Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mischal Menden
UoD: 1000202590
28/1/2011
ABSTRACT
This proposal critically assesses a sport event held in Fochheim, Germany. It outlines
key concerns raised by attendees and visitors. By applying analytical tools, such as
the Ishikawa diagram and Toyoda’s 5-Why method, the root causes of the complaints
have been determined. The theoretical stances used in this proposal are from the
Furthermore innovative ideas are presented with the aim of making the event even
more sustainable and environmental friendly. The key concerns which have been
determined are the usage of paper, the noise during the night, the sufficiency of food
and beverage outlets. More over the usage of more marketing tools has been
Abstract.........................................................................................................................2
Introduction....................................................................................................................3
Methodology..................................................................................................................6
The Tournament............................................................................................................7
Paper Usage..............................................................................................................8
Conclusion...................................................................................................................15
Reference List.............................................................................................................16
INTRODUCTION
determinable time and place, with or without the participation of human agents. It
as the cause of a succeeding occurrence.” Getz (2005) adds that a principle which
applies to every event is that they are temporary in nature. Furthermore he adds that
people.
The Quattro-Ball tournament is a yearly occurring sport-event held over one weekend
basketball, volleyball and football/ soccer. Every team has to play each sport twice a
day against previously allocated teams. The teams consist out of 12 players of which
4 have to be female. In every game at least two women have to play per team. The
Throughout this report the author will use the term Quatt-Fo, which is the name of
teams divided into 4 groups compete against each other. The history of this
tournament goes back into the 1990s, when it was first held in 1995. The event is
held at a public sports area in Forchheim, Germany, during the second weekend of
July. On Saturday the teams are being allocated in 4 different groups and will than
compete against each other within their own groups. At the end of this day the first
four of each group will be put into one group A. The second four into group B
continuing until every team is allocated again. On Sunday the teams compete for one
more time in their groups against each other. At the end the winner of group A on
Sunday is the winner of the tournament and receives a trophy, a voucher and a food
basket. Prices are given away for all kind of actions, i.e. Best-Referee, Fair-play,
The organizing team always refers to the headline of this event. “This is a Fun-
mostly local, can be spotted. But like at every other sport event the drive to win is
very high.
It can be argued now that the Quatt-Fo tournament is a festival in its nature when
looking at the definition of Goldblatt and McKibbon (1996, p.70),”a public celebration
and spectators,” especially because of its huge meaning to all the participants. On
This sport event together with the Annafest (huge local Bavarian Beer-festival) is for
the people from Forchheim essential. The Annafest, starting two weeks after the
Quattro-Ball is not only the start of the big summer vacation in Bavaria but also a
religious tradition. Taking this occurrence and comparing it to the previously stated
whereas the Annafest with its religious tradition is a typical festival. Furthermore the
Annafest determines as of when the Quatt-Fo will be held. The Quattro-Ball event
a big get-together, hence 80% of the teams are participating since the early days of
because of it special connection to the location where it is held. Supporting that is the
special anthem created by one team 10 years ago for this tournament with its
location.
This report will outline different key concerns made of participants, as well as
meet the demands of the participants and the inhabitants living in the close
This report will demonstrate the application of sport and leisure event management
communicate the innovation as well as justify the innovations made. The major
changes this report is outlining are the usage and waste of paper during this
tournament, furthermore the supply with food and beverage, as well as the
reorganization of the camping space. All this innovations will help satisfying not only
customer needs but also the demand of the people living in the surroundings to keep
it quiet during night hours. More over appropriate theory will be demonstrated to
justify the concluded. The relationship between sport and leisure events will be
shown according the work of McMahon-Beattie and Yeoman. The innovations made
are all concerning the greening of this sport and leisure event, which is a major
An innovation can be defined as, any new action which increases human
The aim of this report is to critically analyze a sports-event in the town of Forchheim,
Germany and to propose innovated ideas as of how key concerns raised can be
overcome.
issues.
