
C LA
AU
URRE CE COMPANY
ENC CO
CO
OMP
MPPA
AN
NY residents, who, poised to take notes, slowly
put down their pens.
One attendee said that Kinkead made an
impressive effort to be transparent by “putting
all the cards on the table,” a crucial counter to
obfuscating tactics of past planning projects
and residents’ suspicions that Detroit Works
was only looking to sell a plan it had already
made. But, the attendee added, “You don’t need
to show all the cards at once.”
This is one of the project’s biggest
challenges: sharing a large amount of data
in a way that engages residents instead of
overwhelming them. “We’re trying to take this
NEW! massive thing and land it so precisely on the
CRL14D DOORS ground,” Kinkead says.
Showcasing the largest selection of door The project’s long-term effort considers
systems in one catalog! Order, view or download 14 quality-of-life factors, such as safety, health,
at crlaurence.com.
and mobility. It introduces a goal for each
(for example, crime-free neighborhoods) and
suggests metrics (a reduction in crime relative
to total population) and strategies to achieve
those goals (forming effective community
watch groups, say). The framework emphasizes
that residents can define their own priorities
and their own ways to measure progress.
The analysis moves from hyperlocal to
citywide, encompassing land use, sustainable
neighborhood revitalization, and infrastructure;
it details ways that government, private, and
other Detroit-focused initiatives can be better
| 'All-Glass' Entrance and | Sliding and Stacking
ng Doors aligned with each other.
Storefront Systems | A Full Line of Nothing will improve quality of life more
| Commercial Patch Hardware Complementary than the reinvention of the economy, the plan
| Panic Handle Systems Accessory Items stipulates. Detroit needs job growth within
city limits and a strengthened tax base. While
most U.S. cities have between 35 and 75 jobs per
C.R. LAURENCE COMPANY 100 residents, Detroit has 26, according to data
800-233-8990tXXXDFSUBJOUFFEDPN
300'*/(t4*%*/(t53*.t%&$,*/(t3"*-*/(t'&/$&t'06/%"5*0/4
GYPSUM t$&*-*/(4t*/46-"5*0/t1*1&
39
A Premium under pver specify school open and instead close Neighborhood B’s
cavity w erforming
Building Enclosure all syste
ms.
school, which, they see in the framework, is in
an increasingly industrialized area.
Kinkead is especially interested in
how more sensitively chosen infrastructure
Percent can interweave neighborhoods with
of Detroit landscape, in contrast to Detroit’s history
residents of big infrastructure investment—namely,
freeways—which he calls “devastating.”
Straight 90º Corner 45º Corner T-Form Ledge Taper Top
ICF Concrete Cores are available in 4", 6", 8", 10" or 12" widths.
who work in “Now we have the opportunity to do soft
the city. infrastructure—seamless with the community,”
he says. Detroit has 37 square miles of open
61
space—more land than all of Manhattan. The
framework suggests creating holistic blue and
green landscape systems, adding trees and
lakes with both recreational and infrastructural
Percent of value. Dispersed ponds, for example, can aid
Circle no. 270 or http://architect.hotims.com stormwater management, easing the burden
residents who on city services while ensuring that residents
www.RewardWalls.com • 1-800-468-6344 work outside don’t face flooded streets on rainy days.
Full CAD details, BIM objects, and specs are available online
the city. But all of this is an idea, not an agenda.
! No planning trend will solve Detroit. No pet
uct
rod
Ne
w P How much R-Value project translates into the transformation of
an entire city.
do you need?
Boost-R Panels can be added to Reward ICFs to The Man Behind the Civic Outreach
add more insulation to achieve higher R-Values for When you meet Dan Pitera, you can hear the
any project! Achieve R-Values of R-30 and above! hum of his live-wire energy. As the leader of
BOOST- R
Panels TM
blog.rewardwalls.com/boostrpanels
Every child deserves to
attend a school filled with
clean and healthy air, where
energy and resources are
conserved, and dreams of
a bright future abound.
Green Apple™ is making
that happen. Join us.
The
Th e co
core
re of ou
ourr wo
w rkk is made
de possible by
ourr Gr
ou Gree
een
ee n Apppl
plee par
a tn
tner
e s.
mygr
mygrree
eena
napp
napple
le.o
.org
g
the community-engagement arm of Detroit not just getting information,” Pitera says. When
Works’ long-term planning team, he needs he started with Detroit Works, he was “as critical
the charge. Pitera, who directs the Detroit as anyone” about the clumsy way conversations
Collaborative Design Center at the University about poverty and policy happened. Pitera says
of Detroit Mercy School of Architecture, is he understands the cynicism of many residents.
partnering on the engagement effort with “It’s very valid,” he says, based on the mixed
two area nonprofits, Michigan Community messages that they’ve heard so far.
Resources and the Community Development Pitera is intrigued by the project’s potential
15
Advocates of Detroit. not to “re-create” Detroit, but to amplify existing
Extraordinary civic engagement was resources—its people, most especially, and its
essential for building the legitimacy of land. “We have a chance to create a 21st-century
Detroit Works after its horror of a debut. So, ecological and equitable city,” he says.
from their cheery Detroit Works storefront One of the many things architects have
in Eastern Market, Pitera and his team learned over the last century is that there’s no
organized community conversations way to plan equitable spaces if the process itself
Percent of Detroit in multiple neighborhoods, as well as a is not equitable, if it does not reflect a deep and
traveling “road show” and telephone town broad interaction with citizens and an honest
businesses that are halls. They posted presentations online accounting of those conversations. The civic
owned by blacks. before they were refined and made data engagement of Detroit Works is groundbreaking
83
visualizations of public feedback. They in its scope, reaching tens of thousands of
created “Detroit 24/7,” an online game where residents. How meaningful those conversations
players envision the city’s future. And they have been will be seen in whether or not the
launched an oral history project fashioned as project helps guide decision making by residents
an elegant online gallery. (“It’s a myth that to on street corners, at dinner tables, and in block
Percent of the potential have community engagement, you have to clubs, to say nothing of City Hall. Poverty is a
workforce that is black. have mediocre design,” Pitera says.) distortion of power, after all, and it is difficult to
“It’s really about building relationships, have an equitable conversation across that line.
Charity Hicks, a local health activist,
describes poverty as “people who have
profound capacities, but no opportunity.
Poverty truncates you.” Hicks has served on
a Detroit Works advisory board, but she’s
critical that more “local brain cells” are not
in leadership positions at Detroit Works,
aside from HAA. “Find those people who are
visionary and innovative, and marry them
with planners,” she said. “Take a group of
citizens through Planning 101. Why not?” More
than just a performance of representative
leadership, she argues, such an approach would
have added additional depth to the many
discussions about the city’s future.
Will the city merge the recommendations
from the long-term plan with its short-term
vision? So many strategies that the framework
describes will, at some point, necessitate city
participation. But Kinkead sidesteps the idea of
it requiring top-down implementation, saying
success depends on a “mosaic implementation,
from a design perspective.”
“This is fundamentally collaborative,”
Kinkead said. “Everybody, from the state to
the city to the citizen, is an important decision
maker. The problems [here] are too deep, too
systemic, for any participant to be missing in
the solution. … We need everyone to rise up
to the challenge. We have to make deliberate
decisions. We have to move beyond ourselves
and think of the city as a whole.”
Kinkead sighs, leans back in his chair, and
adds: “There’s a bit of a leap of faith in that.
Circle no. 177 or http://architect.hotims.com
I solved for x with walnut shells.
We strive to create products that are not only good for the
environment, but also good for people and good for our customers’
bottom lines. Because creating products that benefit everybody is
the best way to keep sustainability, well, sustainable.
TECH TALK
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
POWER HUNGRY
DATA CENTERS ARE CROPPING UP AROUND THE WORLD IN MODEST BUILDING SHELLS
THAT BELIE THE AROUND-THE-CLOCK ACTIVITY INSIDE. USING INNOVATIVE DESIGN AND
PLANNING, ARCHITECTS ARE HELPING ABATE THE BURGEONING BUILDING TYPOLOGY’S
APPETITE FOR ENERGY.
30
The number
of watts in
billions that
data centers
worldwide
use—
roughly
equivalent
to the
output of
30 nuclear
power
plants.
SOURCE: THE NEW YORK TIMES
Pionen, a 1,200-square- Text by Rose Eveleth country,y including this one. I apologize to him
meter (13,000-square-foot) for being nearlyl an hour late, explaining that I
data center designed
FROM THE OUTSIDE, NY4 doesn’t look like hadn’t expected the journey from Brooklyn l to
by Albert France-Lanord
Architects, is located in much. Its ambling, concrete façade is dotted take two hours in rush hour. “I knew it would,”
a former nuclear bomb with tinted windows, not unlike many n he says
a with a laugh, as he escorts me through
shelter 30 meters under industrial buildings here in Secaucus, N.J. But the third and final door.
bedrock in Stockholm. that’s where the similarities end. Inside, the Walking into the heart of NY4 is like
lobby is empty except for a wall-mounted entering the future—or the guts of a megascale
telephone that dials straight to a security desk. computer. The space is vast: 343,000 square
If—and only l if—you hav
a e an appointment, feet, the size of nearly
l six football fields. Its
they’ll let you through the doors and into a core is packed with machines, and offices line
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
met a tall man with white curly l hair. Michael The servers are dizzying arrays
a of
Poleshuk is the senior director of Northeast flashing blue and green diodes. Each one
data center operations for Equinix, a company n releases a mess of rainbow-colored spaghetti;
that owns and operates data centers across the the wires miraculously l sort themselv
l es into
PROTEK®. THE POWERHOUSE IN HURRICANE IMPACT RESISTANCE AND BLAST MITIGATION.
States. Data centers generally fall into one site, a former nuclear bomb shelter, was chosen
of two categories: colocation or enterprise. A for its visual impact: The James Bond–esque
colocation center, such as NY4, hosts servers setting has an immediate effect on prospective
from different companies—banks, Internet clients—building users who might never
w! Searching for Natural Stone?
