Professional Documents
Culture Documents
=
+
=
N
j
j
NR
1
) 1 ( 1
1
n o
(3)
Where is the other to own interference ratio which is
assumed to be a constant value of 0.6, N is the total
number of users in the cell and
j
is user j uplink load
factor which is calculated according to:
W
R
N
Eb
j
+
=
0
1
1
1
n
(5)
Where Eb/N0 is the energy per bit to noise power
spectral density ratio, R is the UE data rate and W is the
chip rate of the HSUPA which is equal to 3.84 Mcps.
The figures depict a large variation of the cell
throughput and the system noise rise for the without
CC scenario compared to the with CC scenario. A
large average cell throughput is achieved by using the
congestion control compared to the other scenario.
Figure 11. HSUPA cell throughput CDF curve with/without CC
Figure 12. HSUPA Noise Rise NR CDF curve with/without CC
C. ATM Cell Discards
The total number of ATM cell discards for the
HSDPA/HSUPA traffic is shown in Figure 13 andFigure
14 respectively. A huge number of ATM cell discards can
be observed for the without CC case. Such effect is
expected since the congestion control algorithm is not
used and the system is congested. This will lead to even
more congestion at the TNL network causing many cell
losses because many retransmissions are triggered by
RLC and TCP layers causing more and more traffic to the
TNL network. Most of these lost packets are recovered
by retransmissions either at the RLC or TCP level; those
retransmissions cause additional traffic to the network.
Figure 13. HSDPA ATM Cells Discard
Figure 14. HSUPA ATM Cells Discard
A clear advantage of using the congestion control
algorithm can be seen from the above figures. The packet
losses at the TNL are significantly reduced which in turn
reduce the higher layer retransmissions and the resultant
TCP end-to-end delays.
D. Application Throughput
The per-user application throughputs for all users as
well as the overall application throughput are shown in
Figure 15, Figure 16, Figure 17 and Figure 18 for both
JOURNAL OF NETWORKS, VOL. 5, NO. 7, JULY 2010 777
2010 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
HSDPA and HSUPA respectively. The per-user
throughput is calculated by considering the file size of 3
MByte divided by its upload/download time. It can be
noticed that the per-user/overall application throughput
for the CC based simulation achieves a clear gain
compared to the other scenario for both the uplink and
downlink.
Figure 15. HSDPA per user application throughput with/without CC
Figure 16. HSDPA total application throughput with/without CC
Figure 17. HSUPA per user application throughput with/without CC
Figure 18. HSUPA total application throughput with/without CC
VIII. CONFIGURATION (II) RESULTS & ANALYSIS
The simulation is performed by configuring only six
HSDPA FTP users in the cell (No HSUPA is configured
for the Uplink). The simulation parameters for this
configuration are exactly the same configured for the
previous one. Except the congestion control functionality,
both simulation scenarios use the same system and
protocol parameter configurations.
It can be seen from Figure 19 that there is a clear
advantage of using the congestion control mechanism in
terms of having higher per user application throughput
compared to the case without CC.
Figure 19. HSDPA (separate) per user app. throughput with/without CC
Figure 20 and Figure 21 show the per user/total
application throughput of running HSDPA separate
compared against deploying it with HSUPA. From the
results it can be seen that deploying HSUPA affects the
performance of HSDPA especially in the cases where the
CC algorithm is not used. The reason for that is mainly
because the HSDPA RLC and TCP ACK/NACK(s) that
are carried through the uplink (HSUPA) are getting
delayed and discarded due to the HSUPA load.
Furthermore a congested uplink leads, as explained
before, to delaying the acknowledgments which may
cause HSDPA RLC/TCP to do unnecessary
retransmissions.
What can also be noticed is that having the CC
algorithm activated helps to reduce these effects and to
keep the throughput relatively the same as in the separate
scenario (the green and blue bars in the figures).
Figure 20. HSDPA (separate) compared to HSDPA (combined with
HSUPA) per user app. throughput
Figure 21. HSDPA (separate) compared to HSDPA (combined with
HSUPA) total app. throughput
IX. CONFIGURATION (III) RESULTS & ANALYSIS
The simulation is performed by configuring only six
HSUPA FTP users in the cell (No HSDPA is configured
for the downlink). The simulation parameters for this
778 JOURNAL OF NETWORKS, VOL. 5, NO. 7, JULY 2010
2010 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
configuration are exactly the same configured for the
previous one. Except the congestion control functionality,
both simulation scenarios use the same system and
protocol parameter configurations.
Figure 22 shows the per user application throughput of
deploying HSUPA separate with and without the CC
algorithm. The result shows a higher application
throughput for the with CC case.
