You are on page 1of 14

Vroeg-Middeleeuwse ringwalburgen in Zeeland

(Early-Medieval circular fortresses in Zeeland)

Robert M. van Heeringen, Peter A. Henderikx & Alexandra Mars (red)


Authors: J. Buurman, R.M van Heeringen, P.A. Henderikx, I. Joosten, H. Kars,
H.W. van Klaveren, R.C.G.M. Lauwerier, B. Oele, A. Pol, F. Verhaeghe.
Goes/Amersfoort 1995. ISBN 90-72138-41-4

English summaries
pages 229-239

1. History of the study


- The natural landscape and the first human presence on the salt marshes
- Archaeological evidence of occupation along the coast
- Historical data on the period 810-839
- Historical data on the period 839-892
- The Zeeland fortresses: size and construction
- Dating of the construction of the fortresses
- The function of the fortresses
- Historical data on the tenth century
- Occupation within the fortresses
- The finds
- Historical data on the eleventh and twelfth centuries
- Developments from the thirteenth century to the present day

2. Summaries of the material studies


- Medieval Coins from the Beach at Domburg
- Plant Remains from a Sewer of the Fortress at Middelburg
- The Early Glazed Pottery found in Oost-Souburg
- Slag and Ironworking in Oost-Souburg
- he Stone Objects from Oost-Souburg
- Objects of Bone, Antler and Horn from Oost-Souburg
- Distribution and Function of Bone Three-pronged Objects
- Stock breeding in Oost-Souburg

1. General summary
This book is the culmination of the research History of the study
project launched in 1990 by the State Service for As shall be explained below, the province of
Archaeological Investigations (ROB) on the early Zeeland has at least five fortresses that were
medieval occupation history of Zeeland in constructed in the last quarter of the ninth century.
general, and more particular on the circular Their locations, where traces of some of them are
fortresses and their later occupation. still present below ground, are all typified by the
An attempt has been made to present all the toponym burg in the present place name:
archaeological and historical information Oostburg in Zeeuws-Vlaanderen, Oost-Souburg,
currently available, as well as the relationship Middelburg and Domburg on the island of
between them. The book also contains the final Walcheren and Burgh on the island of Schouwen-
elaboration of the results of the excavations at the Duiveland. A sixth fortress might be located near
fortress of Oost-Souburg, and a series of studies to the village of Kloetinge on the island of Zuid-
concerning the material culture that give us a Beveland .
better insight into how the early medieval society
in Zeeland functioned. In 1935 the historian J. Huizinga published a
The main results are reviewed briefly below. historical-topographical study which drew
attention to the fortresses on Walcheren and their necessary rescue excavations were carried out at
relationship with the earliest history of the island. Burgh, Domburg, Middelburg and Oostburg. One
He convincingly linked the circular site on the of the most remarkable results of the field work
border of the late medieval town centre of Oost- was the discovery of the fortress at Domburg, and
Souburg and of the double circle located within possibly a fortress at Kloetinge. Another aspect of
the street plan of Middelburg with the the project involved collating all the available
construction of fortresses in the Early Middle information on the occupation history.
Ages, which is mentioned in the historical sources
fort the Flanders and northern France region. Independently of the ROB project, the historian
Huizinga presented sound arguments for the P.A. Henderikx recently undertook a study of the
existence of a burg at Domburg, although its early medieval occupation history of Walcheren.
precise location could not be determined. He He has argued that the northern French, Flemish
called upon archaeologists to substantiate or and Zeeland fortresses did not actually form a
dispute his conclusions. The archaeologist W.C. chain along the coast, but in fact can be divided
Braat of the Archaeological Museum in Leiden into groups. They were concentrated in places
took up the challenge. With a series of trial where the seafaring Normans generally entered a
excavations carried out between 1939 and 1952 country: at points where large rivers flowed into
he demonstrated conclusively that there had been the sea. For instance, the fortress at Oostburg is
fortresses and moats at Oost-Souburg, situated on one of the two estuaries of the Zwin,
Middelburg and Burgh. The dating of the few and the other Zeeland fortresses are on the estuary
finds roughly concurred with the historical dating of the river Scheldt, which flowed towards the sea
to the ninth or tenth century. along what is now the Eastern Scheldt. This new
interpretation of the historical facts once more
In 1969 it became necessary to conduct an underlines the need for an indepen-dent
archaeological investigation into the western half archaeological dating of the construction of the
of the fortress at Oost-Souburg. The investigation Zeeland fortresses.
was carried out by the ROB and was led by the
then provincial archaeologist, J.A. Trimpe Burger. The natural landscape and the first human
The excavations continued until 1971 and presence on the salt marshes
produced a wealth of information, particularly With the exception of a narrow strip comprising
about the later settlement situated within the beach barriers and Older Dunes along the coast,
ramparts. the whole of Zeeland was flooded after the
Roman period. Geologists refer to this as the
In view of the historical significance of the Dunkirk II transgression phase. Early medieval
fortresses location, the first, preliminary occupation, in the sixth and seventh centuries, has
publication of the excavations in 1973 referred to been established only in the elongated dune
the study published in 1965 by H. van Werveke, landscape along the coast. As a result of erosion,
who had assumed that the Zeeland fortresses in many places this original landscape can be
formed part of the line of defences that extended reconstructed only on paper. In the course of the
from northern France to Zeeland. This theory was ninth century, and possibly as early as the end of
based largely on a historical reference to the eighth century, a number of areas of marine
fortifications erected prior to 891 (castella ibi sandy clay and clay had silted up to such a level
recens facta) near St. Omaars in the estuary of the that people were able to settle on them. Initially,
river Aa in northern France. visits to the 'new land' would have been only
temporary. But since the huge salt marsh area was
From 1990 to 1994, the ROB undertook a new naturally highly suitable for the raising of sheep,
project, led by provincial archaeologist R.M. van in particular, and the mineral subsoil was found to
Heeringen, focusing on the early medieval be very fertile for arable use, the human presence
occupation history of Zeeland. The fortresses there soon became a permanent feature. The
were one of the main subjects of study. The prospect of salt extraction would also have
project involved a problem-oriented archaeo- attracted newcomers. Unfortunately, we have no
logical investigation designed to increase our precise archaeological dating for this pioneering
knowledge of the fortress sites. To this end, phase on the salt marshes.
