You are on page 1of 5

This article appeared in Harvard Design Magazine, Fall 2003/Winter 2004, Number 19.

To order this issue


or a subscription, visit the HDM homepage at <http://www.gsd.harvard.edu/hdm>.

© 2003 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Not to be reproduced without the permission of
the publisher: hdm-rights@gsd.harvard.edu.

Kit-of-Parts Conceptualism
Abstracting Architecture in the American Academy
by Timothy Love

Most core architecture curricula in the enterprise resistant to mainstream and


United States are predicated on the as- popular culture.
sumption that new students arrive with Within this framework, an argument
cultural preconceptions about design that can be made that beginning students em-
need to be expunged. To counter students’ phasize the semantic attributes of architec-
uninformed assumptions, many schools es- ture that they have learned through
tablish a reductive conceptual basis for ex- exposure to mainstream media like film,
ploring architectural issues through television, and shelter magazines. Acade-
carefully bounded design exercises. In mics interpret student’ received images of
many beginning studio problems, the con- domestic and public space are then inter-
ceptual boundaries and the strategies of preted based on the prevalent tastes and
design that are promoted are closer to class aspirations of a student’s particular
those of artists Sol Le Wit and Donald cultural milieu. Upper middle class stu-
Judd than to the two-dimensional and dents from metropolitan centers will come
compositional conventions of traditional to architecture programs with their tastes
art history and art theory. At the same more closely in line with the tastes of stu-
time, the need to instrumentalize a pro- dents and instructors of architecture pro-
gram of “forgetting” to focus on the purity grams than students from lower middle
of autonomous architectural problems class suburban communities. Perhaps at a
bears a strong resemblance to the ideolog- superficial level, Dwell and Metropolitan
ical and strategic tenets of American mini- Home better prepare beginning architec-
malism, perhaps best articulated by New ture students than Architectural Digest,
Yorker staff writer Lawrence Wechler in since they imply general ground rules for
his book on Robert Irwin, Seeing is Forget- acceptable architectural and decorative vo-
ting the Name of the Thing One Sees.(1) cabularies. Considered within this frame-
Both contemporary minimal art and work, architecture is initially understood
the terms of beginning design exercises as a vehicle of lifestyle differentiation. Stu-
frame the possibilities of creative endeavor dents unfettered by a pedagogical struc-
on the specific attributes of a set of physi- ture will think about design in terms of
cal elements. The “syntactical” and “phe- “amenities” such as fancy kitchens, Jacu-
nomenal” are emphasized over the zzis, and loft mezzanines, or in terms of
“semantic.” A pedagogy based on forget- iconography and symbols such as pitched
ting and retraining may be linked to the roofs, decorative front doors, and Palladi-
broader influence of neo-Marxist ideology an windows. Most design schools elimi-
in the American academy. In both literary nate the possibility of relying on these
and art theory, the avant-garde was reposi- preconceptions by teaching beginning de-
tioned as a distinct and important cultural sign with a series of exercises that keep

