Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NGUYN TH TUYT HN
B GIO DC V O TO
TRNG I HC KINH T THNH PH H CH MINH
*********
NGUYN TH TUYT HN
: 60.34.05
LI CAM OAN
*********
Nguyn Th Tuyt Hn
-1-
MC LC
Trang
Li cam oan
Mc lc
Danh mc ch vit tt
Danh mc bng
Danh mc hnh
CHNG I: GII THIU .............................................................................1
1.1 Trnh by vn nghin cu........................................................................1
1.2 Mc tiu nghin cu.....................................................................................3
1.3 Phm vi v phng php nghin cu...........................................................3
1.3.1 Phm vi nghin cu ........................................................................3
1.3.2 Phng php nghin cu ................................................................4
1.4 ngha thc tin ca nghin cu ................................................................4
1.5 Kt cu ca lun vn ....................................................................................6
CHNG 2. TNG QUAN L THUYT ...................................................7
2.1 Tng quan l thuyt v s hi lng ca khch hng trong dch v .............7
2.1.1 nh ngha v dch v.....................................................................7
2.1.2 nh ngha s hi lng khch hng v ti sao phi lm hi lng
khch hng.....................................................................................9
2.1.3 S cn thit ca o lng nhu cu v tha mn khch hng........10
2.1.4 Cc m hnh o lng tha mn khch hng trong dch v.........12
2.2 Tng quan l thuyt v giao nhn hng khng ..........................................21
2.2.1 Nh giao nhn hng khng ..........................................................22
2.2.2 c im ca vn ti hng khng................................................23
2.2.3 C s vt cht k thut ca vn ti hng khng ..........................24
2.2.4 Hng ho thng c vn chuyn bng ng hng khng .....24
2.2.5 Cc yu t nh hng n s hi lng khch hng v dch v vn
chuyn hng khng ........................................................................24
-2-
-3-
DANH MC CH VIT TT
IATA:
ISO:
ACSI:
NQRC:
TNHH:
Trch nhim hu hn
TB:
trung bnh
Hawb:
Mawb:
DANH MC BNG
Chng 2
Bng 2.1: Thang o SERVQUAL..................................................................... 14
Chng 3
Bng 3.1: Thang o 1 v cc yu t nh hng n mc hi lng ca
khch hng v dch v giao nhn hng khng ................................. 27
Bng 3.2: Thang o 2 v cc yu t nh hng n mc hi lng ca
khch hng v dch v giao nhn hng khng .............................. 31
Bng 3.3: Bng tng hp thng tin mu ........................................................... 36
Bng 3.4: Cronbach alpha ca cc thnh phn thang o mc hi lng
khch hng v dch v giao nhn hng khng ................................. 39
Chng 4
Bng 4.1: Tng hp tm quan trng ca cc yu t ......................................... 44
Bng 4.2: Tng hp mc hi lng khch hng i vi cc yu t .............. 46
Bng 4.3: Tng hp khong cch gia im s tm quan trng v im s hi
lng................................................................................................... 48
Bng 4.4: Tng hp mc hi lng khch hng v tm quan trng i vi
nhn t p ng .......................................................................... 52
Bng 4.5: Tng hp mc hi lng khch hng v tm quan trng i vi
nhn t chuyn nghip ............................................................... 59
Bng 4.6: Tng hp mc hi lng khch hng v tm quan trng i vi
nhn t tn tm ........................................................................... 66
Bng 4.7: Tng hp mc hi lng khch hng v tm quan trng i vi
nhn t hu hnh......................................................................... 67
DANH MC HNH
Chng 2
Hnh 2.1: M hnh ch s tha mn khch hng ca M ................................... 12
Hnh 2.2:M hnh cc khong cch cht lng dch v ................................... 18
Hnh 2.3: M hnh nh gi tha mn khch hng ............................................ 19
Hnh 2.4: M hnh nh gi tm quan trng ca yu cu .................................. 20
Hnh 2.5: Ma trn nh gi mc tha mn v tm quan trng ..................... 21
Hnh 2.6: Cc yu t cht lng quan trng ca nh vn chuyn hng khng . 25
Chng 3
Hnh 3.1: Quy trnh nghin cu ......................................................................... 26
Chng 4
Hnh 4.1: Mc hi lng ................................................................................. 43
Hnh 4.2: Phn b tm quan trng ca cc yu t ............................................. 45
Hnh 4.3: Phn b mc hi lng ca khch hng i vi cc yu t............ 47
Hnh 4.4: Ma trn nh gi mc tha mn v tm quan trng ..................... 50
-1-
-2-
-3-
-4-
-5-
-6-
-7-
-8-
-9-
- 10 -
- 11 -
- 12 -
S than phin
(Customer Complaints)
Gi tr c
nhn thc
(Perceived
Value)
S tha
mn ca
khch hng
(ACSI)
S mong i
(Customer expectations)
S trung thnh
(Customer Loyalty)
- 13 -
- 14 -
- 15 -
Nhn vin cng ty xyz nhanh chng thc hin dch v cho bn.
Nhn vin cng ty xyz lun sn sng gip bn.
Nhn vin cng ty xyz khng bao gi qu bn n ni khng p ng
yu cu ca bn.
S m bo (assurance)
Cch c x ca nhn vin xyz gy nim tin cho bn.
Bn cm thy an ton trong khi giao dch vi cng ty xyz.
Nhn vin cng ty xyz lun nim n vi bn.
Nhn vin cng ty xyz c hiu bit tr li cu hi ca bn.
thu cm (empathy)
Cng ty xyz lun c bit ch n bn.
Cng ty xyz c nhn vin bit quan tm n bn.
Cng ty xyz ly li ch ca bn l iu tm nim ca h.
Nhn vin cng ty xyz hiu r nhng nhu cu ca bn.
Cngty xyz lm vic vo nhng gi thun tin.
hu hnh (tangibility)
Cng ty xyz c trang thit b rt hin i.
Cc c s vt cht ca cng ty xyz trng rt bt mt.
Nhn vin cng ty xyz n mc rt tm tt.
Cc sch nh gii thiu ca cng ty xyz c lin quan n dch v trng
rt p.