The methodology used in order to obtain appropriate data and meet the aim and
Saunders et al. (2007), secondary data is data which was previously collect and/ or
analyzed focusing on a different purpose. In this assignment the author retrieved his
data from the Swiss Hospitality Management School Library, as well as from the
Emerald and Ebsco database, in order to provide a wide range of source and
enhance the validity of the statements, as well as the Wiesentbote database for
press releases. The philosophies applicable for this research are of scientific nature,
as well as social science nature. The epistemological background used for this
Hussey (2009) constructivism aims to generate new knowledge through the usage of
already existing knowledge. This stance is the most appropriate because only
secondary data has been used and the author has been asked to critique on what
has been stated earlier. Moreover enables this stance the author to synthesize the
existing knowledge and create new knowledge. Limitations within this research are
the availability of `true´ data, as well as the reliability and validity of secondary
research.
THE TOURNAMENT
Yeoman and McMahon (2004) stressed out that sports are only a part of leisure
activities. In this report the author will use the terms interchangeably. The application
the relationship between the two. Both subjects are just parts of the broad topic
`concerned with the design and operation of systems for manufacture, transport,
The tournament is held open-air, including camping at site, live music in the evening
and different food and beverage outlets. Furthermore garden showers are allocated
in order to provide the necessary refreshment while playing in 30° to 35°C. A first aid
tent is available just next to the basketball courts. The first aid team is partly
participating in the event itself as well. Live time, round, lost and found item
announcements are made as well as music is plaid throughout the day. Garbage
bags are handed out on Saturday morning and hourly controls are being made.
The event has participants from all over the country; even one team from Austria is
attending since the beginning. Some individuals are flying in from all over the world,
rumors of closing it down have been spread, to some extend because of the amount
of waste produced. People living close by the tournament complain about the noise
throughout the nights. Participants are being upset about the increasing prices of
These points have been determined to be the major issues after applying the
Ishikawa diagram as shown below, in order to achieve the first two objectives of this
proposal. This diagram is the most appropriate because of the strong relationship
Looking at this event from a more strategic perspective, the tools and theory applied
is common in the application and implication of blue ocean strategies. The market of
the Quatt-Fo is a niche market, which is associated with being a blue ocean,
the teachings of Chan Kim and Mauborgne (2005) suggest when already located in a
blue ocean the main aim should be to extend the ocean and convert red oceans into
implementing the suggested changes the author aims with the support of the blue
PAPER USAGE
The problem of waste is a common issue when holding an event In the case of the
Quattro-Ball tournament the massive amount of paper which is being used in order to
display recently taken pictures or current stats on how one team is doing, as well as
the distribution to every team of a tournament plan and a plan for referees. Each
team needs to be the referee for each sport once per day. Summing this up round
about 1000 sheets of paper is being used per day only to communicate information.
Although there are different ways of communicating these information nowadays, the
pictures which were taken by the organizing team, could for example be displayed in
digital frameworks as a slide show with a direct pick and print option (Photo-Porst,
2011). For the display of the rankings and scores an excel spreadsheet could be
projected on any HD TV. Furthermore the different tournament plans and rules and
locations. In Order to prevent the unlikely event of robbery, the TVs are monitored by
2 security cameras each. In order to communicate the results of the different games
happening during the day, the organizing team should allocate a neutral person as
counter, equipped with an Ipad or any other smart pad. These innovations will not
only help the organizing team saving the environment but also would bring such an
simplify the work which needs to be done by the organizing team. The idea is to
make this weekend event as comfortable as possible for all attendees, visitors and
The table below (1.2) provides a detailed calculation regarding the paper wasted,
s l
Saturday 64 128 512 300 1004
Sunday 64 128 512 300 1004
Table 1.1 Source: Author
Looking at the innovation from a different point of view it can be argued that the
production and usage of HD TVs is ecologically worse than the usage of paper, when
looking at the short term. Although current studies on the topic; “How green are
digital devices” (Maxwell, 2011) are being made and reviewed. In the current stage of
this argument the comments made are balanced. In order to make an appropriate
conclusion and for reaching the objectives three and four, the author decided to take
the point of view that the usage of TVs and digital frameworks is environmentally
more friendly than the production and recycling of 2000 pages of paper. Furthermore
it can be argued that Plasma TVs are environmental friendlier than HD-TVs, whereas
Greenzer (2009) pointed out in a comparison of HD TVs and Plasma TVs that the
longer one lasts the greener it is. The HD TV with about 60,000 hours last twice as
All this is quiet costly, but hence the sportsmen attending are satisfied and highly
loyal, deals can be made with local shops and participating teams. For example the
biggest Photoshop in town is attending. Digital Frameworks could be lent and in
return a reduction on F&B could be given or even a discount on the participation fee.
