testimony Prof. (Dr.) Amool R. Singh Director, RINPAS cum Professor & Head Department of Clinical Psychology Ranchi Institute of Neuro-Psychiatry & Allied Sciences (RINPAS) Kanke, Ranchi - 834006
Eyewitness testimony plays an
important role within the criminal justice system. For example, the positive identification of suspect can provide major advances in an investigation.
The witnessed event:
There are various types of eye-witness variables affecting the identification: Stable characteristics of eye-witnesses (e.g., gender, personality) Malleable characteristics of eye-witnesses (e.g., whether the eye-witness was intoxicated at the crime or identification Eye-witness testimony (e.g., the diagnosticity of other testimony given by the eye-witness, such as confidence in the accuracy of identification)
Stable target (perpetrator) characteristics
(e.g., gender, attractiveness) Malleable target characteristics (e.g., disguises worn by the perpetrator) Eye-witness environment (e.g., lighting conditions, exposure duration) Post-event factors (e.g., the amount o time between the crime and identification and what occurs during the time)
Findings from various
studies: Witness factors: Research examining factors such as gender, race or intelligence, specific personality factors has not revealed any particular robust effects indicating that members of some groups are better witnesses than others.
The age of the witness has been has been
found associated with identification accuracy. When a culprit is not present in the lineup, both young children and elder witnesses are more likely than young adults to make a false identification of an innocent foil. Older eyewitnesses (e.g., 60 to 80 years) tend to make more false identification than younger adults. Blood alcohol level is also found associated with false identification.
Perpetrator factors: Facial
distinctiveness increases chance of identification. Disguise, belonging to different race, ethnic group etc. increases false identification. There is preferential processing mechanism for familiar stimuli.
Situational factors: Exposure duration,
distance (more than 15 meters), amount of stress or fear a witness may experience, Orienting response leads to enhanced memory for informative aspect of a scene but that the defensive response can lead to either enhanced memory of significant memory impairment depending on other cognitive and physiological factors.
Retention interval and false
memory: In the delay between an individual witnessing a crime and making an identification attempt, the witnesss memory is not only prone to decay, nut it is also vulnerable to the influence of post-event information form various sources. It is related to recall completeness and accuracy.
Delay systematically decreases the
amount of information that can be recalled. There is a decline in the correct identification of previously seem faces after a delay. A decrease in correct identification and an increase in false alarms over various intervals up to three weeks.
Misinformation effect is a powerful
phenomenon resulting in memory distortions. Co-witness also influence memory. The difference between two individuals recalling the incidence may be due to various reasons including naturally occurring differences in attention paid to various details of the event, difference in temporal and spatial location and difference in ability to recall those details.
False memory refers to development
of a memory for an entirely new event that never occurred. False memory can be created because memory is (re)constructed. While false memory and suggestibility clearly involve distortions of memory, social factors may also play a role in encouraging false reports.
Witnesses may generally be more susceptible
to post-event information generated by the police officer than when generated by a member of the public. Witnesses may be susceptible to cues. These may influence memory more if the actual memory for the event is poor. Therefore, interviewer should approach with an open mind and seek collaborative evidences to support witnesses claim wherever possible.