Nghin cu v vic o lng cht lng dch v tp trung ch yu vo
cch thc tho mn hay p ng vt mc s mong i ca khch hng
bn ngoi v xem cht lng dch v nh s o lng mc dch v p
ng ph hp vi mong i ca khch hng nh th no. Khi nim o lng
s khc nhau gia mong i v cm nhn v dch v di hnh thc ca im
- 16 -
- 17 -
- 18 -
Nhu cu c nhn
Kinh nghim qu kh
Dch v mong i
Khch hng
KC5
KC6
KC4
KC3
Nhn thc ca
nhn vin v
mong i ca
khch hng
KC7
- 19 -
Mc
tha
mn
Mc tha mn trung bnh
Yu cu cht lng
- 20 -
Tm quan
trng TB
Yu cu cht lng
- 21 -
IV
Mc
tha
mn
Mc tha
mn TB
II
1
III
3
Tm quan trng
- 22 -
- 23 -
- 24 -
- 25 -
tin cy ca
dch v
43%
- 26 -
Thang o
1
Nghin cu nh lng
Vit bo co tng hp
- nh gi mc hi lng
- xut gii php
Tho lun
tay i
Thang o
2
- 27 -
- 28 -
3. Gi cc ca cng ty a ra ph hp vi mong i
4. Cng ty c hp ng gi vi nhiu hng hng khng
5. Cng ty c kh nng thng lng vi cc hng hng khng c gi tt
6. Cng ty c chnh sch gi tt cho khch hng
Thi gian vn chuyn (Transit time)
1. Thi gian hng n ng theo lch trnh
2. Mc chm tr ca hng nu c khng gy nhiu kh khn cho khch
hng
Dch v khch hng (Customer service)
1. Nhn vin lun phc v nhanh chng, ng hn
2. Nhn vin lun sn sng gip khch hng
3. Nhn vin lun phc v chu o ngay c trong ma cao im
4. Nhn vin lun t ra lch s, nh nhn
5. Nhn vin tr li tha ng cc cu hi/ yu cu ca khch hng
6. Nhn vin cung cp chng t nhanh chng, chnh xc
7. Nhn vin c nng lc chuyn mn tt
8. Thi ca nhn vin hp tc v tn tm trc nhng yu cu ca khch
hng
Mng li vn phng v i l (Network coverage)
1. Cng ty c mng li vn phng v i l rng khp p ng nhu cu vn
chuyn hng ha
2. Cng ty c mi quan h tt v tin cy vi h thng i l
3. H thng i l cung cp cht lng dch v tt
4. H thng i l cung cp gi tt
5. H thng i l lun c phn hi nhanh
Cng ngh (Technology)
- 29 -
- 30 -
- 31 -
- 32 -
- 33 -
- 34 -
- 35 -
- 36 -
S ngi
T l (%)
99
100.00
Cng ty sn xut
24
24.20
Cng ty thng mi
75
75.80
99
100.00
8.10
31
31.30
4.00
56
56.60
Mc thng xuyn
99
100.00
Hng ngy
1.00
Mi tun
35
35.40
Mi thng
36
36.40
Lu hn na
27
27.30
99
100.00
Chu / Chu c
25
25.30
17
17.20
C hai
57
57.60
Ni n
- 37 -
V loi hnh cng ty, trong 99 bng cu hi hon tt, c 75 khch hng
c phng vn thuc loi hnh cng ty thng mi (chim 75.80% kch
thc mu), 24 khch hng thuc loi hnh cng ty sn xut (chim 24.20%
kch thc mu). Vinalink hng n khch hng mc tiu l loi hnh cng
ty thng mi v cng ty sn xut.
V mc trng lng tnh cc ca hng, c 8 khch hng c phng
vn i hng mc trng lng tnh cc <=100kgs, chim 8.10% kch thc
mu. 31 khch hng i hng mc trng lng tnh cc 101-500kgs, chim
31.30% kch thc mu. 4 khch hng i hng mc trng lng tnh cc
>500kgs, chim 4.00% kch thc mu. 56 khch hng i hng tt c cc
mc trng lng tnh cc trn, chim 56.60% kch thc mu.
V mc thng xuyn, c 1 khch hng i hng qua Vinalink hng
ngy, chim 1% kch thc mu. 35 khch hng i hng qua Vinalink mi
tun, chim 35.40% kch thc mu. 36 khch hng i hng qua Vinalink mi
thng, chim 36.40% kch thc mu. 27 khch hng i hng qua Vinalink
vi mc thng xuyn lu hn na, chim 27.30% kch thc mu. Khch
hng cng thng xuyn i hng qua dch v ca Vinalink s c nhng nhn
xt chnh xc hn v dch v ca Vinalink.
Trong tng s 99 bng cu hi hon tt, c 25 khch hng i hng n
khu vc Chu / Chu c, chim 25.30% kch thc mu. 17 khch hng i
hng n khu vc Chu u/ Chu M/ Chu Phi, chim 17.20% kch thc
mu. 57 khch hng chim 57.60% kch thc mu i hng n c hai khu
vc ny. Khu vc Chu / Chu c l khu vc gn vi thi gian vn chuyn
nhanh v gi cc r, trong khi khu vc Chu u/ Chu M/ Chu Phi l khu
vc xa vi thi gian vn chuyn hng lu hn v gi cc cao hn.
- 38 -
- 39 -
Alpha nu loi
bin
tin cy ca dch v
C1
17.6061
6.4045
0.5953
0.8034
C2
17.6061
6.1187
0.6352
0.7951
C3
17.5455
7.0260
0.5975
0.8068
C4
17.8384
6.6471
0.5295
0.8168
C5
17.7172
5.8988
0.6271
0.7988
C6
17.8485
6.5788
0.6602
0.7924
Alpha = .8297
Gi cc, ph dch v v a dng ca sn phm
C7
7.1616
1.6879
0.7438
0.7604
C8
6.8990
1.6836
0.6635
0.8324
C9
7.8384
1.5042
0.7388
0.7614
C10
26.3030
8.6623
0.6321
0.8362
C11
27.0606
8.5881
0.6743
0.8314
C12
27.2020
8.3873
0.6574
0.8329
C13
26.2727
9.3228
0.5521
0.8458
C14
27.5354
7.9043
0.6203
0.8416
C15
26.6970
9.0297
0.5911
0.8413
C16
26.6263
9.5426
0.5614
0.8464
C17
26.4040
8.5902
0.5818
0.8426
C18
7.3737
1.1344
0.6084
0.7400
C19
7.7374
1.0528
0.6711
0.6705
C20
8.0404
1.2432
0.6198
0.7299
C21
19.5152
3.9258
0.6357
0.7410
C22
18.5051
4.0893
0.6321
0.7432
C23
19.4747
4.2519
0.4995
0.7757
C24
18.3333
5.0204
0.2801
0.8160
C25
19.6263
4.3589
0.6031
0.7533
C26
19.1919
3.8710
0.6480
0.7376
Alpha = .8460
Dch v khch hng
Alpha = .8571
Mng li vn phng
Alpha =
.7900
Cc yu t hu hnh
Alpha =
.7948
- 40 -
- 41 -
- 42 -
- 43 -
Hon ton
hi lng,
20.20%
Khng hi
lng, 1.00%
C th hi
lng,
32.30%
13
Hi lng,
46.50%
Khng hi lng
C th hi lng
Hi lng
Hon ton hi lng
- 44 -
Tm quan trng
th
t
1
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
TB im
Yu t
p ng
01
Quan h i l
0.00
0.00
7.10
35.40
57.60
4.51
02
Cc cnh tranh
0.00
0.00
0.00
33.30
66.70
4.67
03
Ph dch v cnh
tranh
Mng li i l
Sn phm a dng
Cht lng i l
Dch v ng
Chuyn mn tt
0.00
0.00
0.00
40.40
59.60
4.60
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
2.00
3.00
8.10
0.00
1.00
38.40
39.40
33.30
33.30
31.30
59.60
57.60
58.60
66.70
67.70
4.58
4.55
4.51
4.67
4.67
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
7.10
35.40
34.30
64.60
58.60
4.65
4.52
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
8.10
0.00
16.20
50.50
57.60
25.30
41.40
42.40
58.60
4.33
4.42
4.42
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
8.10
8.10
26.30
41.40
65.70
50.50
4.58
4.42
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
chuyn nghip
Cung cp chng t
Gii quyt vn /
khiu ni
Thng bo vn
Tr li tha ng
Chu o ma cao
im
Khng sai st
Phc v ng hn
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
16.20
66.70
34.30
33.30
49.50
4.33
4.33
18
tn tm
Lch s, nh nhn
Tn tm vi cc yu
cu
Gip khch hng
0.00
0.00
8.10
58.60
33.30
4.25
19
20
21
hu hnh
C s vt cht
Cng ngh
Thng hiu
