Professional Documents
Culture Documents
c
Y
rooms for improvement in their service level. The objective of this report is to analyze the
customers¶ satisfaction and dissatisfaction towards Maxis¶ customer service level, as well as
In this research, both primary and secondary methods are applied to attain the researchers¶
goals. The research started with the collection of secondary data that is related to Maxis.
Primary methods such as survey questionnaires, focus groups and individual depth interviews
were undertaken for further study. The targeted population was the residents in Klang Valley.
However, due to time and budgetary constraints throughout the research, the researchers only
As a result, the researchers recognized the dissatisfaction and the demand of the respondents
towards Maxis¶ service level. In primary data, the researchers discovered the respondents¶
needs and wants from a telecommunication provider. Furthermore, the data collected shown
that most of the respondents prefer to use Maxis as it has the widest network coverage
From both primary and secondary data, the researchers found out that most respondents
prefer a fast service from the provider. Besides, most users would not make any complaints
although they face problems with their telecommunication line. This is due to the slow
service provided by the provider which leads the customers to have negative perception. Even
if the customers make a complaint, their problems would not be resolved immediately. The
company could improve their operators by giving them a better training before providing a
c cc cc
c
c
c
u
differentiate themselves from their competitors and gain benefits over competition. A variety
of promotional services were attempted over the years. A high level of service becomes the
selling point to attract customers¶ awareness as it is the most significant driver in customer
satisfaction (McDougall & Levesque, 2000 cited in Chang & Ernest, 2009). By the end of
number three with 7.7 million subscribers. U-Mobile, one of the new operators estimated to
Tunetalk too managed to get 1.2 million subscribers on its first year of operation.
u Y
Maxis Berhad was founded by Ananda Krishnan. It is the leading mobile communications
service provider in Malaysia with over 12.0 million mobile subscriptions as of 31 December
company in Malaysia provides a full set of services which includes mobile, fixed line
telephony, data and network service in order to fulfill the demand of telecommunication.
Maxis was the first to launch Maxis3G service in Malaysia in 1995. It was also among the
world¶s first to use HSDPA to further enhance wireless broadband services in 2006. Maxis
was also the first telecommunication service provider to bring the BlackBerry and Apple
c cc cc
c
c
c
Maxis has won numerous awards over the year. The latest awards include:
c Maxis Customer Service Strikes GOLD as Best Malaysian In-House Contact Centre
for 2010
c Malaysia's Top Ten Companies: Ranked 1 ± Asia's 200 Most Admired Companies,
u u
each other to gain more productivity and profitability. However, customer service should not
telecommunication industry. In the case of Maxis, it has to consider in all aspects particularly
on customer service level. It is important to identify the needs, demands and perception of the
c cc cc
c
c
c
-
Research methodology refers to the procedural framework within which the research is
conducted (Remenyi et al., 1998). Research method is concerned with how the design is
(Pecceault & McCarthy, 1999). It is normally direct observed, recorded or collected directly
from the respondents. Generally, these data are original and collected to address the current
Maxis¶ customer service. The research process started off with the questionnaires
distributions, e-mail surveys, followed by focus groups and individual depth interviews.
The research process first started with questionnaire distribution because it is the easiest
method to obtain substantial data. 50 questionnaires were being distributed in colleges (KDU,
Help) and shopping malls compounds (One Utama, The Curve) which located in Klang
Valley. All these venues were selected by the researchers due to their familiarity and the
well-located spots that provide more conveniences. Questionnaire is vital in the research
process because it gives an advantage to understand better on the customers¶ needs, wants
and expectations towards the Maxis¶ service level. It also provides opportunities for the
c cc cc
c
c
c
However, there would be some inaccurate and insufficient information given. Thus, the
researchers required to print more questionnaires and distribute out to other respondents again.
Both time and money were wasted. As the researchers did not get sufficient information, so
- Y u
Researchers targeted the young adults who are frequent computer users. This is because those
young adults are introverted and would most likely give more accurate answers in this
method. 30 questionnaires were sent out to them via e-mail for acquiring the data at a faster
pace without wasting any cost. Moreover, it is flexible regardless of time and location.
Nevertheless, this method may not be the most effective way because the researchers would
not know how reliable the information gathered is. Thus, focus groups were being conducted
- Y - !"
Researchers targeted students who are active and bold in interacting. 10 were chosen and
divided into Group A and Group B. In each session, 3 researchers would observe them in
order to identify and record down each respondent¶s action and behaviour. It helps to
understand more on what an individual needs and perceives towards Maxis¶ service level.
