Modest Web Site Is Behind a Bevy of Memes - WSJ.

com

21.07.08 2:12

More

Enter Symbol(s) or Keyword(s)

User Name: Password:

SEARCH

Remember Me

Log In

Forgot your username or password? | Subscribe

As of Wednesday, July 9, 2008

Set My Home Page | Customer Service

News

Today's Newspaper

My Online Journal

Multimedia & Online Extras

Markets Data & Tools

Classifieds

OTHER FREE CONTENT FROM THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

Modest Web Site Is Behind a Bevy of Memes

By JAMIN BROPHY-WARREN
July 9, 2008

EDITORS' PICKS
Presidential Dining A Special Round Must-See Videos Review: 'The Dark Knight' 'Save Our Starbucks' This Jupiler's For You Five Best MORE EDITORS' PICKS

Creating viral videos and concepts has become a keystone for many businesses marketing online. Such Web phenomena are known by technophiles as "memes." Coined by biologist Richard Dawkins in his 1976 book "The Selfish Gene," a meme is a unit of cultural information -- an idea, a practice, a phrase, or an online video --that's passed on virally. Although sometimes frivolous, every word-of-mouth marketer dreams of creating memorable memes that will catapult their product or client to fame. Over the last few years, 4chan.org has become one of the most talked-about sites when it comes to launching new memes. After appearing on the site, "LOLcats," humorous images of cats with loud text beneath them in a fake language called "LOLspeak", stormed the Web last year. (For example, instead icanhascheezburger.com of saying "hello," the cats An example of a LOLcat. would say "oh hai.") Another phrase "So I herd u like mudkips," a reference to a sea creature from the popular animated show "Pokmon," spawned thousands of tribute videos on YouTube. 4chan.org began as a simple message board with pictures and text. It was started by Christopher Poole in his Long Island bedroom in 2003 when he was 15 years old. Since then it has grown to more than 3 million monthly users, according to Mr. Poole. One of the site's most popular memes is an online bait-and-switch known as the "Rick Roll." Here's how it works: A friend sends an email suggesting you take a peek at an "amazing" online video and passes along the link. You follow the link, but instead of the video you expect, you've been sent to the music video of Rick Astley's "Never Gonna Give You Up," a hit song from 1988. Over the past year, Rick Rolling has become an online sensation, pushing Mr. Astley's video past 16 million views on YouTube. 4chan is a quaint throwback to EARLIER the earliest Web pages that have Time Waster: With 'LOLcats' Internet Fad, since been eclipsed in the newest Anyone Can Get In on the Joke 8/25/07 iterations of the Web. While other Web sites focus on flashy- 4CHAN'S GREATEST HITS social networking features and Over the last five years, 4chan has generated several viral phenomenon. Here's at a few of eye-catching advertisements, them: 4chan's design is archaic and the Rick Rolling: In a classic bait-and-switch, color scheme is two-tone. Each friends lure their colleagues to follow a link to an "AMAZING WEBSITE." In reality, it's a link page on 4chan features photos to a music video for Rick Astley's 1988 hit and text. One user will post an "Never Gonna Give You Up." "so i herd u like mudkips": Originally posted image of something to start a on another Web site, members of 4chan discussion on one of the more adopted the phrase as in-joke. A "mudkip" is a lovable, water creature from the animated than 40 different subject areas series Pokmon. You can watch some of the spanning origami and thousands of tribute videos on YouTube. automobiles. Other users follow LOLcats: Every Saturday, 4chan users began posting pictures of cats in an event known as up with responses or requests for "Caturday." Soon, users posted humorous phrases with their felines which eventually more images.

BLOGS
Most Popular Posts 1. Covington Partner Demonstrates Treatment of Detainees 2. Democratic Party Unity Proves Elusive at Netroots Gathering 3. Index Shows Falling Home Prices, Rising Sales of Religious Statuettes 4. Mean Street: How A Banker Earns His $25 Million Fee SEE ALL BLOGS MORE FREE CONTENT >> Personal Journal >> Personal Finance >> Leisure >> Markets Data Center >> Video >> Blogs >> Forums >> Interactives >> Autos >> CareerJournal >> Real Estate >> Small Business >> OpinionJournal >> MarketWatch >> AllThingsDigital

MORE FROM TODAY'S JOURNAL

$ Subscription may be required | Subscribe Now

PEOPLE WHO READ THIS...

Also read these stories: The Metaphysics and Some Politics of Global Warming Spain Says Hello The Era of Big Punitive Damage Awards Is Not Over It's Hard To Predict Which Mergers Are Threat to Consumers The Future of Securitization

NEW! Are you on Facebook? See what content on this site is popular with your friends! Learn more Your Facebook Friends Are Reading Sofia Goes Flat
Seen by 4 friends | 2 groups | New York

Ledger Dazzles in Suffocatingly Dark 'Knight'

Seen by 8 friends | 3 groups | Stanford

The End of White Flight

Seen by 8 friends | 3 groups | New York

WHAT'S NEWS Iraq PM Says U.S. Should Leave 'As Soon as Possible,'
Says Magazine

Short-Sale Rule Gets Bad Reviews Iran Nuclear Talks Stall Ford Plans to Sell Small Car in U.S. Batman Movie Sets Box Office Record
MORE

WHAT'S POPULAR
1. Cities, Customers Seek to Save Local Starbucks 2. Why No Outrage? 3. Opinion: How a Young Lawyer Saved the Second Amendment

became know as "LOLcats." You can see some examples at I Can Has Cheezburger.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB121564928060441097.html?mod=rss_E-Commerce/Media

Page 1 of 3

Modest Web Site Is Behind a Bevy of Memes - WSJ.com

21.07.08 2:12
examples at I Can Has Cheezburger. 4. Ledger Dazzles in Suffocatingly Dark 'Knight' 5. Ford Plans to Sell Small Car in U.S. MORE

"It's like Craigslist -- hugely simple and highly useful," says David Weinberger, a fellow at Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet and Society. 4chan's utility is its ability to gather millions of people in conversation in a single place and create a "meme-rich" environment, says Mr. Weinberger.