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
4.00
21.20
8.10
40.40
24.20
35.40
55.60
54.50
56.60
4.52
4.33
4.48
Trung bnh
0.00
0.00
6.02
38.82
55.18
4.49
16
17
- 45 -
Tm quan trng
4.70
4.60
4.50
4.40
7 8 9
3 4
14
Tm5quan
bnh chung
6 trng trung10
12 13
15
11
4.30
19
16 17
21
20
18
4.20
4.10
4.00
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Yu t
Tn yu t
Cc cnh tranh
Chuyn mn tt
Dch v ng
Cung cp chng t
Ph dch v cnh tranh
Mng li i l
Khng sai st
Sn phm a dng
C s vt cht
Gii quyt vn / khiu ni
im s tm quan trng
4.67
4.67
4.67
4.65
4.60
4.58
4.58
4.55
4.52
4.52
- 46 -
Mc hi lng
th
t
TB
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
im
Yu t
p ng
01
Quan h i l
0.00
0.00
29.30
57.60
13.10
3.84
02
Cc cnh tranh
0.00
0.00
22.20
50.50
27.30
4.05
03
Ph dch v cnh
tranh
Mng li i l
Sn phm a dng
Cht lng i l
Dch v ng
Chuyn mn tt
0.00
19.20
53.50
24.20
3.00
3.11
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
2.00
0.00
11.10
34.30
49.50
46.50
11.10
57.60
52.50
47.50
38.40
81.80
31.30
13.10
3.00
13.10
7.10
4.20
3.79
3.54
3.63
3.96
0.00
0.00
25.30
10.10
46.50
41.40
26.30
47.50
2.00
1.00
3.05
3.39
0.00
0.00
0.00
12.10
0.00
4.00
31.30
51.50
57.60
49.50
44.40
34.30
7.10
4.00
4.00
3.52
3.53
3.38
0.00
0.00
3.00
0.00
58.60
20.20
35.40
70.70
3.00
9.10
3.38
3.89
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.00
1.00
10.10
66.70
58.60
32.30
30.30
4.31
4.18
0.00
0.00
7.10
57.60
35.40
4.28
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
5.10
0.00
4.00
50.50
36.40
49.50
42.40
53.50
46.50
2.00
10.10
4.42
3.41
3.74
0.00
3.90
32.08
49.83
14.18
3.74
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
chuyn nghip
Cung cp chng t
Gii quyt vn /
khiu ni
Thng bo vn
Tr li tha ng
Chu o ma cao
im
Khng sai st
Phc v ng hn
tn tm
Lch s, nh nhn
Tn tm vi cc
yu cu
Gip khch
hng
hu hnh
C s vt cht
Cng ngh
Thng hiu
Trung bnh
- 47 -
Mc hi lng
5.00
4.50
4.00
17
18
19
15
Mc
5 hi lng trung bnh chung
3.50
3.00
16
10
11 12
13 14
21
20
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Yu t
Tn yu t
Cung cp chng t
Ph dch v cnh tranh
Khng sai st
Chu o ma cao im
Gii quyt vn / khiu ni
Cng ngh
Thng bo vn
Tr li tha ng
Cht lng i l
Dch v ng
im s hi lng
3.05
3.11
3.38
3.38
3.39
3.41
3.52
3.53
3.54
3.63
- 48 -
TB mc
TB tm
TB
th
hi lng
quan trng
chnh lch
(1)
(2)
(3 = (2)-(1)
Yu t
p ng
01
Quan h i l
3.84
4.50
0.67
02
Cc cnh tranh
4.05
4.67
0.62
03
Ph dch v cnh
tranh
Mng li i l
Sn phm a dng
Cht lng i l
Dch v ng
Chuyn mn tt
3.11
4.60
1.49
4.20
3.79
3.54
3.63
3.96
4.58
4.55
4.51
4.67
4.67
0.38
0.76
0.97
1.04
0.71
3.05
3.39
4.65
4.52
1.60
1.13
3.52
3.53
3.38
4.33
4.42
4.42
0.81
0.89
1.04
3.38
3.89
4.58
4.42
1.20
0.53
4.31
4.18
4.33
4.33
0.02
0.15
4.28
4.25
-0.03
4.42
3.41
3.74
4.52
4.33
4.48
0.10
0.92
0.74
3.74
4.49
0.75
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
chuyn nghip
Cung cp chng t
Gii quyt vn /
khiu ni
Thng bo vn
Tr li tha ng
Chu o ma cao
im
Khng sai st
Phc v ng hn
tn tm
Lch s, nh nhn
Tn tm vi cc
yu cu
Gip khch
hng
hu hnh
C s vt cht
Cng ngh
Thng hiu
Trung bnh
- 49 -
Tn yu t
Cung cp chng t
Ph dch v cnh tranh
Khng sai st
Gii quyt vn / khiu ni
Chu o ma cao im
Dch v ng
Cht lng i l
Cng ngh
Tr li tha ng
Thng bo vn
- 50 -
4.60
19
Mc tha mn
4.40
16
18
4.20
4.00
17
15
Mc tha mn TB
3.80
3.60
II
3.40
20
11
12
21
Tm
quan
trng
1 TB
4
2
8
07
6
10
13
14
3.20
3.00
4.20
4.30
4.40
IV
4.50
4.60
III
4.70
4.80
Tm quan trng
Ghi ch:
- Trong Hnh 4.4, cc yu t c nh s theo s th t cc yu t trong
Bng 4.3
4.4.1 Bn yu t nm trong vng I Khu vc gi tr gia tng khng cn
thay i
Yu t
Yu t 15
Yu t 17
Yu t 18
Yu t 16
Tn yu t
Phc v ng hn
Tn tm vi yu cu
Gip khch hng
Lch s, nh nhn
im s
im s tm
hi lng
quan trng
3.89
4.18
4.28
4.31
4.42
4.33
4.25
4.33
Khong cch
chnh lch
0.53
0.15
-0.03
0.02
- 51 -
Yu t 13
Yu t 20
Yu t 11
Yu t 12
Yu t 21
Tn yu t
im s
im s tm
hi lng
quan trng
3.38
3.41
3.52
3.53
3.74
4.42
4.33
4.33
4.42
4.48
Chu o ma cao im
Cng ngh
Thng bo vn
Tr li tha ng
Thng hiu
Khong cch
chnh lch
1.04
0.92
0.81
0.89
0.74
Yu t 9
Yu t 3
Yu t 14
Yu t 10
Yu t 6
Yu t 7
Tn yu t
im s
Cung cp chng t
Ph dch v cnh tranh
Khng sai st
Gii quyt vn / khiu ni
Cht lng i l
Dch v ng
im s tm Khong cch
hi lng
quan trng
3.05
3.11
3.38
3.39
3.54
3.63
4.65
4.60
4.58
4.52
4.51
4.67
chnh lch
1.60
1.49
1.20
1.13
0.97
1.04
Yu t 5
Yu t 1
Yu t 8
Yu t 2
Yu t 4
Yu t 19
Tn yu t
Sn phm a dng
Quan h i l
Chuyn mn tt
Cc cnh tranh
Mng li i l
C s vt cht
im s hi
im s tm
lng
quan trng
3.79
3.84
3.96
4.05
4.20
4.42
4.55
4.51
4.67
4.67
4.58
4.52
Khong cch
chnh lch
0.76
0.67
0.71
0.62
0.38
0.10
- 52 -
Mc hi lng
th
t
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
Yu t
TB
TB
TB
im
tm
chnh
(1)
quan
lch
trng(2)
(3)
=(2-(1
01
Quan h i l
0.00
0.00
29.30
57.60
13.10
3.84
4.51
0.67
02
Cc cnh tranh
0.00
0.00
22.20
50.50
27.30
4.05
4.67
0.62
03
Ph dch v cnh
tranh
Mng li i l
Sn phm a dng
Cht lng i l
Dch v ng
Chuyn mn tt
0.00 19.20
53.50
24.20
3.00
3.11
4.60
1.49
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
2.00
0.00
11.10
34.30
49.50
46.50
11.10
57.60
52.50
47.50
38.40
81.80
31.30
13.10
3.00
13.10
7.10
4.20
3.79
3.54
3.63
3.96
4.58
4.55
4.51
4.67
4.67
0.38
0.76
0.97
1.04
0.71
p ng
0.00
2.65
32.19
51.26
13.88
3.77
4.60
0.83
04
05
06
07
08
- 53 -
- 54 -
- 55 -
- 56 -
- 57 -
- 58 -
- 59 -
Mc hi lng
th
t
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
Yu t
TB
TB
TB
im
tm
chnh
(1)
quan
lch
trng(2)
(3)
=(2)-(1)
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
46.50
41.40
26.30
47.50
2.00
1.00
3.05
3.39
4.65
4.52
1.60
1.13
31.30
51.50
57.60
49.50
44.40
34.30
7.10
4.00
4.00
3.52
3.53
3.38
4.33
4.42
4.42
0.81
0.89
1.04
58.60
20.20
35.40
70.70
3.00
9.10
3.38
3.89
4.58
4.42
1.20
0.53
43.87
44.01
4.31
3.45
4.48
1.03
- 60 -
- 61 -
nn vic cung cp chng t cho khch hng thng b chm tr. Con
s ca kt qu kho st phn nh ng thc t c vn ny.