The oldest archaeological traces are layers of As we stated above, the island had a seditio, or
manure of unknown date, which have been military settlement, although no evidence of
observed under a number of small terps that can physical defences were found under the
be roughly dated to the tenth century although settlement remains on the beach. There is at any
their exact age is uncertain. The layers of manure rate no link with the fortress at Domburg. These
might indicate places where sheep were kept. defences lie around a kilometre to the south-west
No settlements are known from this period. One and are almost half a century younger.
may assume, by way of a working hypothesis, There must also have been a significant site on
that the activity observed does not pre-date the the island of Schouwen, since similar finds were
ninth century. However, there are references to found on the beach on the other side of the
salt marsh meadows and salt extraction in eighth Scheldt estuary. Identification with Scaltheim
century texts. It seems obvious to assume that the mentioned in the early medieval sources however
huge salt marsh area was especially exploited is nothing more than speculation.
from the occupa-tion centres along its edges, thus
from the Wa1cheren and Schouwen dune area, Historical data on the period 810-839
and from the Flemish sandy area.. From the end of the seventh century the Zeeland
coastal area formed part of the Frankish empire.
Archaeological evidence of occupation Little is known for certain about how the emperor
along the coast Charlemagne (768-814) and his successor Louis
There was an important settlement in the Older the Pious (814-840) ruled the province of
Dunes at Domburg from the sixth to the early Zeeland, situated as it was on the periphery of
ninth century. The remains of this settlement and their empire. In principle, the emperor delegated
the associated cemetery(ies) were visible for 600 some of his power to a count, who held sway over
m along the high tide line on the beach in 1866. a certain area of one or more pagi (countships).
Remains of wooden houses and numerous graves We know the name of one countship in the
with coffins were recorded by amateur Zeeland coastal area, the pagus Rodaninsis. This
archaeologist avant la lettre I.C. Frederiks from countship, which was situated in what is now
Oostkapelle. Unfortunately, no attention was paid Zeeuws-Vlaanderen, was named after the river
to the dating of any of these remains or their Rodana, for which Aardenburg (Rodenburg) was
interrelationship. Attention was subsequently also named.
focused mainly on washed up coins and other,
mainly metal, objects. Few of the other artefacts The countship occurs in historical sources
found, including fragments of pottery and stone between 707 and 840. We also know the name of
objects, were collected. Study of the coins, more a count, Eggihard, who was mentioned in 837 in
than a thousand in number, has shown that the relation to the island of Wa1cheren.
settlement existed from the sixth to the ninth
century. The settlement might be the Walichrum The king possessed a number of estates which
mentioned in the sources; the name literally were managed by bailiffs. The management of the
means 'wet sandy ridge'. The name Walcheren countship and the king's lands was probably in the
eventually came to be applied to the entire island. hands of one person, the count. The sources also
refer to homines franci, who played a role in the
As an emporium, the settlement was involved in military defence of strategically located areas.
long-distance trade between the Frisian area and The Vikings first attacked the Frankish empire in
England, among others, and its status can be 810. Charlemagne had watches set up along all
compared with that of Dorestad in the central the estuaries, including the Scheldt estuary, and
Netherlands river area. A renewed study of the built ships to stop the Vikings landing. In 811 he
youngest coins, Carolingian denarii, carried out even visited Ghent personally to inspect the
by the numismatist A. Pol of the Cabinet of Coins progress of the work.
and Medals in Leiden, has suggested that
Wa1cheren had become less important by the In 820 thirteen Viking ships appeared off the
mid-ninth century. Clearly, this may well have Flemish coast. The defence system appears to
been linked to the historically recorded Viking have worked, since the Vikings were forced into
attack on Wa1cheren in 837. retreat by men who had entrenched themselves in
a praesidium (a fortified guard post). One can authority in the region was not wholly effective.
deduce from a report in 834 that the custodia After the death of Lothair II, Lorraine was
maritima, the coast guard, was still intact in the divided by the Treaty of Meersen in 870.
Flemish coastal area after this campaign.
When the war for the succession of Louis the For a short time, the Zeeland coastal area then
Pious broke out, the attacks by the Normans also became part of West Francia under Charles the
became more frequent. From 834 to 839 the entire Bald. After his death in 877, Zeeland finally, and
coastal area was pillaged and many Frankish permanently, became part of East Francia (under
trading settlements were destroyed, including the Treaty of Ribemont in 880). It was ruled by
Dorestad in the central Netherlands river area, Charles III the Stout ( 882-887), Arnulf (887
Witla in the Maas estuary, and Antwerp and -895), Zwentibold (895-900), Louis the Child
Walcheren (Walichrum) on the Scheldt. (900-911) and Charles III the Simple (911-923).
Unfortunately, we are unable to deduce with After 925, 'Zeeland' Lorraine became part of the
certainty from the written reports whether the Holy Roman empire. Again, a lack of
settlement of Walcheren was made physically contemporary written evidence means that we
capable of defending itself prior to the attack in have no information regarding the actual power
837. There is mention of a seditio on Walcheren; relationships in the Zeeland coastal area.
in Medieval Latin, this word can refer either to
the presence of a military settlement, a garrison, During the periods 850-864, 879-885 and 891-
or to a reinforced garrison. The surviving text 892 the Scheldt area was repeatedly attacked by
does however indicate that there was some kind Vikings. At the beginning of the first period, most
of military settlement on the island of Walcheren. of these were lightning attacks made by ship.
Eggihard, the count of the area, Hemming, a Having entered the country via the Eastern
Danish leader fighting for the Franks and other Scheldt, the Vikings set St. Baaf's Abbey in Ghent
high-ranking individuals are mentioned. on fire in 851. In 859 and 860 they plundered the
area to the east of the river in Lorraine, and the
Historical data on the period 839-892 area upstream towards France. They attacked
After the death of Louis the Pious in 840, the Flanders from the sea in 850, 860, and 864. There
Frankish empire was divided into three parts by are few sources about the coastal defences. Any
the Treaty of Verdun in AD 843. The border reports that do exist refer to West Francia, the
between West Francia (the Kingdom of west Flemish countship. There must have been
franks) under Charles the Bald and the Middle fortifications in Bruges, and it is also known that
Kingdom under Lothair I was the river Scheldt, Charles the Bald charged Count Adalelmus, count
although in Flanders (which included the present of Laon, with the defence of the Flemish coast in
province of Zeeuws-Vlaanderen) the border 853, but it is not known how he carried out the
turned slightly towards the south. Present-day task.
