Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Visions of Society
Four diverse perspectives on what accounts for social change and societal evolution
Gerhard Lenski
Society and technology
Karl Marx
Society in conflict
Max Weber
The power of ideas shapes society
Emile Durkheim
How traditional and modern societies hang together
Gerhard Lenski
Sociocultural evolutionThe changes that occur as a society gains new technology Societies range from simple to the technologically complex. Societies simple in technology tend to resemble one another. More technologically complex societies reveal striking cultural diversity.
Sociocultural Evolution
Technology shapes other cultural patterns. Simple technology can only support small numbers of people who live simple lives. The greater amount of technology a society has within its grasp, the faster cultural change will take place. High-tech societies are capable of sustaining large numbers of people who are engaged in a diverse division of labor.
Hunter-gatherers
Pygmies deep in the forests of the Democratic Republic of Congo still live in traditional mud houses but their life is changing.They say they are often the victims of discrimination by the local Bantu people, as their hunter-gatherer existence is swapped for employment as cheap labour. This village of Bakoyo, in the northern Equateur province (some 800km up the Congo River from the capital Kinshasa) has about 100 inhabitants, belonging to seven families.
No Census
Pygmies are believed to be the first inhabitants of the Congolese forests. Some estimates put their population at 30,000, others say it is more like 150,000. Noone knows the exact figures, as Pygmies have never taken part in a census. They cannot afford the hunting and fishing permits sometimes required by the local authority. But they still fish in a tributary of the Congo River and sell their
Husband Left
Mbayo Ekota (left) is in her thirties, although she doesnt know her exact age. She was married when she was about 15 years old, and she has four children: two boys aged nine and 12; a three-year-old daughter and a newborn baby. Two other babies have died. Mbayos husband has left home to look for employment in the neighboring small town of Boteka, so her brother, who lives in the next door hut, helps
Slaves
Mbayos day starts with a one-kilometre walk to fetch water at a nearby river.She then works to clear a field for 30 Congolese francs (7 US cents). Her children help out too, as there is not enough money to send them to school. For the same amount of work, other people would receive 11 cents. Mbayo says Pygmies are treated like "slaves".
Track Prey
These teenagers still use ancient techniques to go hunting. They use bows, arrows and machetes and are accompanied by a small dog to track the prey. Here, they caught a small forest antelope, but they do not get to taste the meat as it is sold for money. Nowadays, in this area, the Pygmies only get to eat fruits and manioc.
Hard Labor
Theophile Mpenza (right), who owns the field, says he uses Pygmy labour because it is cheap."Only Pygmies accept to do such hard work for this pay. The work is too difficult for any Bantu to accept." Because Pygmies have never taken part in any census they are not allowed to own land.
Dance
When Mbayo gets back home at the end of the afternoon, she cooks food and washes her children.In the evening, families meet up to discuss the daily problems and sometimes dance to the sound of drums.
Poor Health
This Pygmy community is poor and has no access to education and health care.The infant mortality rate is over 30% in the villages of this area and most parents cannot buy medicine. Pictures and words: Arnaud
In these societies the family and kinship group remain central. The family network grew larger and the concept of kin included dead ancestors. Economic consequences of secure food supply:
Food Surplus Permanent to semi-permanent specifically to the Horticultural societies. Involving in non food producing activities Lead to the emergence of trade Accumulation of private properties Generates greater social inequality. Practice of marriage for economic interest.
Political governance remains simple and power is usually exercised by clan leaders whose influence is based on greater wealth. There are also greater presence of warfare. Horticultural societies gave rise to ancestor worship while pastoral societies developed beliefs system based on Gods or God as a shepherd guiding is flock.
Developed about 5,000 years ago as plows or other energy sources (animal source) allowed for large scale food production. Direct Result of Food Productivity (Food Surplus)
Dramatic increase in population. The vast majority of population is composed of peasants, children working along side with adults in gender differentiated tasks. Increase the number of communities as well as the development of the first cities (Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, Greece and Rome).
The invention of money change the barter system. The notion of fair exchange during the part society was replaced by the notion of profits.
Artisan class Merchant class Mark the degradation of the status of women.
Families loses its significance as a distinct, political system. Politically, it marks the beginning of the structured organization called state.
Emergence of the governing class-decline of kinship ties Emergence of the military class. Gave rise to the first formal codes of law and the corresponding legal occupation
Proprietary theory of the State - Rulers of the agrarian societies do not manage their empire for the common good but as a piece of property they own and can do as they please. If agrarian societies are so unequal and exploitative, why do the people put with affairs of the state?
Developed in Europe 250 years ago (1750s in Great Britain) as energy was harnessed to drive machinery Fuel-powered machinery turned agrarian production to agribusiness. Emergence of the steel, automobile and textile industries. Cities contain most of the population. Reduces importance of traditional family. Distinct religious political, economic, educational arise.