However, finding the most appropriate respondents and conducting focus group were not an
easy job. The researchers were required to be alert at all times to ensure all respondents are
c cc cc
c
c
c
- Y #
"
$
Researchers targeted the working class respondents because they have more ideas and
feedbacks towards Maxis. Researchers conducted 5 sessions and managed to know whether
the respondent is lying by observing at their gestures and eyes. Most respondents were
providing sufficient and accurate information which helped the researchers to adapt their
According to Glass (1976), secondary analysis is the re-analysis of data for the purpose of
answering the original research question with better statistical techniques, or answering new
questions with old data. This is the most significant advantage for the researchers to save
their time and cost when doing research for Maxis. The data and facts were obtained by the
researchers through different ways, which included electronic databases such as EBSCOhost
for journals and articles, online research on Maxis and other competitors¶ homepage, collect
company¶s annual report from Bursa Malaysia, and in depth research in KDU library for
Nevertheless, secondary data are often out-of-date and not all information fits a problem
completely. This is because secondary data are collected from other resource in other location
and it may not fit all customers as each customer varied from each other. Furthermore,
accuracy of secondary data may also be questionable as there are errors found in the
c c c cc
c
c
c
V
Gi
6c
G
Gi t t t
icllcclctc
cc
illcclc
c c c cc
c
c
c
Figure 2
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Chinese Malay Indian Others
Female 50% 2% 1% 2%
Male 35% 3% 1% 6%
0 85% of the respondents are Chinese. This is because questionnaires were
distributed in Chinese-oriented areas. Only 5% of Malays and 2% of Indians took the survey
because most of them were unavailable during that period when the survey was conducted.
Besides, the survey was taken on a public holiday. Furthermore, only a small number of
foreigners who have been residing in Malaysia for years were found in the survey because
c c
c cc
c
c
c
Figure 3
"
thers
Student
Lecturer
Businessman
0 There are 56% of students being conducted in the survey due to most students were
having holidays during that period. Majority of the survey was conducted in shopping malls,
whereas minority was conducted in colleges. Nevertheless, the time conducted was during
lunch break or after working hours. Therefore, these situations explained regarding limited
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
cc
!
%
G
M
'
c
c c c
Mlc c c
Glc !c "c
c
Gi
ccctctc
tccM#ic
c
ctclc
c icc
ctctcil
ccilicciccciii
lc
c
ilc
cctcic cc
tic
iccM#ic&c 'c
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 5
RM 21,000 - RM 30,000
Gemale
RM 11,000 - RM 20,000
ale
%& '!"(
30 - 39 Years Old
Gemale
19 - 29 Years Old
ale
Figure 5 shows the Maxis users which based on annual income and age group.
0 The majority of maxis users based on annual income are RM 10,000 & below,
whereas the majority based on age group are 19-29 years old. This phenomenon indicates that
most of the Maxis users are students and teenagers. According to the survey results,
youngsters are fancier towards Maxis compared to the older age groups. The main reason is
due to the attractiveness and benefits of iPhone and Blackberry packages. Furthermore,
today¶s teenagers are mostly associated with family packages as Maxis provides a superior
$)
*'
%+
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
1 - 3 Years 4 - 6 Years 7 - 9 Years 10 Years & Above
Male 39 16 26 19
Female 24 30 32 14
Figure 6 shows how long the users have used Maxis in their entire life.
0 Majority of the users are using Maxis for 1 to 3 years because most of them started
using this provider after 3G was being introduced to Malaysia. Besides, Maxis also brought
in the latest technologies to its users so more new users found compared to users of 10 years
and above. Moreover, more males were using Maxis for 1 to 3 years because they were
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
c!c
Gl
Ml !
c
it c tc tc
ic
c tc tic
*c +
itc c tc c ic c c
cctc
c
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 8
Figure 8 shows the reasons of why the users stop using Maxis.
0 There are several reasons that caused the users stop using Maxis: bad services of
Maxis centre, high cost rate, peer influence, and others more. The major reason was the cost
rate of Maxis which was relatively higher compared to others. Furthermore, some users
stopped using Maxis due to their bad services. Peer influences make them to switch to other
brands with lower cost. Besides, some users stop using due to low coverage in certain areas
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 9
o ,*- +
Others
20%
Prefer Digi &
Celcom
40%
Peer Influence
20%
Figure 9 shows the reasons of why users did not choose Maxis.