Zeeland formed part of the Middle Kingdom, In July 879 the huge Norman army crossed to the
apart from the area around Aardenburg and continent after their defeat in England. They first
Oostburg, which belonged to West Francia. After sacked the Flemish coastal area and then sailed up
the division of the empire, regional rulers the Scheldt to plunder Brabant. They set up camp
increased their power, as evidenced, for instance, for the winter six times between November 879
by the creation of the county of Flanders under and October 885, in Ghent, Kortrijk, Asselt,
Baudouin I of Flanders (862-879). His successor, Conde, Amiens and Louvain. By this time they
Baudouin II (879-918), was the first truly had changed their battle tactics. Since most of the
powerful example of these new regional rulers, wealthy places near the river had already been
whose county included the Oostburg area. pillaged, they used horses to venture further
inland. Their forays mainly took them south and
Little is known about public authority in the east, where they fought many battles with the
Zeeland area governed by Lothair I. Since the local population. For instance, in November 880
time that Lotharius granted Walcheren as land in the Normans defeated from their camp at Kortrijk
fief to the Norseman Harald (841), most likely the Flemings and Zeelanders. The chronicler of
under pressure from adverse political conditions, this incident stated that the Normans were
it can be assumed that the imposition of central particularly vengeful towards the Zeelanders,
perhaps because of earlier skirmishes, although The inside and outside of the ramparts are made
this is not known for certain. In the period 890- of regular piles of clay sods. The centre usually
892 the Normans were mainly active on the comprises unstructured sandy clay or sand. There
Seine, Oise, Somme and the upper reaches of the may have been a palisade on top or just inside the
Scheldt in northern France. The Scheldt was ramparts. Only in Burg was such a palisade well
almost certainly used as an access route for the documented during an excavation. However, the
fleet, although no records have survived. Records radiocarbon dating does not exclude the
of one of their journeys overland, in April 891, possibility that the palisade was constructed later,
include a detailed description of the fortress of St. during the occupation of the fortress site.
Omaars. Besides describing the ramparts, the
author also mentions that on the way to Lorraine, The total width of the rampart base varies from 4
in the West Francia coastal area they marched past to 12 m. Various phases of the ramparts are often
the castella ibi recens facta. These 'recently visible, although it is not clear whether these
constructed fortifications' cannot possibly be one building phases should be interpreted as localised
of the Zeeland fortresses because, with the repairs or as a pars pro toto of an entirely new
exception of Oostburg, they were all in Lorraine. fortress. It was possible to calculate that there was
an interval of some 50 to 70 years between the
If we consider all the voyages made by the two phases at Domburg. The excavated fragments
Vikings between 879 and 892 of which records of the Domburg fortress contained at least one,
have survived, the fleet must have passed the and possibly even two, building sacrifices .
Scheldt estuary upstream and downstream, in
both directions, at least four times. Since during Archaeological evidence and later maps show that
that period the Vikings spent the entire year in the all the fortresses had a system of two paths that
Scheldt valley, it must have been a great effort for crossed at right angles in the centre. These paths
them to gather enough food and horses for their lead to the passages through the ramparts, each of
cavalry. It is very probable that the chronicles which lead to a narrow bridge over the moat.
make no mention of these forays, since no These bridges have been confirmed archaeo-
treasure would have been plundered or important logically by the discovery of the west and south
places attacked - the very things that interest passages in Oost-Souburg and by the north-
chroniclers. And this is where the islands of western passage in Middelburg. The structure of
Zeeland come in. It is quite likely that the the ramparts of the Zeeland fortresses concurs
Zeelanders did not appreciate the regular visits by largely with a description of the construction of
Vikings in search of provisions, and therefore similar defences built between 878 and 882
built the Zeeland fortresses. The Bayeux Tapestry around the Church of St. Omaars. These ramparts
(ut cibum raperentur) shows clearly how the consisted of fuste, gleba et cespite, or 'posts, earth
Vikings went about collecting food. and sods'. The earth and clay sods used for the
construction of the Zeeland fortresses came from
The Zeeland fortresses: size and outside the fortress sites themselves. The method
construction of construction was extremely efficient. The
Structures that have been interpreted as the ramparts were built and a wide, shallow moat
remains of early medieval fortresses have been containing water was created at the same time.
found at five locations in Zeeland. There is The archaeologically determined width of the
historical and geographical evidence to suggest moat varies from 30 to 50m.
that a sixth fortress may have existed. The
defences all have the same construction, with Dating of the construction of the
circular ramparts of varying diameters. In cross fortresses
section, the outer ramparts range, in ascending It is essential that the Zeeland fortresses will be
order of size, from 144 meters in Oost-Souburg, dated as accurately as possible, since as we have
200 m in Burgh, 220 m in Middelburg and seen, the dating based on the castella ibi recens
Oostburg and 265 m in Domburg. The possible facta text (Miracula Sancti Bertini) can no longer
fortress site near Kloetinge could contain a be regarded as applicable to the situation in
fortress with a diameter of some 200 m. Zeeland. Thanks to the favourable conditions in
the Zeeland coastal area, a great deal of organic
material, such as wood and animal bone, has been attack on Walcheren in 837 - when the known
preserved. fortresses had not yet been constructed - a few
vague reports have survived from the tenth
A dendrochronological dating of an oak plank century which refer to Walchenars who were
from a coffin in the rampart of the fortress of defeated, and their land despoiled. At this time,
Domburg has been obtained and the radioactive too, the area was apparently still important
carbon content of twenty samples of organic enough to the Vikings for them to continue
material from the ramparts and the later visiting. However, the tenth-century sources also
occupation of the different fortresses has been make no mention of defences.
determined. The results of the measurements must
be calibrated to establish the precise age of the Fortresses of this kind were not unknown outside
samples. In around AD 900 there was a deviation the province of Zeeland, in the Netherlands and
in natural radiocarbon levels in the atmosphere, neighbouring countries in the Early Middle Ages.