Ne
marble-institute.com
For its first enterprise step foot inside again. “What is different from The Big Chill
data center, located other projects is that [a data center is] not One way to tackle cooling is through strategic
in Prineville, Ore., designed for people; it’s really designed for site selection. Mild climates help keep server
Facebook had an internal
machines,” France-Lanord says. temperatures down naturally. Data centers
infrastructure team that
worked with Sheehan Depending on the client and the project, can also capitalize on their surrounding
Partners Architects to architects can have little or nothing to do with environment: A building on Lake Erie can
design everything from the building’s computing components. For take advantage of cool lake winds, while an
the building form to the
Bahnhof’s newest data center in Stockholm, underground building, such as Pionen, can
servers. Though data
centers are typically which opened in mid-October, France-Lanord benefit from the milder temperatures subgrade.
nondescript buildings, was given only the server cabinet dimensions, Companies are also allowing their servers
Facebook modeled this around which he essentially designed the to run a little hotter to reduce the building’s
LEED Gold–certified facility space. In other projects, firms may work cooling load. Facebook is elevating its data
after the traditional
with mechanical engineers and technology centers’ operating temperatures a few degrees
residential architecture
found in the region’s arid consultants from day one to design the space above the standard 70 F. Increasing the running
desert climate. and to determine how to marry energy temperature of a data center by a single degree
efficiency with immense computing demand. can save 2 percent on utility costs, says Garr
To address energy efficiency, architects Di Salvo, an associate principal in the New
have two primary options: improve server York office of Arup. This handful of percentage
performance through scheduling or incorporate points is significant considering that data
more efficient cooling systems into the building. centers can consume upwards of 50 megawatts
Using the first tactic, architects can work with of energy per year and generate annual utility
the client’s IT team to assess when the servers bills that run easily into the millions.
require the most power, and then batch which Architects can also design the building
servers run at full capacity and which stay shape and form to exhaust heat more
dormant. Operations such as routine backups effectively. Completed in 2009, Yahoo’s data
can wait a few hours or even a few days. HP, for center in Buffalo, N.Y., “looks very much like
one, is trying to optimize power consumption an oversized chicken coop,” Di Salvo says.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
and capitalize on off-peak rates by altering Controlled louvers clad the entire building
which servers are used and when, Bash says. exterior. “The idea is that they allow the
It’s on the cooling side of the equation, building to exhaust all that heat in an energy-
however, where architects can have the greatest efficient manner,” Di Salvo says.
effect. “A data center is essentially a great big The cooling systems themselves can also
ONNU SINGLETON
box full of hot air,” says Neil Sheehan, AIA, a be improved. “Based on the selection of the
principal at Chicago-based Sheehan Partners, mechanical system, the architects can provide
which designed NY4. Exhausting the hot air both experience and innovation in wrapping
efficiently comes down to design decisions. that building around that mechanical system,”
CAN YOU
SP T
THE VENT FAN?
Ceramics of Italy, is a trademark of Confindustria Ceramica - the Italian Association of Ceramics - and Edi.Cer, the organizer of Cersaie, the
world’s largest international exhibition of ceramic tile and bathroom furnishings (Bologna, Italy - September 24-28, 2013) - www.cersaie.it.
For more information, please contact: Italian Trade Commission – Ceramic Tile Department – 33 East 67th Street – New York, NY 10065-5949
ph (212) 980-1500 – fax (212) 758-1050 – newyork@ice.it
Just two years after opening the 343,000-square-foot NY4 data center in Secaucus, N.J., Equinix is buildng NY5, a
myMarvin 400,000-square-foot data center just two doors down. Both NY4 and NY5 are designed by Sheehan Partners.
ARCHITECT’S
CHALLENGE often have no say regarding the types of
computing equipment used within the
Shapeshifters
The evolution of data center design remains
building shell. If one server style is far more open-ended. Some architects believe that data
WINNERS efficient, the architect can’t ask the remaining centers will become smaller and more modular.
server owners and operators to emulate that They might be little boxes on telephone poles,
The winning entries have particular configuration. As a result, data or they might be mobile and cater to user
centers conceived in collaboration with the IT demand. The advent of cloud computing might
been selected from an array of
consultants from the project outset are far more result in fewer, larger data centers where
inspiring designs. Each project successful in pursuing sustainability goals. processing is pooled or, conversely, it might
®
features Marvin Windows and This is where the difference between a lead to smaller, scattered data center facilities
Doors, and the best examples of colocation data center and an enterprise data owned by individual businesses. Colocation
center matters. The most-efficient data centers centers will then have to find ways to increase
solution-driven design, innovation, often fall into the latter category, where the the flexibility of their internal structure.
beauty and sustainability. To see all building owner not only has input on the Regardless of the form data centers take,
that Marvin has to offer architects, facility’s design, but also in its implementation one thing is certain: they will continue to
including a comprehensive line of and use. When Google designs a center, Google rise in sheer numbers. Two years after NY4’s
gets to pick what kind of servers it uses, when completion, Equinix is building NY5, a 400,000-
BIM tools and our new interactive to use them, how to cool them, and where the square-foot data center, just two doors down.
iPad app, visit Marvin.com. energy comes from. If a company owns the Despite interacting with them thousands
entire center, and all the processing within it, of times each day, communities for the most
View the winners’ showcase at it can be bold in its approach. So, HP can batch part will remain oblivious to the existence of
marvin.com/inspired its server usage to coincide with down times in the data centers that are quietly multiplying in
demand, and Facebook can run its servers at a their backyards. This suits data center owners
slightly higher temperature. just fine. For security and safety reasons, they
At NY4, these options don’t exist. Poleshuk embrace the anonymity of their buildings.
has his job because he can guarantee his clients Two hours after first pulling into NY4’s
three things: first, they can run whatever parking lot, I begin my trip home to Brooklyn. At
processes they need at whatever time of day; a stop sign, I type my address into my phone. In
second, their servers will remain a specific a split second, a little blue line appears, plotting
BILYANA DIMITROVA
©2012 Marvin Windows and Doors. All rights reserved. temperature; and third, power will be supplied. my route through the Holland Tunnel and across
®Registered trademark of Marvin Windows and Doors. When asked about the amount of power Manhattan. And somewhere in the world, a
1-800-268-7644
NY4 uses, Poleshuk shrugs. “We need these server deep inside an unmarked building is
computers,” he says. “We need these centers.” spinning frantically to process my request.
Circle no. 210 or http://architect.hotims.com
conn
e
t0 ct
Request these e-newsletters and receive
industry news as it’s happening
ARCHITECT Newswire is a FREE
comprehensive daily e-newsletter com-
piling Web articles, blog posts, and other
information on the business and design
of architecture. Also included is content
from various social networking tools and
opinions from leaders across the Web.
SIGN UP TODAY!
www.omeda.com/arch/1M1ENBD
112
CENTER
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
a 24-year-old with exactly zero curatorial pertinent when thinking about 9+1 Ways of
experience. He did, however, have some very Being Political: 50 Years of Political Stances in
concrete ideas about the way the museum Architecture and Urban Design, the inaugural
should address its audience. “I believe every show from the newest member of MoMA’s
show should have a point,” he wrote. “An architectural department, Pedro Gadanho.
exhibition planned with the idea of explaining In the sense that it is clearly conceived to
and developing a certain problem or aspect make a point, 9+1 falls squarely within the
of modern art is much more certain to attract Johnsonian tradition, though Gadanho is
the public.” trying to locate rather than efface the politics
Webinars, videos, and
free training courses
at your fi ngertips.
Find AIA-, NAHB-,
NARI-, and USGBC-
approved training
courses. Fact sheets
and research
are yours to
download.
Azon Saves Energy materials to which the general public can react
to more effectively than criticism can,” he said.
He’s right, in a sense. The power
of traditional criticism has, inarguably,
diminished with the fall of print journalism
and the rise of the Internet, although I would
“Our main purpose is to provide suggest that this power was never that great in
the first place. Though there are now countless
high-performance fenestration
outlets for criticism, there are few with a large
1 components that meet our customers’ readership or the funds to support a full-time
professional. Critics, meanwhile, seem to be
sustainability goals and expectations.” engaging in curatorial activities as never before.
This past year Evening Standard critic Kieran
1 Long served as assistant director of the Venice
Architecture Biennale. The American entry to
that event was curated by a team of current and
2 2
reformed writers, including the editor-in-chief
mechanical lock profile of this magazine.
+ Who wouldn’t envy the steady stream of
bodies filtering through MoMA’s architectural
Universal No-Tape™ 304 galleries? The question is, what exactly is
structural thermal barrier polymer
Gadanho telling them? Even after viewing his
show several times, I wasn’t quite sure, though
I found it well worth the repeated visits.
NEW total design system: The essential premise of 9+1 is that, despite
economic pressures, the architectural avant-
MLP™ (mechanical lock profile) for commercial window, door, garde has been, for the past half century, deeply
politicized. Gadanho has mined the museum’s
storefront and curtain wall applications offers the best balance of
collection to illustrate the various forms of
energy efficiency and high strength for aluminum fenestration this engagement. Somewhat arbitrarily, he
products used in the most demanding climates and conditions. has divided the strategies of that activism into
nine chronological but overlapping thematic
Modern daylighting systems produced with both Azon structural categories (hence the show’s title), making it at
once a survey of the collection and an operating
thermal barrier technologies—the MLP™ thermal barrier method for
manual for contemporary practice. (A pair of
aluminum windows and Warm-Light® warm-edge spacer for related video works constitute the “+1.”)
The effect is not unlike a lecture delivered
insulating glass, will yield a fenestration system capable of upholding by a particularly gifted member of the
the highest efficiency and sustainability standards. architectural professoriat, which is no accident.
Gadanho is Portugese by birth, but hails from
the borderless nation that is architectural
academia. (He has a doctorate in architecture
and mass media from the University of Porto,
Contact us to learn about the and served on its faculty.) Behind a lectern, the
role of Azon thermal barriers in breadth of his knowledge, his sympathy for
architectural culture, and his native optimism
energy conservation.
make him a sympathetic propagandist. But
those qualities don’t seamlessly translate to
1 HSW Learning Unit 1-800-788-5942 | www.azonintl.com the walls of MoMA’s galleries.
One of the ironies of this show is
Circle no. 293 or http://architect.hotims.com
e
tiv
ita
EW
or
th
Au
d
te
en
N
ed
ec
757 Buildings . 97 Countries . 699 Architects . 3,800 Photographs . 1,300 Line drawings
pr
Un
ue
iq
Un
The
landmark
book for the
landmark
century
“Beautifully
detailed and
well organised”
Richard Rogers
WĞƌĨĞĐƚ
WĞŽƉůĞĂƌĞŇŝƉƉŝŶŽǀĞƌƚŚĞŶĚƌŽŝĚǀĞƌƐŝŽŶ
hƐĞƚŚĞZdĂƉƉƚŽĮŶĚďƵŝůĚŝŶŐƉƌŽĚƵĐƚƐƐƉĞĐƐ/DĂŶĚŵŽƌĞ
&ZƚŽƵƐĞĂŶĚŶŽƌĞŐŝƐƚƌĂƟŽŶƌĞƋƵŝƌĞĚ
Zd
CONTINUING EDUCATION
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
AIA/CES CREDIT:
You can earn 1 CEH
(Continuing Education
Hour) for reading this
article and successfully
completing the quiz. You
must answer eight of 10
questions correctly to
earn credit and obtain a
certificate of completion.