Ha n thanh ton: chm tr trong vic fax ha n nhp, cung cp
ha n gc cho khch hng do 02 nguyn nhn chnh: do cc b
phn bn hng v chng t cung cp chng t thanh ton chm cho
b phn k ton v do qu ti b phn k ton ch c 03 nhn vin
nhng cng vic qu nhiu.
4.5.2.2 V yu t gii quyt tha ng cc vn pht sinh/ khiu ni ca
khch hng (Yu t 10)
Bng 4.5 cho thy: 1.00% khch hng nh gi rt cao, 47.50% khch
hng nh gi cao, 41.40% nh gi trung bnh v 10.10% nh gi
thp yu t ny.
Mc hi lng ca khch hng 3.39. Trung bnh chnh lch gia
im s tm quan trng v im s hi lng ca khch hng 1.13 cho
thy Vinalink p ng c rt t so vi mong mun ca khch hng,
khch hng cha hi lng vi yu t ny.
Cng vic giao nhn hng khng khng trnh khi cc vn pht
sinh/ khiu ni ca khch hng. Khi vn pht sinh, mong mun ca khch
hng l cng ty s cng n lc hp tc gii quyt nhng kh khn. Vic
gii quyt nhng vn pht sinh/ khiu ni cha lm khch hng hi lng do
02 nhm nguyn nhn chnh sau y:
Khng c c s gii quyt tha ng t cc nh cung cp dch v
cho Vinalink: cc hng hng khng khng c ngi chuyn ph trch
cho gii quyt khiu ni, cng vic hng ngy li rt bn rn chnh v vy
cc vn pht sinh nh hng n tr, tht lc chng t gi km theo
hng, hng b v, h hng, tht lcthng h khng ch ng thng
bo v cng khng ch ng gii quyt khiu ni. Vic n b t cc
- 62 -
hng hng khng nu c khng c gii quyt ngay cho khch hng m
ch c cn tr sau ny vo cc l hng c gi cao hn gi sn bn ra
ca cc hng hng khng v vic cn tr vo tng l hng cng khng
c cc hng hng khng ch ng thc hin m phi ch Vinalink c
th yu cu th mi xem xt thc hin.
Nguyn nhn t pha nhn vin ca Vinalink: do nhn vin cha nhn
bit c tm quan trng ca vic x l khiu ni ca khch hng. Vic
gii quyt khiu ni i hi nhiu thi gian trong khi cng vic hng ngy
bn rn v nhn vin khng c thi gian tp trung gii quyt cc vn
pht sinh cho khch hng. Nhn vin ngi thng bo cc vn pht sinh
ln cp trn n khi lnh o phng v cng ty bit th qu tr v pht
sinh nhiu chi ph lin quan.
4.5.2.3 V yu t thng bo vn pht sinh (Yu t 11)
Bng 4.5 cho thy: 7.10% khch hng nh gi rt cao, 49.50% khch
hng nh gi cao, 31.30% nh gi trung bnh v 12.10% nh gi
thp yu t ny.
Mc hi lng ca khch hng 3.52. Trung bnh chnh lch gia
im s tm quan trng v im s hi lng ca khch hng 0.81 cho
thy Vinalink ch p ng c phn no mong mun ca khch hng
i vi yu t ny.
Nhng vn c th pht sinh hng ngy nh hng n tr, tht lc
chng t, chng t c sai st, hng b v, mt mtthc t t c nhn
vin theo di v ch ng bo vi khch hng. Vic theo di lch bay ca l
hng l rt cn thit can thip kp thi vi hng hng khng khi hng b rt
chuyn bay hay tht lcnhng thc t s l hng rt nhiu v cha c nhn
vin chuyn thc hin vic ny dn n tnh trng c nhng l hng b rt
chuyn rt lu cha bt c chuyn ni hay tht lc nhng n khi khch
- 63 -
- 64 -
- 65 -
- 66 -
Mc hi lng
th
t
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
Yu t
TB
TB
TB
im
tm
chnh
(1)
quan
lch
trng(2)
(3)
=(1)-(2)
16
17
18
Lch s, nh nhn
Tn tm vi cc
yu cu
Gip khch
hng
tn tm
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.00
1.00
10.10
66.70
58.60
32.30
30.30
4.31
4.18
4.33
4.33
0.02
0.15
0.00
0.00
7.10
57.60
35.40
4.28
4.25
-0.03
0.00
0.33
6.07
60.97
32.67
4.26
4.30
0.05
- 67 -
Mc hi lng
th
t
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
Yu t
TB
TB
TB
im
tm
chnh
(1)
quan
lch
trng(2)
(3)
=(1)-(2)
19
20
21
C s vt cht
Cng ngh
Thng hiu
hu hnh
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
5.10
0.00
4.00
50.50
36.40
49.50
42.40
53.50
46.50
2.00
10.10
4.42
3.41
3.74
4.52
4.33
4.48
0.10
0.92
0.74
0.00
1.70
30.30
48.47
19.53
3.86
4.44
0.59
- 68 -
- 69 -
- 70 -
trn th trng tuy nhin vn khng nhiu khch hng bit n 02 s kin ny.
Thc t, thng hiu Vinalink c bit n nhiu trong ngnh giao nhn
nhng vn cha c ph bin rng ri i vi nhng khch hng ngoi
ngnh do thiu s qung b thng hiu trn cc phng tin truyn thng.
4.6 nh hng ca cc bin nh tnh n cc yu t nm trong vng II
v vng III Khu vc cn ci tin ca Ma trn nh gi mc tha
mn v tm quan trng (Hnh 4.4)
4.6.1 nh hng ca bin nh tnh Loi hnh cng ty n cc yu t cn
ci tin ca Ma trn nh gi mc tha mn v tm quan trng (Hnh
4.4)
T kt qu kim nh Independent-samples T-test Ph lc 7 ta thy
c 5 yu t c s khc bit c ngha v mc hi lng gia 02 nhm
khch hng Cng ty sn xut v Cng ty thng mi.
Yu t 10 gii quyt vn / khiu ni, Yu t 14 Lu khng
xy ra sai st v Yu t 13 Chu o ma cao im c gi tr Sig trong kim
nh Levene nh hn 0.05. Kt qu kim nh t phn Equal Variances not
assumed c Sig nh hn 0.05 nn ta kt lun c s khc bit c ngha v
mc hi lng gia 02 nhm khch hng Cng ty sn xut v Cng ty
thng mi.
