Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WAT E R R E S E A R C H 40 (2006) 61 – 66
Available at www.sciencedirect.com
Article history: In this study, the dewatering of glass sand plant tailings from Mersin, Turkey was
Received 19 November 2003 investigated using an electrokinetic technique. The particle size ðd80 Þ of the solid waste
Received in revised form material tested was less than 0.020 mm and consisted mainly of silica, orthoclase, alumina,
18 July 2005 potassium and iron oxides. In current plant practice, Larox high-pressure filters are used to
Accepted 18 October 2005 produce a filter cake containing 22–25% moisture. As an alternative, a laboratory-scale
dewatering pond using an electrokinetic technique was designed and a final product (cake)
Keywords: containing 34% moisture was obtained after 24 h treatment using 14.6 V direct current
Tailings disposal applied for 40 min. When the treatment continued up to 48 h, a firm-to-hard cake was
Dewatering produced.
Flocculation & 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Recycling
Waste processing
1. Introduction are now able to produce flocs of larger size and density
(Newman, 1984; Koren and Syverson, 1995; Mollah et al., 2001;
Silica sand occurs in abundance in varying degrees of purity, Larue and Vorobiev, 2003). It is generally accepted that the EC
but only a small percentage is suitable for glassmaking and process involves three successive stages: (a) formation of
other high-grade industrial applications, including foundry, coagulants by electrolytic oxidation of the ‘sacrificial elec-
ceramics, chemicals, fillers and the construction industry. trode’; (b) destabilization of the contaminants, particulate
Mineral processing is an essential step in upgrading the raw suspension, and breaking of emulsions; and (c) aggregation of
sand to meet industrial specifications, such as a high silica the destabilized phases to form flocs. The destabilization
content (495.4% SiO2), narrow size distribution and small mechanism of the contaminants, particulate suspension, and
amount of clay combined with low levels of TiO2, Al2O3 and breaking of emulsions has been described in broad steps and
Fe2O3. Sedimentation of glass sand tailings is frequently may be summarized as follows (Mollah et al., 2001):
difficult and lengthy, owing to their nature and small particle
size. Chemical dosing with metal ions is often used in (i) Compression of the diffuse double-layer around the
primary treatment to remove colloidal materials from waste- charged species, which is achieved by the interac-
water, but new technologies such as electrocoagulation (EC) tions of ions generated by dissolution of the sacrificial
Corresponding author. Tel.: +90 322 3386119; fax: +90 322 3386126.
E-mail addresses: obayat@cu.edu.tr (O. Bayat), zenkilic@cu.edu.tr (O. Kilic), bbayat@cu.edu.tr (B. Bayat), manil@cu.edu.tr (M. Anil),
hakarsu@sisecam.com.tr (H. Akarsu), c.poole@leeds.ac.uk (C. Poole).
0043-1354/$ - see front matter & 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.watres.2005.10.021
ARTICLE IN PRESS
62 WAT E R R E S E A R C H 40 (2006) 61– 66
electrode, due to passage of current through the be stimulated by reversing the polarity, with the bottom
solution. cathode acting as a drain. In an electrical field established
(ii) Charge neutralization of the ionic species present in between two separated electrodes buried in slurry, the solid
wastewater, which is caused by the counter ions, produced particles will not move appreciably because of their relatively
by the electrochemical dissolution of the sacrificial elec- dense packing, but the water will be carried toward the
trode. These counter ions reduce the electrostatic inter- negatively charged cathode by the viscous drag of the
particle repulsion sufficiently so that the van der Waals migrating positive ions. The effectiveness of electrokinetic
attraction predominates, thus causing coagulation. techniques (direct current application) in consolidating slur-
(iii) Floc formation, and the floc formed as a result of ries of fine-grained solids in watery suspensions has been
coagulation creates a sludge blanket that entraps and investigated since the 1970s (USBM, 1974a, b, 1975; Mollah
bridges colloidal particles that have not been complexed. et al., 2001, 2004; Larue and Vorobiev, 2003; Larue et al., 2003).