1 H A RVA R D D E S I G N M A G A Z I N E
ARCHITECTURE AS CONCEPTUAL ART? KIT-OF-PARTS CONCEPTUALISM

these issues and desires at bay. that evolved immediately after the Second work within which elaboration and inven-
From the late 1970s until the World War. A primary protagonist was tion was possible.
early 1990s, the “kit-of-parts problem” Rudolf Wittkower, who had published im- Another important influence on the
was a common introductory studio prob- portant essays on role of geometry in the nine-square grid problem was Rudolf Arn-
lem. By reducing possible design solutions works of Alberti and Palladio, essays later heim, an art historian who had developed
to reductive elements like “walls-as- collected in Architectural Principles in the a theory of the psychology of form based
planes” and “piers,” students were encour- Age of Humanism (1949, 1962).(3) The on the principles of German gestalt theo-
aged to think about spatial relations. book includes “Palladio’s Geometry: the ry. In his seminal Art and Visual Perception:
Other issues—such as the relation be- Villas,” in which Wittkower argues that A Psychology of the Creative Eye (1954),(7)
tween function/program and form, the re- similar organizational schema underlie all Arnheim uses an analytic method that de-
lation between iconography/symbol and the villas. Wittkower’s diagrams of the vil- ploys a wide variety of art historical exam-
form, and the relation between construc- las are variations of a three-bay by three- ples to illuminate specific compositional
tion technique and form—were not con- bay diagram—a nine-square grid. strategies, a method of comparative analy-
sidered. More significantly, the Wittkower suggests that Palladio’s villas sis that is structurally similar to Rowe’s
kit-of-parts problem deflected attention can be consid- ered as a single conceptual analysis of Malcontenta and Garches.
away from reasons for architecture-to-be- project based on variations of an ideal plan When considered within the framework of
in-the-world (displays of identity, for ex- diagram: “What was in Palladio’s mind gestalt theory, the nine-square grid be-
ample) by focusing attention on the when he experimented over and over came the ideal geometric format for un-
principles of architecture as an au- again with the same elements? Once he derstanding the interrelation between
tonomous discipline. The classic example had found the basic geometric pattern for pier/column and wall, because the format
of the kit-of-parts was the nine-square the problem ‘villa,’ he adapted it as clearly inherently includes “center,” “edges,” and
grid problem, developed by John Hejduk and as simply as possible to the special re- “corners” within the its neutral frame-
at the University of Texas in the mid- quirements of each commission. He rec- work. The attributes of the grid thus bear
1950s.(2) onciled the truth at hand with the ‘certain an explicit relationship to the recurring

© 2003 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Not to be reproduced without the permission of the publisher
In the typical nine-square grid prob- truth’ of mathematics which is final and compositional themes that Arnheim artic-
lem exercise, students were given a pre-ex- unchangeable.”(4) ulates in his book. Spatial elaboration
isting nine-square cage within which other The idea that the plan diagram itself within the framework of the nine-square,
architectural elements could be added and could a subject of critical inquiry emerged made possible by the addition of walls, is
arranged. The problem was predicated on from post-war architectural theory in Col- therefore established against the back-
two notions of a priori elements. The first in Rowe’s essay “Mathematics of the Ideal ground of the natural hierarchy of the
was the frame that provided the context Villa”(1947).(5) Rowe, a student of Wit- pre-existing grid.
for subsequent architectural operations. tkower at the Warburg Institute from Since the architectural elements that
The second were the elements that could 1945 to 1947, extends Wittkower’s analysis make up the nine-square grid exercise
be added to the frame; their attributes de- of the grid/bay by comparing Palladio’s were meant to be abstract, compositional
fined in the rules of the project brief. The Villa Malcontenta with Le Corbusier’s Vil- decisions were meant to focus on the spa-
precise terms of the exercise ensured an la at Garches. The essay serves as both a tial figures (or implied spatial figures) that
abstract architectural language predicated historical legitimatization of Le Cor- resulted from the placement of walls with-
on the dialectic between the cage/frame busier’s oeuvre and a reassertion of Wit- in the framework of piers. Spaces were not
and the other additive elements, prioritiz- tkower’s dialectic of the ideal concept of defined by complete and unambiguous en-
ing the syntactical relation between the the plan diagram with the specific elabora- closure but rather implied by the corre-
piers of the cage (as ‘points’ in plan) and tion of the plan. Some of the original au- spondence of the edges of elements. The
the walls (as ‘lines’/’planes’). The prob- dacity of the essay can be grasped if one definition of space through inference en-
lems also tended to emphasize the under- realizes that Rowe compared Palladio to couraged minimal means for creating a
lying validity of the plan diagram as a tool Le Corbusier as an architect at the prime spatial figure. This strategy also permitted
for making sequential design decisions of his career, yet the essay was written be- the simultaneous definition of several in-
since the 9-square grid was the neutral fore the building of Ronchamp, Ahmed- terpenetrating spaces. Thus the nine-
game-board on which elaborations were abad, Chandigarh, and La Tourette.(6) square grid problem became the ideal
explored. The transformation of the sim- While ostensibly a historical analysis, vehicle to explore the theory of spatial re-
ple geometric order of the 9-square frame Rowe’s essay reads in hindsight as a thinly lations articulated in Colin Rowe and
into a more spatially complex geometric veiled argument for an architectural agen- Robert Slutzky’s seminal essay “Trans-
schema became the preoccupation of the da based on a negotiation between the parency: Literal and Phenomenal.”(8) In
exercise. ideal terms of the diagram and the messy their essay, Rowe and Slutzky argue for a
The terms of the nine-square grid circumstance of the program. The plan di- more sophisticated understanding of
problem were influenced by a specific agram was less a paradigm in the neo-clas- transparency by comparing the relatively
pedigree of art and architecture history sical tradition but rather a loose frame- simple phenomenal definition (seeing one

