12-01-17 Events Surrounding the Death of the Clerk of the Israeli Supreme Court Shmaryahu Cohen Should be Thoroughly

and Publicly Investigated.

Survey of the electronic decision forms of the Supreme Court over the past two decades shows continuous erosion in their validity and integrity. Key events took place under the tenure of former Chief Justice AHARON BARAK (1995-2006). Irregularities are particularly noted around the untimely death (March 2002) of Clerk of the Court SHMARYAHU COHEN from an on-the-job heart attack. Further investigation may establish that in the months prior to his death, the Late Clerk SHMARYAHU COHEN created permanent internal and public records of his protest against the corruption of the electronic record systems of the Supreme Court. The matter should be thoroughly and publicly investigated.

Clerk Shmaryahu Cohen zl; Former Chief Justice Aharon Barak; Supreme Court of the State of Israel

View as PDF: afdfa View PDF Appendix: Table, Notes, Records: http://www.scribd.com/doc/78494051/ Jerusalem, January 17 in a previous study, Joseph Zernik, PhD, Human Rights Alert (NGO), documented that the issuance of simulated decisions and conduct of simulated case reviews are enabled and practiced through the electronic record systems of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel. [1,2] In a supplemental study, released today, Dr Zernik provides detailed review of the evolution of the electronic decision form of the Supreme Court, and noted material irregularities in this respect around 2001-2002, and beyond. [3] The supplemental study was based on review of Writs, Decisions, and Judgments from the online public access systems of the Supreme Court: Elyon1 (1988-2010), Elyon2 (1999-~January 1, 2002 and ~February 20, 20022010), and records found through Google searches (1997-2011) The results were compiled and posted online, a) Summary Table, b) Survey Notes, and c) Survey Records (Writs, Decisions, Judgments). [3] The survey shows: 1. Continuous erosion in the validity and integrity of the electronic decision forms, relative to the attestation by the Clerk of the Court, particularly under the tenure of Chief Justice Aharon Barak (19952006), and 2. Inexplicable irregularities in the months surrounding the untimely death of Clerk of the Court Shmaryahu Cohen from an on-the-job heart attack in early March 2002. Of note: Discontinuities are found in the succession of certification authority, from Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court, through unnamed Rasham (Magistrate) and Sarah Lifschitz Clerk of the Court, to no certification at all.

New Court case files are missing from the index of the contemporary system, Elyon2, corresponding approximately to the Case Filing Dates of January 1, 2002 and February 20, 2002. Some, but not all of the files are found on the legacy system Elyon1.

Further investigations may establish that in the months prior to his death, the Supreme Court Clerk Shmaryahu Cohen created permanent internal and public records of his protest against the corruption of the electronic record systems of the Supreme Court. The matter should be thoroughly and publicly investigated. In studies published and presented in international, peer-reviewed computer science and criminology conferences, Dr Zernik showed that similar systems, which had been implemented in the US courts a decade earlier opened the way for widespread corruption of the courts and failing banking regulation. [4,5] The 2010 submission of Human Rights Alert to the Human Rights Council (HRC) of the United Nations was reviewed by the HRC professional staff and incorporated in the official HRC Professional Staff Report with a note referring to corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California. [6] Joseph Zernik, PhD Human Rights Alert (NGO) Bio: http://www.scribd.com/doc/46421113/ LINKS: [1] 11-12-04 Simulated Records, Simulated Litigation Enabled by the Electronic Record Systems of the Supreme Court of
the State of Israel (English) http://www.scribd.com/doc/73239491/ [2] "Simulated litigation", "simulated decisions", "simulated service" here refer to conduct defined in the Texas Criminal Code as follows: Texas Penal Code 32.48. SIMULATING LEGAL PROCESS. (a) A person commits an offense if the person recklessly causes to be delivered to another any document that simulates a summons, complaint, judgment, or other court process with the intent to: (1) induce payment of a claim from another person; or (2) cause another to: (A) submit to the putative authority of the document; or (B) take any action or refrain from taking any action in response to the document, in compliance with the document, or on the basis of the document. (b) Proof that the document was mailed to any person with the intent that it be forwarded to the intended recipient is a sufficient showing that the document was delivered. [3] 12-01-17 Evolution of the Electronic Decision Forms of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel Instant paper and its Appendix: afdfa [4] 10-08-18 Zernik, J: Data Mining as a Civic Duty Online Public Prisoners Registration Systems, International Journal on Social Media: Monitoring, Measurement, Mining 1: 84-96 (2010) http://www.scribd.com/doc/38328591/ [5] 11-08-01 Zernik, J: Design and Operation of Information Systems of the US Courts are Linked to Conduct of a Simulated Banking Regulation Litigation http://www.scribd.com/doc/44663232/ [6] 10-04-19 Human Rights Alert (NG0) submission to the United Nations Human Rights Council for the 2010 Review (UPR) of Human Rights in the United States as incorporated into the UPR staff report, with a note referring to "corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California". http://www.scribd.com/doc/38566837/