0 ! ! " Majority of the respondents did not choose Maxis as they prefer Digi and Celcom
due to the lower rate. Those subjective respondents despise Maxis¶ phone number, call rate,
and service manner. Peer influence, high cost rate and other reasons do affect the users¶
decisions. Some respondents did not think of using Maxis at all due to the numerous
influences within their social cycle, because most of their friends were using other mobile
network. Users these days are smart in comparing in this competitive market. Hence, they get
to identify that Maxis offered a higher cost rate compared to others. Furthermore, low
coverage in certain users¶ areas would also affect the respondents¶ perception on not
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
cc
$t
"
1ic0c2c
tc
3
Gilc/l
'' c
cc
titcctc
lc
tccM#ictcllcilccctc
lctc
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
cc
%
'
#
i cc
lc c ctccttc c
c c cc ii
ltic itc
M#ic ic
ilc
ctcctc
lctc ticc
c cictc
illcc ic
tclc c c cctc tc c
lcttc
c c c cc
c
c
c
Gi
c'c
%%
c c ii ltic tc tic lic /tc c tc c c c tc tc Mli*c
lt
cc
lcciccl5ctcc
litc
ctcl
cicctc
M#i*c
lc
i tcicBcMlicBictc
cl5ctc
cctc
c llic
c tc i c tc c c tc
c c c
tc tc tc
ctc
lcicii
ltctcclc
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 13
Others
8
roblem of overage
Billing roblem
Transaction 34
ayment
17
Multiple SMS
Being Sent
Received
8
Figure 13 shows the major issues that the users were complaint about.
0#$%& & ' The major complaints that have been made by the users were regarding the
coverage problem of Maxis. Some users stated that they faced line problems in certain areas
and low signal during the period 3G was being upgraded. Some users complain about
unknown charges found hidden in their monthly bills without any further notice. Furthermore,
there were complaints on faulty SIM card, multiple SMS being sent and received, and poor
customer service. It was either they were unable to save new contact numbers due to the
faulty SIM card or abundant same messages being sent and received occasionally. Besides,
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 14
High Satisfaction
Troublesome, Towards Their
Not Interested & Service
Lazy 15%
32%
0()*+ + , The main reason is due to the users¶ perception of finding it troublesome as they
think it is unnecessary to make any complaints even when they face any problems. Some
users did come across minor problems with Maxis, but due to their laziness, their problems
turned into major ones along or even could not be fixed anymore. Besides, 24% stated that
they have never face any problem with Maxis. Generally, these users are not heavy users;
they might be just subscribing the line for normal usage and they would normally not alert
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 15
No 16%
Yes 84%
Figure 15 shows whether the users were being answered politely during the interaction with
0-./0 0 1c 84% of the users were being answer courteously when they tend to make any
complaints to the employees, but only 16% were not. This shows a positive sign that majority
users were satisfied with Maxis¶ customer service. Maxis provides numerous training courses
for the employees frequently, so that their employees are more aware in serving customers
professionally at all times. However, for those customers were not being answered politely
could be due to some minor problem which caused some misunderstanding between
customers and employees. Thus, it gave a wrong perception for the customers towards the
employees.
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 16
o
./
!
"/
*+
No 28%
Yes 72%
Figure 16 shows whether the information given by Maxis helpful in solving the users¶
problem.
02345 5 6 Majority agreed that the information given by the Maxis¶ employees are useful in
helping them to solve their problem. Customers¶ satisfaction plays an important role for
Maxis. Thus, they recruit knowledgeable and professional employees to provide sufficient
information in order to help the customers to solve their problem immediately. However, 28%
of respondents were not happy because the information given was not helpful. This can be
either the customer did not follow the instruction given or unable to give sufficient
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 17
60%
50%
40%
32%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Yes No
Figure 17 shows whether the users are satisfied with the outcome.
0789: : ; 68% are satisfied with the outcome due to the sufficient and helpful information
given by Maxis operators in helping them to solve the problems. Besides, it only takes within
1 day to get their problems resolved. Conversely, only 32% were not satisfied due to the poor
customer service encounter and did not obtain much useful information in solving their
problems. Although some get to resolve their problem, but the exact same problem would
occurred again after few days. Therefore, this causes the customers to seek for help and
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
c"c
"#
$!%!