and in consequence there are several possible A revival in the construction of wood and earth
absolute datings for a number of results. defences in fact occurred throughout north-
Nevertheless it proved possible to draw further western Europe from the eighth century. The
conclusions from comparison between the datings defences were advanced for their time, and could
and with the archaeological context of the well withstand attacks from men on foot or
samples. This indicated that all the fortresses were horseback, armed with bows and arrows. The
almost certainly built in the same period, in the reasons for their construction differed from place
last quarter of the ninth century. In those cases to place. Of course, the primary need for
where there is information about the dating of the protection in times of unrest and strife played a
later occupation of the fortress sites, it appears role, but the construction of such defences might
that, with one exception, the occupation began in also have been connected with power politics
the early tenth century. The exception is the among local rulers.
fortress at Domburg, which was largely covered Real refuge places for civilians and fortresses that
with dune sand in the second half of that century. were constructed around a pre-existing settlement
The fortresses in Zeeland- Lorraine were or the king's or count's base both occur. Other
therefore probably built in the reign of Charles III defences can best be interpreted as strongholds,
the Stout or of King Arnulf of East Francia. We while buildings were added to others whose
do not know to what extent they were constructed strictly geometrical pattern could point to military
on the orders of the local power in the Zeeland use. The Danish fortresses are an example of this.
coastal area. The fortress at Oostburg, on the West
Frankish side, could have been built under the Historical data on the tenth century
'authority of Count Baudouin 11 (879-918) of In the course of the tenth century the fortress
Flanders. However, it would be more obvious to settlement of Middelburg developed into the
assume that the fortresses were built on the orders central settlement on the island of Walcheren
of the powers that be in the area, given the eventually becoming the regional centre for the
manpower needed for their construction. whole of Zeeland to the south-west of the Scheldt
(Zeeland Bewestenschelde). During this century
The function of the fortresses Zeeland Bewestenschelde was one parish, under
No occupation remains on the old ground level the church at Middelburg later known as
within the fortresses have been found. It is Westmonster. This church was probably
therefore assumed that they were built as established in the mid-tenth century. On
vluchtburgen (refuge places) to offer a safe haven Schouwen and the neighbouring island of
for the population and - more especially - Duiveland, too, there must have been one or two
livestock when danger loomed. We have assumed parishes.
that the population at the time of the construction
of the fortresses consisted of shepherds, at least in The abbeys owned a lot of land, the majority of
the salt marsh area around Oostburg, Oost- which was used for pasturing sheep. For instance,
Souburg and Middelburg. in 949 Count Arnulf I of Flanders presented some
It is uncertain whether the fortresses ever did of his land to St. Peter's Abbey in Ghent,
actually sustain a Norman attack. Apart from the including pasture for 120 sheep at Morena. This
place is near to, or was actually, the settlement occupation phase the houses were built on
immediately bordering the fortress at Oostburg. individual sandy clay platforms. These podia were
Emperor Otto 11 placed St. Baaf's Abbey in raised along a system of axes that crossed at right
possession of pasture for 900 sheep on Schouwen angles in the centre of the site. The systematic
in 976. The area must have relied for a large raisings automatically created ditches along the
proportion of its income on the production of system of paths which were covered with wooden
wool or worsted, known better in other written trackways. These 'ditches' carried rainwater
sources as pallia Fresconia, or Frisian worsted. In through a wooden drain or sewer via the passage
972 Otto 11 gave the provintia UUalacra, through the rampart to the moat. Remains of the
Walcheren, to his wife Theophanu as a gift drain were found in Oost-Souburg, and in
(morgengave). Forty years later, in 1012, King Middelburg the wooden sewer was found in situ
Henry 11 rewarded Count Baudouin IV of in the north-western passage. It is not possible to
Flanders with Walcheren. Zeeland to the east of determine which houses were in use at the same
the Scheldt (Zeeland Beoostenschelde) came time. However, it is highly likely that the
under the influence of the counts of Holland. In excavation reflects the building over the entire
985 King Otto III gave Dirk 11 everything he had occupation period, lasting around 75 to 100 years.
previously had in fief in the villa Sunnimeri. There would therefore have been some four to six
The time of the great Norman invasions was over buildings in use at the same time in the western
by the tenth century, although they probably half of the fortress site.
visited the Scheldt estuary several more times. Of
the fortresses, in the tenth century only Oostburg The buildings constructed on the podia are all
is mentioned in passing in 949 in connection with rectangular, but display little uniformity. Those
the above-mentioned gift from Arnulf I. with walls more than 1 m thick made out of clay
sods are undoubtedly among the oldest. No
Occupation within the fortresses doorways or inner walls were found, and there are
Occupation has been established in all the no divisions that might indicate the presence of
fortresses. In the cases where it was possible to stalls. Large, rectangular pits were found in many
see signs of occupation, it was preceded by a buildings, however. These might have been used
raising of the ground level using clean sandy clay. for storing sheep dung, and the rooms they are in
Apparently the sites were suitable for occupation may have been used as sheep stalls. Round
only once they had been raised to a minimum hearths made of clay sods were found in most of
height above the water table. The water table was the houses. Some of these hearths contained
of course associated with the average high tide, smithing slag and have therefore been interpreted
since the land was still undiked. Systematic dike as smithy furnaces.
building did not begin until the mid-twelfth
century. The reports of the huge storm surge of It can be shown, on the basis of the age at which
1014, which according to a Ghent analyst cost the pigs were slaughtered and the presence of bone
lives of many inhabitants of Zeeland, show that skates, that people lived in the settlement in the
even the artificial raisings were probably not autumn and winter at least. Given the fact that
always adequate. It is difficult to establish by spindle whorls were found - wool spinning being
archaeological means the amount of time that traditionally women's work - and that horse
elapsed between the construction of the fortresses breeding and the growing of arable crops such as
and the moment at which the raising and first barley, wheat and linseed have been established, it
occupation commenced. The dating of the pottery is likely that the fortress settlement was occupied
is too inaccurate for this purpose. However, one all year round.