2 H A RVA R D D E S I G N M A G A Z I N E FA L L 2 0 0 3 / W I N T E R 2 0 0 4
ARCHITECTURE AS CONCEPTUAL ART? KIT-OF-PARTS CONCEPTUALISM

element through another) to a spatial con- link to the history of enduring architectur- white architecture of both Le Corbusier
ception of the term. The possibility exist- al principles by embracing the primacy of and Guiseppe Terragni (the latter “discov-
ed, within the terms of their argument, to the plan diagram. In addition, and more ered” by Peter Eisenman and added to the
occupy two spatial figures simultaneously. significantly, the houses tend to deploy the canon in the early 1970s).(10)
Significantly, Rowe, Slutzky, and Hejduk architectural grammar and compositional The nine-square grid and its progeny
were teaching together in Texas when the tactics of Mies van der Rohe (and to a can be considered formative in the redi-
essay was written and published. lesser extent, Le Corbusier), establishing rection of pedagogy in American architec-
With both Arnheim and Rowe/Slutzky for the first time in the academy a self- ture schools, although it was not a perv-
providing the conceptual underpinning for conscious rather than a casual acknowl- asive until the late 1970s with the diaspora
the motives of the kit-of-parts design exer- edgement of a prevalent Modernist canon of the graduates of Cornell, Syracuse,
cise, the focus of projects was clearly es- within the structure of a design curricu- Princeton, and Cooper Union to more
tablished. Instead of starting with a lum.(9) This is evident in both their spa- and more architecture programs. The
program or verbally articulated set of in- tial character and the precise syntactic growing popularity of the kit-of-parts de-
tentions (a brief) from which a design was relation between pier, wall, and furniture. sign exercises both encouraged and re-
then to be developed, the kit-of-parts The systematic representation of pre-ex- flected the general return to autonomy in
problem made composition and the elabo- isting architectural languages is consistent the discipline of architecture in the late
ration of a compositional schema the mo- with the role that the analysis of historical 1960s and 1970s manifested in the work of
tive for design. “Spatially complex rather precedent played in the new curriculum at Aldo Rossi and the Tendenza movement
than simplistic” became the goal of design the University of Texas. The implication in Italy and in the New York Five (includ-
development and critique. Architectural was that architecture was a language to ing Michael Graves, John Hejduk and Pe-
composition explored within the format of learn—a pedagogical emphasis different ter Eisenman) in the United States. While
the design exercises was understood from the problem-solving methodology the influence of these exercises can be
against the cultural history of composi- developed by Gropius at Harvard. considered positive for having energized
tional strategies demonstrated in art and The emphasis on the transformation and inspired avant-garde practice, the spe-

