You are on page 1of 6

NIT-BN THEO QUAN IM B TT LONG TH

I-LN ---o0o--Ngun http://thuvienhoasen.org Chuyn sang ebook 28-7-2009 Ngi thc hin : Nam Thin namthien@gmail.com Link Audio Ti Website http://www.phatphaponline.org ---o0o--T khi c Pht tuyn b: Sarvam Snyam (Mi vt u khng), t s gi ca ba php n: V thng-Kh-V ng v sau cc php c quan nim nh l Mi vt u v thng, mi vt u v ng, th vn Nitbn (Nirva), sau khi c Th tn dit c cc b phi nu ra t vn tr li theo quan nin hiu bit ca h v Nit-bn, v cng t mi tranh lun v n cng nh cc phn gio l khc tr nn gay gt. Nit-bn, vn hin hu hay khng hin hu, c (bhva) hay khng (abhva), mt ti lm ny sanh ra mi s tranh lun, cng ngy cng gay gt gia Hu b hay cn gi l Nht thit hu b (Sarvsti-vdin) v Kinh b cn gi l Kinh lng b (Stra-vdin), gia cc nh Tiu tha v i tha Khng tng (Snyat-vadin), v vn ny khng cn dng li ni y m cn tin xa hn na, trong vic ha gii gia hai quan im ni trn bng cch gp chng li ri chp nhn c hai c mt ci Nit-bn hin hu theo s ha gii ca h, hay ph nhn c hai l chng phi c, chng phi khng; l bn th quan im ca cc b phi, nhng theo ngi Ngrjuna (Long Th) th c Pht cha tng ni ra mt th Nit-bn no nh vy, ngay c khi Ngi cn ti th, hay sau khi Ngi vo Nit-bn, Ngi ni: Khi Nh lai hin hu, Chng ni c cng khng; Cng chng ni c-khng, Hay chng c, chng khng. V: Sau khi Nh Lai dit, Chng ni c cng khng;

Cng chng ni c-khng, Hay chng c, chng khng. i vi B tt Long Th, th nhng quan nim nh vy ca cc b phi i vi Nit-bn l hon ton khng chnh xc, v khng hiu c ngha Sarvam Snyam cho nn c nhng quan nim sai lm nh vy v ngha Nit-bn. T s hiu lm ny nn i lch con ng Trung o ca Ngi, v c nhng kin th lch lc v cc php ni chung v Nit-bn ni ring. V con ng Trung o ca c Pht khng ri vo Hu hay V, khng ri vo va C va Khng, cng khng ri vo chng phi c chng phi khng, ca nhng quan im thin kin t chp tri buc ny, m con ng Trung o l con ng gii thot mi s tri buc kh au gia hai b. i vi cc nh Tiu tha Hu b, th nht h hiu Mi vt u Khng ch dnh cho cc php hu vi m thi cn cc php v vi nh Nitbn, th khng b l thuc vo chng, th hai Mi vt u khng ch dnh cho Nhn khng ch khng dnh cho Php khng, th ba Mi vt khng th khng ny l khng trng rng, khng c g ht, khng ny l khng i lp li vi ci c. Do h mi c nhng ct vn nh vy: Nu tt c php khng, Th khng sanh, khng dit; Lm sao c on-dit, gi l Nit bn ? trn l cch tip thu Mi vt u khng v theo cc nh Tiu tha t vn l, nu tt c cc php u khng, khng c g ht, th s khng c hin tng sanh dit, khi khng c hin tng sanh dit th mi vn c t ra theo sau , chng khng hin hu. Vy th on ci g, dit ci g c th gi l Nit bn? Cho nn theo h, tt c cc php khng phi khng, m cc php phi c tht. V cc php chng phi khng, nn n on tr c tt c mi phin no nghip hoc, tiu dit c nm m a n Nit bn. tr li cho nn vn ny, ngi Long Th cng ng trn lp trng ca h, hi nghch tr li: Nu cc php l c, Thi khng sanh khng dit; on g, dit ch no, M gi l Nit bn ?

