Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0
columbia building intelligence project - integrated design studio - spring 2012
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
statement:
Current building envelope design is thermally inefficient, fractured into several layers. Perimeter heat gain/loss add significant loads to the mechanical system which must then be over-designed to compensate for this inefficiency. This increases the size/cost of the mechanical system and adds cost to the buildings operation and maintenance during its lifetime. A simpler, cheaper, and more thermally effective envelope may be obtained by combining the enclosure with a radiant heating system into a single layer, creating a heat exchange-relation between the envelope and the occupants. In order to test this hypothesis, the following process-design is used to measure the proposed assembly. By measuring its value within the domains of aesthetics, structural performance, mechanical performance, material cost and profit, one is able to obtain a qualitative and quantitative understanding of the many design permutations that the system can generate.
cooling s/r
heating s/r
ventilation s/r
exteriors/ cladding
exterior sheathing
interior finishes
EXTERIOR
INTERIOR
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
statement:
Current building envelope design is thermally inefficient, fractured into several layers. Perimeter heat gain/loss add significant loads to the mechanical system which must then be over-designed to compensate for this inefficiency. This increases the size/cost of the mechanical system and adds cost to the buildings operation and maintenance during its lifetime. A simpler, cheaper, and more thermally effective envelope may be obtained by combining the enclosure with a radiant heating system into a single layer, creating a heat exchange-relation between the envelope and the occupants. In order to test this hypothesis, the following process-design is used to measure the proposed assembly. By measuring its value within the domains of aesthetics, structural performance, mechanical performance, material cost and profit, one is able to obtain a qualitative and quantitative understanding of the many design permutations that the system can generate.
ventilation s/r
EXTERIOR
INTERIOR
summer
winter
water return
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
statement:
Current building envelope design is thermally inefficient, fractured into several layers. Perimeter heat gain/loss add significant loads to the mechanical system which must then be over-designed to compensate for this inefficiency. This increases the size/cost of the mechanical system and adds cost to the buildings operation and maintenance during its lifetime. A simpler, cheaper, and more thermally effective envelope may be obtained by combining the enclosure with a radiant heating system into a single layer, creating a heat exchange-relation between the envelope and the occupants. In order to test this hypothesis, the following process-design is used to measure the proposed assembly. By measuring its value within the domains of aesthetics, structural performance, mechanical performance, material cost and profit, one is able to obtain a qualitative and quantitative understanding of the many design permutations that the system can generate.
ventilation s/r
design scorecard:
EXTERIOR INTERIOR
aesthetics
summer
heat input
heat radiates from the warmer body to the cooler body
evaluation of system
winter
radiative heat transfer
material cost
water return
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
statement:
Current building envelope design is thermally inefficient, fractured into several layers. Perimeter heat gain/loss add significant loads to the mechanical system which must then be over-designed to compensate for this inefficiency. This increases the size/cost of the mechanical system and adds cost to the buildings operation and maintenance during its lifetime. A simpler, cheaper, and more thermally effective envelope may be obtained by combining the enclosure with a radiant heating system into a single layer, creating a heat exchange-relation between the envelope and the occupants.
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
EVALUATION
In order to test this hypothesis, the following process-design is used to measure the proposed assembly. By measuring its value within the domains of aesthetics, structural performance, mechanical performance, material cost and profit, one is able to obtain a qualitative and quantitative understanding of the many design permutations that the system can generate.
process design map version 3.0
DESIGN PERMUATATION SCORECARD
user inputs surface area required code + radiant heat info excel data geometric output design iterations output data to inform next iteration?
MATERIAL PROPERTIES
Summary
Issue: Building envelope design has a major impact on both heat loss in winter and solar gain in summer. Using the flexibility in current energy codes, designers can meet energy-efficiency requirements by trading off the efficiency of mechanical and lighting equipment against the thermal integrity of the envelope. Since the building envelope will be in use for a century or more, this trade-off is short-sighted. Recommendation: Establish fixed performance requirements for building envelopes with respect to heat loss, independent of mechanical and lighting equipment choices.
Summary
Issue: The Citys definition of floor area, which determines how large a building can be, includes exterior wall thickness. This penalizes thick, energy-efficient walls, and rewards poorly insulated thin-wall construction. Recommendation: For super-insulated walls, exclude up to eight inches of the exterior wall thickness from the floor area calculation.
DESIGN PERMUATATION
ENVIRONMENTAL INPUTS SYSTEM QUANTITATIVE OUTPUTS
output parameters surface area volume of concrete solid / void ratio square footage gained
URBAN GREEN
EF 3
output data to drive other elements? user design input parameters amount of heat to radiate geometric inputs evaluation metrics design scorecard material costs
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
00
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
Summary
Issue: Building envelope design has a major impact on both heat loss in winter and solar gain in summer. Using the flexibility in current energy codes, designers can meet energy-efficiency requirements by trading off the efficiency of mechanical and lighting equipment against the thermal integrity of the envelope. Since the building envelope will be in use for a century or more, this trade-off is short-sighted. Recommendation: Establish fixed performance requirements for building envelopes with respect to heat loss, independent of mechanical and lighting equipment choices.
UA =
the U-factor for each individual exterior building envelope component excluding the roof but including skylights (except those over semiheated spaces) multiplied by the total area of such component incorporated in the exterior building envelope. The U-factor for each component shall be calculated by taking into account thermal bridging at metal studs and members, shelf angles, floor edges, projecting balconies, window frames, and other components passing through the thermal barrier. U-factors can be determined using test results as required by this standard, tabulations provided by this standard, Standard NFRC-100-2004 methods, or two-dimensional or three-dimensional heat flow modeling, provided that three-dimensional heat flow modeling shall not be used to determine the U-value for standard wall-types listed in the above referenced tables. For residential construction with exposed slab edges, the following table must be used for U-factors.