This course is valid through
November 2015.
PARKING GARAGES HAVE RECENTLY GARNERED NEWFOUND DESIGN ACCLAIM, Affter completing this
A
BUT THEIR POTENTIAL TO BECOME CENTERS FOR COMMUNITY GATHERING AND course, you can leave
feedback with us directly;
TECHNOLOGICAL TRAILBLAZERS REMAINS OPEN FOR EXPLORATION. AIA members can also leave
feedback by logging into the
AIA CES Discovery
r system.
In Santa Monica, Calif., LARGE, LOOMING, AND DIMLY LIT parking barren-walled sidewalk. “When I started doing
Brooks + Scarpa renovated
garages are a fact of life in cities and suburbs parking garages 10 to 15 years ago, when you CUSTOMER SERVICE
eight parking garages
surrounding the Third across the U.S., wh
w ere the automobile reigns as would tell a story about the structure, folks hwuniversity
t @
Street Promenade, our fav
a orite mode of personal transportat a ion. would say ay, ‘Why
h even hava e an architect?’” says
a hanleywood.com
a popular shopping, W rldwide, the nu
Wo n mber of vehicles on the George Hibbs, AIA, a principal at Trenton, N.J.–
restaurant, and roads surpassed 1 billion in 2010, according to based firm Clarke Caton Hintz. “It seems like
entertainment district. To LEARNING OBJECTIVES
W rdsAuto Group, and will only
Wa l continu
n e to an engineering job.” 1. Identify
f how parking
improve the pedestrian
experience, the firm left increase. Providing space for this burgeoning But the parking garage is entering a structures can fit into the
large expanses of the fleet is an ongoing challenge for commu m nities, renaissance. The New Urbanism movement New Urbanism movement.
façade open for art and particularly
l as they become denser. has emphasized walkable env n ironments and
cultural installations, 2. Describe how parking
Generally
l considered the province of multl i-modal transit, and the design profession structures have changed
including Cradle by design
and fabrication studio engineers and design/build contractors, has transitioned from the machinelike over time.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Ball-Nogues. parking structures hav a e long been a rote sort efficiency and compartmentalization that
3. Describe the benefits
of project that is often ruled by the mandates underpinned Modernism to more humanistic
of integrating parking
of zoning laws, building codes, and the bottom spaces. Fresh approaches to the typology can structures into the
line. Other than physical
h proximity,y they hav
a e be seen in the slew of high-design parking urban fabric.
JOHN EDWARD LINDEN
largely
l been conceiived separately l from the structures that hava e landed in Miami,
buildings that they serve. And that thinking designed by the likes of Gehry Partners, Herzog 4. Identify
f how
automation and advances
has resulted in the utilitarian steel-and- & de Meuron, and Arquitectonica. Parking
in automobile design
concrete behemoths that interrupt the flow structures are no longer just a means to will affect the design of
of the urban fabric with long stretches of multl iply
l the surface parking lot; rather, they parking structures.
μ1O\g]cW\abOZZg]c`[SaV
Qc`dSRW\bVSRW`SQbW]\Wb¸a
5]/VSORBV`]eCaO1c`dS \]bcacOZZgQc`dSR-¶
BVObeOabVS_cSabW]\^]aSR
Pg>SZZW1ZO`YS>SZZW/`QVWbSQba
bVOb`SacZbSRW\bVS/@7/
@Sa]`b1OaW\]¸aP`SObVbOYW\U
# T]]bZ]\U"%T]]bVWUV
c\RcZObW\UabOW\ZSaa[SaV
TOQORS
Ac`SW\abOZZW\UaSZTbS\aW]\W\U
TZSfWPZS[SaV]\OZObS`OZQc`dS
VOR\SdS`PSS\R]\SPST]`S
0cbbVOb¸aSfOQbZgbVSYW\R]T
QVOZZS\USeSZ]]YT]`eO`Rb]
[SSbW\USdS`gROg
>`]XSQb(/@7/@Sa]`b1OaW\]
:]QObW]\(:OaDSUOa<D
/`QVWbSQb(>SZZW1ZO`YS>SZZW
/`QVWbSQba<Se6OdS\1B
1/;0@7253/@167B31BC@/:1=;
;/237<B63CA/
Designed by Clarke Caton can be key to the urban fabric and a vital piece structural members, along with newer
13
Hintz, the Ruppert Plaza of infrastructure that can profoundly affect automobiles that were more durable made it
Garage in New York blends how we plan for a more sustainable future. feasible as well as cheaper to build the for-cars-
into the surrounding
“We’re at a point now where, while only, open-steel, and concrete-decked parking
environment and hosts
the Macombs Dam Park there are certainly folks who don’t see the structures that we know today. At the same
on its roof. Pedestrian typology as being at the forefront, it’s come a time, city zoning laws began to mandate that
bridges built over a berm
The number, in
long way,” Hibbs says. “We are now seeing the new developments include off-street parking.
connect the park with the
integration of light, of color, the integration Despite the obvious connections between
millions, of cars
neighboring Heritage Park.
of mass transit, and the belief that it’s parking structures and the buildings and and trucks sold in
something that adds to the complexity of urban environments that they served, the two the U.S. in 2011.
the urban environment.” entities were mostly conceived separately. The In 1931, the first
building was architecture, the streetscape was year on record,
The Shift to Functionalism a part of urban planning, and the garage was 2.2 million
At the dawn of the parking garage in an engineering exercise whose goal was little vehicles were
Chicago in 1918, the building typology had more than satisfying functional requirements. sold. The number
little distinction from other structures. In the words of Lawrence Scarpa, FAIA, of sales peaked
Automobiles of this era were not designed or principal at Los Angeles–based firm Brooks
in 2000 at
built to weather the elements and had to be + Scarpa, “Parking garages evolved into
17.8 million.
housed much in the same manner as people. utilitarian structures for stacking cars.”
As a result, garages’ façades looked virtually Logistically, parking structure designs SOURCE: WARDSAUTO GROUP
identical to the apartment buildings that must fulfill several requirements. Parking
JEFFREY TOTARO FOR CLARKE CATON HINTZ ARCHITECTS
they abutted, complete with ornamental geometries are based on the sizes, heights, and
embellishments such as pilasters, gargoyles, turning radii of contemporary automobiles,
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
803-%$-"44&%6$"5*0/130(3".t4&44*0/4t$&35*'*$"5*0/4."45&3$&35*'*$"5&4
XXXXPSMEPGDPODSFUFDPN
'FCSVBSZ
t4&.*/"34'FCSVBSZ
-BT7FHBT$POWFOUJPO$FOUFSt-BT7FHBT
/FWBEB
exhaust vehicular emissions are also critical, in our cities,” Scarpa says. He notes exceptions
and even more so for underground or semi- such as Paul Rudolph’s Temple Street Parking
enclosed garages. Garage in New Haven, Conn., which “is better
A parking garage design team—typically architecturally, [but] even that [structure] didn’t
comprising an architect, civil engineer, and house any uses that contributed to the urban
structural engineer—has a fairly standardized fabric,” he says. “Today, there’s an effort to make
kit of parts at its disposal. The kit includes basic garages that are part of the urban fabric.”
ramp configurations, such as dedicated spiral While the basic functional requirements of
“up” and “down” ramps, or the more common parking structures cannot be ignored, architects
interior two-way cutback ramps. can design neighborhood-friendly facilities
“PARKING GARAGES LOST THE The de facto structural systems include
steel, poured-in-place concrete, and pre-
by adding programming that goes beyond
housing cars. Commercial or institutional space
MAGIC—THE POTENTIAL TO cast concrete, all with standardized bay on the structure’s ground floor perimeter can
® ®
Eldorado Custom Veneto Fieldledge & Hillstone eldoradostone.com 800.925.1491
Circle no. 479 or http://architect.hotims.com
126
CENTER
Whoa. Exactly.
foot light wells that penetrate all four garage
levels, shedding natural light on the garage’s
rock gardens and pedestrian benches at grade.
Perhaps the most significant architectural
gesture of the facility is Clarke Caton Hintz’s
design for the facility’s vertical circulation. “We
added glass elevators and escalators so that
folks rushing to catch their plane would see the
parking garage as an extension of the terminal
and not so much as [a] separate experience,”
Hibbs says. The glass elevators, combined
with the parking structure’s precast concrete
structure, mimic the swooping concrete ceilings
and glass curtainwalls of the 1970s terminal.
The firm’s penultimate neighborhood-
friendly parking garage may be the Ruppert
Plaza Garage in New York. Sited on 7.2 acres,
the two-story, 1,500-space facility sits directly
across from the home plate entrance of the
new Yankee Stadium in the Bronx, adjacent to
Heritage Field, the public baseball field located
on the site of the former Yankee stadium.
From roots to rooftops and beyond, To extend the experience of Heritage
Field as an attraction for the community—
we’re with you all the way. and to compensate for parkland lost to
development—New York City specified that the
At Firestone Building Products, we’re committed to making your job parking structure’s roof would host Macombs
easier. By taking the entire building envelope into consideration, we can Dam Park. The rooftop park, which covers the
provide you with superior services, support, warranty and expertise. structure’s entire footprint, features a synthetic
football/soccer field, a running track, and
Count on Firestone for complete building performance solutions that basketball and handball courts. The west side of
will help you and your building perform at a level above the rest. the field has bleacher seating for 600 people as
well as restrooms and storage facilities, while a
firestonebpco.com | (800) 428-4442 fitness circuit and misting stations occupy the
m
park’s south end. On the perimeter, landscaped
gardens planted with a mix of ornamental
Circle no. 206 or http://architect.hotims.com grasses and trees buffer the park from the city.
go forward
The Destination is a dramatic one:
An entirely new way of thinking about
architectural downlighting.