Matteson et al. (1995) investigated the EC of aqueous
Differences in the mobilities of ions, molecules, or particles suspensions of ultrafine kaoline particles in a single stirred
in an electric field can also be exploited to perform useful cell apparatus and in a continuously flowing system consist-
separations. For electrolytic solutions, the migration of ing of three cells in series. By taking advantage of the
charged species in an electric field constitutes an additional electrical surface charge on solid particles in water, fast
mechanism of mass transfer. Thus, the flux of an ionic species particle settlement and sediment dewatering can be achieved
Ni in g mol/cm2 s in dilute solutions can be expressed as by imposing a relatively large dc voltage (60–240 V/m) between
electrodes placed in the slurry. This technique has already
Ni ¼ zi ui Ici rE Di ci þ ci v, (1)
been successful for treating siliceous tailings from Idaho,
where the ionic mobility ui is the average velocity imparted to USA, metal mines. Slurry properties found to affect response
the species under the action of a unit force (per mole); v is the included electrical conductivity, particle size distribution,
stream velocity in cm/s. In the present case, the electric field water content, and surface charge density. Chemical proper-
rE is in V/cm and the charge zi I per mole, where I is the ties also influenced behaviour, but their importance was
Faraday constant in C/g equivalent, Di is the ionic-diffusion specific to each sample and difficult to characterize (Sprute
coefficient, cm2/s, and zi is the valence of the ith species. and Kelsh, 1980).
Multiplication of this force by the mobility and the concen- Camis Madencilik AS has been operated in Mersin (a
tration ci (g mol/cm3) yields the contribution of migration to southern province of Turkey) since 1970. The ore contains
the flux of the ith species (Robinson and Stokes, 1959). Particle quartz (88%), orthoclase (10%), iron oxides (0.25%) and trace
sedimentation can be accelerated by imposing an electrical elements such as Zr, Cr, Ca and Ti (Bayat and Akarsu, 2002).
field in the proper orientation; that is, for negatively charged As shown in Fig. 1, froth flotation is used for the removal of
particles, horizontal placement of the anode (positive elec- the colouring impurities, including pyrite, garnet, chromite,
trode) near the bottom of the slurry, with the negatively ilmenite, haematite, mica, etc. The capacity of the concen-
charged cathode floating on the surface (Sprute and Kelsh, trator is 450,000 tonnes per year and tailings (approximately
1974). When sedimentation is complete, further drainage can 50,000 tonnes per year) are thickened and filtered by Larox
Grinding (Rodmill)
Hydrocyclone
+0.6-0.106 mm
-0.106 mm H2SO4
Froth Flotation
Aero 801+825; 370 g/t
(from Cytec Int., Holland)
Tailings Concentrate Superfloc A 110; 70 g/t
Electrokinetic Process
Dewatering water
high-pressure filters. A filter cake containing 22–25% moisture tests were performed using various dewatering arrangements
is conveyed to the tailings disposal area and the current (Kilic, 1998). Optimum results were achieved with the follow-
dewatering cost is about $1/tonne. ing procedure. Two iron pipes, with an outside diameter of
In this study, dewatering of the tailings from the glass sand- 2.1 cm and 36 cm long, placed on the horizontal floor and
processing plant using an electrokinetic technique was embedded in gravel, served as a cathode. A 36 cm 20 cm
investigated on a laboratory scale. rectangular grid of a 0.95 cm iron rod acted as the moveable
anode: this was placed on the surface of the cell. For each test,
a 32 litre-suspension containing 3–5% solids was taken from
the plant thickener and poured into the cell after 10 min of
2. Materials and methods
mixing. In the first stage of a two-stage dewatering procedure,
power was applied to the front section at a rate of 14.5 V
Physical and chemical properties of the solid waste (tailings)
between electrodes, with an average current density of
before treatment are summarized in Table 1. Chemical
11.88 A/m2 until drainage ceased. For the second stage (after
analysis of the sample was carried out at the Camis plant
10 min), the anode was moved to a position 6 cm below the
by XRF spectrometry using a method described in detail by
surface over the cathode, and power was applied at 14.6 V
Skoog et al. (1998). The particle size of the sample ranged
between electrodes at an average current density of 5.63 A/m2
from 0.005 to 0.105 mm and the d80 was less than 0.020 mm. X-
until water discharge from the pump well ceased. The power
ray measurements were performed using a Philips X-ray
was then switched off after 40 min and the cake was left for
difractometer employing nickel-filtered CuKa radiation. X-ray
24 h for additional settlement. The final product in the model
diffraction data for crystalline phases of the tailings are given
was sampled for moisture content. During electrolysis, the
in Table 2. The mineralogy was found to be mainly orthoclase
positive side underwent anodic reactions, while on the
(KAlSi3O8), alumina (Al2O3), potassium (K2O), iron oxides
negative side, a cathodic reaction was encountered. Consum-
(Fe2O3) and silica (SiO2). The zeta potential (ZP) measurements
able metal plates, such as iron or aluminium, were usually
of the suspensions were made in distilled water of a constant
used as sacrificial electrodes to continuously produce ions in
ionic strength (0.01 M NaCl) by Zeta-Meter 3.0. Prior to ZP
the system. The released ions neutralized the charges of the
measurements powder sample was dispersed at 0.1% (w/v)
particles and thereby initiated coagulation.