Yu t 9 - Cung cp chng t nhanh chng chnh xc v Yu t 3 Ph
dch v cnh tranh c gi tr Sig trong kim nh Levene ln hn 0.05. Kt
qu kim nh t phn Equal Variances assumed c Sig nh hn 0.05 nn ta
kt lun c s khc bit c ngha v mc hi lng gia 02 nhm khch
hng Cng ty sn xut v Cng ty thng mi.
Kt qu cho thy cc Cng ty sn xut c yu cu cao hn v tnh
chuyn nghip ca Vinalink so vi cc Cng ty thng mi. Cc Cng ty sn
- 71 -
- 72 -
- 73 -
- 74 -
- C nhn vin chuyn chu trch nhim ly mawb t cc hng hng khng
trnh tnh trng chm tr, nhn vin hin trng bn lm hng khng c thi
gian i ly mawb.
- Quy nh nhn vin hin trng c trch nhim fax v gi t khai gc cho
khch hng ngay sau khi lm hng v thc xut t khai nhm khc phc
tnh trng khch hng yu cu nhn vin chng t nhng nhn vin hin
trng khng cung cp t khai kp thi do ang bn ngoi hoc i nhc
nh nhiu ln mi cung cp.
- B phn bn hng v chng t thc hin cung cp chng t thanh ton cho
b phn k ton ngay 01 ngy sau khi hng bay m bo vic cung cp ha
n cho khch hng c nhanh chng trnh tnh trng khch hng yu cu
nhng b phn k ton khng h hay bit v l hng.
* Theo phn tch mc 4.6.1, nhm khch hng cng ty sn xut c yu cu
cao hn v nhanh chng chnh xc ca cc chng t cung cp, v vy cn
u tin lm hi lng hn nhm khch hng ny.
* Theo phn tch mc 4.6.3, cc gii php cn c u tin hn cho nhm
khch hng i hng mc t thng xuyn mi thng v lu hn na.
5.1.2 V mc tiu khng sai st (Yu t 14)
t c mc tiu khng sai st, cn ph bin v nghim tc thc
hin cc quy nh ca ISO nh sau:
- 100% qu trnh nghip v ca cc b phn phi c kim sot bi lnh o
cng ty, lnh o phng, trng b phn v cc nhn vin nghip v.
- 100% chng t giao nhn vn chuyn phi c nhn vin nghip v cc b
phn lin quan k xc nhn kim tra
- Hn ch cc sai st c pht sinh chi ph mc khng qu 03 v/ nm/
phng
- Mt li nghip v khng c lp li qu 02 ln mt nhn vin.
- 75 -
- 100% nhn vin cc phng ban phi am tng nghip v, thu hiu chnh
sch cht lng, mc tiu cht lng c ban hnh v c th ha nhng
iu hiu bit qua hot ng nghip v.
- Nhn vin bn hng cn c hng dn c th i vi cc b phn khc
cc yu cu ca khch hng c p ng y v chnh xc.
* Theo phn tch mc 4.6.1, nhm khch hng cng ty sn xut c yu cu
cao hn v yu t ny v vy cn u tin lm hi lng hn nhm khch hng
ny.
* Theo phn tch mc 4.6.3, cc gii php cn c u tin hn cho nhm
khch hng i hng mc t thng xuyn mi thng v lu hn na.
5.1.3 Dch v c thc hin ng nh tha thun/ gii thiu (Yu t
7) v Gii quyt vn / khiu ni (Yu t 10)
- Lnh o phng v ban QA (ban m bo cht lng) kim sot thc
hin nghim tc quy nh ca ISO t c mc tiu cht lng: hn ch
cc phn nn ca khch hng mc khng qu 8 ln/ nm/ phng.
- X l tc thi khi c s khng ph hp xy ra: Khi c s khng ph hp
xy ra, Trng phng ban, cc b phn v nhn vin c lin quan phi thc
hin ngay vic x l c th cc s khng ph hp ny. C th nh sau:
Nu chng t khng ph hp th phi:
Chnh sa hoc lp li chng t mi sau khi kim tra xc nhn s
ph hp
Nu chng t lp sai c gi i th phi lin h vi i l giao
hng chnh sa.
Nu s khng ph hp xut pht t li nghip v ca cc nhn vin th
phi x l k thut ngay s khng ph hp v bo co cho trng
phng ban
- 76 -
- 77 -
- 78 -
- 79 -
- 80 -
- 81 -
- 82 -
- 83 -
- 84 -
Ting Anh
12. Air Cargo World (2003) What Do Shippers Think? - Industry Trends
and Issues in Intercontinental Air Freight,.
http://www.aircargoworld.com/features/1003_2.htm
13. Dr. Arash Shahin, SERVQUAL and Model of Service Quality Gaps: A
Framework for Determining and Prioritizing Critical Factors in
Delivering Quality Services, Department of Management, University of
Isfahan, Iran
14. ASI Quality Systems (1992), Quality function deployment Practitioner
workshop, American Supplier Institute Inc., USA.
15. Curry, A. (1999), "Innovation in public service management", Managing
Service Quality, Vol.9, No.3, pp. 180-190.
16. Gabbie, O. and O'Neill, M.A. (1996), SERVQUAL and the northern
Ireland hotel sector: A comparative analysis Part 1, Managing Service
Quality, Vol.6, No.6, pp. 25-32.
17. Hair & ctg (1998, 111), Multivariate Data Analysis, Prentice-Hall
International, Inc.
18. IATA (2000), International Cargo Agents, Aviation Training and
Development Institute.
19. Luk, Sh.T.K. and Layton, R. (2002), "Perception Gaps in customer
expectations: Managers versus service providers and customers, The
service Industries Journal, Vol.22. No. 2, April, pp. 109-128.
20. Parasuraman, A., Zeithaml, V.A. and Berry, L.L. (1985), "A conceptual
model of service quality and its implication", Journal of Marketing, Vol.
49, Fall, pp. 41-50.
21. Parasuraman, A., Zeithaml, V.A. and Berry, L.L. (1986), "SERVQUAL:
a multiple-item scale for measuring customer perceptions of service
-1-
-2-
Gi cc (Rates)
1. Mc gi ca cng ty a ra ph hp vi cht lng dch v
2. Gi cc ca cng ty cnh tranh so vi cc cng ty khc
3. Gi cc ca cng ty a ra ph hp vi mong i
4. Cng ty c hp ng gi vi nhiu hng hng khng
5. Cng ty c kh nng thng lng vi cc hng hng khng c gi tt
6. Cng ty c chnh sch gi tt cho khch hng
Thi gian vn chuyn (Transit time)
1. Thi gian hng n ng theo lch trnh
2. Mc chm tr ca hng nu c khng gy nhiu kh khn cho khch
hng
Dch v khch hng (Customer service)
1. Nhn vin lun phc v nhanh chng, ng hn
2. Nhn vin lun sn sng gip khch hng
3. Nhn vin lun phc v chu o ngay c trong ma cao im
4. Nhn vin lun t ra lch s, nh nhn
5. Nhn vin tr li tha ng cc cu hi/ yu cu ca khch hng
6. Nhn vin cung cp chng t nhanh chng, chnh xc
7. Nhn vin c nng lc chuyn mn tt
8. Thi ca nhn vin hp tc v tn tm trc nhng yu cu ca khch
hng
Mng li vn phng v i l (Network coverage)
1. Cng ty c mng li vn phng v i l rng khp p ng nhu cu vn
chuyn hng ha
2. Cng ty c mi quan h tt v tin cy vi h thng i l
3. H thng i l cung cp cht lng dch v tt
4. H thng i l cung cp gi tt
-3-
PH LC 3: BNG CU HI IU TRA
Xin cho anh/ ch.