can argue that the occupation would not have
begun any more than a generation later. With the The finds
exception of Domburg, the occupation ceased in No finds are known from the time of the
the last quarter of the tenth century. construction of the fortresses, with the exception
of wooden posts from the ramparts at Burgh and
The large-scale investigation at Oost-Souburg has Domburg, a vague posthole on top of the rampart
revealed details of the internal structure of the of the Middelburg fortress and two irregular
western half of this fortress settlement. In the first burials. The other find material can be linked with
the occupation of the inner sites, which almost A further study by F. Verhaege, a senior
immediately followed the construction of the researcher for the National Fund for Academic
fortress. Research in Belgium, has clearly shown that this
Most of the material naturally comes from the category of pottery opens up interesting prospects
large-scale investigation at OostSouburg. Since for the study of the origins of glazed pottery in
the find material from the other fortresses is north-west Europe. The white pottery with
virtually identical, only the OostSouburg material yellow-green glaze found at Oost-Souburg
is discussed here. In terms of numbers, the most probably originated in Hoei in the Belgian Meuse
important category of finds from Oost-Souburg is valley. The groups of reliefband, Hunneschans
the sherds of earthenware pots. Since very few and Badorf ware are the youngest representatives
tenth-century find assemblages have been of these categories of imported ceramics, which
discovered in the Netherlands, the pottery from are so characteristic of the Early Middle Ages.
Oost-Souburg is an important point of reference The Paffrath ware, which generally dates from
for the study of the development of form, later, is one of the earliest occurrences.
distribution and dating of ceramic types in the Not only a lot of the pottery was imported. All the
transition from the early to High Middle Ages. stone implements - querns and whetstones and a
bowl or bucket - came from outside the Scheldt
Around half of the total of sherds are from coarse region. The analysis of the type of stone shows
grey pottery. This is also known as that the querns came from the Eifel in Germany,
Kugeltopfware, after the type of sagging base while the whetstones come from Scandinavia.
prevalent among this pottery. But not all the jars
have this type of base. In fact, geographically The iron, too - whether objects, semi-finished
Zeeland marks the transition from the actual products or raw iron - must have been imported,
Kugeltopfware of the north to the grey ware of the as is shown by the slag that was studied by Ms C.
south. Although the origins of the 'local' pottery Joosten as part of a larger study on the early
found at OostSouburg are unknown, it is assumed medieval iron industry on the Ve1uwe.
that it was produced nearby in the area. In the In a number of cases, the distribution of iron slags
case of the Zeeland findspots, this might also and further study of the slag material were used as
mean that it came from production centres further a basis to show that some of the hearths found
up the Scheldt. were used for smithing iron. This traditional
activity will mainly have involved manufacturing
The second important category of pottery is or repairing the implements used in the
Pingsdorf ware, which comes from Pingsdorf in settlement. These included simple knives, many
the German Rhineland. More than 40% of the of which are included in the find material.
sherds are of this type. In relation to the findspots
outside Zeeland this is a very high proportion, The category of bronze objects makes a fairly
which suggests that this high quality product was poor impression and consists of a series of simple
easily available, probably by means of the port of fibulae. These items were almost certainly made
Middelburg. However, a more well-founded elsewhere. A round bone fibula might well have
explanation for the high percentage of Pingsdorf been made in the settlement, and might serve to
ware must wait until further, urgently required, illustrate the difficulty of obtaining metal
research has been carried out. equivalents. The study of the objects of bone,
antler and horn have shown that at least some of
The other types of pottery found in Oost-Souburg them, such as the combs and spindle whorls, came
occur only in low percentages. They comprise, in from outside the Scheldt region. This is suggested
descending order of abundance, white pottery by the wide variety of types and the fact that the
with a yellow-green glaze, reliefband, Paffrath, raw material, red deer antler, cannot have come
red-fired, Hunneschans and Badorf ware. Braat's from Walcheren. The salt marsh landscape is not
suggestion that the white pottery with yellow- suitable for red deer, and no red deer remains
green glaze from Oost-Souburg represents an were found among the slaughtered animal
early group that pre-dates the Andenne remains within the settlement.
production, has long been the subject of doubt. If one looks at all the objects found from the
tenth-century settlement in Oost-Souburg, one is
forced to conclude that many of these objects Flanders and the Count of Holland alternately
must come from elsewhere. Clearly, the indicates that, in practice, the area found itself in
settlement was dependent on trade or barter in a kind of power vacuum. Internal defences were
order to obtain these goods. The most obvious therefore organized by the local lords, each of
place for the exchange of goods was of course whom built a motte-and-bailey castle, generally a
Middelburg, which probably already had port simple moated timber-earth defence. At one time
facilities in the tenth century. Exported products there were over 135 such small timber-earth
will have included sheep's wool (possibly spun), castles in Zeeland. Nowadays no more than 30
salt, and perhaps horses. The opportunities for survive, which are known by the somewhat
surplus agricultural production would not have confusing name of vliedberg (refuge mound).
been great in the brackish landscape, where there
was a great risk of flooding. Imported products at The population also had to fight a constant battle
any rate included quality pottery and querns from against the water. Floods - those in 1014 and 1134
the Belgian Meuse valley and the Rhineland. Both were recorded as particularly serious - led to the
areas were then part of the Holy Roman empire, building of dams and dikes. Much of this work
to which Zeeland also belonged in this period. was done by the large Flemish abbeys. The
written sources are not terribly informative when
Historical data on the eleventh and twelfth it comes to the old fortress sites in the eleventh
centuries and twelfth centuries. The following information
In 1012 King Henry 11 rewarded Count Baudouin is, however, available about the individual fortress
IV (988-1035) of Flanders with the villa Walcras, settlements.
thus adding Zeeland Bewestenschelde (the area
between the Eastern- and Westernscheldt) to Oostburg The mother church of the north-
Flanders. The punitive expedition carried out by eastern part of the countship of Flanders, the
Robrecht de Vries, the brother of the count of Church of St. Eligius, would appear to have stood
Flanders in 1067 indicates that the inhabitants of directly to the south of the fortress site in 1038. It
Middelburg and Walcheren were not always was a private church belonging to the count,
obedient. The Count was defeated and the which makes it likely that the fortress, too,
inhabitants of Walcheren subsequently became belonged to the count. The centre of the
embroiled in skirmishes among themselves. We settlement was probably already outside the
know this because abbot Thiofried of Echternach fortress by 1038.
wrote of it in 1103 in his biography of Willibrord.