The owner of a local electronics store is attending as well since the past 10 years,
where the necessary technical equipment could be lent to similar conditions. Ipads
can be lent from the various mobile shop owners as well as electronic store owners
participating. This supports the previously stated argument that the usage of
TVs/Ipads is environmentally friendlier than using paper, since the TV/Ipad is not only
From the Ishikawa diagram (Figure 1.1) it is clear that the inhabitants have
complained about the noise made in the early morning hours. These arguments are
strongly related to the usage of portable music players as well as singing and
laughing attendees. In order to analyze the root cause of this concern, the author has
chosen to apply the “5-Why” method by Toyoda. (Figure 1.2) The link between
which has been established previously, is evident for this example as well.
No Sleep for
inhabitants.
WHY?
WHY?
People singing
WHY?
A large variety
of portable
music players
WHY?
No control by
the organizing
team.
WHY?
Disorganized
Source: Toyoda,1930 camping site. Figure 1.2
Not only the usage of paper, but also the noise produced by the attendees and
visitors during the night is a major issue the event is facing. In order to overcome this
McMahon (2004) support this by stating that strategic planning is crucial for every
part of the event. For further detail on the camping space please refer to Figure 1.3.
Not every team is camping at site but the numbers are increasing each year, and
camping at site last year. Allocating specific camping places for each team would
help keeping track, as of how many people are staying at site. Furthermore, the data
tournament even smoother and more comfortable for everyone. In order to meet the
demand of the inhabitants living close to the area, the camping area which is situated
at the far end of the public sports area needs to be controlled and organized. Every
team should be advised to build their tents in the shape of a circle. This reduces the
noise, if teammates still want to chat and drink in the early morning hours. Moreover,
planting of local trees, around the fences of this area will reduce the noise even
the BBQ stations could be arranged. Furthermore the usage of these spot needs to
be organized by reservations and clear allocation of camping spots for the different
teams. The idea is that on every 4 teams one BBQ is being allocated, so a total of 16
BBQs.
A further major concern, raised by attendees, was the increasing prices on Food and
Beverage as well as missing of direct food and beverage supply. The table below
lists the price and the variety of Food and Beverage options at this tournament.
Small Big
This clearly points out the missing opportunities for the event. The idea is to create
the option of direct selling of meat and vegetables. These will be already prepared by
the local butcher. The possibility of buying fresh sandwiches should be arranged, as
well in corporation with the local butcher, nutritious food is very important especially
while doing sports at such high temperatures. Furthermore the local beer brewers
would sell directly to the end consumers at the event. The average consumption per
team is around 4 crates of beer, 4 crates of water per day. A crate exists out of 24
0,5l bottles of beer, and 12 0,7l bottles of water. This is not only additional revenue
for the brewer who in exchange could sponsor i.e. the trees for the fences or
benches for the camping area. Looking at this idea from a different point of view, it
can be argued that the support of local stores is strongly related as of how
inhabitants see this local event. The habits of the inhabitants in that town are very
traditional, if a local store especially beer brewery is support and sponsors the event
vice versa, the reputation will rise automatically. Furthermore it can be stressed out
that, since every team needs to buy its food and beverages, they need to drive there
and buy it one by one. The table below shows a clear calculation of the distanced
travelled by attendees and the related usage of petrol, as well as the distanced
travelled by the beer truck and the related usage of petrol. This equation misses out
on the energy used for cooling the truck, since no data could be gathered regarding
this issue. Although it can be assumed that this will not be a distinct factor in
The data used for calculating the variables were gathered from the homepage of
during the day. The local store is 2,4km away from the event. In addition to arranging
the direct selling option for the suppliers, the camping site itself could be arranged
more attractively, as pointed out earlier with the BBQ sites. This in combination with
the direct sell of the required food would create an unforgettable experience not only
for the attendees, but also for visitors and the organizing team.
In order to prevent losses for the organizing team and commission charge can be
arranged.
MARKETING AND PR
The Marketing and PR ambitions from the organizing team are considerable. With
has established the basics of online marketing. Furthermore the press work is also
rather rare, one press release is being posted at the beginning of February; that
registration is open now. One more is published a week before, as well as on the
weekend itself. The follow up report is released three to four days after the event has
happened.
As Zarrella (2010)pointed out over 250 Million users are on facebook, 184 Million are
bloggers and over 346 Million read blogs on a day to day basis, it is clear that the
usage of social media marketing is essential for every business and event.