© 2003 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Not to be reproduced without the permission of the publisher
architectural history. In truth, something of the plan diagram and the elaboration of cific attributes of the exercises can also be
more original was being proposed within space had the reciprocal effect of de-em- criticized for what they left out. Most im-
the reductive framework of the studio de- phasizing the facts of construction, detail, portant, the term of the exercises severed
sign problem since the relations between and the quality of materials. What began the relationship between the sense of play
architectural elements themselves, and the as a set of exercises with a bias towards a afforded by sophisticated syntactical oper-
spaces that resulted, could be a meaningful Miesian language ended up favoring the ations and the qualifying “content” of an
endeavor. less material-specific Corbusier of La architectural problem, whether the pro-
In addition to spatial elaboration, the Roche/Jeanneret, Garches, Ahmedabad, gram or the rules of a constructural sys-
nine-square grid problem also established and La Tourette. In House 4 of the Texas tem.
the plan diagram as the conceptual under- Houses, the physical characteristics of the While the kit-of-parts problem refo-
pinning of an architectural work. Both H column results in specific wall thick- cused design education on the definition
Wittkower and Rowe had introduced a nesses and details related to the width and and articulation of space, and on the en-
method of formal analysis the aim of thickness of the column flange. This level richment of the “architectural promenade”
which was the reduction of a work of ar- of articulated resolution of building ele- (achieved with spatial elaboration), the ex-
chitecture to a geometric schema typically ments ran against the spatially biased ercises most decidedly de-emphasized the
represented in plan. With the nine-square agenda of Rowe and Slutzky. As a result, a material aspects of architecture and the
grid, Hejduk had developed a design Miesian language that could balance spa- role of program in the thinking-through
methodology in which the diagram could tial elaboration with the syntactical elabo- of an architectural project. If the kit-of-
be a starting point for the kinds of spatial ration of the construction joint was parts exercise became de rigueur at a broad
elaborations that Rowe and Slutzky cham- ultimately replaced with Corbusier’s free range of American architecture schools in
pioned. To clarify the theoretical under- plan. In Corbusier’s vocabulary of the the mid to late 1970s, perhaps their perva-
pinning of the new pedagogical focus, 1920s, round columns and walls come tan- siveness as a methodology for design
Hejduk designed a series of houses that talizingly close but rarely touch, resulting thinking partly contributed to the change
explore the rich variety of spatial relations in a lack of need for syntactical resolution in emphasis in the 1980s from an architec-
possible within the perceived constraints at their intersection. With this language of ture based on material expression and
of the nine-square grid exercise. The elements, walls and columns can more “big-move” platonic geometries (as typi-
“Texas Houses” are presented as variations purely operate as instigators of a spatial fied by the work of I.M. Pei) to an archi-
of a single idealized diagram; as such, they agenda, better servicing the larger peda- tecture based on the elaboration of the
bear a strong resemblance to Wittkower’s gogical goals of the kit-of-parts exercise. plan diagram generated from a response to
diagrams of Palladian villas. An emphasis on space and complex com- contextual conditions and typological
The Texas Houses acknowledge the positional strategies finally favored the precedent (as typified by James Stirling’s

3 H A RVA R D D E S I G N M A G A Z I N E FA L L 2 0 0 3 / W I N T E R 2 0 0 4
ARCHITECTURE AS CONCEPTUAL ART? KIT-OF-PARTS CONCEPTUALISM

Staatsgalerie in Stuttgart). The material bled or aggregated to create viable con- parts project, however, the itinerary of the
and construction facts of building were no structional strategies. These studio prob- spatial sequence is motivated only by the
longer part of the architectural agenda. lems became popular during the late 1980s spatial clues, creating a tautology of inten-
Facades, instead, were meant to mimic or and early 1990s, when the academy began tion and effect that could never quite sat-
comment on the context of the building to lament the loss of “authenticity” in isfy in the purest manifestations of the
but not be generated from the poetic elab- American architecture.(11) This was also project. What was missing was a juicy sto-
oration of constructional necessities. a period when model making became ry that could drive the content of the
The Wexner Center at Ohio State more homespun and “authentic” in archi- promenade and thus also the spatial effect.
University by Peter Eisenman is an exam- tecture studios. Instead of representing Maya Lin’s Vietnam Memorial was the
ple of a building that exhibits characteris- buildings “to scale” in carefully detailed ideal example of the possibilities of narra-
tics motivated by the framework of the basswood, students at Harvard began to tive to provide fuel for an abstract archi-
kit-of-parts problem. It is a spatially com- favor models built of poured plaster and tectural solution. With the Challenger
plex building that discounts the material found materials. They were meant to be as Space Shuttle Memorial competition in
facts of the architecture except as they much art objects imbued with their own the late 1980s, the memorial became a
serve as “signs.” The richly overlapping material qualities as representations of fu- popular design problem because it encour-
spaces, whether implied by frames or ture construction. The change was influ- aged consideration of Big Ideas in the
planes, are all defined by painted gypsum enced as much by Rafael Moneo’s interest academy. A series of Holocaust memorial
board and off-the-shelf acoustic ceiling in experimentation (and critique of the competitions, the Oklahoma City Memor-
systems. Brick is selectively deployed to al- more ‘professionalized’ character of the ial, and Daniel Libeskind’s Jewish Muse-
lude to pre-existing buildings on the site school) (12) as it was by the publication of um in Berlin have further legitimized the
(in a series of faux ruins), but not for its a monograph highlighting the recent stu- need for a weighty narrative to justify
material qualities and uses. The program dio projects from Cooper Union.(13) meaningful architectural production. The
content of the building is not the driver of An emphasis on material research was grief of September 11 and the subsequent
design development; the form of the also generated by the implementation of process to choose an appropriate response