Thiofried also described how he tried to settle the Middelburg In 1123 the count placed the
dispute, travelling to Middelburg by ship for this northern part of the fortress site at Middelburg at
purpose. This is also the earliest indication that the disposal of the Abbey of Our Lady and in the
Middelburg had a harbour or roads. Until the end mid-thirteenth century, the area directly to the
of the first quarter of the twelfth century Zeeland west was given to a monastery of the Order of
Bewestenschelde belonged to Flanders, after Friars Minor. The manifestations of the count's
which the Count of Flanders presented the Count social and judicial power were then concentrated
of Holland with the whole of Zeeland Bewesten- within the fortress. In addition, the fortress also
schelde. functioned as a spiritual centre. The actual trade
settlement would appear to have had two centres
In the eleventh century, many village settlements at that time: one to the south-west of the fortress
arose, almost all of them with their own church. around the Westmonster Church established there
Since the presence of a parish church was a in the tenth century, which had a market function.
precondition for an independent trade, the local And one immediately to the north-east of the
lords played a major role in founding churches. fortress, centred around the Noordmonster
This is indicated among other things by village Church, which had been founded at the end of the
names, which were composed of an individual's eleventh century, and which was the focus of port
name with the suffix -kerke (church), such as 's- activities.
Heer-Arendskerke on ZuidBeveland.
The fact that in the eleventh century Zeeland Oost-Souburg The old parish church of the
Bewestenschelde was owned by the Count of village of Souburg was a daughter church of the
Westmonster church in Middelburg. The Souburg Kloetinge It is known for a fact that one of the
parish covered a large part of south Walcheren. oldest dikes on Zuid-Beveland, dating from the
Part of this area probably originally belonged to mid-twelfth century, bisects the presumed fortress
the count. The church stood at some distance from site. The relatively low location of the site
the fortress in what would later (after 1250) possibly explains why no settlement arose at the
become known as West-Souburg, possibly at the fortress site in the tenth century. This is why the
central manor house, on the counts estate. The natural character of the place where the settlement
parish was first mentioned in 1162, but the church was founded eventually determined its name. The
probably dates from the first half of the eleventh name Clotinge means something like 'place
century. The church at Oost-Souburg dates from characterized by an elevation'. The village was
1250, when the parish of (West-) Souburg was first mentioned in the sources in 1216.
split into an eastern and western section.
Developments from the thirteenth century
Domburg When, in around the year 1000, the to the present day
parishes of Oost- and Westkapelle were created as After the period when the towns and villages were
divisions of the parish of St. Maarten, which that established, the state of the fortress sites changed
time covered the whole of Walcheren, the fortress, little. The fortress at Domburg, hidden by dune
which had partially disappeared under the sand, sand, was forgotten. The circular form of the
was used as the border. The site of the fortress fortress of Middelburg can still be seen within the
was assigned to the territory of Oostkapelle. In street plan of Middelburg. The fortress sites at
the course of the eleventh century, a settlement Oost-Souburg, Burgh (and Kloetinge) have
called Dumburgh infra castellum, 'Dune fortress continued to be used for agriculture. Finally, the
within the fortress' arose on the site of the uninhabited fortress site at Oostburg was
fortress. The name suggests that the fortress must incorporated into the construction of town
still have been partially visible. defences in the early seventeenth century.
Subsequently, a settlement known as Dumburgh
extra castellum, 'Dune fortress outside the In 1860 the round fortress at Oost-Souburg was
fortress', was established directly to the west of still regarded as the site of a castle built against
the former fortress site, in the parish of the Flemish invasions.
Westkapelle. In both places village churches were The true nature of the fortresses has only been
created as divisions of the parishes of Oostkapelle revealed by the interest of twentieth century
and Westkapelle. The names Domburg binnen archaeologists and historians. The investigations
(within) and Domburg buiten (outside) the prompted by this interest have shown that many
fortress occur for the first time in a charter remains of the fortresses are still present in the
establishing the abbey of Middelburg in 1235. soil, remains which have much to tell, as
Burgh Little mention is made of Burgh in the demonstrated by this book.
written sources, except that in 1219 a local lord The sites of these, more than a thousand year old
by the name of Wolfert van Burgt was appointed. defences, will in future enjoy the status of
The parishes of Burgh and Haamstede were first 'archaeological monuments'. A good example of
mentioned in the second quarter of the thirteenth the benefits of this new status was the
century. Both parishes are divisions of the mother reconstruction in 1994 of the fortress rampart at
church of western Schouwen; Haamstede is Oost-Souburg in the municipality of Vlissingen.
probably the eldest of the two. The mother church With its double role of archaeological monument
probably stood to the west of Westenschouwen, and local park, this site has taken the lead among
and is mentioned in a written source concerning the fortresses in terms of their role in the
possessions of the Lorsch Abbey in 776. preservation of archaeological monuments and
the cultural and historical life of the province of
Zeeland.
2 Summaries of the material studies
Medieval Coins from the Beach at
Domburg It appears that the plant species could not have
Arent Pol grown together, but must originate from very
different vegetations. Plants which grow on the
On the beach at Domburg many early medieval highest parts of the salt marshes are particularly
coins have been picked up in the last few well represented in the sludge. They indicate the
centuries. The finds include quite a few presence of extensive natural grasslands suitable
Merovingian and other gold pieces (tremisses) for grazing. The pollen analysis also shows a very
from the sixth and seventh centuries, but the bulk open vegetation. The animals might have been
of the coins found there are Merovingian, Anglo kept in the settlement within the fortress during
Saxon and Frisian silver coins (denarii and the night, so that dung passed into the sewer from
sceattas) struck over a period of three-quarters of the stables. The plant remains may also derive
a century around the year 700. This large from bedding, hay or sods originating from the
discrepancy need not come as a surprise, for the high salt marshes. Plants from ruderal habitats
rate of production of the coins in the second may have grown in the fortress itself on dung
group was much higher than that of the gold heaps, roadsides, waste ground, neglected
coins. The picture, however, changed in the gardens, etc. Barley, wheat and linseed/flax were
Carolingian period. While the silver coins grown on the highest parts of the salt marshes.
