Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EXPERIENCE ON TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATIONS
Gerlin Catangui
July 2005
DISCLAIMER
“The views expressed in this report are strictly those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of
the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) and the Ateneo de Manila University”.
Abstract
This policy issue paper surveys international and specific country experiences of
taxpayer unions and associations, their objectives and accomplishments. It
summarizes influences, lessons learnt from, and policy gains made by these
associations.
Policy Issue Paper on Int’l Experiences of Taxpayers Unions/Asso. Page 1 of 7
EPRA Tax Administration Sector
October 2005
Most associations have both individual and business members. Others have focused
primarily on services to small businesses. Majority of the members live in the larger
cities, but many countries are trying to mobilise taxpayers in rural areas as well (e.g.
Sweden and Canada, focusing on local issues). In Germany and the US, local branches
have emerged on a wider scale.
Most associations are financed by membership fees thus recruitment of new members is
important. Retaining members is a big problem faced by most associations. Associations
offering both a fixed set of services and a vision about taxation have fared well in keeping
their members.
1.2.2 Canada
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) is an advocacy organisation operating
federally and in satellite offices in five provincial capitals. CTF organises speak out on
behalf of taxpayers, campaigns, conferences, annual events, publications and website, and
offers reports and submissions to legislative hearings and committees.
CTF espouses a political message about taxation: lower taxes, less waste and accountable
government. As such, its priorities are: corporate welfare, health care reform,
intergenerational equity, gas tax honesty campaign, accountability and democratic reform
measures, Teddies and TaxFighter of the Year awards, municipal reform and tax reform,
and budgets.
The National Taxpayers Union (NTU), the biggest and oldest national TA, was
established to educate taxpayers, the media, and elected officials on a non-partisan basis
on the merits of limited government and low taxes. NTU uses a variety of means to
accomplish its work including direct mail, research papers, public speaking, email,
advertising, the Internet, and lobbying. The National Taxpayers Union Foundation
(NTUF) was established to conduct extensive study and research into critical aspects of
taxation, government spending, economics, and regulation. Its work examines policies at
the federal, state, and local levels.
Most associations have been created both to put pressure on the tax administration and to
educate and inform taxpayers about their rights and obligations.
On paper, most of the TA’s are politically independent, however in some TA’s prominent
politicians, members of parliament and top tax administration bureaucrats hold leadership
positions (e.g., Ukraine, Russia). Many other associations maintain links with political
parties, although they claim that they are not serving any particular party interests. Most
TA’s value the importance of maintaining a good relationship with politicians and
working together with the tax administration and other government institutions to make
change.
Most TA’s have been established primarily due to voluntary efforts and grants from
external sources. Most associations have difficulty getting enough money to finance their
operations and programmes. Although membership fees contribute to the overall budget,
it is not substantial. Foreign grants and donations still make a substantial contribution:
Eurasian Foundation, GTZ, Soros Foundation, USAID, Open Society Institute, Winrock
International, US Women’s Group, Canadian Government, The Netherlands Government,
UNDP, Friedreich Ebert Foundation.
Purpose
WTA’s purpose is to work “towards a society with lower taxes and more individual
freedom. It wishes to stimulate efficiency and economy in the public sector. It supports
legislation to limit tax burdens, prevent unjust harassment by tax collectors, and provide
clear information about government taxation and expenditure.” Towards this end, its aim
is to:
Stimulate contacts and exchanges of information between the different countries
and their organisations;
Spread the taxpayers’ movement to other countries;
Stimulate comparative studies of public expenditure and taxation;
Enable members in one country to receive assistance in tax matters from
associations in other countries; and
Stimulate research on the effects of taxes and government spending on
economic development.
Accomplishments
Aside from the regular conferences it holds and the networking privileges, the WTA have
also developed a:
Guideline on “How to Start and Run a Taxpayers Association”. The proposed
mission statement incorporates the following components and advocacies:
Legal rights for taxpayers; Efficient public sector; Privatisation and
deregulation; Low taxes; Transparent and visible taxes; and, Simple and clear
tax system.
Taxpayers Associations Knowledge Sharing.
Its purpose and aims are the same as that of the WTA, though much of its political focus
is on the European Union (EU) and Brussels.
