Electronic Band Structure of

Solids
Introduction to Solid State Physics
http://www.physics.udel.edu/~bnikolic/teaching/phys624/phys624.html

What are quantum numbers?

Quantum numbers label eigenenergies and eigenfunctions of a Hamiltonian

Sommerfeld:
Bloch:
and

k -vector ( hk

is momentum)

k -vector ( hk is the crystal momentum)

(the band index).

The Crystal Momentum is not the Momentum of a Bloch electron: the rate of change of an
electron momentum is given by the total forces on the electron, but the rate of change of
electronic crystal momentum is:

dr
1 n (k )
v n (k ) nk v nk
;
dt
h k

d hk
e E(r, t ) v n (k ) B(r, t )
dt

where forces are exerted only by the external fields, and not by the periodic field of the lattice.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

Semiclassical dynamics of Bloch electrons

Bloch states have the property that their expectation values of r and k , follow
classical dynamics. The only change is that now n (k ) (band structure) must be
used:
e

H classical n hk eA (r ) e (r )

B L k

2m
dp d ( hk )
H dr
H

,
v

dt
dt
r dt
p
p

A perfectly periodic ionic arrangement has zero resistance. Resistivity comes from
imperfections (example: a barrier induces a reflected and transmitted Bloch wave),
which control the mean-free path. This can be much larger than the lattice spacing.
A fully occupied band does not contribute to the current since the electrons cannot be
promoted to other empty states with higher k . The current is induced by
rearrangement of states near the Fermi energy in a partially occupied band.
Limits of validity:

n const (no interband transitions)

2
2
gap
(k )
gap
(k )
eB
eEa =
, hc
=
, gap (k ) n (k ) n (k )
F
m
F
h = gap , ? a

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

What is the range of quantum numbers?

k

Sommerfeld:
runs through all of
k-space consistent with the Born-von
Karman periodic boundary
conditions:
( x L, y , z ) ( x , y , z )
2

( x L, y , z ) ( x , y L , z ) k
nx , n y , nz nx , n y , nz 0, 1, 2, K

( x, y , z ) ( x , y , z L )
( x L, y , z ) ( x, y , z ) 0

( x L, y, z ) ( x, y L, z ) 0 k nx , n y , nz nx , n y , nz 1, 2, K
L
( x, y, z ) ( x, y, z L) 0
Bloch: For each n, k runs through all wave vectors in a single
primitive cell of the reciprocal lattice consistent with the Bornvon Karman periodic boundary conditions; n runs through an
infinite set of discrete values.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

What are the energy levels?

Sommerfeld:

hk
(k )
2m

Bloch: For a given band index n, n (k ) has

no simple explicit form. The only general
property is periodicity in the reciprocal space:

n (k G ) n (k )
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

What is the velocity of electron?

Sommerfeld: The mean velocity of an electron in a
level with wave vector
is:

hk 1
v

m
h k

Bloch: The mean velocity of an electron in a level with

band index
and wave vector
is:

Conductivity of a perfect crystal:

1 n (k )
v n (k )
h k

NOTE: Quantum mechanical definition of a mean velocity

v v

h
dr (r ) mi (r )
*

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

What is the Wave function

Sommerfeld: The wave function of an electron with
wave vector
is:
ikr
k

1
(r )
e
V

Bloch: The wave function of an electron with band index

and wave vector
is:

k (r ) e nk (r )
ikr

where the function nk ( r ) has no simple explicit form. The

only general property is its periodicity in the direct lattice
(i.e., real space): nk (r R ) nk (r )
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

Sommerfeld vs. Bloch: Density of States

Sommerfeld Bloch

D( )

dk (k ) D( )
dk (k )

2
2
d

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

n B.Z .

Bloch: van Hove singularities in the

DOS
D( )

d k (k )
n

n B.Z .

D( )d

dS
n dk (k )
k n
Sn ( E )
1

dS k

2
d

d k n (kk
)

k kn ( ) k

D( )

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

Bloch: van Hove singularities in the

DOS of Tight-Binding Hamiltonian

n (k ) 2t cos(k x a) cos( k y a) cos(k z a) k n (k ) 2ta sin(k x a) sin(k y a) sin( k z a)

k (0, 0, 0) max

k n (k ) 0 for k , , min
a
a
a

0 , 0, 0, saddle
k , 0, 0 , 0, ,
a
a

a

1D

3D
Local DOS: (r, ) ( r ) ( )
2

DOS: D( ) dr (r, )
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

10

Sommerfeld vs. Bloch: Fermi surface

Fermi energy F (T 0) represents the sharp occupancy
cut-off at T=0 for particles described by the Fermi-Dirac statitics.
Fermi surface is the locus of points in reciprocal space where

F
k F

(k ) F

No Fermi surface for insulators!

kF

Points of Fermi
Surface in 1D
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

11

Sommerfeld vs. Bloch: Fermi surface in 3D

Sommerfeld: Fermi Sphere
Bloch: Sometimes sphere, but more likely anything else

For each partially filled band there will be a surface reciprocal space separating occupied
from the unoccupied levels the set of all such surfaces is known as the Fermi surface
and represents the generalization to Bloch electrons of the free electron Fermi sphere.
The parts of the Fermi surface arising from individual partially filled bands are branches of
kvariable.
n (k ) F in
the Fermi surface: for each n solve the equation

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

12

Is there a Fermi energy of intrinsic Semiconductors?