(denarii) continued to be struck on a large scale Whether or not oats were also cultivated is not
until far into the second half of the ninth century, clear. Rye may have been imported. The seeds of
there is a considerable decline in the incidence of arable weeds, together with some chaff remains,
finds on the Domburg beach: coins struck before may derive from the waste from crop processing
840 abound, whereas coins struck after that date activities. These weeds may also have grown in
are much more scarce. This seems to confirm the vegetable gardens in the fortress. The
supposition that 'Domburg' was severely hit by environment was very suitable for animal
the Viking attack of 837, because a similar break husbandry, but the archaeobotanical investigation
does not occur in the general pattern of finds in of the sludge from the sewer shows that arable
the Netherlands around that date. farming was also practised.

Plant Remains from a Sewer of the The Early Glazed Pottery found in Oost-
Fortress at Middelburg Souburg
Janneke Buurman Frans Verhaeghe

During the excavation of the early medieval This contribution discusses the early white-fired
fortress at the Balans in Middelburg the remains pottery with yellow lead glaze which was
of a wooden sewer containing undisturbed sludge associated with the settlement within the late
were found. This sludge has been dated to the last Carolingian circular fortress at Oost-Souburg and
phase of use of the sewer in the first half of the dates to the period 900-975. The small, but
tenth century. The sludge was subjected to an nevertheless indicative, amount of these wares
archaeobotanical investigation to allow a represents 4.6% of the total sherd assemblage and
reconstruction of the vegetation and may well include two separate fabric groups, both
environmental conditions in and near the fortress tempered with quartz-like inclusions: a fine-
and to provide an insight into the plant component grained fabric with a smooth surface, reminiscent
of the food. A sample from the sludge was sieved of the typical Andenne-type wares and a slightly
using meshes of 1.0, 0.5 and 0.25 mm. Seeds and coarser fabric with a more pimply surface. The
fruits appeared to be very well preserved in an finds comprise a coherent group of specific types
uncarbonized condition. Some carbonized plant of tableware: medium-sized to fairly large, ovoid-
remains were also present. Pollen analysis was shaped spouted pitchers with small strap-handles
also carried out on two small samples from the on the shoulder and an reverted rim which often
sludge. ...
has a lid-seat (at least six and possibly twelve finds of this type is needed, particularly in
examples), conical lids (four examples) and small Flanders and in the Netherlands, including
globular-shaped drinking vessels (at least seven attempts at ranking the relevant sites. Together
and possibly twelve examples). Many of the with related finds, the Oost-Souburg examples of
vessels are decorated with block or diamond early glazed wares do point to tenth-century
rouletting or with applied strips (some with thumb processes of innovation and behavioural patterns
impressions); only a few are decorated with which were far more complex than was
bosses or incised lines. Cooking pots seem to be previously generally believed. They also show the
totally absent from the assemblage, but the dangers of linking white-fired, glazed sherds
fragmentary state of the finds makes definite intuitively to the well-known Andenne-type
conclusions in this respect difficult. products and of using them indiscriminately as
Technical and typological features indicate that reliable chronological guide-fossils for the late
the finds are closely comparable to others from eleventh and twelfth centuries.
Alkmaar, Antwerp, Bruges, Douai, London and
elsewhere, a fact which, in addition, confirms
their chronology. The origins of such features are, Slag and Iron-working in Oost-Souburg
however, more difficult to identify. A brief survey Ineke Joosten
of the main finds in France, England, Belgium
and the Netherlands makes it possible to Excavations in the early medieval fortress at
emphasize that white-fired glazed wares occurred Oost-Souburg produced 16 kg of slag and 1 kg of
fairly regularly from the late ninth century furnace lining which was associated with the
onwards, having been produced in many regions. settlement from the tenth century. Macroscopical
Two possible sources are identified for the Oost- and chemical analyses of the slag material
Souburg and related finds: north-western France showed that it originated exclusively from
(including the Paris area) and the Belgian Meuse smithing activities and not from iron production.
valley. A reassessment of some of the earlier finds A perforated clay disc, fired on the outside and
suggests the Meuse valley as the more likely vitrified on the inside, was also found. This had
provenance and kilns may quite possibly have been used as a bellows protector. In order to
been located in or near the town of Hoei. investigate the provenance of the iron, a
The evidence re-establishes the credibility of W.E. metallographic study of some of the iron objects
Braat's somewhat intuitive hypothesis for the from the site was undertaken. The slag inclusions
existence of an early, pre-Andenne group of in the iron objects were known to carry the
glazed wares, characterized by a more lavish use chemical characteristics of the ore from which the
of glaze. iron was produced. Analysis of these inclusions
with a micro-probe indicated high phosphorus and
The interpretation of the finds in terms of socio- low manganese contents. Such a chemical
economic patterns remains difficult. These composition is thought to be the 'fingerprint' of
quality, or even luxury, items do not necessarily bog iron ore.
indicate the presence of an elite, though they do
point to a certain degree of well-being. Together
with the fairly large amount of other imports The Stone Objects from Oost-Souburg
found at Oost-Souburg, mainly Rhenish red- Henk Kars
painted wares, they also suggest that the site had
close links with the new urban network of The stone object assemblage excavated at Oost-
international exchange which emerged after the Souburg (900-975) comprises fragments of fifteen
Viking invasions and after the demise of the querns, around 30 whetstones and one fragment
major emporia such as Dorestad. of a bowl or bucket. The querns, which are
typologically comparable to early medieval
Many questions related to the production and querns (as described earlier), are all made of
socio-economic significance of these wares tephrite deriving from the Mayen quarries in the
remain unanswered pending further research Eifel region of Germany. Amongst the
(including science-based approaches). Similarly, whetstones, one rotary whetstone of new red
more detailed comparative work on other early sandstone (Buntsandstein) was identified. This
sandstone type also derives from the Eifel region, wares in the fortress. In addition, it is possible
most probably from a quarry south of Aachen. that combs were acquired via the market. There is
The other whetstones are bar-shaped and mostly no evidence to suggest that the handled combs
heavily used; three of them have a hole bored from Oost-Souburg were imported from Friesland
through them. Most of these whetstones are of or England, as has been put forward for handled
quartz phyllite. Whereas one may have come combs found elsewhere.