Figure 22. HSUPA (separate) per user app. throughput with/without CC
Figure 23 Figure 24 show per user/total application
throughput of the separate deployment of HSUPA
compared with the simultaneous deployment with
HSDPA. The results show that deploying HSDPA does
affect the HSUPA performance especially in the without
CC scenario. The reason is similar to the one explained
before in configuration 2, because now the HSDPA flow
in congested which in turn leads to delaying and
discarding the HSUPA RLC/TCP acknowledgments.
Which means that having the CC algorithm in
congested scenarios leads to significant gain in the per
user/overall performance, which can be seen in the green
and blue bar in the figures.
Figure 23. HSUPA (separate) compared to HSUPA (combined with
HSDPA) per user app. throughput
Figure 24. HSUPA (separate) compared to HSUPA (combined with
HSDPA) total app. throughput
X. CONCLUSION
This paper shows the different aspects of the TNL
congestion control algorithm in the HSPA simulation
model. The effects of the TNL congestion control
algorithm for the simultaneous deployment of both
HSDPA and HSUPA performance are presented.
The results showed that using the congestion control
algorithm leads to significant performance enhancements,
ranging from higher per user and total application
throughput, reducing the losses over the TNL network
significantly, lower burstiness and better resource
utilizations by reducing the overall number of
retransmissions.
In addition, the results also showed the effect of
deploying both HSDPA and HSUPA together in one
system. The RLC/TCP acknowledgments that are being
carried by the opposite direction are getting delayed and
in some case even discarded, leading to reducing the
performance slightly when the CC algorithm is in use,
whereas in the case the CC algorithm in inactive the
performance of both HSDPA and HSUPA are
significantly reduced due to TCP mainly because the TCP
acknowledgments that are being carried over the opposite
direction suffers from higher delays and even discards in
the high loaded situations (congested link).
REFERENCES
[1] 3GPP TS 25.309 V6.6.0 (2006-03), Technical
Specification, 3rd Generation Partnership Project;
Technical Specification Group Radio Access Network;
FDD Enhanced Uplink; Overall description; Stage 2
(Release 6).
[2] 3GPP TR 25.855 V5.0.0 (2001-09), Technical Report, 3rd
Generation Partnership Project; Technical Specification
Group Radio Access Network; High Speed Downlink
Packet Access; Overall UTRAN Description (Release 5).
[3] M.C. Necker and A. Weber, Impact of Iub Flow Control on
HSDPA System Performance, Proceedings of the 16th
Annual IEEE International Symposium on Personal Indoor
and Mobile Radio Communications, Berlin, Germany
2005.
[4] S. Floyd, M. Handley, J. Padhye, A Comparison of
Equation-Based and AIMD Congestion Control, ACIRI,
May 2000.
[5] Van Jacobson, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory & Michael
J. Karels, University of California at Berkeley, Congestion
Avoidance and Control, November, 1988.
[6] Sagfors, M. Virkki, V. Kuningas, T., Overload Control
of Best-Effort Traffic in the UTRAN Transport Network,
VTC 2006 conference, May. 2006, Melbourne, Vic.
[7] Sz. Ndas, S. Rcz, Sz. Malomsoky, S. Molnr:
Connection Admission Control in the UTRAN Transport
Network, Telecommunication Systems, 28(1): 929,
2005.
[8] Thushara Weerawardane, Andreas Timm-Giel, Gennaro C.
Malafronte, Durastante Gianluca, Stephan Hauth,
Carmelita Grg., Preventive and Reactive based TNL
Congestion Control Impact on the HSDPA Performance
VTC IEEE conference, May 2008, Singapore.
[9] OPNET technologies Inc., OPNET Modeler Accelerating
Networks R&D, www.opnet.com (Last accessed in
04.11.08)
[10] Harri Holma and Antti Toskala. WCDMA for UMTS:
Radio Access for third Generation Mobile Communication.
Third Edition. John Wiley & Sons 2004.
[11] Harri Holma and Antti Toskala. HSDPA/HSUPA for
UMTS: High Speed Radio Access for Mobile
Communication. John Wiley & Sons 2006.