V cc nh Tiu tha khng hiu thu c ch su xa ca php Khng (Dharmasnyat), nn nhm ln, cho rng php Khng l php trng rng, h v, khng c g ht; php khng ny i li php c ca h, nn sanh ra kin gii sai lm v cc php, v t a ra nn vn nh trn. Cng ng trn lp trng kin gii sai lm ny, ngi t ngc li vn rng: Nu cc php chng phi khng tc l c, v v xa nay chng lun lun hin hu, chng lun lun l c nn chng s khng c sanh, khng c dit; vy khi khng sanh khng dit th lm sao chng c ch on c ch dit m gi l Nit bn ? y hai ca hu-v (Bhva-Abhva) khng phi l ca i n Nit-bn, m Nit-bn phi c gi l : Khng c, cng khng n, Chng on, cng chng thng; Chng sanh, cng chng dit, gi l Nit bn. y, mi s hin hu n l, l thuc, chp th thin kin nh nguyn nh : c-tht, n-i, on-thng, sanh-dit v.v... u b ph nh. Trong ph nh mi xem ra nh l mang c hai tnh cht va p ph va xy dng. Nhng y, nu c xc nh nh vy, th lp tc ri vo onthng (Ucchada-Nitya) ngay. Do , mi xc nh u cng b ph nhn, t m ra mt con ng rng thnh thang khng b tri buc, l con ng Trung o i n Nit-bn. Ngha l sau khi chng ta thc hin v s i vi cc php, th t n l con ng, t n l Nit-bn khng phi mt cng khng phi khc. y, hnh-qu khng phi l ch t c, khng phi l ch n, khng phi l ch on tr, chng c php phn bit; chng sanh chng dit, cho nn Nit-bn chng phi c, chng phi chng khng, chng chp th tt c cc php, bn trong tch dit gi l Nit-bn. V sao ? V tt c mi hin tng hin hu ca vn vt mt chng ta nhn thy, lun lun trong trng thi sanh dit bin hoi, ch l tng lo t b v thng sanh dit chi phi nn khng phi l Nit-bn. Nu c mt Nit-bn no mt chng ta nhn thy l c th Nit-bn y cng ch l tng lo t, m tng lo t khng phi l tng Nit-bn, cho nn Nit-bn khng gi l c c, v n xa la tng lo t. Hn na, nu Nit bn l c (hu), th ci c ny, hay Nit-bn ny thuc vo tng hu vi. Nhng tng hu vi, theo c Pht dy th chng lun trong trng thi bin dit khng tht c. V sao ? V chng hin hu c c l nh vo cc duyn m thnh. Do , tt c mi php ang hin hu gia chng ta khng c bt c mt php no gi l hu vi c, cho d l php

thng m gi gi l v vi dng l tm hiu n. Php v thng cn khng c, hung chi l php thng khng th thy, khng th t c. Li na, theo Ngi: Nu Nit bn l c, Sao gi khng chp th; V-hu khng t chp (th), M gi l c php. Nu tht s Nit bn l tht c th ti sao trong kinh, c Pht li bo Nit bn l khng chp th (v th, hay V d y: nirupadhizewa)? l khng chp th th cho d php l php g i na cng khng th hin hu y c. Nu c php no hin hu c th khng phi l ch v th, v theo kinh th Nit-bn l v th, nn khng c php khng chp th y. Vy Nit-bn chng phi c. Nn vn : Nu hu khng phi l Nit-bn, vy th v l Nit-bn ? Ngi bo : Hu chng phi Nit-bn, Hung chi i vi V; Nit-bn khng c Hu, Ni no s c V ? Qu r rng nh bi k trn bo Hu-V khng t chp th m c. Vy th ti sao y li t vn V tr li i vi Nit-bn c ? V sao ? V nh vo hu m c v. Nu khng c hu th lm sao c v c. Nu ni trc c nay khng, th vt ny l v. Nhng Nit-bn chng phi vy, v khng c php c no li l khng c, cho nn v cng khng th to nn Nit-bn c. Li na, th t v l Nit-bn i. Nhng y, chng ta khng gii quyt c vn khng chp th l Nit-bn nh c Pht dy trong kinh. Nu v l Nit-bn th c Pht khng ni khng chp th l Nitbn nh kinh dy. V sao ? V khng c php khng chp th no gi l php v c, cho nn Nit-bn khng th gi l v c. Hn na,