© 2003 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Not to be reproduced without the permission of the publisher
building is instead a result of the selective more rigorous criteria for tenure review in (and team) to redevelop Ground Zero has
mapping of “physical forces” on the site, university architecture departments. De- only further popularized this kind of exer-
resulting in an itinerary that is choreo- sign generalists could no longer satisfy the cise; many schools, have recently included
graphed both outside and inside the build- scrutiny of non-architects in the academy a World Trade Center problem in their
ing. The overlap of competing spatial with “design research” in practice alone. curricula.
systems is generated by two axes that exist Separate “defendable” research agendas While the Learning-by-Making and
on the campus; the program/content and were required for tenure review, forcing Narrative/Memorial problems both ad-
the constructional logic play relatively mi- design professors to choose between either dress the potential shortcomings of the
nor roles in the design. Perhaps it is the a more scholarly history/theory path or classic kit-of-parts exercise, they both fail
relative disregard for the quality of the more scientifically grounded material re- at providing a fine-grain framework for
building materials and details that makes search agenda. Architecture programs are learning the rich possibilities of opera-
the Wexner Center so decidedly postmod- still adjusting to the resulting professional- tional design strategies. In the materials-
ern in character today. ization of the academy and the diminish- oriented foundation problem, the student
Whether the underlying motives of ing presence of the practicing architect/ is encouraged to think about materials to
the kit-of-parts exercise can be blamed for design instructor. Certainly, the paradigm create phenomenal “effects” and rich pat-
the worst excesses of Postmodernism can for the design theorist changed dramati- terns based on logics of assembly, but the
be debated, but several new beginning de- cally from the mid-1970s to the late- broader terms of composition and syntac-
sign exercises were developed Harvard and 1980s. Influential practitioner-theorists tical relations are not considered. In the
elsewhere in the late 1980s and early such as Robert Venturi, Fred Koetter, and Narrative/Memorial problem, metaphor
1990s that competed with the kit-of-parts Michael Graves were being supplanted by and iconography are highlighted at the ex-
problem as the primary method for teach- a new generation of scholar-theorists such pense of the finer grain of design thinking.
ing students a new language. The first was as Michael Hayes, Beatriz Colomina, and Rather than reject the kit-of-parts prob-
a category of exercises that can be loosely Mark Wigley.(14) lem in favor of the alternatives I have out-
called “Learning by Making,” exercises The second category of new founda- lined, I would argue that the original
that began with the selection of specific tion exercise was predicated on the idea intentions of the kit-of-parts problem still
materials. In this genre of problem, stu- that “narrative” could be a driver of archi- provide a useful pedagogical platform for
dents are encouraged to discover design tectural elaboration. Perhaps this kind of beginning architecture students. By focus-
potential in the properties of material exercise was the result of the latent signifi- ing on the specific attributes of architec-
themselves; both in terms of their inherent cance of the architectural promenade as tural elements and the operational relat-
character (“translucence,” for example) the motive for spatial elaboration in the ions between them, students are best able
and in terms of how they can be assem- classic kit-of-parts problem. In the kit-of- to explore the expressive boundaries of the