JOURNAL OF NETWORKS, VOL. 5, NO. 7, JULY 2010 779
2010 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
[12] X. Li, R. Schelb, C. Grg and A. Timm-Giel, "UMTS
HSPA and R99 Traffic Separation," in 10th IFIP
International Conference on Mobile and Wireless
Communications Networks (MWCN), Toulouse, France,
Sept. 30-Oct. 2, 2008,
[13] Yasir Zaki, Thushara Weerawardane, Xi Li, Andreas
Timm-Giel, Gennaro Ciro Malafronte and Carmelita Grg:
Effect of the RLC and TNL Congestion Control on the
HSUPA Network Performance, Mosharaka International
Conference on Communications, Computers and
Applications MIC-CCA 2008 in Amman-Jordan
[14] T.L. Weerawardane, A. Timm-Giel, C. Grg, T. Reim:
Performance Analysis of the Iub Interface in UMTS
Networks for HSDPA, Mobilfunk Technologien und
Anwendungen, 10. ITG-Fachtagung, Juni 2005,
Osnabrck.
[15] L. Zhao, T.L. Weerawardane, A. Timm-Giel, C. Grg, U.
Trke, M. Koonert: Overview on UMTS HSDPA and
Enhanced Uplink (HSUPA), Mobilfunk Technologien und
Anwendungen, 11. ITG-Fachtagung, Mai 2006,
Osnabrck.
[16] Thushara Weerawardane, Andreas Timm-Giel, Carmelita
Grg, Thomas Reim, "Impact of the Transport Network
Layer Flow Control for HSDPA Performance", IEE
conference, Sep. 2006, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
[17] X. Li, R. Schelb, C. Grg and A. Timm-Giel,
"Dimensioning of UTRAN Iub Links for Elastic Internet
Traffic." International Teletraffic Congress, Beijing,
Aug/Sept. 2005, 2005.
[18] X. Li, R. Schelb, C. Grg and A. Timm-Giel,
"Dimensioning of UTRAN Iub Links for Elastic Internet
Traffic with Multiple Radio Bearers," in Proc. 13th GI/ITG
Conference Measuring, Modeling and Evaluation of
Computer and Communication Systems, Nrnberg, March
2006, 2006
[19] X.Li, W. Cheng, A.Timm-Giel, and C. Grg, "Modeling
IP-based UTRAN for UMTS in OPNET", distinguished
paper award, in Proc. OPNETWORK 2007, September,
2007, Washington DC, USA, 2007
[20] X.Li, Y.Zeng, B. Kracker, R.Schelb, C.Grg and A. Timm-
Giel, Carrier Ethernet for Transport in UMTS Radio
Access Network: Ethernet Backhaul Evolution, (accepted
for publication) 2008 IEEE 67th Vehicular Technology
Conference VTC2008-Spring, May 2008, Singapore, 2008.
Yasir Zaki received his bachelor (B.Sc.) degree in
Electronics and Communication at the University of Baghdad,
Iraq in 2004 and master degree (M.Sc.) in Communication and
Information Technology at University of Bremen, Germany in
2007.
After completing his bachelor degree he was awarded a
DAAD scholarship to finish his master studies in Germany.
Then after completing his master degree he joined the Center
for Computer Science and Information Technology (TZI) of the
University of Bremen in the Communication Networks group as
a scientist researcher and a PhD candidate in 2007. He worked
in the industrial research project funded by Nokia Siemens
Networks on performance optimization of UMTS/HSPA radio
networks and transport networks from 2007 to 2008. Starting
from 2008 he started working in the 4WARD European project
that is focusing on the Future Internet; where he is mainly
focusing on the network virtualization. Currently he is
investigating how the LTE (Long Term Evolution) system can
be virtualized, the wireless resources in particular and how this
could be shared between multiple virtual operators.
Mr. Yasir Zaki has published a number of scientific papers in
the field of communication networks.
Thushara Lanka Weerawardane received bachelor (B.Sc.)
degree in Electrical Engineering at the University of Moratuwa,
Sri Lanka in 1998 and master degree in Communication and
Information Technology at University of Bremen, Germany in
2004.
He worked as an assistant network manager in the
department of electrical engineering and as a system engineer
for Lanka Educational and Research Network (LEARN) in Sri
Lanka from 1999 to 2002. After completing his master degree,
he joined Center for Computer Science and Information
Technology (TZI) of the University of Bremen in the
Communication Networks group as a scientist researcher in
2004. He led the industrial research project funded by Nokia
Siemens Networks on performance optimization of
UMTS/HSPA radio networks and transport networks from 2004
to 2007. His main responsibilities are UMTS/HSPA based
protocol design and development, HSPA (HSDPA/HSUPA)
simulator design and development for performance analysis of
HSPA radio networks and transport networks, optimization of
the HSPA transport network (Iub/Iur) by deploying different
congestion control and flow control features. Currently, he is
leading an LTE simulation research project funded by Nokia
Siemens Networks. In this ongoing research project, LTE
system level simulator design and development for the
optimization of LTE transport networks are the main
consideration.
Mr. Thushara Weerawardane has published many scientific
papers in the field of communication networks and is a member
of IEEE.