If F is defined as the energy separating the
highest occupied from the lowest unoccupied
level, then it is not uniquely specified in a solid
with an energy gap, since any energy in the gap
meets this test.
People nevertheless speak of the Fermi energy
on an intrinsic semiconductor. What they mean is
the chemical potential, which is well defined at any
non-zero temperature. As T 0 , the chemical
potential of a solid with an energy gap approaches
the energy of the middle of the gap and one
sometimes finds it asserted that this is the Fermi
energy. With either the correct of colloquial
definition, n (k ) F does not have a solution in a
solid with a gap, which therefore has no Fermi
surface!
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

13

DOS of real materials: Silicon, Aluminum, Silver

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

14

Colloquial Semiconductor Terminology in Pictures

PURE

DOPPED
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

15

Measuring DOS: Photoemission

spectroscopy

Fermi Golden Rule: Probability per

unit time of an electron being ejected
is proportional to the DOS of occupied
electronic states times the probability
(Fermi function) that the state is
occupied:
1

I ( kin )

( kin )

D( bin ) f ( bin ) D( kin h ) f ( kin h )

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

16

Measuring DOS: Photoemission

spectroscopy

Once the background is subtracted

off, the subtracted data is proportional
to electronic density of states
convolved with a Fermi functions.
We can also learn about DOS above the Fermi
surface using Inverse Photoemission where electron
beam is focused on the surface and the outgoing flux
of photons is measured.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

17

Fourier analysis of systems living on

periodic lattice

f (r ) f (r R ) f (r ) f G eiGr
G
1
iGr
iGr
fG
d
r
e
f
(
r
);
e
dr 0

V pcell pcell
pcell

(k ) (k G ) (k ) R eiRk
R
dk
iRk
R V pcell
e
(k )
3
BZ 2
Born-von Karman:

f (r ) f k e
k

ikR

ikr

,k
i 1

N k ,0

e
k

ikR

mi
bi ;
Ni

N R ,0

fk

f (r ) f (r N i ai )
1

Vcrystal

na , 0 n
i 1

dr e ikr f (r );

crystal

eikr dr 0

crystal

N i , N N1 N 2 N 3 ; k BZ

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

18

Fouirer analysis of Schrdinger equation

U (r ) U (r R ) U (r ) U G eiGr , G R 2 m

h
2

H (r )
U (r ) (r ) (r ), (r ) Ck eikr
k
2m

h2 k 2
ikr
i ( k +G)r
ikr
C
e

C
U
e

C
e

k
k G
k
2m
k
k G
k
2 2

h
k
ikr
k k G : e
Ck U G Ck-G 0, for all r
k
G
2m

h2 k 2
Ck U G Ck-G 0, for all k k (k )

G
2m

Potential acts to couple Ckwith its reciprocal space translation Ck G

and the
problem decouples into N independent problems for each k within the first BZ.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

19

Fourier analysis, Bloch theorem, and

its corollaries
k (r ) Ck G e
G

i ( k G ) r

Ck G e e
G4 4 7 4 48

6
(r ) (r R )
iGr

ikr

H k G (r ) (k G ) k G (r )
1. k G (r ) k (r )
H k (r ) (k G ) k (r ) (k ) (k G )

h2
2
2.
ik U (r) nk (r) n (k )nk (r)
2m

h2

2
3.
ik U (r) n,k (r) n (k )n,k (r)
2m

Each zone n is indexed by a

vector and, therefore, has as
many energy levels as there
are distinct k vector values
within the Brillouin zone, i.e.:

4. n*,k (r ) n , k (r ) , n (k ) n ( k ) (Kramers theorem)

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

N N1 N 2 N 3
20

Free Bloch electrons?

Really free electrons Sommerfeld
degenerate eigenvalues.

h2 k 2
continuous spectrum with infinitely
n (k )
2m

n (k )= n (k + G ) does not mean that two electrons with wave vectors k and k G
nof(k )
have the same energy, but that any reciprocal lattice point can serve as the origin
.

In the case of an infinitesimally

small periodic potential there is
periodicity, but not a real
potential. The n (k ) function than
is practically the same as in the
case of free electrons, but
starting at every point in
reciprocal space.
Bloch electrons in the limit

U 0

: electron moving through an empty lattice!