&
%
'
<
itc itic.c Btc 'c Btc c Mc c ,tillctc
<
Rl
ti ( c c( cc( .c Rlc
t
c
<
itcRl
tic itic.c(c Btc'c c c(c Btc c cc(c
'c %c "c 'c
<
Mc c.c c ,tillctcRlctc
c 'c
c
Gi
c"ccclccM#ictcclic
*c
lc
llc lc iitlc c itic tc c &c ic tc
lc c tc ilc
lc
ctci
ltcci it cciticicc
ctcclc
c
lc
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
c6c
c i
i
$
lcclc
c tc tc
ilc ti c c tc
tc c c i
ilc ttc
c tc
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
c'c
' %
c2
2
tl
/
'
ticic#
tticcM#i*c c
cM#icc#
tctcc ci itc
clilc
ctctc
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 21
*
" '
+
80%
70%
76%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
24%
10%
0%
Yes No
0=>?@ @ A 76% of users did not experience any bad service but only 24% did experience the
bad service. It shows a positive sign that most of the customers did not experience any bad
service with Maxis because of its excellent services that beyond the level of customer
expectation. Furthermore, users have nothing serious to complain about when the service
provided is good. However, 24% chose that they experienced bad service. This may due to
the misunderstanding and language barriers between the users and employees.
c c
c cc
c
c
c
Figure 22
40%
35%
31%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
10% 10%
5%
2%
0%
*1 *2 *3 *4 *5
Figure 22 shows the ratings of the service quality that received by the users
0BCDE E F Some users rated the service quality as low as 1 or 2 because they were not
satisfied with the service quality provided as they assume that Maxis focused more on new
customers instead of the existing customers. Existing customers do not receive good service
quality compared to when they first become Maxis users. Besides, they faced bad experience
before and this leads them to have negative perception. Nevertheless, majority rated the
service quality as high as 4 because they are satisfied with the services since their problems
c c
c cc
c
c
c
Figure 23
o *-
.'.
+
No 78%
Yes 22%
Figure 23 shows the possibility of users will change to another telco service brand.
0GHIJ J K The chart indicates that 78% of users are loyal to Maxis and would not change into
other providers. This is possibly because most of the problems encountered were usually
solved and think that other providers might not provide the exact good service. Conversely,
there has 22% of users would change to other providers because of the unsolved problems
they encountered before and the unsatisfying services they received. The services given to the
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 24
o
o*-+
90%
78%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
22%
20%
10%
0% 0%
0%
Celcom Digi Tunetalk U-Mobile
Figure 24 shows which brand that the respondents would choose as their first preference
0LMNO O P The chart proves that 78% of the respondents would choose Digi. This is because
Digi is fairly affordable as it offers a lower rate compared to others. Furthermore, 22% of the
the graph shows that none of the respondents would choose Tunetalk and U-Mobile due to
their unattractive market strategies and not well-known in society. Therefore, these two
brands have failed to catch the attention from the society due to the insecure sensation.
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
c'c
!
Gi c 'c c tc tic c tc llc tc i c c M#ic ttc c c
#
i cctc
cc
0 c c c c c tiic itc tc llc tc i c ic c ttc
M#icc
icc
iticcc+
litcci cc tcctc
cMjitcc
l
c ctc M#ici c tc tlcctc
tiic
c
lc
ilc
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 26
Effectiveness of
Service
Department &
Call Centre
28%
Communication
Skills &
Worker's
Knowledge
41%
No
9%
Figure 26 shows the areas of customer service that need to be improved which recommended
by the users.
0QRST T Uc The major area that needs to be improved is regarding the communication skills
and worker¶s knowledge. Employees were unable to fulfill users¶ requirements due to their
limited knowledge and language barriers. The effectiveness of service department and call
centre were needed to be improved as well. The service quality of 24-hours call centre was
dissatisfying because no one picked up the phone or engaged for several times when the
customers call. In fact, as a fundamental rule, a call centre should answer every call within 3
rings. Furthermore, worker¶s attitudes also needed to be improved. Meanwhile, some users
suggested no areas of customer service ought to be improved because these users do not have
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 27
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Rank 1 Rank 2 Rank 3 Rank 4 Rank 5
U-Mobile 0% 0% 8% 57% 35%
Tunetalk 0% 3% 0% 38% 59%
Maxis 52% 35% 10% 2% 1%
Digi 34% 39% 25% 1% 1%
Celcom 14% 23% 57% 2% 4%
Figure 27 shows the ranking of the 5 telecommunication brands: Celcom, Digi, Maxis,
0VWXY Y Z The chart shows that majority of the respondents placed Maxis as Rank 1, which
clearly illustrates that Maxis able to strive the top position in the telecommunication industry.
