Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The first published work relative to ferroresonance dates In this paper a software model has been developed to
from 1907 and it analyzed transformer resonances [1]. simulate the ferroresonance phenomenon in voltage
The word ferroresonance was firstly used by Boucherot transformers. It will be used to develope ferroresonance
in 1920 to describe a complex resonance oscillation in a detection methodologies in voltage transformers in a very
series RLC circuit with nonlinear inductance [2]. near future.
Nowadays, ferroresonance is a widely studied
phenomenon in power systems involving capacitors,
saturable inductors and low losses. 2. Theoretical Principles of Ferroresonance
That is why it is a frequent phenomenon in electrical Ferroresonance implies resonance with saturable
distribution systems, due to the transformers saturable inductance, so it is important to analyze the behaviour of
inductance and the capacitive effect of the distribution a resonant circuit.
lines. This capacitive effect is provided by several
elements, such as protective elements (circuit breaker A. Resonance
grading capacitance), power transmission elements
(conductor to earth capacitance, cables capacitance, In a resonant circuit, inductive and capacitive reactances
busbar capacitance, coupling between double circuit of the circuit are equal to each other (1). The only
lines, capacitor banks), isolation elements (bushing opposition to current is the circuit resistance, resulting in
capacitance) or measurement elements (capacitive undesired overvoltages and overcurrents at the resonance
voltage transformers). frequency (2). This resonance effect presents one stable
operation state, and its effects are mitigated by the system
Furthermore, low resistance systems (low-loss frequencies control or by the introduction of pure
transformers, unloaded transformers, low circuit losses) resistances.
increase the risk of ferroresonant conditions. A good
1 voltage or current from one stable operating state to
ωL = (1) another one.
ωC
1
f= (2) V
E + VC
VC
2π LC 3 VL
wLsat
1
B. Ferroresonance 1/wC
E wLlinear
E = VL - VC E = VC – VL
• Linear zone fl X L − linear = ωL linear INDUCTIVE (VL>VC) CAPACITIVE (VC>VL)
• Saturation zone fl X L −sat = ωL sat V
VC E
VL
Like resonance, depending on the connection between the
capacitance and the nonlinear inductance, ferroresonance
may be series or parallel. This paper analyzes only series
ferroresonance (3) (Fig. 1).
3 2
r r r E
1
E = VL + VC (3)
I
(b)
E L
Fig. 2. Graphical solution of a series ferroresonant circuit
VC
V Fig. 5. Periodic ferroresonance conditions
VL
Increase of E
E’’
B. Ferroresonant modes
Fig. 6 Saturation curve of the voltage transformer model
According to the steady state condition, ferroresonant
states can be classified into four different types:
This software model has been used to simulate the
1) Fundamental mode. The signals (voltage and energization of a no-load voltage transformer, analyzing
current) have a distorted waveform, but are the behaviour of the model with the variation of initial
periodics with a period equal to the source conditions, such as voltage source amplitude, capacitance
period (T). The signal spectrum is made up of value or switching instant (residual flux has not been
the fundamental frequency of the system (f) and considered). The critical capacitance values for the
its harmonics. The phase plane shows a single periodic ferroresonance appearance have been calculated
closed trajectory and the Poincaré map shows based on the model saturation curve and equation (4).
one point moved far away from the normal state According to the capacitance values obtained, periodic
point. ferroresonance is possible to appear with capacitance
values between 0.06 nF and 0.01 mF approximately.
2) Subharmonic mode. The signals are periodic, but Thus, the parameters values to run the simulations have
the period is an integer multiple of the source been determined, such as it is shown in table I.
period (nT). These states are known as
subharmonics of order 1/n. The signal spectrum TABLE I. – Parameters of the Simulations
is made up of a fundamental component (f/n)
and its harmonics. The phase plane shows a Values
closed trajectory with n sizes and the Poincaré Parameter From… To…
map shows n points. Capacitance 1e-5 mF 0.01 mF
Voltage Source (RMS) 15 kV 50 kV
3) Quasi-periodic mode. In this mode, the signals Degrees (switching instant) 0º 180º
are not periodic. The signal spectrum is still a
discontinuous spectrum. The phase plane shows In order to analyze the behaviour of the voltage
changing trajectories and the Poincaré map transformer model with the variation of switching instant
shows several points representing a closed and capacitance value, several simulations at 25 kV
curve. voltage source are shown below.
The ferroresonance phenomenon in voltage transformers TABLE II. – Parameters – Switching Instant
is analyzed in this section through several software
simulation examples, using the software tool MATLAB. Parameter Value
A software model has been developed based on test data Capacitance 4e-4 mF
obtained on a real voltage transformer. Figure 6 shows Voltage Source (RMS) 25 kV
the saturation curve of the voltage transformer model Simulation A1 90º
developed. Degrees (switching instant) Simulation A2 30º
Simulation A3 0º
The graphical solution of these simulations is shown in
figure 7. Simulation A1 is a non-ferroresonant situation.
Simulations A2 and A3 are ferroresonant situations.
B. Capacitance variation
Aknowledgements
References
[1] Bethenod, J., "Sur le Transformateur à Résonance",
L’Éclairage Électrique, vol. 53, Nov. 30, 1907,
pp. 289-96.
[2] Boucherot, P.,"Éxistence de Deux Régimes en
Ferrorésonance", Rev. Gen. de L’Élec., vol. 8, no. 24,
December 11, 1920, pp. 827-828.
[3] Berrosteguieta, J. “Introduction to instrument
transformers” Electrotécnica Arteche Hnos., S.A
[4] Ferracci, P.,"Ferroresonance", Groupe Schneider: Cahier
technique no 190, March 1998.
[5] Santoso, S., Dugan, R. C., Grebe, T. E., Nedwick, P.
“Modeling ferroresonance phenomena in an underground
distribution system” IEEE IPST ’01 Rio de Janeiro,
Brazil, June 2001, paper 34