Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fractionation Trays
Sulzer Chemtech Ltd
Table of Content
1 General..........................................................................................................................................2
1.1 Scope ............................................................................................................................................2
1.2 References ....................................................................................................................................2
2 Materials ........................................................................................................................................2
2.1 Specifications ................................................................................................................................2
2.2 Comparison Table ASTM – DIN...................................................................................................4
2.3 Gaskets .........................................................................................................................................5
2.4 Material properties.........................................................................................................................5
2.5 Tray hardware ...............................................................................................................................5
3 Mechanical design.........................................................................................................................5
3.1 Loads and stresses .......................................................................................................................5
3.2 Allowable deflection.......................................................................................................................6
3.3 Minimum thickness ........................................................................................................................6
3.4 Corrosion allowance ......................................................................................................................6
3.5 Depth of tray structural members ..................................................................................................7
3.6 Support ring sizes..........................................................................................................................7
3.7 Gaskets .........................................................................................................................................8
3.8 Bubble caps and valves ................................................................................................................8
3.9 Chimney trays & draw-off sumps ..................................................................................................8
3.10 Multi-Pass trays .............................................................................................................................9
3.11 Drainholes and Ventholes .............................................................................................................9
3.12 Bolt size and spacing.....................................................................................................................9
3.13 Thermal expansion ........................................................................................................................9
3.14 Column manhole .........................................................................................................................10
3.15 Tray supports...............................................................................................................................10
3.16 Tolerances...................................................................................................................................10
3.17 Maximum weight..........................................................................................................................10
3.18 Heavy duty trays..........................................................................................................................10
4 Tray fabrication............................................................................................................................11
4.1 Tolerances...................................................................................................................................11
4.2 Welding........................................................................................................................................11
4.3 Sieve and valve hole punching....................................................................................................11
4.4 Surface finishing ..........................................................................................................................11
5 Shop Inspection and testing ........................................................................................................12
5.1 Shop inspection - trial assembly..................................................................................................12
5.2 Leakage test ................................................................................................................................12
5.3 PMI Examination (when applicable) ............................................................................................12
5.4 NDE Examination (when applicable)...........................................................................................12
6 Marking and shipping ..................................................................................................................13
6.1 Part marking ................................................................................................................................13
6.2 Standard packaging.....................................................................................................................13
6.3 Shipping.......................................................................................................................................13
7 Tray installation ...........................................................................................................................13
7.1 Tray manway(s)...........................................................................................................................13
7.2 Standard connection....................................................................................................................14
7.3 Tolerances...................................................................................................................................14
7.4 Spares for erection ......................................................................................................................14
8 Documents ..................................................................................................................................15
1 General
1.1 Scope
This specification covers the mechanical design, fabrication, inspection, testing, installa-
tion, handling, storage, shipping and packaging of trays.
1.2 References
American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) Material Specifications.
American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code.
ASME Section IX, Qualification Standard for Welding and Brazing Procedures, Welders,
Brazers and Welding and Brazing Operators.
DIN (Deutsche Industrie Norm) German Industry Norm for Material Specifications.
2 Materials
2.1 Specifications
The following ASTM standard material specifications apply.
The reference shall be taken to mean the latest edition of the code.
Temperature Services
ASTM A563 Carbon and Alloy Steel Nuts
ASTM A675 Steel Bars, Carbon, Hot-Wrought Special Quality, Mechanical
Properties
ASTM B127 Nickel-Copper Alloy Plate, Sheet and Strip
ASTM B164 Nickel-Copper Alloy Rod, Bar, and Wire
ASTM B265 Titanium and Titanium Alloy Strip, Sheet and Plate
ASTM B348 Titanium and Titanium Alloy Bars
DIN 17100 Steel for General Structural Purposes
DIN 17155 Plate and Strip of Steels for elevated temperatures
DIN 17440 Stainless steels, plates, hot rolled strip, wire rods, drawn wire, bars
and forgings
DIN 17750 Plates, strips and sheets of wrought nickel and nickel alloys
DIN 17743 Wrought nickel alloys with copper
2.3 Gaskets
Gaskets are tape or braided rope fabricated from asbestos-free material suitable for the
processing environment. Minimum thickness of gasket tape shall be 1.5 mm (1/16”).