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

21

Schrdinger equation for free Bloch

electrons
h

2
0
2m ik (k )

Counting of Quantum States:

2
h
2
0
0
k G
k (r ) 0 (k )
2m
1 iGr
0
k (r )
e
V

Extended Zone Scheme: FixG (i.e., the BZ) and then count
region corresponding to that zone.
Reduced Zone Scheme: Fix
equivalent states in all BZ.

vectors within the

in any zone and then, by changing

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

, count all

22

Free Bloch electrons at BZ boundary

: eiGx / 2 e iGx / 2 : cos

x
a

: eiGx / 2 e iGx / 2 : sin

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

x
a
23

Free Bloch electrons at BZ boundary

Second order perturbation theory, in crystalline potential, for the reduced
2
zone scheme:

k (G ) (G ) G k U G k
0
k

r G k (r )e
0
nk

ikr

Hk U G k

k0 (G ) k0 (H )

... O(U 3 )

1 i ( G k)r

e
V

1
i ( H+G+G )
G k U H k U G e
dr U G G,G-H U G-H
V G
G
1
G k U H k U (r )dr
2
V
U G
second order correction 0
0

(
G
)

G k
k (G + G )
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

24

Free Bloch electrons at BZ boundary

For perturbation theory to work, matrix elements of crystal potential have to
be smaller than the level spacing of unperturbed electron Does not hold at
the BZ boundary!
2
2

h 2
h
2
2

(G 0) (G )
k G + k G 2G k

2m
2m
0
k

0
k

0 at BZ boundary Laue diffraction!

eikr ei (G+k)r

G 0

1 0
(k ) G 0 (k ) G0 (k )
2

0
G 0

(k ) (k ) 4 U G

0
G

'
'
G'
G
G
k G 0 (k ) G0 0 (k ) U G ; G 0 (k ) G0 0 (k ) U G
2
2
2

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

25

Extended vs. Reduced vs. Repeated

Zone Scheme

In 1D model, there is always a gap at the Brillouin zone boundaries, even for an
arbitrarily weak potential.
In higher dimension, where the Brillouin zone boundary is a line (in 2D) or a surface
(in 3D), rather than just two points as here, appearance of an energy gap depends on
the strength of the periodic potential compared with the width of the unperturbed band.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

26

Fermi surface in 2D for free Sommerfeld electrons

2

S BZ
S state

4 2
2
2
b
, Scell a 2

S cell
a

S BZ
4 2
2 2

, N N1 N 2
2 N 2 NS cell Scrystall

S Fermi N e S state

2 2 S BZ
2
kF
a
2

S Fermi 2 N e S state S BZ k F 1.128

S Fermi zN e S state

Sb

0.798
2
a

S BZ
z
, for crystal with z-valence atoms
2

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

27

Fermi surface in 2D for free Bloch electrons

There are empty states in the first BZ and occupied
states in the second BZ.
This is a general feature in 2D and 3D: Because of
the band overlap, solid can be metallic even when if
it has two electrons per unit cell.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

28

Fermi surface is orthogonal to the BZ boundary

(k )

(k ) (k G )

2
0

k (k )

0 (k ) 0 (k G)
4

1
2

1
2 k 0 (k ) k 0 (k G) 2

UG

(k ) 0 (k G ) k 0 (k ) k 0 (k G )

0 (k ) 0 (k G)
4

UG

at the BZ boundary : 0 (k ) 0 (k G)
h2
h2 k
k (k ) k + k + G + G G 0
2m
m 2

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

29

Tight-binding approximation
Tight Binding approach is completely opposite to free Bloch electron: Ignore core
electron dynamics and treat only valence orbitals localized in ionic core potential.

There is another way to generate band gaps in the electronic DOS they naturally
emerge when perturbing around the atomic limit. As we bring more atoms together
or bring the atoms in the lattice closer together, bands form from mixing of the orbital
states. If the band broadening is small enough, gaps remain between the bands.
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

30

Constructing Bloch functions from

atomic orbitals

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

31

From localized orbitals to wave functions overlap

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

32

Tight-binding method for single s-band

Tight Binding approach is completely opposite to free Bloch electron: Ignore core
electron dynamics and treat only valence orbitals localized in ionic core potential.

Notation: x i ( x R i )
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

33

One-dimensional case
Assuming that only nearest neighbor orbitals overlap:

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

34

One-dimensional examples:
s-orbital band vs. p-orbital band
tp 0

ts 0

ts t p
kl ( x)

ikx
e
l x na

Re kl ( x)
bandwidth: W 4dtl 2 ztl
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

35

Wannier Functions
It would be advantageous to have at our disposal localized wave functions with vanishing
overlap i j ij : Construct Wannier functions as a Fourier transform of Bloch wave
functions!