Gotham Incito luminaires replace the need to specify
TM
color temperature
2700K
3000K
3500K
4000K
distribution
20º 25º 30º 35º 40º 45º 55º 60º 65º 70º
I I I I
lumen packages — 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 I I I I I
tm
incito
h i g h - lu m e n s o l i d - s tat e lu m i n a i r e s
GO T H AM A R CHI T EC T UR AL DO W NL IGH T I NG
1400 Lester Road, Conyers, Georgia 30012, 800-315-4982 P 770 -860- 3129 F
t
t
For the 40-space, automated vehicle storage system at One York, a residential
building in New York by Ten Arquitectos, Park Plus installed a palletless comb
exchange that can convey a car from its parking space to its driver within a minute.
Hanley Wood is committed to publishing quality The following Hanley Wood brands
have been recognized over 85 times
content that serves the information needs of for editorial achievement.
ARCHITECTURAL LIGHTING
CUSTOM HOME
POOL & SPA NEWS | Best Technical Content
ECOHOME
REMODELING | Best Instructional Content
ECO-STRUCTURE
MULTIFAMILY EXECUTIVE
2012 FI N ALI STS POOL & SPA NEWS
RESIDENTIAL ARCHITECT
operations personnel. Users simply drive their of cars than a conventional parking garage Automated systems require less excavation.
vehicle onto a steel pallet, exit the car, and does since space for roadways, ramps, and Finally, and perhaps an ancillary point, project
swipe a card through a reader. The system does pedestrians is unnecessary. This space savings developers can write-off automated systems
the rest, carrying the vehicle horizontally and can be a real boon, particularly where zoning on their taxes. “It’s like a computer, and not a
vertically to a designated storage cubby. codes mandate a set number of parking spaces building,” says Shannon Sanders McDonald, AIA,
Automated systems are more expensive for developments that otherwise couldn’t an assistant professor of architecture at Southern
to build, but several factors mitigate this up- accommodate that number of spaces on site. Illinois University and the author of The Parking
front cost. Their primary advantage is that For underground parking structures, Garage: Design and Evolution of a Modern Urban
they need less space to store the same number this saved space translates to cost savings: Form. “In terms of your business model,” she
says, “when you buy machinery, it has a different
financial structure: It’s deductible.”
Automated parking facilities have long
been popular in the space-starved and highly
populated regions of Europe and Asia, and
they are now catching on in the United States;
companies such as Park Plus and Automotion
are manufacturing and selling systems here.
Many high-density cities such as New York have
a few in place, while other cities, including Los
Angeles, have them in the pipeline. Though
these systems do not call upon the skills of
architects, they are yet another tool architects
can use when planning parking for a project.
5IFFrQPD¡-&%GVMMEJTUSJCVUJPOMVNJOBJSF
XJUIBEWBODFETPMJETUBUFFMFDUSPOJDT
IBT
TJHOJGJDBOUMZJNQSPWFEQFSGPSNBODFUPPGGFS
VQUPBSFEVDUJPOJOJOQVUXBUUTPWFS
UIFQSFWJPVTWFSTJPOXIJDIUSBOTMBUFTUP
FWFOMPXFSFOFSHZDPTUTBOENFFUTUIFNPTU
EFNBOEJOHQPXFSEFOTJUZSFRVJSFNFOUT
QUIZ
ARCHITECT THE AIA MAGAZINE NOVEMBER 2012
1. Parking geometries are based on which 5. Which of the following is not a way 8. Through thoughtful design and
characteristic of automobiles? to improve the integration of a parking planning, parking structures have the
a. Size structure in the neighborhood? potential to:
b. Height a. Adding commercial space on the a. Strengthen the community fabric.
c. Turning radius ground floor b. Improve the user experience.
d. All of the above b. Including other modes of transit to c. Support the urban continuum.
the facility d. All of the above.
2. True or False: Designers and planners c. Adding more levels for parking
can use parking structures to multiply d. Providing visitor amenities 9. Even though automated systems are
the surface parking lot, enhance the more expensive to build, which of the
urban fabric, and help create a more 6. For the Terminal C Parking Garage at following factors help mitigate this
sustainable future. Newark Liberty International Airport, why up-front cost?
did the design team specify 11-foot-9-inch a. They need less space to store the same
3. Parking structures are a project type that floor-to-ceiling heights? number of cars.
is often ruled by the mandates of: a. To meet code mandates b. They do not require a lot attendant.
a. Zoning laws. b. To comply with ADA requirements c. They can be written off on the →T To earn credit and
b. Building codes. c. To accommodate larger vehicles architect’s taxes. obtain a certificate
c. The bottom line. d. To increase daylight penetration d. They do not need to comply with the of completion, visit
d. All of the above. same zoning laws. go.hw.net/archceu and
7. True or False: To extend the experience complete the online quiz
4. True or False: For the most part, parking of Heritage Field as an attraction for the 10. True or False: Changes and advances in for free. Follow the “Click
here to start this course”
structures and the buildings that they serve local community, the architects designed automobile technology will influence the
link to launch the quiz for
are designed and planned together. the Macombs Dam Park on the parking design of parking structures in the future.
this story.
y If you are new to
structure’s ground floor.
Hanley Wood University, y
create a free learner
account; returning users
log in as usual.
Specify
Ultra-tec cable railing
in your next
commercial project.
Ultra-tec
CABLE RAILING SYSTEM
®
Darrk fabriic
with
h briightt Visit Draper at GreenBuild
performance. 2012 in Booth 2021S
Wind
Wi
fa
nd
abr
dow ssha
briics
hade
ics ha
des
de
have
es wi
ve a
w th dar
alw
lway
lw
arkk co
ayss of
ay offe
olo
lore
fere
fe
red
re
red
re
d
d th
thee
(South Building) to see
high
hi ghes
gh esst gl
glar
glar
are
e co
cont
ntro
nt rol
ro
ol an
andd mo
most
st KoolBlack Technology
comf
comf
co mfor
mfor
orta
tabl
ta b e vi
bl view
ew-t
ew -tthr
ho ou
ugh
gh.. Wi
W th
Kool
Ko olBl
Bla
Bl ack
ck Te
Tech
chno
nolo
logy
gy,, da
dark
rk c
col
olor
olors
ors on display.
now
now al
also
so offfer h
hea
eatt co
c nt
ntro
roll pr
ro preevio
evi
ev ious
usly
uslly
only available in liigh
on ght fa
ght fabr
bric
bric
i s.
Be
elo
ow ar
are th
are ther
theermal
erm
ma ph
hoottos
o ooff a we
west
st--
st
GreenBuild 2012
faci
fa cin
ng So
ng South Carol
arolin
ina
a wiind
ndow
dow
waatt 4p
4pmm San Francisco, CA
in
nAApr
prililil. Th
pr Thee im
mag e on the right shows
age
sta
st andard
and
dard Charcoal colored fabric. The November 14-16, 2012
image on the left shows the same fab
im abri
ric
c
with KoolBlack Technology.
Booth 2021S
118
118
18°° F 13
136
366° F
47.8°
47. 8° C 57.
57
5 7.
7 8°
8° C
Wit
Wi
W ih With
With
Withou
hoout
Ko
Koo
oolBl
Black
ack
c Koo
Koo
ollB
lBl
Blla
B ack
ack
ac
www.draperinc.com
ETHICS
PRISON BREAK
RAPHAEL SPERRY WANTS TO BAN ARCHITECTS
FROM DESIGNING DEATH CHAMBERS AND
SOLITARY CONFINEMENT CELLS. CAN HIS
CAMPAIGN HELP CREATE A MORE HUMANE
PRISON SYSTEM?
Raphael Sperry, a Text by Karrie Jacobs Munn, for his part, argues that the “ragtag
Bay Area–based Photo by Noah Kalina group” was off-base in its efforts because Toronto
architect, in front of
South had nothing to do with the federal crime
San Francisco’s Hall
of Justice, home to ONE OCTOBER AFTERNOON in downtown initiative. Rather, the crisply modern facility
police headquarters, Toronto, a small band of protestors clustered with its Miesian entry pavilion was the solution
courtrooms, and a jail. outside the Hilton holding handmade signs to a provincial problem, a replacement for older
Sperry has launched a with slogans like “Food not Prisons” and Toronto prisons, one of which dated back to 1858.
campaign to revise the
AIA’s code of ethics.
“Housing not Prisons.” The so-called Prison “It’s really a response to some terrible conditions
Moratorium Action Coalition was denouncing in existing facilities,” Munn insists.
a sprawling piece of legislation passed in Rightly or wrongly, it seems almost
Canada’s Parliament earlier this year, one that unprecedented to hold architects accountable
imposed mandatory minimum sentences for for decisions that are political in nature.
many offenses and authorized a multibillion- Normally, the only dissent heard at AIA events
dollar program for prison construction. comes from the architects themselves.
The target of this demonstration, however, In fact, deep inside the Hilton, the
wasn’t government officials or law enforcement protestors had an ally. On the agenda was a
agencies. Instead, it was the annual fall meeting panel called “Long-Term Solitary Confinement
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
of the Academy of Architecture for Justice. The in the U.S.: Design and Implications.” One of the
protestors had decided to go after “others who panelists, Raphael Sperry, a 38-year-old Berkeley,
profit from locking people away.” In this case, Calif.–based architect, has dedicated the past
the “others” were architects—specifically, the 10 years of his life to persuading his colleagues
Toronto-based Zeidler Partnership, including to stop designing prisons. Currently, he has a
senior partner Alan Munn and several of his grant from the Open Society Foundations, a
colleagues—who were at the Hilton presenting nonprofit founded by George Soros, to focus on
their newly completed maximum security his mission—the first architect selected as one
Toronto South Detention Centre. of that organization’s Justice Fellows.