solid ratio in distilled water, pH and ionic strength were
adjusted to desired values and stirred on a magnetic stirrer
for 5 min at room temperature. Required amount of suspen-
sion was transferred into the electrophoresis cell of the zeta
meter. During the ZP measurement 10 particles were tracked 3. Results and discussion
and the average of their ZP values was taken. Consequently,
the ZP changes of the suspensions as a function of pH were 3.1. Zeta potential measurements
determined. The working principle of the zeta meter 3.0 is
based on the electrophoresis method and it computes The surface charge characteristics of precipitated metal
automatically the ZP using the Smoluchowski equation. hydroxides are of great importance in coagulation. In
Laboratory electrokinetic dewatering tests were conducted common with oxides and other minerals they show an
at the Camis plant using a specially built Plexiglas model (see isoelectric point (i.e.p.) at which the apparent (electrokinetic)
Fig. 2) 112 cm long 24 cm wide 24 cm deep. Two series of surface charge is zero. At pH values below the i.e.p. the
Property Values
a
LOI, loss on ignition.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
64 WAT E R R E S E A R C H 40 (2006) 61– 66
Table 2 – XRD data for crystalline phases of the tailings observed at a pH of 7.7 and 8.8, respectively. These values are
in accordance with the values reported by earlier researchers
Crystalline phase d spacing (Å)
(Syed Ahmed, 1975; Rudzinski et al., 1992). Below the pH of
Fe2O3_A 2.7000 i.e.p., precipitates of oxy-hydroxides are positively charged.
FeO(OH)_B 2.6900 From the results it is apparent that the magnitude of positive
Al2O3_A 2.5520 ZP of iron and aluminium oxy-hydroxides reduces in the
FeTiO3_B 2.5440 presence of sulphate and sulphite ions without any shift in
Fe3O4_A 2.5320
i.e.p. This clearly indicates that there is no chemical interac-
FeCr2O4 2.5200
Fe2O3_B 2.5190
tion between these ions and metal hydroxy precipitates. At
ZrSiO4 2.5180 the same time, a decrease in the magnitude of ZP of metal
FeO 2.4900 hydroxides in the presence of these ions clearly suggests an
SiO2_qrz 2.4570 electrical interaction. This reduction in positive charge may
FeO(OH)_A 2.4500 be due to a weak electrical interaction between negatively
FeS2_B 2.4300 charged sulphite and sulphate ions and positively charged
Cryolite_C 2.4340
oxy-hydroxy species of iron and aluminium. Transmission
Cu2O 2.4700
FeTiO3_A 2.7540 electron microscopic (TEM) studies conducted by earlier
FeS2_A 2.7090 researchers (He et al., 1996) have revealed that at a pH of
FeO(OH)_B 2.6900 6.0, the aggregated Fe(OH)2 colloids exist as three-dimen-
Fe2O3_A 2.7000 sional (branched or spread out) porous sponge-like precipi-
Al2O3_A 2.5520 tates. Thus, better dewatering under slightly acidic conditions
FeTiO3_B 2.5440
can be explained in the light of the ZP results.
Fe3O4_A 2.5320
Ca2_A 2.5990
MnO 2.5680
Cr2O4 2.5800 3.2. Electrokinetic dewatering
CaSO4_h2 2.5966
Iron upon oxidation in an electrolytic system produces iron
hydroxide, Fe(OH)n, where n ¼ 2 or 3. When a dc current flows
between two iron electrodes, the following electrolysis
reactions are expected to occur in the vicinity of the
Anode electrodes (Mollah et al., 2001):
(Oxidation) Anode:
+
Colloidal Particle FeðsÞ ! Fe2þ
ðaqÞ þ 2e , (2)
Fe2+
E DC power
Fe(OH)2 supply
OH−
Suspension Fe2þ
ðaqÞ þ 2OHðaqÞ ! FeðOHÞ2ðsÞ . (3)
H2
Cathode
Cathode:
(Reduction)
-
Coagulation+Flocculation Sediments 2H2 OðlÞ þ 2e ! 2OH
ðaqÞ þ H2ðgÞ . (4)
62
70
Initial 58
68 pH = 4
Moisture of the cake (%)
pH = 6
Moisture of the cake (%)
66 54
pH = 8
64
62 50
60 46
58
42
56
54 38 Initial
pH = 4
52
34 pH = 6
50 pH = 8
180 210 300 450 600 30
Dewatering time (min) 180 210 300 450 600 1200 1440
Dewatering time (min)