Nhm mc ch nng cao s hi lng ca khch hng v dch v giao
nhn hng khng ti cng ty C Phn Giao Nhn Vn Ti v Thng Mi
VINALINK, chng ti ang tin hnh kho st mc hi lng ca khch
hng tm hiu nhng mong mun ca khch hng v nhng im mnh,
im yu trong hot ng ca cng ty.
Xin anh/ ch vui lng dnh t thi gian tr li gip chng ti mt s cu
hi sau bng cch khoanh trn s im m anh/ ch nh gi. Khng c cu
tr li no l ng hay sai. Tt c cu tr li ca cc anh/ ch u c gi tr i
vi nghin cu ca chng ti.
Hng dn tr li:
Mc quan trng ca yu t
nh gi v dch v ca VINALINK
Khng ng
C th ng
Quan trng
ng
Rt quan trng
Hon ton ng
Mc quan
Yu t
nh gi v
trng ca yu
dch v ca
VINALINK
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
ca khch hng
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
2- 101- 500kgs:
3- > 500kgs:
4- Tt c
3- C hai
-1-
TN BIN
NI DUNG
BIN
c1
khach hang
no th cng ty s lm nh vy
thoa thuan
c3
c4
khieu nai
ni
c2
c5
c7
c8
c9
tranh
cng ty khc
c10
hn
c11
Giup do khach hang Nhn vin lun sn sng gip khch hng
c12
diem
ma cao im
c13
c14
cu ca khch hng
-2-
c15
c16
c17
c18
c19
Quan he dai ly
c20
c21
Cong nghe
c22
Co so vat chat
C s vt cht ca cng ty
c23
c24
Vi tri
c25
Phong oc
c26
Thuong hieu
-1-
PH LC 5
KT QU PHN TCH NHN T KHM PH (EFA)
Factor Analysis
KMO and Bartlett's Test
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling
Adequacy.
Bartlett's Test of
Sphericity
Approx. Chi-Square
df
Sig.
.892
1492.878
300
.000
Component
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Total
11.171
1.749
1.418
1.188
.986
.833
.795
.776
.679
.598
.583
.541
.483
.401
.380
.369
.359
.332
.293
.250
.221
.186
.171
.125
.113
Initial Eigenvalues
% of Variance Cumulative %
44.682
44.682
6.995
51.677
5.673
57.351
4.751
62.101
3.943
66.045
3.331
69.376
3.180
72.556
3.102
75.658
2.718
78.376
2.394
80.770
2.333
83.103
2.163
85.266
1.933
87.199
1.605
88.803
1.519
90.323
1.477
91.800
1.438
93.237
1.328
94.565
1.170
95.736
1.001
96.737
.885
97.622
.744
98.366
.683
99.048
.500
99.548
.452
100.000
-2-
Component Matrixa
1
San pham da dang
Phi dich vu canh tranh
Chat luong dai ly
Dich vu dung nhu thoa
thuan
Phan hoi doi voi khach
hang
Thuong hieu
Khong sai sot
Phong oc
Cuoc canh tranh
Chu dao mua cao diem
Quan he dai ly
Cung cap chung tu
Hang den dung lich
Giup do khach hang
Tra loi thoa dang cac
yeu cau
Phuc vu dung han
Thong bao van de
Chuyen mon tot
Tan tam voi cac yeu cau
Mang luoi dai ly
Giai quyet van de/ khieu
nai
Thoi gian lam viec
Cong nghe
Co so vat chat
Lich su, nha nhan
Component
3
.780
.777
.772
.769
.719
.713
.712
.711
.700
.686
.681
.679
.677
.674
.673
.657
.646
.639
.632
.594
.580
.556
.534
.515
.527
.623
.561
-3-
1
Cuoc canh tranh
Quan he dai ly
Phi dich vu canh tranh
San pham da dang
Mang luoi dai ly
Dich vu dung nhu thoa
thuan
Chat luong dai ly
Chuyen mon tot
Hang den dung lich
Phan hoi doi voi khach
hang
Thoi gian lam viec
Cung cap chung tu
Giai quyet van de/ khieu
nai
Thong bao van de
Tra loi thoa dang cac
yeu cau
Chu dao mua cao diem
Khong sai sot
Phuc vu dung han
Co so vat chat
Cong nghe
Thuong hieu
Phong oc
Lich su, nha nhan
Tan tam voi cac yeu cau
Giup do khach hang
2
.743
.742
.675
.654
.650
Component
3
.522
.591
.588
.544
.775
.662
.658
.638
.508
.633
.571
.566
.834
.792
.591
.793
.731
.624
-1-
PH LC 6
KT QU PHN TCH HI QUY BI
Regression
Variables Entered/Removedb
Model
1
Variables
Entered
Do tan
tam, Do
huu hinh,
Do chuyen
nghiep, Do
a
dap ung
Variables
Removed
Method
Enter
Model Summaryb
Model
1
Adjusted
R Square
.555
R
R Square
.757a
.573
Std. Error of
the Estimate
.49553
Regression
Residual
Total
Sum of
Squares
30.938
23.082
54.020
df
4
94
98
Mean Square
7.735
.246
F
31.498
Sig.
.000a
a. Predictors: (Constant), Do tan tam, Do huu hinh, Do chuyen nghiep, Do dap ung
b. Dependent Variable: HAI LONG KHACH HANG
Coefficientsa
Model
1
(Constant)
Do dap ung
Do chuyen nghiep
Do huu hinh
Do tan tam
Unstandardized
Coefficients
B
Std. Error
3.859
.050
.339
.050
.306
.050
.222
.050
.241
.050
Standardized
Coefficients
Beta
.457
.412
.298
.324
t
77.477
6.781
6.107
4.426
4.809
Sig.
.000
.000
.000
.000
.000
-2-
Residuals Statisticsa
Predicted Value
Residual
Std. Predicted Value
Std. Residual
Minimum
2.6568
-1.2517
-2.139
-2.526
Maximum
5.1605
.9434
2.317
1.904
Mean
3.8586
.0000
.000
.000
Std. Deviation
.56187
.48532
1.000
.979
Charts
Histogram
Dependent Variable: HAI LONG KHACH HANG
12
10
8
6
Mean = 0.00
N = 99.00
00
2. 5
7
1. 0
5
1. 5
2
1. 0
0
1.
5
.7
0
.5
5
.2 0
0
0.
5
-.2
0
-.5
5
-.7 0
.0
-1 5
.2
-1 0
.5
-1 5
.7
-1 0
.0
-2 5
.2
-2 0
.5
-2
.75
Frequency
.50
.25
0.00
0.00
.25
.50
.75
1.00
N
99
99
99
99
-1-
PH LC 7
KT QU KIM NH INDEPENDENT-SAMPLES T-TEST
T-Test
Group Statistics
24
Mean
3.63
Std. Deviation
.647
Std. Error
Mean
.132
75
3.63
.767
.089
24
3.13
.537
.110
75
3.48
.704
.081
24
3.13
.537
.110
75
3.47
.600
.069
24
3.33
.868
.177
75
3.57
.774
.089
24
3.42
.504
.103
75
3.56
.598
.069
24
3.21
.415
.085
75
3.44
.683
.079
24
2.75
.608
.124
75
3.15
.800
.092
24
3.46
.588
.120
75
3.56
.551
.064
24
3.42
.584
.119
75
3.41
.639
.074
24
2.83
.702
.143
75
3.20
.735
.085
24
3.58
.504
.103
75
3.79
.664
.077
Dich vu dung
nhu thoa thuan
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
1.500
Sig.
.224
Sig.