;,99(AA6LHYUZHU(
H[)YVVRZ,SLTLU[HY`PU
)YVVRZ2LU[\JR`
¸>OLUKLZPNUPUNLK\JH[PVUHS
ZWHJLZP[PZPTWVY[HU[[V
ZLSLJ[TH[LYPHSZ[OH[VMMLY
K\YHIPSP[`HUKLUKSLZZHLZ[OL[PJ
VWWVY[\UP[PLZ;LYYHaaV
WYV]PKLZSVUNSHZ[PUNZ\YMHJLZ
HUKLUHISLZPU[LYPVYZWHJLZ[V
IL[YHUZMVYTLKPU[VILH\[PM\S
\UPX\LL_WLYPLUJLZ¹
4`YH=H\NOU
(0(3,,+(7
:OLYTHU*HY[LY)HYUOHY[
O[[W!^^^ZJIHYJOP[LJ[ZJVT
7OV[VJV\Y[LZ`VM4HYPH:OVYL
^^^U[THJVT
bottom photo: Scott Shigley / top photo: Martin Luther King, Jr., Federal Budiling by Lord, Aeck & Sargent / Jonathan Hillyer
The maximum security Toronto South Detention Centre, designed by the Zeidler
Partnership, features a light-filled entry pavilion and a bright reception area. The
Prison Moratorium Action Committee, as part of its protest against the facility,
initiated a letter-writing campaign to all Zeidler employees, calling them to task for
profiting from a system that locks people up.
correctional officers can see what’s going on the same reasons Sperry thinks architects system. We were going to bring new ideas.”
inside the cell from above.” should shun those commissions. “Laura and Still, Sperry argues that the criminal
Of course, not all architecture firms I have devoted our entire lives to improving justice system is so corrupt that it can routinely
that design jails and prisons also design environments for the incarcerated,” Ricci says. overwhelm architects’ best intentions: “The
supermaxes. For example, Kenneth Ricci, “So, far from thinking that we would boycott, architects who have built the prisons over the
FAIA, president, and Laura Maiello, associate we rolled up our sleeves and decided at a very past 30 years intended to make it better. But we
principal, of the New York–based specialists early point in our respective careers that we didn’t. What we did is far, far worse.” He sees
Ricci Greene Associates, design jails for roughly were going to improve the criminal justice architects as enablers, supporting a system that
warehouses more and more people in remote
rural prisons, despite evidence suggesting that
most offenders would fare better if they were
kept closer to their own communities.
Which is precisely what Ricci thinks.
With some exceptions, the firm steers clear
of state and federal prisons, as well as most
privately built and run facilities. Most of its
work is designing lockups where individuals
await trial, and, as Ricci points out, still retain
their constitutional rights. “We stay away from
clients that are not buying what we’re selling,”
he says. And what they’re selling are facilities
in urban environments where they are visible
and accessible, such as the Van Cise-Simonet
Detention Center in downtown Denver, or
the award-winning Union County Juvenile
BARCLAYS
CENTER
SHOP ARCHITECTS’ NEW ARENA
OPENS TO GREAT FANFARE AT THE
ATLANTIC YARDS DEVELOPMENT
IN BROOKLYN, N.Y.
Text by Philip Nobel
Photos by Bruce Damonte
It is, at its roots, a deeply functional struc- including a proprietary iPhone app that al-
ture. Not in the usual sense—it doesn’t keep out lowed delivery and installation progress to be
the rain; it doesn’t hold anything up—but in rendered and tracked in real time, to marshal
terms of psychology, experience, and urbanism. the 12,000 unique façade panels into place.
The bones of Ellerbe’s arch-roofed stadium, a de- “They know how to make technology work for
sign derived from its Conseco Fieldhouse in In- them: I would sit there and watch their app all
dianapolis, were largely a given when SHoP first the time,” Ratner says. “We got a firm that was
got the job: The steel had already been ordered. extraordinary, and we got them at a time when
Ratner, to his credit, recognized that the bland they were blossoming.”
146 Event-Level Plan Main Concourse–Level Plan
Vault Bar
Main
Loading/service concourse
Dean Street entrance
Loading
bay
40/40 club
Suites Concessions
N
0 25 50
East–West Section
Upper concourse
level Main entrance
Main concourse
level
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Event level
Arena floor
0 25 50
147
Top: The Barclays Center faced community opposition from the early stages of the process, largely from neighbors concerned about how the larger Atlantic Yards development
might change the neighborhood. But the south and east façades, seen here from Flatbush Avenue, demonstrate the consideration that SHoP Architects gave to scale and materials,
in order to ensure that the arena does not overwhelm its surroundings. Bottom: At the rear of the arena, the façade peels away to enclose the loading dock.
148
ARCHITECT NOVEMBER 2012
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Opposite: After passing under the 85-foot-deep cantilever and through the main entrance, visitors arrive in the atrium, where they can pick up tickets and get their first
glimpse into the arena proper. Top left: Along the concourse, public areas are marked by a rhythmic progression of strip lights across the ceiling plane. Concessions are wrapped
in warm wood to counter the overall black and gray interior. Top right: Several bars and lounges were designed into the Barclays Center, each with its own visual identity.
Bottom: With black seats, walls, floors, and ceiling, the main bowl of the arena is a multifunctional space (here hosting an exhibition game for the Harlem Globetrotters)
that can seat nearly 18,000 for a New York Nets game and 19,000 for a concert.
149
NEW YORK–BASED COOPER JOSEPH STUDIO’S NEW CONCRETE SHADE PAVILION IS MORE THAN A SIMPLE
STRUCTURAL CANOPY, IT CREATES A NEW SCULPTURAL LANDMARK IN A PUBLIC PARK IN DALLAS.
Text by John Gendall ity,
y and ample sightlines through the space. seating area on three sides and serves as a ther-
Photos by Eduard Hueber The old pavili
a ons being replaced were simple mal mass that reinforces the cooling effect.
concrete T-beam shade canopies. Cooper Joseph Thanks to the pavili
a on’s boxlike form, the
IN MANY MUNICIPALITIES, public shade struc- turned to the same material for its Webb
W Chapel architects were also able to minimize the visible
tures can be an afterthought: Prop a canopy on Park Pavili
a on.“Dallas is known for the quality of supports and promote a visual seamlessness
some posts, and shade you shall hav a e. Not so in its concrete industry,
y so for us, it was the perfect between the enclosure and its surroundings. A
Dallas, Texas. Two bond referenda there, in 2003 material for a small structure with integrity and thin concrete canopy would demand a grove of
and 2006, allocated money to replace some 30 of boldness,” Evans Joseph says.
a But the architects columns, but the volumetric roof allowed the
the city’s park pavili
a ons, and Dallas Park & Rec- modified their approach in formally l and func- architects to embed bracing beams within, mini-
reation assistant director Willis C. Winters, FAIA,
F tionally
l in
nventiv
i e ways.
a mizing the structural demands underneath. “By
envisi
n oned something rather ambitious: The Rather than follow the precedents for a going with this robust depth, we could achieve
city would treat each pavili
a on as a distinct com- minimal profile, Cooper Joseph went maxi- a cantilever,” Cooper says,
a which wouldn’t hav a e
mission, hiring architects—including firms such mal. “We
W didn’t want thin,” says a partner Chris been possible with a thin concrete profile.
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
The canopy provides shade
for benches and tables
made with Ipe wood seats
on painted-steel supports.
The terraced concrete
seating is nestled into
an earthen berm that
absorbs heat and helps
choreograph views.
Site Plan 155
Existing pavilion
New pavilion
N
0 30 60
West–East Section
Ventilation skylight
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Concrete canopy
0 4 8
PIERRESVIVES
ZAHA HADID’S NEW MUNICIPAL BUILDING ADDS TO THE ARCHITECTURAL
RENAISSANCE OF MONTPELLIER, FRANCE, AND DRAWS TOGETHER THREE PUBLIC
AGENCIES UNDER A SINGLE CONCRETE, GLASS, AND GOLD-LOUVERED ROOF.
158
eco-city of about 900 apartments, that will link to La Paillade, public owns the building.
an existing neighborhood with some 25,000 people—includ- When Pierresviv i es opened in September, it was visited
ing a large Maghrebian population living i in public housing. by thousands of residents, many n of them Maghrebian wom-
Pierresvivi es now anchors the entire commu m nity with en wearing headscarves. At the opening, Hadid spent hours
an institution open to all. Ve V zinhet sited the building strat a e- with people from La Paillade, fielding questions, sometimes
gically
ly, wh
w ere it mat a tered, in an overlooked, low-income area in Arabic, and introducing the building by introducing her-
separata ed from more affluent parts of town: “My passion was self. The response was clear: Vezinhet
V recalls one visitor from
to integrat a e La Paillade with the rest of the city by building a the neighborhood, wearing a head scarf, telling him: “Thank
h phen,” he say
hy a s. you for giving
i us beauty.”
159
Previous spread: On the second level of Pierresvives, a triple-height lobby features a curving roof incised with cove lighting. Top left: The multimedia library is filled with low
stacks that allow views out through the aluminum louver–covered windows. Top Right: On the western edge of the building, an office’s slanted glass wall offers views out over
Montpellier. Bottom right: Throughout Pierresvives, carefully curated sightlines and transparency between interior spaces were used to help connect various elements of the
program, as in this breakout space overlooking the lobby. Bottom left: On the ground floor, visitors enter under the cantilevered form of the médiatheque and use escalators to
access the upper levels. Floor detailing echoes the lines of the louvers and the lights above.
160
ARCHITECT NOVEMBER 2012
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Fixed aluminum
brrise-soleil
Aluminum profile
Finish floor
Ceiling
Finish floor
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
0 10 20
164
North–South Section
Archives
ARCHITECT NOVEMBER 2012
Ground-Floor Plan
Second-Floor Plan
Offices Gallery
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Exhibition space
p
Auditorium Magazine archive
165
Third-Floor Plan
Audiovisual
Archives
Fourth-Floor Plan
Courtyard
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Pierresvives serves as
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
an architectural bridge
between the center of
Montpellier and the
outyling community of
La Paillade, with its 25,000
residents, many of whom
live in public housing.
Some 900 new apartments
are being constructed
around Hadid’s concrete-
and-glass structure.
YOUTH CENTER OF QINGPU
SHANGHAI-BASED ATELIER DESHAUS’S ASSEMBLAGE OF PAVILIONS AND COURTYARDS
CREATES A HUMAN-SCALED OASIS FOR CHILDREN AMID THE MEGADEVELOPMENTS OF
THIS EXPANDING CHINESE CITY.