Nh trong kinh Pht bo: on c, on chng c; Bit l Nit-bn, Chng c cng chng khng. Chnh c Pht dy nu on tr c hai : C v chng c ny th Nitbn s hin hu. V sao ? V C l ch cho tam hu (tam gii) v chng c ch cho tam hu c on dit. Nu on tr c hai chng ngi hu-v ny, th bit rng Nit-bn chng phi c (phi hu) cng chng phi khng (phi v), mi gi l Nit-bn. Nn vn : Nu hu hay v khng phi Nit bn th by gi hp c hu v v li, c phi l Nit bn khng ? Ngi bo : i hu-v, nu bo: Hp li l Nit-bn; Hu-v l gii thot, Thi iu ny chng ng. phn trn hu-v b ph nh, nhng ngi nn vn vn em chng t vn tr li. y, li ny sanh mt phi l khc na, l vic hp nht gia hu-v li c mt ci Nit-bn theo quan im ca h. Nhng theo ngi, nu hp c hu v v li l Nit-bn, tc l hp c hu v v li l gii thot, iu ny ch thng cho Nit-bn v gii thot thi. Cn ngay chnh n, hu v v, trong mt v m t mu thun nhau vi chnh mnh, vy th lm sao thng vi v th hai c. V sao ? V hu v v chng tng phn nhau, lm sao hin din cng lc cng mt ch c. Do , hp c hai hu v v li l Nit-bn th khng ng. Li na : i hu-v, nu bo: Hp li l Nit-bn; Nit-bn l ch chp, C hai t chp sanh. trn, t chng khng thng ri. Nu y m hp chng li l Nit-bn c th chp nhn i, vi iu kin t chng khng mu thun nhau; nhng y t thn Nit-bn khng phi l ch chp th, trong khi hu-v t ch chp th sanh ra, cng nh vo nhau m hin hu. Vy th c

hai v mu thun v khng thng nhau c, do chng khng phi l Nit-bn. Li na, Nit bn l V vi, n vt ln trn hu-v ca hu vi. Trong khi hu-v hp li m thnh th khng thot khi hu vi, ngha l chng thuc php hu vi. Nhng php hu vi l php sanh dit nh c Pht dy, trong khi php v vi l php khng sinh dit. Vy th lm sao bo huv hp li thnh l Nit-bn ? Hay, Cng hai vic hu-v Lm sao l Nit-bn ? Hai vic khng cng ch Nh sng ti khng hp. trn, hp hai vic c-khng khng thnh l mt vn . y, li l mt vn khc na trong vic cng hai khi nim ny li c Nit-bn hin hu, th lm sao chng ta c th lm c. V sao? V c-khng chng t tng phn mu thun nhau nn khng th cng hin hu mt ni c. Nh nh sng v bng ti, khng th no cng hin hu cng mt lc c. Khi no C hin hu th Khng s khng hin hu, ngc li khi no Khng hin hu th c s khng hin hu. Vy th lm sao c-khng cng hp nhau li m gi l Nit-bn ? Li nn vn : Nu C-Khng cng hp nhau li khng l Nit-bn, th by gi chng phi c chng phi khng l Nit-bn c khng ? Ngi bo : Nu chng c chng khng, Gi l Nit-bn; Chng c chng khng ny, Lm sao m phn bit ?

HT

You might also like