Gasket material shall be used for internal flange connections and Bubble Cap gaskets (if
applicable).
• PTFE
• Fiberglas
• Graphite
• Aramid
• Teflon
The valves for carbon steel trays shall be of 410S stainless steel.
To avoid galling, it is possible to use 304 grade material for nuts when bolting is 410 grade
material.
3 Mechanical design
Active area:
A design load of 1000 N/m² (21 lb/ft²) or the head of water twice the outlet weir height,
whichever is the greater.
Tray assemblies shall be capable of supporting their own weight plus a concentrated load
of 1350 N (300 lbs.) located at any trusses on the tray at ambient temperature. The maxi-
mum allowable stress permitted under this condition is at ambient temperature.
Heavy-duty trays will be designed based on a uniform load of 6900 N/m² (1psi). Under
these conditions trays are not designed for deflection and the maximum stress permitted
under this condition is 90% of the yield stress at design temperature.
Baffle trays, shed decks and disc and donut trays will be designed for a design load of
7000 N/m² (146 lb/ft²).
An initial camber may be made in the principal support members of the assemblies to re-
duce the deflection due to the dead load.
Support members are to be located on the underside of the tray floor except for open-type
(lattice) trusses supporting two trays.
Support beams shall not restrict the flow of vapor between tray passes.
The beam shall occupy not more than 50% of the vertical area between the trays meas-
ured along the flow path.
Note 1:
For carbon steel, two times the vessel corrosion allowance (SCA) have to be added to the
thickness.
3.7 Gaskets
The seams of bubble cap trays will be provided with gaskets.
Chimney trays and draw-off sumps should be seal welded in services where leakage is
deemed detrimental to process operation. Welded chimney trays and draw-off sumps will
have the minimum number of sections to minimize potential for leakage.
Partial draw-off trays with overflow provision can be equipped with bolted downcomer de-
sign located below the tray deck.
Chimney tray hats will be designed with ‘V’ hats to focus liquid drainage on the small face
of the chimney (hat support).
Chimney trays in services where minimum leakage through hats is desired will be de-
signed with inverted U-hat or flat caps that completely seal and cover the risers.
Chimney tray risers are specified with approximately 15% riser area for vessels equipped
with trays.
Picket Fence type outlet weirs and clearances are used to balance the 3-pass, 4-pass and
6-pass tray designs.
No vapor equalizers are supplied in the intermediate and center downcomers of 3-pass,
4-pass and 6-pass trays.
One drainhole is required in each distributor pipe where process fluid does not discharge
vertically downward.
One venthole is required for each distributor pipe, except for spray nozzle distributor
where ventholes are not required.
Tray clamp spacing shall not exceed 180 mm (7") around the tray perimeter of the active
area and around the perimeter of the inlet area. Bolt and/or clamp spacing shall not ex-
ceed 150 mm (6") along downcomer clamping bars.
Bolt spacing on truss seams shall not exceed 180 mm (7”) spacing.
Manway clamp spacing shall not exceed 250mm (10”). Each side of the manway shall be
connected to the tray deck with at least two manway clamps.
Clamping shall be used except where bolting is necessary for load supporting capabilities.
Bolt and clamp spacings are not applicable for heavy duty trays.
Welded chimney trays are normally seal welded directly to the support ring.
Welded chimney trays in towers that are designed for operation at elevated temperatures
with dissimilar material from the vessel are recommended to both evaluate and make pro-
vision for differential expansion using expansion angles around the tray perimeter. Expan-
sion angles are seal welded on site between the chimney tray deck and the tower wall.
3.16 Tolerances
Trays shall be designed to allow for manufacturing tolerances on both the vessel and the
trays. Allowances shall be made for the vessel shell being out of roundness as limited by
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel code Section VIII – Division I.
All tray parts shall be made adjustable so that when installed, the trays and pans will be
within the specified tolerances.
For perforated trays, the number of holes shall be within plus or minus 2% of the number
specified.