URBAN GREEN
EF 3
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
erwin hauer
concept sketches
CATIA workshop
CATIA workshop
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
version 1.0
version 2.0
version 3.0
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
v50kb2543ActiveThermalEnvelopePC03
kb2543XshapeUDF06
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
window water chamber heidi werner - CBIP 2012 solar ivy ben brennan - CBIP 2012
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
window water chamber heidi werner - CBIP 2012 solar ivy ben brennan - CBIP 2012
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
01
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
EVALUATION
MATERIAL PROPERTIES
DESIGN PERMUATATION
ENVIRONMENTAL INPUTS SYSTEM QUANTITATIVE OUTPUTS
FINANCIAL INPUTS
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
horizontal opening ratio vertical opening ratio horizontal grid deformation vertical grid deformation deformation factor surface thickness projection from edge of slab material density specific heat Cp temp T1 temp T2 surface temp T3 surface temp T4
qualitative inputs
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface physical properties user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
total surface area (interior) radiating surface area (interior) total volume volume of radiating surface
quantitative inputs
mass of radiating surface heat input required to heat water radiant heat transfer (surface to body)
financial inputs
design scorecard
new rentable square footage added value of new rentable square footage
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
horizontal opening ratio vertical opening ratio horizontal grid deformation vertical grid deformation deformation factor surface thickness projection from edge of slab material density specific heat Cp temp T1 temp T2 surface temp T3 surface temp T4
qualitative inputs
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface physical properties user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
quantitative inputs
02a
financial inputs
design scorecard
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
horizontal opening ratio vertical opening ratio horizontal grid deformation vertical grid deformation deformation factor surface thickness projection from edge of slab material density specific heat Cp temp T1 temp T2 surface temp T3 surface temp T4
qualitative inputs
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface physical properties user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
quantitative inputs
02b
financial inputs
design scorecard
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
horizontal opening ratio vertical opening ratio horizontal grid deformation vertical grid deformation deformation factor surface thickness projection from edge of slab material density specific heat Cp temp T1 temp T2 surface temp T3 surface temp T4
qualitative inputs
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface physical properties user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
quantitative inputs
02c
financial inputs
design scorecard
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
horizontal opening ratio vertical opening ratio horizontal grid deformation vertical grid deformation deformation factor surface thickness projection from edge of slab material density specific heat Cp temp T1 temp T2 surface temp T3 surface temp T4
qualitative inputs
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface physical properties user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
quantitative inputs
02d
financial inputs
design scorecard
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
INPUTS
OUTPUTS
horizontal opening ratio vertical opening ratio horizontal grid deformation vertical grid deformation deformation factor surface thickness projection from edge of slab material density specific heat Cp temp T1 temp T2 surface temp T3 surface temp T4
qualitative inputs
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface physical properties user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
quantitative inputs
02e
financial inputs
design scorecard
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS
EVALUATION
design variations
UDF instantiation upon hosting surface user defined feature (UDF) system physical properties
total surface area (interior) radiating surface area (interior) total volume volume of radiating surface
mass of radiating surface design scorecard heat input required to heat water+ design radiant heat transfer (surface to body)
variations
03
design scorecard
new rentable square footage added value of new rentable square footage
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
scorecard diagram:
heat input benchmark 1 boiler horsepower BHP = 33,445.6 Btu or tbd by mechanical engineer aesthetics tbd by architect profit from new sf tbd by real estate input or tbd by owner
heat input
material cost
radiative heat transfer benchmark 28 btu/h/sf tbd by mechanical engineer structural performance benchmark 10 psf DL, 6 kip WL, typ. aluminum curtain wall typical DL + LL for cavity wall tbd by structural engineer material cost current cost per unit area for a given material glass fiber reinforced concrete or lightweight structural concrete size of circle magnitude relative to benchmark proximity to dominant domain describes influence of biased domain to peripheral domain (closer = stronger connection)
structural performance
biased domain takes the center marginalized domain moved to the periphery driven by dominant domain
aesthetics
material cost
heat input
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
aesthetics
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
aesthetics
71.9 % 421 16,850 44,013 lb 3,526 345 sf 52,376 btu 7.17 btu/hr/person
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
aesthetics
71.9 % 421 25,276 7,213 lb 578 345 sf 8,583 btu 7.17 btu/hr/person
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
aesthetics
67.9 % 304 18,289 8,057 lb 645 386 sf 9,588 btu 8.00 btu/hr/person
heat input
material cost
STRUCTURAL PERFORMANCE
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
aesthetics
71.9 % 304 18,289 7,051 lb 565 387 sf 7,390 btu 7.00 btu/hr/person
heat input
material cost
STRUCTURAL PERFORMANCE
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
aesthetics
23.9 % 421 25,276 19,565 lb 1,568 937 23,283 btu 19.44 btu/hr/person
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
38.9 % 214 12,845 47,488 lb 3,805 1,168 25,561 btu 24.22 btu/hr/person
AESTHETICS
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
63.8 % 214 12,845 28,138 lb 2,254 852 33,485 btu 17.67 btu/hr/person
AESTHETICS
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
76.8 % 214 12,845 18,041 lb 1,445 587 21,469 btu 12.18 btu/hr/person
AESTHETICS
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
OUTPUTS opening percentage new sf added value new sf added $ total wt. concrete total material cost $ emitting surface area required heat input radiation loss rate
54.1 % 304 18,289 17,358 lb 1,391 565 20,656 btu 11.72 btu/hr/person
AESTHETICS
heat input
material cost
structural performance
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012
KARL H. BENGZON COLUMBIA BUILDING INTELLIGENCE PROJECT INTEGRATED DESIGN STUDIO - COLUMBIA GSAPP SPRING 2012