Furthermore he stated the eight most common tools of social media; blogs (Twitter),
voting sites (Digg, Reddit), review sites (Yelp), forums and virtual worlds. Foe this
tournament the application of facebook, Youtube and Twitter are of the greatest
interest. The other tools can be considered to be inappropriate because of their
A Facebook group page needs to be created, where monthly updates etc. can be
posted. Furthermore pictures of the event can be uploaded and viewed by anyone at
any point in time. Moreover live-video streams from the event can be published via
YouTube and linked to the Facebook page. Press releases should be published more
frequently over Twitter. All this will also help innovating this event every year.
something especially the fast paced event industry needs. Live video-streams can be
environmental more friendly and free of charge, but also a “must-have” for every
The points raised had all on common factor, the sustainability and environmental
improvements and innovations which can be made, with the example of the smart
pads, but also at the other stakeholders of this event, the inhabitants living close by.
The reorganization of the camping size will not only prevent the complaints of
inhabitants but also to improve the organization and structure as well as reputation of
this event. Furthermore with the innovation in the supply of food and beverage, the
attendees concerns will be directly addressed. This proposal outlined three major
concerns and their solution, with the aim of pleasing all stakeholders.
The event held in Forchheim, Germany has been critically assessed; the advantages
and concerns existing have been presented and evaluated. The event itself is well
structured and evidence of improvement over the years is available. On the other
hand key concerns raised by attendees and inhabitants have been critically analyzed
by using appropriate tools. The Ishikawa diagram Figure 1.1 points out the
importance of the issues raised and their relationship, with having environmental
concerns, which includes all the points established and critically assessed previously;
Paper usage, Food and Beverage supply, reorganization of the camping space, as
one of the causes presented. The key concerns have been broken apart and
innovative ideas to overcome these issues have been presented. These innovations
require a certain level of acceptance towards change, not only from the organizing
team but also from the customers/visitors. The order in which they could be
implemented is starting with the creation of online marketing and public relations,
moving forward towards the new set-up of the camping space. Since this change
requires the longest amount of time to be finished. A possibility would be to post
follow-ups on the online public relations campaign. The other two innovations should
Concluding the stated the objectives previously set have been achieved, which leads
Auto, Motor und Sport (2011) CO2 rechner. [online] available from: <http://www.auto-
Chan Kim, W. and Mauborgne R. (2005) Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create
Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant. Boston: Harvard
Getz, D. (2007) Event tourism: Definition, evolution, and research. [online] available
from:
<http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6V9R-4PT2FJ6-
1&_user=10&_coverDate=06%2F30%2F2008&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_
origin=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_searchStrId=1617546533&_rerunOri
gin=google&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=cae0
Godelnik, R. (2010) Which e-reader is the greenest one-Kobo, Sony, Nook or the
<http://ecolibris.blogspot.com/2010/11/which-e-reader-is-greenest-one-kobo.html>
<http://maps.google.de/maps?hl=en&rlz=1T4SKPB_enES377ES378&q=waste
Hickman, L. (2010) Are ebooks greener than paper books? [online] available from:
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/green-living-blog/2010/oct/05/ebook-printed-
2011.
Laing, J. and Frost, W. (2010) How green was my festival: Exploring challenges and
Maxwell, A. (2011) How Green is Your Favorite CE Product and Company [online]
<http://www.greenlivingonline.com/article/are-e-books-environmental-choice> last
Nordbayrische Nachrichten c (2010) Da wo’s das besde Bier gibbd. [online] available
Janurary 22nd.
Photo Brinke (2011) digitale Kompetenz vom Bilderprofi. [online] available from:
Robles, D. (2008) How would you define innovation? [online] available from:
Saunders M., Lewis P., Thornhill A., (2007) Research Methods for business students.
Sierra Club (2010) E-readers vs. Old fashion books- which is greener? [online]
2011.
Toyoda S. (1930) King of Japanese inventors: the 5 why method [online] available
from: <http://www.adb.org/Documents/Information/Knowledge-Solutions/The-Five-
2011
Wiesentbote b (2007) 12. Quattroball turnier 14/15 Juli auf der Sportinsel Forchheim.
Zarrella D. (2010) The Social Media Marketing Book. O’Reily Media Inc. Sebastopol:
California.