(2-tailed)
df
Mean
Difference
Std. Error
Difference
95%
Confidence
Interval of the
Difference
Lower
Upper
-.010
97
.992
.00
.174
-.346
.343
-.010
45.493
.992
.00
.159
-.322
.318
-2-
Cung cap
chung tu
Cong nghe
Phi dich vu
canh tranh
Thuong hieu
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
Equal
variances
assumed
Equal
variances not
assumed
10.65
1
8.060
.450
2.078
14.44
5
1.984
.083
.314
.021
.594
.002
.006
.504
.153
.000
.162
.774
.576
.886
.443
-2.264
97
.026
-.36
.157
-.666
-.044
-2.602
50.571
.012
-.36
.136
-.629
-.081
-2.487
97
.015
-.34
.137
-.614
-.069
-2.635
42.962
.012
-.34
.130
-.603
-.080
-1.283
97
.202
-.24
.187
-.611
.131
-1.209
35.481
.235
-.24
.198
-.643
.163
-1.059
97
.292
-.14
.135
-.412
.125
-1.157
45.570
.253
-.14
.124
-.393
.106
-1.569
97
.120
-.23
.148
-.525
.061
-2.003
64.961
.049
-.23
.116
-.463
-.001
-2.228
97
.028
-.40
.178
-.750
-.043
-2.564
50.730
.013
-.40
.155
-.707
-.086
-.774
97
.441
-.10
.131
-.362
.159
-.748
36.835
.459
-.10
.136
-.377
.174
.023
97
.982
.00
.147
-.288
.295
.024
42.088
.981
.00
.140
-.279
.286
-2.149
97
.034
-.37
.171
-.705
-.028
-2.202
40.433
.033
-.37
.167
-.703
-.030
-1.378
97
.171
-.20
.148
-.496
.090
-1.586
50.785
.119
-.20
.128
-.461
.054
-1-
PH LC 8a
KT QU KIM NH ONE WAY ANOVA
Oneway
Descriptives
<=100kgs
101-500kgs
>500kgs
Maximum
3.38
.744
.263
2.75
4.00
31
3.81
.703
.126
3.55
4.06
.000
.000
4.00
4.00
3.54
.762
.102
3.33
3.74
Total
99
3.63
.737
.074
3.48
3.77
2.88
.991
.350
2.05
3.70
31
3.32
.653
.117
3.08
3.56
3.50
.577
.289
2.58
4.42
56
3.50
.632
.085
3.33
3.67
Total
99
3.39
.682
.069
3.26
3.53
<=100kgs
<=100kgs
3.00
.756
.267
2.37
3.63
31
3.48
.677
.122
3.24
3.73
3.50
.577
.289
2.58
4.42
56
3.61
.867
.116
3.37
3.84
Total
99
3.52
.800
.080
3.36
3.67
<=100kgs
2.88
.641
.227
2.34
3.41
31
3.35
.608
.109
3.13
3.58
3.25
.500
.250
2.45
4.05
56
3.48
.572
.076
3.33
3.64
Total
99
3.38
.601
.060
3.26
3.50
2.38
.744
.263
1.75
3.00
31
3.19
.654
.117
2.95
3.43
3.00
.000
.000
3.00
3.00
56
3.18
.765
.102
2.97
3.38
Total
99
3.11
.741
.074
2.96
3.26
3.25
.707
.250
2.66
3.84
31
3.48
.508
.091
3.30
3.67
101-500kgs
>500kgs
<=100kgs
101-500kgs
>500kgs
<=100kgs
101-500kgs
>500kgs
Minimum
4.00
>500kgs
95% Confidence
Interval for Mean
Lower
Upper
Bound
Bound
101-500kgs
Std. Error
56
>500kgs
Std.
Deviation
101-500kgs
Mean
4.00
.000
.000
4.00
4.00
56
3.55
.601
.080
3.39
3.71
Total
99
3.53
.578
.058
3.41
3.64
3.38
.916
.324
2.61
4.14
31
3.26
.575
.103
3.05
3.47
3.00
.000
.000
3.00
3.00
56
3.48
.632
.084
3.31
3.65
Total
99
3.38
.634
.064
3.26
3.51
<=100kgs
101-500kgs
>500kgs
-2-
<=100kgs
2.63
1.061
.375
1.74
3.51
31
2.97
.752
.135
2.69
3.24
3.00
.000
.000
3.00
3.00
56
3.16
.757
.101
2.96
3.36
Total
99
3.05
.774
.078
2.90
3.20
101-500kgs
>500kgs
<=100kgs
101-500kgs
>500kgs
Thuong hieu
3.38
.744
.263
2.75
4.00
3.48
.508
.091
3.30
3.67
3.75
.500
.250
2.95
4.55
56
3.57
.568
.076
3.42
3.72
Total
99
3.54
.559
.056
3.42
3.65
3.38
.744
.263
2.75
4.00
31
3.77
.497
.089
3.59
3.96
3.75
.500
.250
2.95
4.55
56
3.77
.687
.092
3.58
3.95
Total
99
3.74
.632
.064
3.61
3.86
<=100kgs
101-500kgs
>500kgs
Cong nghe
8
31
<=100kgs
3.50
.756
.267
2.87
4.13
31
3.35
.551
.099
3.15
3.56
3.50
.577
.289
2.58
4.42
56
3.43
.657
.088
3.25
3.60
Total
99
3.41
.623
.063
3.29
3.54
101-500kgs
>500kgs
-3-
ANOVA
Sum of
Squares
Dich vu dung nhu thoa
thuan
Thuong hieu
Cong nghe
Between Groups
df
Mean Square
2.529
.843
Within Groups
50.642
95
.533
Total
53.172
98
2.987
.996
Within Groups
42.649
95
.449
Total
45.636
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
2.628
.876
Within Groups
60.099
95
.633
Total
62.727
98
Between Groups
2.710
.903
Within Groups
32.704
95
.344
Total
35.414
98
Between Groups
4.850
1.617
Within Groups
48.928
95
.515
Total
53.778
98
Between Groups
1.606
.535
Within Groups
31.081
95
.327
Total
32.687
98
Between Groups
1.622
.541
Within Groups
37.793
95
.398
Total
39.414
98
Between Groups
2.351
.784
Within Groups
56.396
95
.594
Total
58.747
98
.545
.182
Within Groups
30.081
95
.317
Total
30.626
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
1.145
.382
Within Groups
38.026
95
.400
Total
39.172
98
Between Groups
.209
.070
Within Groups
37.811
95
.398
Total
38.020
98
Sig.