Andreas Timm-Giel, Dipl.-Ing in Electrical
Engineering/Information Technology (EE/IT) at University of
Bremen, Germany, 1994, Dr.-Ing. (PhD) in EE/IT on radio
channel modeling, University of Bremen, 1999.
From 1994 1999 he led a group at the University of
Bremen, that participated in several European R&D projects on
mobile and satellite communications. Starting in January 2000
he joined Media Mobil Communication GmbH as Technical
Project Leader of the EU funded project SATISFY2000. He was
involved in the technical and commercial set up of the mobile
satellite network and service provider M2sat Ltd. as Technical
Product Manager and Manager Network Operations. In
December 2002 he joined the Communication Networks Group
at the University of Bremen as senior researcher and lecturer.
He is leading several industry, national and EC funded research
projects at the university. Since October 2006 he is additionally
directing the interdisciplinary concerted activity Adaptive
Communications of the Center for Computer Science and
Information Technology (TZI) in Bremen. His research interests
are adaptive mobile and wireless communication and sensor
networks.
Dr Timm-Giel is author or coauthor of 10 book contributions
and more than 65 reviewed publications in journals and on
international conferences. Dr. Timm-Giel is frequent reviewer
and TPC member for international conferences and journals and
is Member of IEEE and VDE/ITG.
780 JOURNAL OF NETWORKS, VOL. 5, NO. 7, JULY 2010
2010 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
Carmelita Grg received her diploma degree from the
Department of Computer Science, University of Karlsruhe and
the Dr. rer. nat. degree and the appointment as lecturer from the
Department of Electrical Engineering, Aachen University of
Technology.
From 1985 until 1989 she worked as a consultant in the field
of communication networks. Since 1989 she has been working
as a group leader and since 1997 as an Assistant Professor at the
Communi-cation Networks Institute, Aachen University of
Technology. Since 1999 she is leading the Communication
Networks Group (ComNets) at the University of Bremen within
TZI (Center for Computer Science and Information
Technology) and MRC (Mobile Research Center). Her research
interests include: Performance Analysis of Communication
Networks, Stochastic Simulation, Rare Event Simulation, High
Speed Networks, Personal Communication, Wireless Networks,
Mobility Support, New Services and Applications in
Telecommunication Networks, Network Virtualization.
Prof. Grg has been active in European projects starting with
the RACE program. She has been an evaluator and auditor for
the European Commission. The research group in Bremen
consists of about 15 Ph.D. students / research assistants, which
are funded by the state of Bremen and third-party projects
(European projects, DFG projects, BMBF projects, bilateral
industry projects). Prof. Grg has published a large number of
scientific papers in the field of communication networks. She is
a member of the board of the ITG (Information Technology
Society, Germany) and speaker of the ITG working group 5.2.1
on "System Architecture and Traffic Engineering".
Gennaro Ciro Malafronte received master degree in
Electronic Engineering in 1999 and PhD in Electrical
Engineering on Electrical and Electronic Measurements in 2003
at the University of Naples Federico II.
In 2001, he joined the Italian COM division of the Siemens
Corporation, then merged in the Nokia Siemens Networks in
2007. He started his activity at Siemens COM for concept
analysis of Smart Antennas and Software Radio Technology.
He then worked as Sales Support for some UMTS service
providers in Europe. He was involved in special projects in
collaboration with the European Space Agency (ESTEC) for
requirement specifications of satellite transmission paths in the
terrestrial Siemens UMTS systems. Since 2004 he joined the
Siemens System Engineering Transport Expert Group and he
focused his activity in the optimization of the transport features
of UMTS terrestrial interfaces (Iub,Iur, Iu). In that field he was
responsible for the definition of HSDPA/HSUPA Iub/Iur
congestion control algorithms and he contributed to the 3GPP
for the definition of standardized procedures for Iub/Iur
congestion control.
Dr. Gennaro Ciro Malafronte holds a number of patents in
the field of Iub/Iur HSDPA/HSUPA congestion control as
Method for congestion control with macro diversity (EP 1
816 879 A1), Controlling congestion over a non-serving
branch (EP 1 901 493 A1), Method for decoupling congestion
control in a cascade of network elements of an UMTS radio
access network (WO 2008/064983 A2) Controlling
congestion detection in HSDPA systems (WO 2008/037357
A1), He is co-author of a number of papers in the field of
Iub/Iur HSDPA/HSUPA congestion control. His current field of
interest is Transport Optimization for LTE systems.
JOURNAL OF NETWORKS, VOL. 5, NO. 7, JULY 2010 781
2010 ACADEMY PUBLISHER