170
Photos by Yao Li
Curtainwall Section
3mm-thick coorrugated
40mm-thick perforated aluminum
reinforced screen
concrete
3mm-thick
polymer
modified asphalt
membrane 40mm-thick XXPS
extrusion-moolded
polystyrene innsulation
Gypsum board
ceiling
2mm-thick
linoleum
Colorized elasstic
exterior wall ppaint
100mm-thickk rubber
stand and draain board WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Downspout
0 6 12
This imag ge: The voids
voidsdss
bettwee
ween n the
thee bui
buildi
ldi
d ng g
vollume
umess allo
allo
llow
w for
for
o ext
exteri
erior
erior
ga her
gat h ingng sp
space
ac s,, lik
ace ike
e this
this
gravel
gra vel-li
-lined
ne co
ned court
urtyyard
urt yard
filled
filled wit
with h plan
pla ters.
Opposite left: Much of
Opp
the circulation around the
Youth Center complex is
outdoors, in gray-paved
alleys and over bridges
that run like streets
through the site. Opposite
right: A courtyard with a
large reflecting pool serves
as a hub for several of the
building volumes, such
as a theater and dance
studios.
175
Courtyard
Classrooms
Terrace
Dancing studio Classrooms Library Open-air Music
theater
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
West–East Section
Theater
0 15 30
Meetingg room
Dance lab
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
TOD WILLIAMS AND BILLIE TSIEN SPEAK WITH LEE BEY ABOUT THEIR FIRST PROJECT IN CHICAGO,
WHICH COMBINES THE FINE AND PERFORMING ARTS DEPARTMENTS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
CHICAGO INTO A BUILDING THAT PAYS HOMAGE TO BOTH THE SKYSCRAPER AND THE PLAINS.
180 Interview by Lee Bey
Photos by Tim Hursley
What is the program of the Reva and David Logan Center for the Arts?
Billie Tsien, AIA: We
W took different people [from] different parts of the arts
ARCHITECT NOVEMBER 2012
and put them all together in a tower, so that it would mix kids practicing
the piano with kids putting on a play
a with kids dancing. And that would
get a sort of synergy happening between both the faculty and the students.
So it’s the tower of the arts.
Let’s talk a little bit about the form of the building from the exterior. As a
guy from the Midwest, it reminds me, in a way, of a silo.
Tsien: That’s interesting because that’s one of the images we first used
when we talked about the building. Tod talked about the vertical building
as the silo and the horizontal building as the Plains. But of course the verti-
cal building is a Chicago tradition, so we’re also referring to the city.
The exterior is comprised of what look like Roman bricks, which we see
with the work of Wright and the Prairie School.
Tod Williams, FAIA: [We W used] long bars of stone that are like horizontal
bars and also bricklike, so we were definitely l thinking about Frank Lloyd
Wright when we made the building. And, as he did, we were thinking about
the … sense of compression where the building is wedded to the ground.
Tsien: We
W wanted to relate to the limestone buildings of the Univi ersity of
Chicago’s Neo-Gothic campus. At the same time, we wanted to say a [that]
we’re on the other side of the [Midway]
a Plaisance [from the main campus];
we’re a new building. So we looked for a limestone that was not the tradi-
tional Indiana limestone. WeW wanted something much more variegated in
its color. There are tones of orange and gray;
a it’s much warmer.
How much of a free hand, or lack thereof, did the university give you in
the design of the building?
Tsien: This was done through a competition. Many n times in competitions,
the buildings themselv l es are not exactlyl built. I think the basis of our
scheme remained intact. The departments had strong needs. So we needed
to balance their requirements with the idea of a sense of wholeness.
Williams: The number of arts elements that are packed together in this
tight base and tower are amazing. If you were to really l belt out music … [in
a music ensemble room], the spaces adjacen
d t would not hear it. You
Y could
hav
a e, next door, a dance performance going on, and you wouldn’t feel it.
But you could go out into the hallway a and hav a e these two groups come
together. So it was a struggle to put all these things together and hav
a e it be
as technically
l addvanced as it is.
How much did the views of the city factor in to how you shaped this space?
Williams: A lot. If we’re standing in a space looking north and east, we get
to see [Lake Michigan]. But if you go to the other side of the building you’ll
also see that we hav
a e interesting views to the south, so we’re trying to ad-
dress both the life of the north of Chicago and the life of the south of Chi-
cago, and make it come together here in the building. The building looks
very solid on the outside, but as you walk through, you’ll find that really l
every space has some dramatic window that connects you to the outdoors.
What freedoms did this site across the Midway Plaisance from the cam-
pus core afford you?
Tsien: It allows us to break free of a Neo-Gothic styl
y e. It also [lets us] look
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
back to the campus, but to the south as well. There are two front doors: the
door that opens on the Plaisance and the door [that] opens onto the South
Side. The entrance to the south is also a drop-off, and it leads to the main
lobby of the three major
a performance spaces. This is a public entrance, and
those are probablyl the most public aspects of the building. This is a kind of
gatewaya … a kind of [a] door opening.
Williams: It maya not seem that way a now, but the reality is that the fu-
ture of Chicago is actually
l in the South Side. And the Univi ersity of Chicago
recognizes that, both for itself and for the whole community.
Previo ous spr
pread
pr ead: The
ead
p tho
pen ouse
us perfo
perfo forma
form
rm ncenc
spa
p ce
c in the
th Rev Re
eva
va and
Davvid Logan Cen enter
en ter foor
the Ar
Arts
ts ove
overlorrlo
ook
oks th the
e
Midway
Mid way Plais
Pl i ance, a relic
of the 1893 World’s Fair,
to ard the Collegiate
tow
Gothic
Got hi core of the t ca ampu
mpus.
s.
Thiss imag
Thi im e: e The he LoLogan
gan
Center
Cen ter co
compr
mprise isess a ttower
w
and twtwoo wing
wingss (capped
(
in saw-toothed and green
roofs, respectively). The The
façades are cla l d not
no in
the traditional India d na
lim
mestone of other
un ver
uni versit
sityy buil
bui dindings,gs
but in a war
warmer mer-to toned
ned
versio
ver sionn that
that is qu quarr
arried
ied
in Mis
Missou
souri.
ri.
183
South–North Section
Penthouse-level
performance hall
Dance rehearsal
lab
Theatrical
rehearsal lab
Restaurant
Auditorium Courtyard Screening room
0 15 30
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Opposite: The southern façade is the public face for the residential communities on
Chicago’s South Side. An entrance underneath the projecting glass-and-metal volume
leads to a lobby from which the performance venues can be accessed. This image: The
eastern courtyard, with concrete pavers designed to mimic the shape of the building’s
stone block, can be used for casual gatherings or performances. A bridge overhead
connects a roof terrace atop the theater volume to the third floor of the arts tower.
187
This image: This lobby anchors what Billie Tsien terms a “Main Street” for
the building—the path connecting the north and south entrances. The
translucent panels enclosing the stair can double as a projection surface. Top:
The penthouse-level performance hall in the tower can serve as a classroom,
a rehearsal space, or a music venue. Micro-perforations in the walnut-lined
walls expose acoustic material that absorbs sound. Middle: Several break-out
study areas are contained within the complex, many lined with either tile from
Heath Ceramics or felt liners. Bottom: The fire stairs serve as the building’s main
vertical circulation, and offer views of the campus.
188 Basement-Level Plan Ground-Level Plan
Costume shop
Lobby
Auditorium
m
Black box
theater
Third-Level Plan
Second-Level Plan
Working gallery
Screening room
Art studios
Connecting bridge
N N
0 15 30 0 15 30
Painting and other fine-art studios are filled with natural
light thanks to windows and skylights, but less visible are
the high-tech systems behind the walls. “This building is
a place where people make art. It can be very dirty,” Tod
Williams says. “All of that dust, and dirt, and sound can
be troublesome to people who are trying to play music at
the highest level or print something in a clean way, so the
filtration system, the air system, all of these things are
crucial to be state-of-the-art.”
Project
j
190 Webb Chapel Park Pavilion Cost Consultant Gec LR—Ivica Knezovic
o ect Webb Chapel Park Pavilion, Dallas, Te
Proj T xas Size 35,000 square meters (376,737 square feet)
Client City of Dallas Cost Withheld
Architect Cooper Joseph Studio, New Yo
Y rk—Wendy
Materials and Sources
ARCHITECT NOVEMBER 2012
Evans Joseph, FA
F IA (principal-in-charge); Chris Cooper,
r
Architecture, Dallas, Te
T xas—Nancy McCoy,
o ect manager/
design team); Read Langworthy (design team)
Associate Architect Quimby McCoy Preservation
y FA
(principal-in-charge); Susan Bruns (proj
F IA
o ect manager)
Adhesives, Sealants, and Coatings Dow Corning Corp.
dowcorning.com; Hilti Corp. hilti.com
Curtainwall Reynaers Aluminum reynaers.com
Exterior Wall Systems Prefabricated concrete panels;
aluminum-finned brise soleil over glazing
Structural Engineer Jaster-Quintanilla Engineering— Insulation Isover,
r a St. Gobain Co. isover.com
John Hoenig Roofing Carlisle Sy
S nTe
T c (Classic EPDM) carlislesyntec.com
Barclays Center Electrical Engineer Gerard & Associates Consulting Structure Steel-reinforced concrete structure
o ect Barclays Center,
Proj r Brooklyn, N.Y
.Y. Engineers—Walter Gerard, P.
P E.
Client Forest City Ratner Companies Concrete Consultant Reginald D. Hough, FA
F IA
Architect SHoP Architects, New Yo
Y rk—Christopher General Contractor Phoenix I Restoration & Y uth Center of Qingpu
Yo
R. Sharples, AIA, William W. Sharples, AIA, Coren Construction o ect Yo
Proj Y uth Center of Qingpu, Shanghai
D. Sharples, AIA, Kimberly J. Holden, AIA, Gregg A. Size 903 square feet Client/Owner Shanghai Dianshanhu Newtown
Pasquarelli, AIA, Jonathan Mallie, AIA (principals); Cost $250,000 Development Co.