This has proved that Maxis has a well-built market in customers¶ perception. Meanwhile,
Digi obtained a rank of second. This could be due to its attractive and cheaper call rate
compared to other brands. Conversely, Celcom can hardly beat down Maxis and Digi, thus it
has been ranked as third. Nevertheless, most people do not have the confidence to use
c cc cc
c
c
c
Gi
c'"c
%
'"
'6
.
t
Gt
Rliilit
$t
!
c itic tc lc ic + iic c i cG tc '6c lc c c c lilc
i c c '"c lc c c c tc i c .c ic t c c lilc c
c
tc ictc c citc tct
c c i c
c cilc c l
lc
i c
c cc cc
c
c
c
Figure 29
o
*)
"
/-
+
Well-Mannered More
And Level Up Professional In
The Training On Interacting With
Employees' Customers
Attitudes 21%
16%
High Level Of
Service Quality
23%
More Efficient
And Responsive
Focus Mainly In Dealing With
On Customers' Customers'
Needs And Problems
Wants 27%
13%
Figure 29 shows the various types of level expectation of the users regarding the quality of
customer service.
0[\]^ ^ _ Majority of the users were expecting to encounter an excellent service which is
more efficient and responsive in dealing with their problems. Hence, Maxis was expected in
providing more efficient, friendly, and warm services that enhance the customers¶ delighted
experience. Some users expected a high level of service quality and also a more professional
customer service. Besides, well-mannered and well-trained employees were expected and
minority aspire the customer service to focus primarily on the users¶ needs and wants.
c cc cc
c
c
c
!"'
` Respondents suggested that the service level of Maxis can be improved particularly
on the process in dealing and resolving problem for customers. The service level of Maxis is
regarded as inefficient and unproductive due to the unprofessional and unreliable employees.
Furthermore, bad customer service existed due to the untrained employees being impolite
a Respondents perceived that Maxis is being bias between new and existing
customers, as Maxis mainly focus more on new customers. Maxis does not really appreciate
loyalty, as not many loyalty programmes were provided for existing customers. Moreover,
c c c cc
c
c
c
· -
Researchers identified that most telecommunication users demand for a fast service from
their providers. This includes Maxis as well. Most users would not spend time on contacting
their providers if any minor problems were being faced. This leads the company to be
unaware of those minor problems. Users do not make any enquiries is because they have this
perception that all providers offer a slow service as they encountered before. Furthermore,
most problems would not be solved immediately as it could be passed on from one operator
to another. Along with the Malaysian¶ culture of not making any complaint although
problems were being faced would most likely worsen the problem.
Maxis should expand their business by focusing more on customers¶ needs instead of earning
profits. The company could introduce new batch of frontline employees and call operators
with high standard of professionalism and knowledge in encountering any situations with the
customers. Meanwhile, Maxis could provide strict trainings to the existed employees in order
to improve their service quality. This would encourage the public to come forward to Maxis
for help when there is any problem. Besides, Maxis could hire local celebrities to advertise
the good and professional services provided by the employees. Young adults and teenagers
would be attracted by the celebrity and in choosing the provider. Therefore, they would
c c
c cc
c
c
c
[ )
The conducted research may have been limited by the chosen sample frame. As most of the
surveys were collected from a specific location which is Klang Valley, this could have given
an effect on the research results as the sample size was not even 10% of the population in
Malaysia. It is not reasonable from the study to infer that the service level of Maxis is better
than other brands, nor can be concluded that the expectations of respondents are the same
throughout Malaysia.
The conducted research was complex and difficult to be carried out due to the limited time
given. To distribute and gather the survey questionnaires can be time-consuming for the
researchers. Due to time constraints in conducting the survey, merely around 100 survey
questionnaires have been distributed out. Therefore, the collection of data and statistic would
be lack of accuracy and insufficient because merely from small proportion of general
population in Malaysia.
In addition, small portions of the surveys were rejected due to some reasons. Irrelevant
incomplete answers were provided by some respondents in the surveys. This could give an
impact in the accuracy of research, thus the researchers had to conduct even more surveys
and analyze over again in a short period. Accordingly, information and data collected can be
costly, as the researchers¶ budgetary constraints would be affected. All these could affect the
researchers to collect more reliable and accurate information from the respondents.
c c
c cc
c