Table 1. Typology
Taxpayers association Undertakes general watchdog activities
Conducts information, education and advocacy
Performs study and research
Examines policies
Engages in lobbying
Offers tax services
Taxpayers union Undertakes general watchdog activities
Conducts information, education and advocacy
Engages in lobbying
Research and policy aspect transferred to foundation
Taxpayers foundation Performs extensive study and research
Examines policies
Table 3. By Activity
Activity Specific Activity/Services Offered by
General Watchdog TA External monitoring All TA’s
Citizen’s voice & participation
Information, Speak out, email, direct mail All TA’s
Education & Campaigns, advertising, PR,
Advocacy TA lobby
Conferences, seminars,
workshops, presentations
Annual events
Publications & websites
Research & Policy TA Studies and research papers Most TA’s
Research programmes & projects Still limited in
Publications, websites Central Asia &
Conferences, seminars, Eastern Europe
workshops TA’s
Policy change, reform &
legislative action
Presentations, hearings,
submissions & reports, in-person
meetings
Lobby
Tax Services TA Assistance in court, legal Most European
assistance and services TA’s
Tax advisory Most Central Asia
Newsletters, exclusive journals and Eastern Europe
and other publications TA’s
Discounts on various services Except France, US
such as gas and telephone
4. Lessons Learnt
5. Policy Results/Accomplishments
Associations that advocate a political “message” about taxation have been generally
successful in influencing policy-making, from policy design to policy reform, policy
change and even policy termination. Policy gains include:
Income tax indexing (e.g., US, Canada)
“Taxpayer Bill of Rights”, taxpayer protection laws (e.g., US, some Canadian
provinces)
Balanced budget amendment (e.g., US, Canada)
Freedom of information, democratic reform, race equality (e.g., US, Canada)
Associations in transition economies have been credited for influencing the movement
for:
Flat income tax (e.g., Russia, Slovakia, Ukraine)
Legal protection and assistance (e.g., Central Asia and Eastern Europe TA’s)
Associations that offer tax services have been successful in assisting members on:
Tax-related publications, newsletters, journals, websites, conferences, seminars
and workshops
Tax advisory, research, legal protection and assistance
Other services (e.g., discounts on utilities, cross-border assistance)
Most associations have claimed credit for policy gains, big or small, in:
Various tax administration reforms and improvements in tax policy
Some specific examples: politicians pay reform, bracket creep squeeze,
dedicated fuel taxes, and end to corporate welfare (Canada); and, state and local
tax limitation movements (US)
SOURCES
Appendix
Table 1: International Experiences of Taxpayers Unions/Associations: National Taxpayers Associations
COUNTRY Typology Mission Activities/Services Management Funding Policy Results/
Accomplishments
Australia Association To educate taxpayers on taxation matters Tax services Independent Membership Annual Tax Summary
(Taxpayers’ and to protect their interests by acting as an Exclusive website fees (tax
Australia, independent tax watchdog access for members deductible)
c1919) Information, Earnings
education & advocacy from various
Research & policy services
Canada Federation Lower taxes, less waste and accountable Information, Independent Donations Democratic reform
(Canadian government education & advocacy No Balancing the budget
Taxpayers Research & policy membership Politicians pay reform
Federation, Strong lobby group fees Tax reform
c1990) No charitable End to corporate welfare
tax number 1995 Federal Budget
No Balanced budget/
government Taxpayer protection laws
grant Aboriginal policy reform
Freedom of information
laws
The bracket creep
squeeze
Dedicated fuel taxes
Sweden Association Fight high taxes Mix of vision and Independent Membership Taxation service &
(Swedish individual tax services fees assistance over the border
Taxpayers Information, Earnings (Norway, Finland)
Association, education & advocacy from various 80% of all registered
c1921) Research & policy services members remain members
Lobby group Interests from
investments
Donations
United Kingdom Alliance To reverse the perception that big Information, Independent Donations Forced HM Treasury to
(TaxPayers’ government is necessary and irreversible education & advocacy publicly respond to its
Alliance, To explain the benefits of a lower tax Research & policy Bumper Book of
Estonia Association To prevent an increase of tax pressure Tax services Cooperates with Limited Worked w/ MoF on 50
(Estonian To inform taxpayers Cooperation with the tax financial amendments to make tax
Taxpayers To protect taxpayers rights legislative institutions administration resources: legislation more taxpayer-
Association, Information, Membership friendly
c1996) education & advocacy fees
Research in tax Charges for
policy tax courses
Russia Association To promote an effective tax legislation Information, Have Limited Passage of the lowest flat
(Russian To control the budget received from taxes education & advocacy prominent financial income tax in the world
Taxpayers To promote a democratic program Taxpayer assistancepoliticians, resources (13%; c2001)
Association, Legal protection & parliamentarians
c1997) assistance and top tax
Research & policy bureaucrats in
*(Russian *(Union) Propaganda on tax leadership
Taxpayers Union, positions
policy through its own
c1996) mass media Cooperates with
the tax
administration
Maintains links
with political
parties
Slovakia Association To decrease total tax and contribution Information, Cooperates with Limited Passage of the flat income
(Slovak burden education & advocacy the tax financial tax (19%, c2004)
Taxpayers To ensure better media coverage of issues Taxpayer assistance administration resources:
Association, of public interest Legal protection & Maintains links No
c1996) To assure more efficient advocacy of assistance with political membership fee
taxpayers interests Research & policy parties Donations
To protect the interests of taxpayers by Auditing
supporting initiatives on reducing tax rates, implementation of
public expenditures and balancing the state political programmes
budget
To strengthen the public debate on public
finance and tax burden
To involve citizens in control over public
finances