from south-eastern England, most are probably
from quarries in Telemark, southern Norway. The As with the combs, the antler spindle whorls, or at
relatively high frequency of good quality least the raw material for their production, must
whetstones at Oost-Souburg is linked to forging have been imported from elsewhere. The varying
activities. dimensions and weights of the spindle whorls
The most intriguing find is the fragment of points to the spinning of threads of different
soapstone that must have been part of a large thicknesses. The absence of loom weights, in a
bowl or a bucket. Although soapstone finds are period when the technique of knitting was not yet
rare in the Netherlands, they are more common in known in north-western Europe, suggests that the
areas with natural deposits of soapstone, such as inhabitants of OostSouburg probably traded wool
southern Scandinavia and the Alpine regions. On in its spun form. The thirteen needles found are
the basis of a comparison between the material all made from the long bones of mammals. As
from Oost-Souburg and that from the early well as needles used for stitching together very
medieval trading site of Haithabu near Schleswig coarse material, or those used in the making of
in Germany, it is concluded that the Oost-Souburg beehives or for mending fishing nets as eyeless
specimen originally derived from either southern needle shaped objects have been found. These
Norway or Sweden. were possibly used as hairpins, styli, or utensils
for either needlework or leatherworking.

Objects of Bone, Antler and Horn from The discovery of production waste means the
Oost-Souburg three-pronged objects were certainly made within
Roel C.C.M. Lauwerier the settlement. The function of these objects is
unclear. Since the inhabitants of OostSouburg
The 129 objects found in the fortress of lived, in part, from the production of wool, one
OostSouburg, mainly combs, needles, needle- could speculate that these comb-like objects had
shaped objects, spindle whorls, three-pronged something to do with its processing.
objects, skates, and spikes from skating sticks, The bone skates from Oost-Souburg were all
give a picture of the rich variety of object types actually used as skates rather than sledge runners.
and decoration current in the tenth century. All the They were made from various bones (the radius,
combs are composite types and, except for one, metacarpus and metatarsus of horse and cattle)
are all made of antler. They can be roughly and can be categorized into different types. Some
divided into four types with very diverse patterns types were made to be used without the need for
of decoration. The fact that red deer was not securing ties. Other types were clearly used with
indigenous on the island of Walcheren, in ties. Yet others were possibly only tied on at the
combination with the presence of semi-finished heel so that they couldn't slip away. Another
comb tooth plates and waste from antler working, possibility for this latter type is that they were
leads to the conclusion that antler was imported as also used without ties and the naturally occurring
raw material for the on-site production or repair or drilled hole under the heel merely allowed the
of combs. This does not exclude the possibility skates to be bound together with a cord. These
that finished combs could also have been coarsely-made objects in which, for example, the
imported from elsewhere. The very variety in holes were made with a knife or another sharp
comb types found, however, makes it unlikely tool and not with a drill, were clearly not
that a specialised craftsman worked within the professionally made but rather home produced.
fortress. The variability, the half-finished state of The same is true of the coarsely-finished spikes.
some objects and the waste material can be better These are probably spikes from skating sticks
explained by assuming that the combs are the which were used for pushing off while skating. A
products of itinerant craftsman who sold their few sawn-off horn-cores indicate the use of horn.
Distribution and Function of Bone Three- worked tools. The meat of red deer was not eaten
pronged Objects by the inhabitants of the site and the animals do
Herman W. van Klaveren not appear to have been hunted since they were
probably not indigenous to Walcheren. The
During the excavations at the site of the early worked antler objects, or the raw material, would
medieval fortress of Oost-Souburg ten specimens therefore have been imported from elsewhere.
of worked animal bone were found, which belong
to a single, three-pronged, artefacts. Similar Cats and dogs were also not eaten by the
artefacts are known from parts of the Netherlands, inhabitants. The bones indicate great variability in
Belgium, France and Germany. Their name and the size and appearance of the dogs. The biggest
function are unknown. The number of specimens dog, perhaps a watchdog or sheepdog, had a
found is steadily increasing. height of 65-68 cm. The smallest dog, with a
The most common material used in their height of only 23-25 cm, had legs bent like a
production is a cattle metapodium; other bones do dachshund and was possibly used for hunting
however occur. The form is tapering and foxes. The horses, with a height of about 138 cm,
resembles a 'D' in cross-section. It carries from were rather small. As well as being used for riding
two to four, usually three, teeth on top; the and as draught animals, the horses were possibly
rounded side is mostly decorated in a simple way. bred for the market. Horse meat was not eaten,
Wear is clearly visible, but only on the outside. but the bones were used for making bone skates.
An enquiry was made into the limited available The cattle, with a mean height of 115 cm, were
data concerning their distribution, context, dating mainly kept for their meat, but possibly also for
and possible function. Dating falls roughly milk. A number of sheep were clearly slaughtered
between the late ninth and the twelfth century or young for their meat. The greater part of the flock,
possibly even somewhat later. These artefacts can however, was kept primarily for wool and only
occur in any kind of settlement of this period and consumed after some years. The sheep were
area. Their name and function could not be probably not milked. Goats were kept for this
deduced from archaeological records. Written or purpose on a small scale, as is indicated in the
pictorial evidence or parallels from other periods bone assemblage from the circular fortress of
in bone or any other material are not known. They Middelburg, dating from the first half of the tenth
might have served some purpose in the working century. For purposes of consumption, beef was
of perishable materials such as leather, wool, flax far more important than mutton: expressed in
and the like. weight, probably three or four times more
important. The contribution of pork to the diet
was markedly small. The overall picture given by
Stock breeding in Oost-Souburg the bone assemblage for the inhabitants of
Roel C.G.M. Lauwerier OostSouburg is, in the first place, not that of a
group of shepherds, but much more that of
The information in tables 23 and 24 gives a stockbreeders. It is concluded that there must
survey of the bone material found in the tenth have been a surplus of animal products. Horses
century circular fortress of Oost-Souburg. No were possibly bred for the market and the
sieved samples were taken which means that little inhabitants sold, amongst other things, wool,
information is available pertaining to fowling and including spun wool, indicated by the presence of
fishing activities. The remains of red deer are all spindle whorls and the absence of loom weights
parts of antler and are mostly found in the form of on the site.

You might also like