Last September, Ben Huh and a team of investors purchased "I Can Has Cheezburger," a site that aggregated the "LOLcats." Mr. Huh hopes to turn the 4chan-generated tradition into a meme empire with several other related sites in the works. The site now has more than 2.5 million unique visitors a month, according to Mr. Huh, and a book based on the site is coming this fall for Gotham Books. Mr. Poole originally just wanted a place to share his fascination with Japanese comics and television shows. He was a fan of the popular Japanese image Web site 2chan and wanted to create a version for American audiences. With his mother's approval, he used her credit card to purchase server space and started 4chan.org. Soon, running 4chan became a full-time job. He hired a programmer (based on his skill playing online Tetris) and recruited a team of active community members to serve as moderators. "It was a struggle to get him to turn off his computer," says Tom Poole, Mr. Poole's father, who says his son built a computer with a water-cooling system as a teen. "He's a bit obsessive." A large part of the site's success is its emphasis on anonymity. Users are not required to provide a working email address or any other personal information, a standard practice for other online communities like Facebook or MySpace. Mr. Poole uses the codename "moot" and says that he's never revealed his connection to the site until The Wall Street Journal inquired. "I have a firewall between my two lives," he says. Mr. Poole says that anonymity encourages unfettered creativity. But it also removes individual accountability as some posts can veer into hurtful or profane territories. "Shock posts," or Jessica Andrews graphic images of violence or sex, occasionally mar the largest general interest board known as Christopher Poole, 4chan's founder " /b/ ." Mr. Poole has a disclaimer that he wrote so that users "don't post anything that violates U.S. or international law." He says a lawyer reviewed the notice, but concedes, "I'm sure they don't have much legal clout behind them." "They get rowdy -- it's like a bar without alcohol," says Willard Ling, a moderator and long-time user of the site. "It's like that psychological concept of deinvidualization -- when groups of people become less aware of their own responsibility." Mr. Poole and his team of moderators have handed out 70,000 bans over the last three years, but preventing long-term abuse can be difficult. 4chan's "Wild West" reputation has created a dilemma for Mr. Poole. While it's brought him Internet fame, albeit through his alter ego, and created enviable traffic, he has trouble selling ads to more cautious companies who don't want their ads appearing next to potentially graphic content. He's attempted to quarantine sexual material on a set of adult boards, but that doesn't stop pornography or other adult content from appearing elsewhere. Max Goldberg, owner of You're The Man Now Dog, a similar community with about 230,000 registered users and a focus on animated videos, says dealing with mature content is a problem for any site that allows its users creative license. "On the Web, you either have clean content or you have pornography. People upload both, but they don't want to buy pornography, because they can get it for free," says Mr. Goldberg. Even a small percentage of racy or blue content can ruin a site's image with advertisers, he says. 4chan's growing pains are part of a larger issue: how to turn a wave of online traffic into a viable business. "That's been an uphill battle for me personally. My biggest time spent has been convincing companies in marketing potential in 4chan but no one sees eye to eye," says Mr. Poole. Part of 4chan's problem is counting how many users are on the site. Many advertisers look at third-party Webmeasurement companies like comScore to determine a site's overall traffic and demographic information. Currently, comScore says 4chan only has around about 796,000 unique visitors a month globally, a more than threefold difference from 4chan's claims. ComScore says that it uses a Nielsen-like system to track Web traffic. Mr. Poole says that comScore's demographic data is correct, but disagrees with their traffic data, arguing that panel-based data is flawed. "It's a generalization," he says of comScore's figures, "Our users are hard to pinpoint." In contrast to other startups that have amassed millions of dollars in seed money from investors, 4chan is a modest operation. Mr. Poole makes money from advertising and the occasional donation drive. He says the site breaks even, but won't release the site's revenue figures. His only paid staff member is his programmer. "He makes more money than I do," says Mr. Poole. Write to Jamin Brophy-Warren at Jamin.Brophy-Warren@wsj.com

RELATED ARTICLES FROM ACROSS THE WEB

Related Content may require a subscription | Subscribe Now -- Get 2 Weeks FREE

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB121564928060441097.html?mod=rss_E-Commerce/Media

Page 2 of 3

Modest Web Site Is Behind a Bevy of Memes - WSJ.com

Related Articles from WSJ.com
Cuomo Charges Alleged Craigslist Scamsters Jul. 17, 2008

21.07.08 2:12

More related content

Powered by Sphere

YAHOO! BUZZ

DIGG THIS

MY SPACE

GET RSS FEEDS

Return To Top WSJ Digital Network: MarketWatch | Barrons.com | AllThingsDigital Dow Jones News Alerts | FiLife | MORE Subscribe Log In Take a Tour Contact Us Help Email Setup Customer Service: Online | Print Privacy Policy Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use Copyright Policy Mobile Devices RSS Feeds News Licensing Advertising About Dow Jones Copyright 2008 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB121564928060441097.html?mod=rss_E-Commerce/Media

Page 3 of 3