The total area of openings elsewhere which may lead to leakage of liquid or vapor shall
not exceed 1% of the total hole area for vapor passage.
1) 35 kg (75 lbs) for vessels up to and including 1.2 m (4ft) diameter and
Exception shall be made for loose main beams and integrated beams in downcomer.
In addition to a stronger tray (but not as an alternative) explosion doors may be used, in
cases where persistent tray damage has occurred.
4 Tray fabrication
4.1 Tolerances
The dimensional tolerances on all similar parts shall be such as to make the parts inter-
changeable.
Local depressions and bulges in panels after installation shall not exceed 6 mm (0.25”)
from the nominal plane.
The tilt of fractionating trays shall not exceed 0.15 % of the column diameter.
4.2 Welding
Approved welding processes are SMAW (Shielded Metal Arc Welding), GTAW (Gas
Tungsten Arc Welding), GMAW-P (Pulsed Arc Welding) and Resistance welding.
Welding electrodes or filler metal of a composition similar to the tray material shall be
used.
Punch press equipment use well maintained dies and tooling along with plasma / laser arc
cutting on some edges.
Goods will be delivered in an “as sheared”, “as punched” and “as cut” condition with no
objectionable burrs.
Welds will only be polished or pickled and passivated on express request by the customer
and agreement by Sulzer. (This may result in additional costs.)
A picture of every assembled tray shall be taken and filed for any subsequent quality
checks.
PMI is normally performed by a 3rd party inspector with a Texas Nuclear Analyzer, which
provides material composition, except for carbon content. If required, a portable Spectro-
graph machine can be utilized which provides material composition, including carbon con-
tent.
For bulk materials (sheet, plate, coil, pipe, flanges and weld wire), one (1) PMI test is per-
formed on each material heat prior to the start of fabrication.
For loose materials, the sample size is five (5) pieces of each type of hardware (bolts,
nuts and fasteners) for PMI testing.
A 3rd party inspector performs the test using special developer and UV-light during the
trial assembly.
Non-leaded and chloride free paint and/or markers shall be used for marking.
Tray hardware shall be packaged separately from the main tray segments and labeled
with item numbers, which refer to the drawings.
1) Order number
2) Vessel number
4) Packing number
5) Size of Packing
6) Net/Gross weight
Carbon steel tray parts are not normally shipped with any rust-ban corrosion inhibitor
unless this service is specifically included in the work scope.
Carbon steel parts are normally shipped in plastic lined or plastic wrapped crates.
6.3 Shipping
Tray components shall be properly packaged to prevent damage during shipping.
7 Tray installation
If access from one side is impossible, typically with small diameter high capacity trays this
requirement is not applicable.
Bolted connections:
Tray bolts shall be tightened, using a calibrated torque wrench, to the Sulzer Installation
instructions and engaged to the full depth of the nuts.
7.3 Tolerances
Tolerances for welded-in supports shall be according to Fig. 1 (page 16) of this docu-
ment.
Outlet weir:
The difference in height between the highest and lowest points of the weir plate top,
measured to a level plane, shall not exceed 6 mm (1/4”).
Height of fixed outlet weir ± 3 mm (±1/8”).
Downcomer Clearance:
Clearance between bottom of downcomer and top of next tray shall not deviate from
nominal clearance by more than ± 3 mm (1/8”).
2) Tray clamps, 5%
3) Gaskets, 25%
4) Movable valves, 2%
Torque: See section 7.2.
8 Documents
Standard documents include final assembly drawings, installation instructions, bill of mate-
rial, shipping list and bill of lading.
If specified by the client, MTR (Mill Test Reports), WPS (Weld Procedures), PQR (Per-
sonnel Qualification Record), PMI reports and NDE test reports can be provided for pro-
jects where these are performed.
The total weight of the internals per column shall be indicated on the assembly drawing.
On customer request Sulzer shall furnish strength calculations that demonstrate the ade-
quacy of its design to support the specified loads under the applicable deflection criteria.
Fig. 1: Tolerances for weld-ins in mm (millimeter). Also applicable for two, three and four pass
trays.
3” & 4” FRI Bubble Cap (with gasket) 6” FRI Bubble Cap (with gasket)