4 H A RVA R D D E S I G N M A G A Z I N E FA L L 2 0 0 3 / W I N T E R 2 0 0 4
ARCHITECTURE AS CONCEPTUAL ART? KIT-OF-PARTS CONCEPTUALISM

discipline. What is missing from the clas- 7. Arnheim, Rudolf, Art and Visual Perception: A Psy-
sic kit-of-parts exercise, however, is an chology of the Creative Eye (Berkeley, CA: The Universi-
overlay of content to instigate the archi- ty of California Press, 1974). First published in 1954.
tectural process. It is precisely the autono- 8. Rowe, Colin and Robert Slutzky, “Transparency:
my of the design exercise, the complete Literal and Phenomenal,” Mathematics of the Ideal Villa
removal of design decisions from both the and Other Essays (Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press,
physical world and a cultural context that 1976, pp. 159-183). Written 1955-56, first published
may limit theoretical sophistication at lat- in Perspecta, 1963.
er stages of design education and eventual- 9. The influence of Mies on Hejduk is much different
ly in practice. than Mies’ direct influence on pedagogy at the Illinois
Content, however, must be introduced Institute of Technology.
not as the Big Idea but rather as small- 10. Eisenman, Peter, “From Object to Relationship I,”
scale everyday intentions. The familiar di- Casabella 344 (January 1970) and “From Object to Re-
mensions of café tables and chairs, the lationship II,” Perspecta 13/14 (1971).
cadence of a row of neighboring trees, the 11. See the issue of Architectural Review on “American
way that wood panels can meet a steel col- Authenticity,” February 1989.
umn—all are examples of particular attrib- 12. Rafael Moneo was the Chair of the Department of
utes that can enrich the kit-of-parts Architecture at Harvard from 1985 until 1990.
exercise to include the corporeal world. 13. Hejduk, John and Richard Henderson (with edi-
In this way, the first architectural problem tors Elizabeth Diller, Diane Lewis, and Kim
can be subtly closer to the world that Shkapich), Education of an Architect: The Irwin S. Chan-
novice architecture students know from dler School of Architecture at Cooper Union, New York:
their own cultural contexts, worlds where Rizzoli, 1988.
need, pleasure, and desire are motives for 14. While the practioner-theorist is a less common ca-

© 2003 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Not to be reproduced without the permission of the publisher
invention. Ultimately architecture can be reer path in the academy today, exceptions do exist
self-reflective and inspired by its poetic such as Monica Ponce de Leon and Nader Tehrani
history only in the service of less hermetic (Office dA), and Brigitte Shim (Shim-Sutcliffe). It is
motives. Architecture cannot only be also worth mentioning that several important thinkers
about itself, an epistemology that was pos- and theorists had all but given up practice by the
sible and even necessary from the late 1970s to concentrate on teaching and writing includ-
1950s until the late 1970s, when the disci- ing Kenneth Frampton, Alan Colquohoun, and
pline rediscovered its bigger foundations. Thomas Schumacher.

Notes
1. Wechler, Lawrence, Seeing Is Forgetting the Name of Timothy Love is Assistant Professor in the Department
the Thing One Sees: A Life of Contemporary Artist Robert of Architecture at Northeastern University. From 1997
Irwin (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, to spring 2003, he lectured for the core studio pro-
1982). gram of the GSD Department of Architecture at Har-
2. For an excellent, if uncritical, history of the devel- vard. Love is a principal at Utile, an architecture and
opment of the pedagogy that I describe in this paper, planning firm in Boston.
see Alexander Caragonne, The Texas Rangers: Notes
from an Architectural Underground (Cambridge, MA:
The MIT Press, 1995).
3. Wittkower, Rudolf, Architectural Principles in the Age
of Humanism (New York: W.W. Norton and Company,
1962). First published in 1949.
4. Ibid., pg. 72.
5. Colin Rowe, “Mathematics of the Ideal Villa,”
Mathematics of the Ideal Villa and Other Essays (Cam-
bridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1976). First published in
Architectural Review, 1947.
6. Rowe’s later essay on La Tourette, published in the
Architectural Review in 1961 (also in Mathematics of the
Ideal Villa and Other Essays), can be interpreted as a val-
idation of Rowe’s original reading of Corbusier’s work.

5 H A RVA R D D E S I G N M A G A Z I N E FA L L 2 0 0 2 / W I N T E R 2 0 0 3

You might also like