Other causes:
Protestant rejection of the Churchs authority and hierarchy; Increase in literacy and standard of living which renders people more politically active and demanding;
Urbanization also makes people more politically sophisticated, as opposed to rural areas where people tend to lack such sophistication and tend to follow traditional authorities; The rise of the mass media (initially, in the form of cheap daily newspapers) which increased the general level of political awareness. Of course, the rise of the mass media also produced the first media mogul who could control how much and what kind of information people were exposed to.
Although religion remains a strong institution, several new secular ideologies emerge that challenge religious and supernatural worldviews:
Republicanism the rejection of the hereditary character of monarchies and of the proprietary view of the state; Capitalism the promotion of market economy as outlines by Adam Smiths An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, published in 1776;
Socialism in its democratic form, it promotes the reform of the economic system toward more equality; in its revolutionary form, promoted by Karl Marx, it promotes the overthrow of the capitalist system; Nationalism a view that shifts sources of loyalty and identity from the clan or the tribe to the larger nation; it is also referred to as patriotism; Pragmatism a philosophical view that is non-political and just prescribes that we do what works and reject what does not; Hedonism a view that emphasizes the pursuit of pleasure.
This decline in industrial economy is accompanied by the rise of a service economy, such as banking and financial services, law, education, and health care. In a service economy, people sell their knowledge and expertise to others. Computer technology becomes an essential component of practically every aspect of peoples lives and the social structure as a whole. Communication technologies, such as the World Wide Web, emails as well as satellite communications, have expanded dramatically, connecting people throughout the world and such technologies gave birth to the Global Village.
we now witness a global division of labor where different regions of the world engage in different forms of production (fruits from the Caribbean area, electronic manufacturing from Southeast Asia, etc Politically, we witness the decline of the nation-state and the rise of global institutions, such as the United Nations, the World Bank, and the World Trade Organization, and of a global civil society through multiple Non-governmental organizations such as Amnesty International or Greenpeace.
Karl Marx
Marx characterised human history in terms of the way in which ownership of the means of production was the most important single variable involved in the characterisation of each distinct period (or epoch) in history. He identified five major epochs:
Primitive communism - characteristic of early human history where people held everything in common. The Ancient epoch (slave society) - societies based upon slavery where the means of production was owned and controlled by an aristocratic elite. Feudal society - where land was the most important means of production. This was owned / controlled by an aristocratic class, the majority of people belonging to a peasant class (who had few, if any, political rights).
Capitalist society - where technological development (machinery etc.) has allowed a bourgeois class to exploit factory forms of production for their private gain. The aristocracy (landowners) have either been marginalized or co-opted into the Bourgeoisie while the majority of people are wage-labourers (they own little or no capital). The main relations of production in this epoch are between employers and employees (those who own and use capital and those who exchange their labour power for a wage). An employer does not own his / her employee in this society and various political freedoms and equalities are able to develop. He condemned capitalism for producing alienation Alienation from the act of working Alienation from the products of work Alienation from other workers Alienation from human potential
Communist society - where the means of production are held "in common" for the benefit of everyone in society (the dictatorship of the Proletariat). In this society class conflict is finally resolved and this represents the "end of history" since no further form of society can ever develop...
Max Weber
Weber took issue with the idea that economic relationships should be considered the most significant relationships in any society. In this respect, Weber rejected what he saw as the "crude economic determinism" of many of the Marxist writers whose work followed-on from the initial, pioneering, ideas and theories of Karl Marx. For Weber, questions concerning how order and change developed and managed were crucial to his sociological understanding. Weber argued for a multi-causal analysis of social change, for example, whereby any number of important variables could, in certain combinations, help to promote and manage social change. His analysis of the development of Capitalism and the role in this development of the Protestant religion
2 of types of society
Traditional Society people are guided by tradition (sentiments and beliefs passed from generation to generation). Rational Society people are guided by rationality (deliberate, matter-of-fact calculation of the most efficient means to accomplish a particular goal.
Examples are the industrial revolution and capitalism Capitalism is just a legacy of Calvinism Calvinist approached life in a highly disciplined and rational way. Central to this religion is the idea of predestination. Religious ethic vs. working ethic
Emile Durkheim
Social Solidarity - the feeling that we belong to a common society (that we have certain basic values in common with people). Solidarity is based upon such things as common culture, socialisation, basic values and norms, etc. b. Collective Conscience - the "external expression" of the collective will of people living in a society. This represents the social forces that help bind people together (to integrate them into the collective behaviour that is society). It can be likened to the "will" of society.
2 types of society
Preindustrial Society governed by mechanical Solidarity
It means social bonds, based on shared morality that unites members of the preindustrial society. It springs from likeness; that is tradition operates as the social cement that binds people together thus collective conscience is so strong that the community moves quickly to punish those who challenge conventional ways of life. Moral consensus