ATTACHED:
A. Table Summary B. Survey Notes C. Survey Records (Writs, Decisions, Judgments) 1. ELYON1 (E1 - 1988-2010) 2. ELYON2 (E2 - 1999-~January 1, 2002 and ~February 20, 2002-2010) 3. GOOGLE (G - 1997-2011)

A. Table Summary Attestation Boxes of the Clerk of the Supreme Courts Electronic Decision Forms Attached # 1 File name [00 00 yy-mm-dd]
00 00 99-02-24 E2 99-500 True copy of the original Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court az/N02.00061900

Image

00-03-02 G Ben Gavriel v Chief of Staff (1595/00)

00-10-12 G RTF file 6190-00 True copy of the original Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court az/N02.00061900

01-04-03 E2 00-500 See below.

01-10-14 G terem pirsumo True copy of the original am/N02.00061900 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes prior to publication in the Collected Decisions of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court This version of the attestation appears as a compromise: The statement regarding possible changes is left intact, but the published copy in the Collected Decisions is defined as the binding copy.

01-11-13 G True copy lifschitz doc type True copy of the original 02027540_L05.doc Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Sarah Lifschitz Clerk of the Court It needs to be ascertained that Sarah Lifschitz was authorized to sign Clerk of the Court on that date. 02-01-01 New court case are missing from the index of E2, but present in E1 (see above), approximately corresponding to the Case Filing Dates of January 1, 2002 till February 20, 2002.

02-01-14 G Lamital v State of Israel (9663-01) intermediate form True copy of the original mp/-.01096630M03 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court Reverting to the older attestation style.

02-01-23 E2 02-10 Cohen with DOT type file True copy of the original COURT.DOT Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court DOT type file is a template file in Word, and could not reasonably be used for the maintenance of the original judicial records.

10

02-02-07 E2 02-10 Cohen True copy of the original B02.02000100 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court

11

02-02-13 E2 02-10 Cohen

12

02-02-20 E2 02-1582 with cohen, okon names

13

02-02-21 E2 02-1583 writ with cohen name

14

02-02-21 E2 02-1585 Intermediate Writ with Cohen name

15

02-02-28 E2 02-1582 with Cohen Okon names on it Issued this date, February 14, 2007 Boaz Okon Magistrate ___________ Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court The record is not attested as True copy of any file, and the date is 5 years into the future in both Hebrew and general calendars

16

02-02-28 E2 02-1583 with Cohen name True copy of the original COURT.DOT Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court DOT type file is a template file in Word, and could not reasonably be used for the maintenance of the original judicial records.

17

02-03-02 __________ True copy of the original J02.02010000 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Magistrate Failing to provide the name of the Rasham (Magistrate Judge). Of note, no Clerk or Deputy Clerks name appears on this record.

18 19

02-03-06 (?) Clerk of the Court Shmaryahu Cohen dies of on the job heart attack. 02-03-13 E2 02-1585 No name, rasham in place of clerk __________ True copy of the original COURT.DOT Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Magistrate Invalid attestation, against a COURT.DOT file, and failing to provide the name of the Rasham (Magistrate Judge). Of note, no Clerk or Deputy Clerks name appears on this record.

20

02-06-17 E2 02-1785 Writ no name of clerk True copy of the original B05.02015850 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes Magistrate The Rasham is not identified by name, but attestation is against a specific original file. Of note, no Clerk or Deputy Clerks name appears on this record.

21

02-11-21 G liftshitz true copy doc type True copy of the original 02073510_K03.doc Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Sarah Lifschitz Clerk of the Court

22

02-12-09 G lifschitz true copy doc type

23

03-01-03 E2 03-01 Beinisch new Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 03000010_N01.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il

MI Presided by Dorit Beinisch. The Hebrew initials at the bottom right may be of a Deputy Clerk, but there is no attestation statement, and the reference is to a DOC file. 03-01-03 E2 03-50 Barak Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 03000010_N01.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il Presided by Chief Justice Aharon Barak. The Hebrew initials MI appear only at the bottom right of the face page. The statement above appears only on the bottom right of the second page.

24

25

03-02-19 E2 03-100 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 03001000_K01.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il Presided by Magistrate Oded Shaham. No initials appear at the bottom right of either page 1 or page 2.

26

03-03-12 E2 03-500 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 03005000_L04.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il Presided by Justice Daliah Dorner. The Hebrew initials MI appear only at the bottom right of the face page. The statement above appears only on the bottom right of the second page.

27

04-09-08 G Lisfschiz TRO Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. MP 04082490_M01.doc MP Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il Hebrew initials after the file name (in DOC) is restore.

28

05-01-16 E2 05-500 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 05005000_T01.doc HG Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il Hebrew initials after the file name (in DOC) are restored.

29

05-03-28 E2 03-100 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 02108420_L05.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il No Hebrew initials after the file name (in DOC) on either page 1 or page 2. 10-02-07 E2 10-500 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 10005000_N01.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website www.court.gov.il Hebrew initials after the file name (in DOC) are restored.

30