1.582
.199
2.218
.091
1.385
.252
2.624
.055
3.139
.029
1.636
.186
1.359
.260
1.320
.272
.574
.634
.954
.418
.175
.913
-1-
PH LC 8b
KT QU KIM NH ONE WAY ANOVA
Oneway
Descriptives
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
Dich vu dung
nhu thoa
thuan
Giai quyet
van de/ khieu
nai
Thong bao
van de
Khong sai
sot
Phi dich vu
canh tranh
Chu dao
mua cao
diem
Minim
um
Maxi
mum
Upper Bound
Hang ngay
1
4.00
Moi tuan
35
4.09
.781
.132
3.82
4.35
Moi thang
36
3.58
.554
.092
3.40
3.77
27
3.07
.474
.091
2.89
3.26
Total
99
3.63
.737
.074
3.48
3.77
4.00
Moi tuan
35
3.80
.473
.080
3.64
3.96
Moi thang
36
3.36
.543
.090
3.18
3.54
27
2.89
.751
.145
2.59
3.19
Total
99
3.39
.682
.069
3.26
3.53
4.00
Moi tuan
35
4.00
.642
.108
3.78
4.22
Moi thang
36
3.42
.649
.108
3.20
3.64
27
3.00
.832
.160
2.67
3.33
Total
99
3.52
.800
.080
3.36
3.67
4.00
Moi tuan
35
3.74
.611
.103
3.53
3.95
Moi thang
36
3.22
.540
.090
3.04
3.41
27
3.11
.424
.082
2.94
3.28
Total
99
3.38
.601
.060
3.26
3.50
4.00
Moi tuan
35
3.60
.695
.117
3.36
3.84
Moi thang
36
3.00
.632
.105
2.79
3.21
27
2.59
.501
.096
2.39
2.79
Total
99
3.11
.741
.074
2.96
3.26
4.00
Moi tuan
35
3.91
.562
.095
3.72
4.11
Moi thang
36
3.39
.494
.082
3.22
3.56
27
3.19
.396
.076
3.03
3.34
Total
99
3.53
.578
.058
3.41
3.64
4.00
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
-2-
Cung cap
chung tu
Chat luong
dai ly
Thuong hieu
Cong nghe
Moi tuan
35
3.74
.657
.111
3.52
3.97
Moi thang
36
3.31
.467
.078
3.15
3.46
27
3.00
.555
.107
2.78
3.22
Total
99
3.38
.634
.064
3.26
3.51
3.00
Moi tuan
35
3.60
.695
.117
3.36
3.84
Moi thang
36
2.86
.593
.099
2.66
3.06
27
2.59
.694
.134
2.32
2.87
Total
99
3.05
.774
.078
2.90
3.20
4.00
Moi tuan
35
3.83
.568
.096
3.63
4.02
Moi thang
36
3.56
.504
.084
3.39
3.73
27
3.11
.320
.062
2.98
3.24
Total
99
3.54
.559
.056
3.42
3.65
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
Hang ngay
4.00
Moi tuan
35
4.06
.591
.100
3.85
4.26
Moi thang
36
3.72
.615
.102
3.51
3.93
27
3.33
.480
.092
3.14
3.52
Total
99
3.74
.632
.064
3.61
3.86
Hang ngay
3.00
Moi tuan
35
3.66
.591
.100
3.45
3.86
Moi thang
36
3.47
.609
.101
3.27
3.68
27
3.04
.518
.100
2.83
3.24
Total
99
3.41
.623
.063
3.29
3.54
-3-
ANOVA
Sum of
Squares
Dich vu dung nhu
thoa thuan
Thuong hieu
Cong nghe
Between Groups
df
Mean Square
15.827
5.276
Within Groups
37.345
95
.393
Total
53.172
98
13.064
4.355
Within Groups
32.572
95
.343
Total
45.636
98
Between Groups
15.977
5.326
Within Groups
46.750
95
.492
Total
62.727
98
7.840
2.613
Within Groups
27.575
95
.290
Total
35.414
98
16.859
5.620
Within Groups
36.919
95
.389
Total
53.778
98
9.314
3.105
Within Groups
23.372
95
.246
Total
32.687
98
9.090
3.030
Within Groups
30.325
95
.319
Total
39.414
98
Between Groups
17.523
5.841
Within Groups
41.224
95
.434
Total
58.747
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
8.099
2.700
Within Groups
22.527
95
.237
Total
30.626
98
8.064
2.688
Within Groups
31.108
95
.327
Total
39.172
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
6.199
2.066
Within Groups
31.821
95
.335
Total
38.020
98
Sig.
13.421
.000
12.701
.000
10.822
.000
9.003
.000
14.461
.000
12.620
.000
9.492
.000
13.461
.000
11.385
.000
8.209
.000
6.169
.001
-1-
PH LC 8c
KT QU KIM NH ONE WAY ANOVA
Oneway
Descriptives
Dich vu dung
nhu thoa thuan
Phi dich vu
canh tranh
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
95% Confidence
Interval for Mean
Lower
Upper
Bound
Bound
Minimum
Maximum
25
3.44
.712
.142
3.15
3.73
17
3.76
.752
.182
3.38
4.15
Ca hai
57
3.67
.740
.098
3.47
3.86
Total
99
3.63
.737
.074
3.48
3.77
25
3.20
.816
.163
2.86
3.54
17
3.24
.664
.161
2.89
3.58
Ca hai
57
3.53
.601
.080
3.37
3.69
Total
99
3.39
.682
.069
3.26
3.53
25
3.36
.860
.172
3.00
3.72
17
3.53
.800
.194
3.12
3.94
Ca hai
57
3.58
.778
.103
3.37
3.79
Total
99
3.52
.800
.080
3.36
3.67
25
3.28
.542
.108
3.06
3.50
17
3.29
.686
.166
2.94
3.65
Ca hai
57
3.46
.600
.079
3.30
3.62
Total
99
3.38
.601
.060
3.26
3.50
25
2.84
.688
.138
2.56
3.12
17
3.06
.659
.160
2.72
3.40
Ca hai
57
3.25
.763
.101
3.04
3.45
Total
99
3.11
.741
.074
2.96
3.26
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
25
3.40
.500
.100
3.19
3.61
17
3.65
.493
.119
3.39
3.90
Ca hai
57
3.54
.629
.083
3.38
3.71
Total
99
3.53
.578
.058
3.41
3.64
25
3.24
.523
.105
3.02
3.46
17
3.24
.664
.161
2.89
3.58
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
-2-
Cung cap
chung tu
Thuong hieu
Cong nghe
Ca hai
57
3.49
.658
.087
3.32
3.67
Total
99
3.38
.634
.064
3.26
3.51
25
3.12
.726
.145
2.82
3.42
17
2.94
.748
.181
2.56
3.33
Ca hai
57
3.05
.811
.107
2.84
3.27
Total
99
3.05
.774
.078
2.90
3.20
25
3.44
.583
.117
3.20
3.68
17
3.65
.493
.119
3.39
3.90
Ca hai
57
3.54
.569
.075
3.39
3.69
Total
99
3.54
.559
.056
3.42
3.65
25
3.44
.583
.117
3.20
3.68
17
3.76
.562
.136
3.48
4.05
Ca hai
57
3.86
.639
.085
3.69
4.03
Total
99
3.74
.632
.064
3.61
3.86
25
3.20
.645
.129
2.93
3.47
17
3.53
.514
.125
3.26
3.79
Ca hai
57
3.47
.630
.083
3.31
3.64
Total
99
3.41
.623
.063
3.29
3.54
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
Chau A/ Chau
Uc
Chau Au/ Chau
My/ Chau Phi
-3-
ANOVA
Sum of
Squares
Dich vu dung nhu
thoa thuan
Thuong hieu
Cong nghe
Between Groups
df
Mean Square
1.286
.643
Within Groups
51.885
96
.540
Total
53.172
98
2.367
1.184
Within Groups
43.269
96
.451
Total
45.636
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
.837
.419
Within Groups
61.890
96
.645
Total
62.727
98
.704
.352
Within Groups
34.710
96
.362
Total
35.414
98
2.915
1.458
Within Groups
50.863
96
.530
Total
53.778
98
.664
.332
Within Groups
32.023
96
.334
Total
32.687
98
1.550
.775
Within Groups
37.864
96
.394
Total
39.414
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
Between Groups
.324
.162
Within Groups
58.423
96
.609
Total
58.747
98
Between Groups
.444
.222
Within Groups
30.183
96
.314
Total
30.626
98
3.076
1.538
Within Groups
36.096
96
.376
Total
39.172
98
Between Groups
Between Groups
1.574
.787
Within Groups
36.446
96
.380
Total
38.020
98
Sig.
1.190
.309
2.626
.078
.649
.525
.974
.381
2.751
.069
.996
.373
1.965
.146
.266
.767
.705
.496
4.090
.020
2.073
.131
-3-
- 85 -