Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Regional Workshop on Human Trafficking Prevention in the Context of Increased Connectivity and Mobility in Asia
11 May 2011 ADB Headquarters
The views expressed in this paper are the views of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Asian Development Bank (ADB), or its Board of Governors, or the governments they represent. ADB does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this paper and accepts no responsibility for any consequence of their use. The countries listed in this paper do not imply any view on ADB's part as to sovereignty or independent status or necessarily conform to ADB's terminology.
Awareness raising
Community level Government officials At destination Micro-credit Vocational Training Scholarships Pledges to keep children in school Migrant Information Reporting Trafficking Improved migration policies Protection at destination
Hotlines
Safe Migration Labor management Border/ transportation management
Workplace Inspections
Monitor recruitment companies Border interception Out-reach at transport hubs
VULNERABILITY TARGETING. Who are the most vulnerable, and are we reaching them? Can they be reached on the origin side? On the destination side? What makes them vulnerable?
IMPACT & COST-EFFECTIVENESS. Awareness raising, microcredit, scholarships, safe migrationwhat is most effective for a particular environment or population? Cost-effective?
Vulnerability targeting
VILLAGE PROFILE: PAKKOKU, MYANMAR
One of the poorest regions of Myanmar (Dry Zone) Extreme seasonal drought which has led to long-established patterns of seasonal labor migration Labor migration patterns over time have shifted from predominantly domestic (to mines in northern Myanmar, as well as more urban areas) to also cross-border, into Thailand and Malaysia
How many of you have at least one family member who has migrated from the village in search of a job?
KEY FINDINGS
Long-established patterns of seasonal labor migration have led to expansive social networks supporting migrants, as well as a level of migrant savviness in dealing with brokers, recruiters, and transport, particularly domestic
Migrants were male and female, single and married, less wealthy and more wealthy but predominantly young and single, or newly married with young children
Risks are only when migrants shifting to jobs in Thailand and Malaysia end up in exploitative labor situations in factories, on farms, and for women and girls in sex but for Pakkoku villagers this was extremely rare, and brought us to the conclusion of wanting to focus on Thailand and Malaysia.
Vulnerability targeting
KEY FINDINGS
Low risk of being trafficked, due to distance from road, no presence of traffickers, and in general not much interest or aspiration in another lifestyle Difficult to persuade some that this was a poor candidate for trafficking prevention programs, because they were so poor and ethnic minority
Answer: The young kids. Rich or poor, they want to go from what they hear on the radio they want the modern life.
How have you learned to protect yourself from trafficking and abuse? We travel around the beach in groups now. If a customer says they have to get money in their hotel room, we do not go with them!
Collaboration with government authorities in monitoring workplaces and potential exploitation sites Establish migrant self-support networks Community leaders, volunteers, and advocacy groups providing watchdog role
2.
COMMUNITY, INDIVIDUAL, AND FAMILY FACTORS THAT INCREASE RISK OF CAMBODIANS BEING TRAFFICKED TO THAILAND
COMMUNITY FACTOR Location
Most migration and trafficking occurs along the major highways linking Cambodia and Thailand
INDIVIDUAL & FAMILY FACTORS Sex Age Number of brokers used Going into debt to pay migration costs Pre-existing knowledge and ideas about Thailand
Marital status Years of education Previous job Number of dependents Ill or recently passed away family member Sibling or child who needs school fees Forced to go to Thailand by family member Violence in the family Recent flood, drought, natural disaster
Points to consider
1. To change behavior We need to understand why more knowledge does not always lead to safer behavior Understanding barriers to changing behavior requires two-way communication
2. To reduce the factors that create vulnerability we need to: Understand what these really are; and Focus on what we can realistically change 3. To measure success, we first need to be clear about our objectives
Sharing updated data, information, and resources to benefit the anti-trafficking sector regionally and globally: Visit UNIAP at
www.no-trafficking.org