A umi Sugiyama, AIA, Nadine Berger,
Ay r Christopher Lee, Architect Atelier Deshaus, Shanghai—Liu Yichun, Chen
Adam Modesitt (proj
o ect managers); Sean Bailey,
y Assoc. Materials and Sources Yifeng (co-founders and principals); Gao Lin, Liu Qian,
AIA, Zach Downey,
y Rajiv Fernandez, Dickson Fogelman, Concrete Cast-in-place concrete: 40% slag mix, Wang Longhai (design team)
Y ungmoo Hur,
Yo r Isaiah King, Jan Leenknegt, Tim 10.8% flyash Interior Designer Atelier Deshaus & Ve
V rmilion Zhou
Martone, Paul Miller,
r Krista Ninivaggi, Anabelle Pang, Finishes Fine-grained exterior plaster; yellow paint Mechanical, Electrical, Structural, and Civil Engineer
Gene Pasquarelli, Daniel Plonski, Brandon Quattrone, Furniture Painted steel benches and tables with Ipe Architectural Design & Research Institute of To
T ngj
gi
Mariano Recalde, Ry
R an Salvas, Lisa Schwert, To
T dd Sigaty,
y wood tops University Group
Zack Snyder,
r Tiffany Ta
T raska, Maria Wong, Georgia Walls Exterior cement board framing (light cones) Geotechnical Engineer Shanghai Civil Defense Survey
Wright, Wontae Ya
Y ng, Bill Ye
Y ung (design team); SHoP and Design Institute
Construction, New Yo
Y rk—Brian Sweeney,
y John Cerone Construction Manager Ma Juyun
(proj
o ect managers); Peter Adams, To
T mek Bartczak, Pierresvives General Contractor Shanghai Huaxin Construction
Lindsey Cohen, Jon David, Russell Davies, Adham o ect Pierresvives, Montpellier,
Proj r France (Group) Co.
ElGhatit, Jesse Embley,
y Adam Gerber,
r Alexis Gonzalez, Client Departement de l’Herault Landscape Architect Atelier Deshaus
Konrad Graser,
r John Gulliford, Ky
K la Farrell, Asmita Jani, Architect Zaha Hadid Architects, London—Zaha Hadid, Lighting Designer Zhu To
T ngyun
Julie Jira, Emily Johnson, Ta
T ek Kim, Mathew Kirkham, Hon. FA
F IA (architectural design); Stephane Hof (proj
o ect Size 154,570 square feet
Alexis Lenza, Steve London, To
T m McInerney,
y Mark architect); Joris Pauwels, Philipp Vo
V gt, Rafael Portillo, Cost ¥52 million (CNY) ($8.3 million)
Ours, Ildiko Ozavath, Mark Pollock, Joseph Reyes, Jason Jaime Serra, Renata Dantas, Melissa Fukumoto, Jens
Roberts, Luke Smith, Foteinos Soulos, Hashim Sulieman, Borstelman, Thomas Vietzke, Patrik Schumacher,
r Kane Materials and Sources
Assoc. AIA, Caroline Yo
Y ung (team) Y negawa, Loreto Flores, Edgar Payan, Lisamarie Villegas
Ya Ceilings Armstrong armstrong.com
Architect of Record AECOM; Ellerbe Beckett Ambia, Karouko Ogawa, Stella Nikolakaki, Hon Kong Exterior Wall Systems Reinforced concrete frame
Design Builder Hunt Construction Group Chee, Caroline Andersen, Judith Reitz, Olivier Ottevaere, structure
Structural Engineer Thornton To
T masetti; Stantec (plaza) Achim Gergen, Daniel Baerlecken, Yo
Y suke Hayano, Flooring Boyn (self-leveling cement) www.boyn.com.cn;
M/E/P Engineer WSP Flack + Kurtz Martin Henn, Rafael Schmidt, Daniel Gospodinov,
v Kia Armstrong (linseed oil floor) armstrong.com
ADA Consultant McGuire Associates Larsdotter,
r Jasmina Malanovic, Ahmad Sukkar,
r Ghita Glass Zhuogao Glass (insulating low-E glass)
Acoustical Engineer Acoustical Design Group Skalli, Elena Perez, Andrea B. Caste, Lisa Cholmondeley,
y V C VRV system
HVA
Audiovisual Parsons; WJHW AIA, Douglas Chew,
w Larissa Henke, Steven Hatzellis, Lighting Philips (fluorescent lamp) philips.com
Code Consultant FP&C Consultants Jesse Chima, Adriano De Gioannis, Simon Kim, Stephane Wallcoverings Dulux (water-based paints) dulux.com
Façade Consultant ASI Limited; SHoP Construction Carnuccini, Samer Chamoun, Ram Ahronov,
v Ross Walls Aerated concrete
Façade Steel Monitoring Admetco; Dissimilar Metal Langdon, Ivan Va
V ldez, Ya
Y cira Blanco, Marta Rodriguez, Windows, Curtainwalls, and Doors Kesheng
Design Leonardo Garcia, Sevil Ya
Y zici, Hussam Chakouf,
f Marie- Curtainwalls Co. (aluminum alloy corrugated perforated
Geotechnical Langan Perrine Placais, Monica Noguero, Naomi Fritz, Stephanie plate curtainwall)
Graphics/Signage/Wayfinding Pentagram Chaltiel (design team)
LEED Consultant e4 Local Architect Blue Ta
T ngo (design phase); Chabanne et
Lighting Goldstick Lighting; Tillotson Design Partenaires (execution phase) Reva & David Logan Center
V rtical Transportation VDA/Lerch Bates
Ve Structural Engineer Ove Arup & Partners for the Arts
Size 675,000 square feet General Contractor Vinci Construction (Nanterre) o ect Reva & David Logan Center for the Arts, Chicago
Proj
Cost $675 million Acoustics Rouch Acoustique and Nicolas Albaric Client/Owner University of Chicago
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
Volume 101, number 11. November 2012. ARCHITECT® (ISSN 0746-0554; USPS 009-880) is published monthly by Hanley Wood, LLC, One Thomas Circle, NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20005. Copyright 2012 by
Hanley Wood, LLC. Opinions expressed are those of the authors or persons quoted and not necessarily those of the American Institute of Architects. Reproduction in whole or in part prohibited without written
authorization. All rights reserved. Printed in the USA.
Periodicals postage paid at Washington, DC, and at additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to ARCHITECT, P.O. Box 3494, Northbrook, IL 60065-9831.
Canada Post Registration #40612608/G.S.T. number: R-120931738. Canadian return address: Pitney Bowes Inc., P.O. Box 25542, London, ON N6C 6B2.
DISCLOSURE ARCHITECT® will occasionally write about companies in which its parent organization, Hanley Wood, LLC, has an investment interest. When it does, the magazine will fully disclose that relationship.
PRIVACY OF MAILING LIST Sometimes we share our subscriber mailing list with reputable companies we think you’ll find interesting. However, if you do not wish to be included, please call us at 888.269.8410.
Architect To
T d Williams Billie Ts
T ien Architects, New Exterior Cladding Earthworks (dolomitic limestone) 191
Y rk—To
Yo T d Williams, FA
F IA, Billie Ts
T ien, AIA (partners- ewgroupinc.com
in-charge); Philip Ry
R an, Felix Ade, Johnny Cho, Azadeh Exterior Glass Transparent and mirror-coated glass
Rashidi, Brian Abell, Aaron Fox, Evan Ripley,
y Archana panels arranged in various locations
Exterior Pavers Pietra Luna
(4) Requested Copies Distributed by Other Mail Classes Through the USPS 0 0
c. Total Paid and/or Requested Circulation [Sum of 15b 1, 2, 3 & 4] 81,615 79,631
d. Nonrequested Distribution
(1) Outside Country Nonrequested Copies Stated on PS Form 3541 1,549 1,627
(2) In-Country Nonrequested Copies Stated on PS Form 3541 0 0
(3) Nonrequested Copies Distributed Through the USPS by Other Classes of Mail 0 0
(4) Nonrequested Copies Distributed Outside the Mail 702 200
e. Total Nonrequested Distribution ((Sum of 15d (1), (2), (3), and (4)) 2,251 1,827
f. Total Distribution (Sum of 15c and 15e) 83,866 81,458
g. Copies not Distributed 1,623 1,080
h. Total (Sum of 15f and 15g) 85,489 82,538
i. Percent Paid and/or Requested Circulation 97.3% 97.8%
16.
Publication of Statement of Ownership for a Requester Publication is required and will be printed in the November 2012 issue of this publication.
17. I certify that all information furnished on this form is true and complete. Signature and title of Editor, Publisher, Business Manager, or Owner - Mary Leiphart, Audience
Marketing Director, 9/17/12
SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION
Classifieds
YOU DESIGN IT
WE MANUFACTURE IT
ANY SIZE ANY COLOR
AT UNBEATABLE PRICES
www.signmaterial.com
Webnet railing infills
BSS Inc.
Circle no. 300
Circle no. 301
www.jakob-usa.com
[ Video
®
WhiteWalls.com
Circle no. 302
NIXALITE ®
Bird Control
6XSHULRU%LUG&RQWURO3URGXFWV
5HTXHVW<RXU)5((&DWDORJ1RZ
ZZZQL[DOLWHFRP
Circle no. 303
0DJQHWIRU7RS7DOHQW
JR Walters Resources, premier A/E/C
recruiting Àrm, can assist in growing your Toll-free 1-866-215-1421
company and your career. Direct and Jakob Inc.
Contract – National and International
ZZZMUZDOWHUVFRP
RUFDOO
Circle no. 304 Circle no. 305 Circle no. 306
SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION
Classifieds/Resource
Fire Protection.
Design Perfection.
Fire-Rated Aluminum
Window And Door
Design in a New Light Systems
Aluflam USA
Phone 714-899-3990 | Fax 714-899-3993
Email info@aluflam-usa.com
www.aluflam-usa.com
Resource
%GXMSR'LERRIP*PI\9PXVE
Floor System
CONTROL NOISE...
products that match their project
vision while meeting product
efficiently & economically performance expectations.
with Eckel’s high performance
acoustic panel systems
The attractive, sound-absorbing Eckoustic ® 866-707-3552 Ř pellacommercial.com
Functional Panels (EFPs) provide a quick, Follow us on Twitter @PellaCommercial
convenient method for reducing background
© 2012 Pella Corporation
noise and reverberation in recreational, athletic,
educational, religious, cultural, commercial, Nature. Now available in aluminum.
correctional, and industrial facilities. These
Reynobond ® Design Line is a breakthrough line
Circle no. 317
v-ridged unit panels combine outstanding
acoustic performance, durability, and easy of Colorweld ® DL paint finishes so realistic they’re
installation, making them ideal for new virtually indistinguishable from nature’s own creations.
construction and for renovation projects.
Since the fire-resistant, graffiti-resistant EFPs Contact your Alcoa representative for information.
are available in virtually any color desired,
panels can be selected to match or contrast with
a room’s decor, allowing great design flexibility.
Resource
With thousands of individual Bradley’s New AdvocateTM
bathroom accessories, you can WHY DRI-DESIGN?
count on ASI to be your full-range Lavatory System Employs • No sealants, gaskets
supplier of high-quality products Touchless “All-in-One” or butyl tape mean
that are appropriately priced, Design no streaking and no
easy to install, even easier to use, maintenance for owners
and exceptionally durable. • Not laminated or a
Bradley Corp. composite material, so
For more information on CLAD WITH
introduces its new UNLIMITED panels will never
the complete line of ASI delaminate
Advocate™ POSSIBILITIES.
washroom accessories visit
Lavatory System — • Available in any anodized
americanspecialties.com or Kynar color on aluminum,
XLI½VWXPEZEXSV] plus VMZINC, stainless,
unit to provide a sink, soap, faucet and dual- copper and titanium
sided hand dryer all in one sleek, touchless
YRMX8LI±EPPMRSRI²HIWMKRWMQTPM½IWLERH-
washing while maximizing a safer restroom
environment because water goes down the
HVEMR°RSXSRXLI¾SSVSVHS[RXLI[EPPW
www.columbialighting.com
Circle no. 324 Circle no. 325 Circle no. 326
SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION
Resource
((E]PMKLX7MQYPEXMSR
*VSQ/EP[EPP
6XS
6XSSRUWLQJ%
%,0
,0 :RU
: NÀRZVIURP
& FHSWWKUR
&RQ KURXJK
KUR XJK&RPSOHWLRQ
XJ
Exelia
nt have this documcomply with g Code,
in accorda docume I
lies in this BASE WALL ent have the accept the wall
assemb SYSTE met that ance criteria assembly
II APPRO or precast)M m criteria of NFPA shall be tested
in place maximu .
e Wall (castMASO VED EXTER installed n 285. The
Concret NRY d types,IOR FINISH
, standar air gap—
betwee Concre
te Wall
listed
anchors m 2 inch l 4 inch
thick (cast in
Brick veneer vertically. Maximu d nomina Brick veneer place
WALL SYSTEM o.c. Standar or precas
I BASE R FINISH— 24 inches Hunter Xci Ply –
n and brick. 24 inches anchor t)
ED EXTERIO exterior
insulatio
brick.
Wall Assembly Guide
exterio o.c. verticas, standard
types,
II APPROVRY clayPer Chapter 26 of the r insulat lly. installe
or greater, International Building or greate ion and Maximum 2 d maxim
MASON in accordance with brick. inch air
and comply with
Code, the r, clay
wall assembly shallStanda gap betweum
assemblies in this HUNT ER the acceptance criteria brick. be tested
rd nomin
al 4 inch en
document havePANE of NFPA 285. The
S Xci PLY LS
met that criteria. listed
Xci PLY thick
HUNT ER PANEL
I BASE WALL SYSTEM
Concrete Wall (cast
II APPROVED EXTERIOR in place or precast)
FINISH—
MASONRY Brick veneer anchors,
standard types,
24 inches o.c. vertically. installed maximum
Maximum 2 inch
exterior insulation air gap between
and brick. Standard
or greater, clay brick. nominal 4 inch thick
BRICK TIES
Wall Assembly
IAL OPTIO
NS 4x8 panels PlywoodHunter
Xci Ply, Treated
IV FLOOR WRB s of Hunter® Certified Fire NFPA
Panels
at Assemb is currentl
thicknes
3.7" max or FSC 3.7" max cavity andfor the ly tests. y conducting
LINE FIREST Plywood in each WRB
fiber)thickne latest
column (IDA-approved),
Fire Treated
OPPIN Fire Treate ssntof updated Please go to addition
S CONCRETE WALL G Therma d Plywoo Hunter Xci literatur www.hu al
AL OPTION V STUD wool (e.g. Z Clips or equivale e. nterxci.
III MATERI CAVIT lb/cu ft
mineral d with4 lb/cu BRICK dTIES or FSC ® Ply, 4x8
panels 5
com
Y 4 line, attache ft Certifi /8" or
VI EXTER each floor each floor mineral wool ed Fire
Treate ¾"
PPING line, attach (e.g. Therm d Plywoo
INE FIRESTO DRAINAGE
IOR SHEAT
SPACE le EXTERIOR BRICK ed FACE
Type II or V distribution,
MEMBRANE
of WRB’s Portla the archite
APPLIED
and number
TO CONCRETE d, Maine
VaproShield: nd,
WrapShield ct.
The location n St, Portlan unterxc
W.R. Grace:
Maine SA
i.com 04101 Carlisle: Barritech VP
t 15 Frankli www.h www.
Perm-A-Barrier
hunte VPS tPROSOCO:
888.746.11 Barritech NP
Panels Sto Corp: EmeraldCoat rxci.co R-Guard
VIII WEATHER Hunter m Henry: 14 t Fax MVP CCW 705 FR
RESISTIVE MEMBRANE Air Bloc 32MR 877.775.17 0312
APPLIED TO EXTERIOR VaproShield: WrapShield Or None69
INSULATION SA Carlisle: Barritech
CCW 705 FR VP Or None
Barritech NP
designed to provide
are determined
by the architect.
Hunter Panels t
15 Franklin St, Portland,
Maine 04101 t 0312
888.746.1114 t
www.hunterxci.com Fax 877.775.1769
exceptional lighting
Hunter Panels introduces an application to performance for urban
help design professionals create NFPA 285
square, parking lot,
compliant wall assemblies utilizing Hunter Xci
“continuous insulation” products. The app is pedestrian walkway, or
visually friendly and walks you through the rural park applications.
process of assembling a compliant wall. The (800)735-8927.
app is available for iPad, iPhone and Droids.
Resource
ArchitectJobsOnline.com is the
official career site of ARCHITECT
and residential architect magazines.
Unlike general job sites, we offer Job
Postings, Career Advice, Architect
News, Architect Events, Salary
Information and Resume Posting.
So visit ArchitectJobsOnline.com Circle no. 336 Circle no. 337
Beach Club Condominiums, Pensacola Beach, FL Bullock Tice Architects Yates Construction General Contractor E. Cornell Malone Corporation Roofing SNAP-CLAD panel roofing system in Copper Penny
Edgy exterior
Bold shadow lines and color options To meet the growing demand for environ-
deliver a dramatic exterior with edge. mentally-friendly roller shade fabrics,
The new PAC Precision Wall Panel Series is a Lutron offers GreenScreen® Revive, a fabric
cost-effective solution for achieving an comprised of 89% Repreve® polyester pre-
utterly unique look. and post-consumer waste (recycled water
Any Career Site A
ArchitectJobsOnline.com
m bottles). Made in the USA, GreenScreen
Revive fabric is 100% recyclable and available
in multiple openness factors and colors.
www.PAC-CLAD.com Elk Grove Village, IL: 1 800 PAC CLAD http://[[[PYXVSRGSQ/Products/
Annapolis Junction, MD: 1 800 344 1400 Tyler, TX: 1 800 441 8661 ShadingSystems/Fabrics/Pages/Overview.aspx
Acworth, GA: 1 800 272 4482 Fridley, MN: 877 571 2025
Circle
Ci l no. 338 Circle no. 339
Pavilion on a Pedestal
1999 P/A Awards Jury
Thomas Fisher, Assoc. AIA
Eva Jiricna, Hon. FAIA
Rodolfo Machado, Intl. Assoc. AIA
Billie Tsien, AIA WITH A HUDSON VALLEY RETREAT, THOMAS PHIFER AND
Mehrdad Yazdani, Assoc. AIA
PARTNERS UPDATED THE EARLY MODERN IDEAL OF A PURE
VOLUME IN AN ARCADIAN LANDSCAPE.
Text by John Morris Dixon, FAIA
“THIS YEAR, ON THE BRINK of a new millenni- the far larger spaces—four times as much floor
um, the P/A Awards offer proof that Modernism area—that infiltrate the house’s landscaped
has weathered a generation of growing pains, plinth. Bedrooms at this level look west, toward
and is all the stronger for it.” So began the intro- the mountains across the river, while the
duction to the 1999 awards issue. Among that kitchen, family dining room, and indoor pool
year’s varied award winners, none expressed face east toward a sheltered terrace. Skylights,
the founding principles of Modernism more set flush with the grass, illuminate some under-
eloquently than did New York–based Thomas plinth spaces, and unexcavated areas allow for
Phifer and Partners’ Taghkanic House, a rural trees to flourish.
retreat on a hilltop in the Hudson Valley. The design was worked out in collaboration
WWW.ARCHITECTMAGAZINE.COM
The most visible part of the house is with landscape architect Dan Kiley, the
a pavilion fashioned with extraordinary reigning expert at extending Modernist
discipline and delicacy—a framework of white- geometries into their settings. The outcome is
painted steel, infilled with glass and fitted with not only minimal apparent disruption of the
manually operable aluminum-mesh panels land, but minimal expenditure of energy for
for sun control. Approaching the house, all such an ample residential program. Completed
SCOTT FRANCES
one sees is this 30-by-60-foot pavilion, which faithfully to the jury-honored design, the house
contains only the living and dining areas. At stands as an elegant millennial interpretation
closer range, one can see the glazed walls of of Miesian ideals.
Circle no. 441 or http://architect.hotims.com
Lutron systems help the
Empire State Building achieve
sustainability goals.
Lutron lighting controls and sensors save up to 65%
of lighting energy.*
t Wireless – simplifies installation and minimizes disruption
t Flexible – for easy retrofits or new construction
t Expandable – add to a system or reconfigure at any time
* Compared with manual (non-automated) controls, up to 65% lighting energy savings is possible on projects that
utilize all of the lighting control strategies used by Lutron in the ESB project (occupancy sensing, high-end trim, and
daylight harvesting). Actual energy savings may vary, depending on prior occupant usage, among other factors.
** Estimates based on Lutron controls installed in ESB pre-built tenant space. Payback claims assume 65% reduction
in energy costs and energy rates of 22 cents per kwh. Actual payback terms may vary.
The Empire State Building design is a registered trademark and used with permission by ESBC. Empire State Building
sustainability goals are provided by ESBC and contain energy saving strategies in addition to lighting control.