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

36

Wannier functions as orthormal basis set

Ri a

Ri a

1D example: decay as power law,

so it is not completely localized!

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

37

Band theory of Graphite and Carbon Nanotubes

(works also for MgB2 ): Application of TBH method
Graphite is a 2D network made of 3D carbon
atoms. It is very stable material (highest melting
temperature known, more stable than diamond).
It peels easily in layers (remember pencils?).
A single free standing layer would be hard to
peel off, but if it could be done, no doubt it would
be quite stable except at the edges carbon
nanotubes are just this, layers of graphite which
solve the edge problem by curling into closed
cylinders.
CNT come in single-walled and multi-walled
forms, with quantized circumference of many
sizes, and with quantized helical pitch of many
types.
Lattice structure of graphite layer: There are two carbon
r atoms per cell,
designated as the A and B sublattices. The vector connects the two
sublattices and is not a translation vector. Primitive translation vectors are
.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

r r
a, b
38

2
sp
Chemistry of Graphite:
hybridization, covalent

bonds, and all of that

1 A, B
2 A, B
s
px
3
3
1 A, B 1 A , B 1 A , B

s m px
py
3
6
2
1 A, B 1 A, B 1 A, B

s
px
py
3
6
2
4A, B pzA, B

1A, B

2A, B
3A, B

b ( onding )
i

1 A
1 A
B
a ( ntibonding )
i i , i
i iB
2
2

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

39

Truncating the basis to a single orbital per atom

s
p ,p

The atomic
orbitals as well as the
atomic carbon x y functions form strong
bonding orbitals which are doubly occupied
and lie below the Fermi energy. They also
form strongly antibonding orbitals which are
high up and empty.
This leaves space on energy axis near the
Fermi level for
orbitals (they point
perpendicular to the direction of the bond
between them)

The
orbitals form two bands, one
bonding band lower in energy which is
doubly occupied, and one antibonding band
higher in energy which is unoccupied.
These two bands are not separated by a
gap, but have tendency to overlap by a
small amount leading to a semimetal.

Eigenstates of translation operator:

kA

1
N

ikm
e
A (r m)
m

1
ikm
kB
e
B (r m)

N m
B (r ) A (r )
Bloch eigenstates:

kn kA kB

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

1
40

Diagonalize 2 x 2 Hamiltonian
kA H kA
kA H kB
H (k )

kB H kA

kB H kB

1
kA H kA eik ( m-m) dr A (r m) H A (r m )
N mm
kB H kB drB (r ) H B (r ) kA H kA dr A (r ) H A (r )
kA H kB dr A (r ) H B (r ) e ika dr A (r ) H B (r a) e ikb dr A (r ) H B (r b)

t
(k ) t 1 e ika e ikb
(k ) t 3 2 cos(ka) 2 cos(kb) 2 cos(k (a b))
PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

1/ 2

41

Band structure plotting: Irreducible BZ

(r ) R | Ta (r ) ( R | Ta
n
Rk

n
k

n
k

R | Ta r Rr a, R | Ta

r ) kn ( R 1r R 1a)

R | R a

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

42

Graphite band structure in pictures

(k )

Plot
for some special directions in reciprocal space: there are three
directions of special symmetry which outline the irreducible wedge of the Brillouin
zone. Any other point
of the zone which is not in this wedge can be rotated into a
k-vector inside the wedge by a symmetry operation that leaves the crystal invariant.

along : (k ) t 5 4 cos 2

1/ 2

0 1

middle section : (k ) t 3 4 cos 2 / 3 2 cos 4 / 3

along : (k ) t 3 2 cos 4 / 3 4 cos 2 / 3

1/ 2

1/ 2

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

43

Graphite band structure in pictures:

Pseudo-Potential Plane Wave Method

Electronic Charge Density:

In the plane of atoms

In the plane
perpendicular to atoms

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

44

Diamond vs. Graphite: Insulator vs. Semimetal

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

45

Carbon Nanotubes

Mechanics: Tubes as ultimate fibers.

Electronics: Tubes as quantum wires.
Capillary: Tubes as nanocontainers.

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

46

From graphite sheets to CNT

C-C distance: a 1.421 A
1 3
primitive vectors: a1 (1,0) a2 ,
2 2
chiral vector: ch n1a1 n2a 2
circumference: L a 3(n12 n1n2 n22 )
d is highest common divisor of (2n1 n2 , 2n2 n1 )
translation vector of 1D unit cell along the axis: R t1a1 t2a 2
3L
d
4(n12 n1n2 n22 )
number of atoms per unit cell: N
d
modulues of translation vector: R
Single-wall CNT consists of rolling the
honeycomb sheet of carbon atoms into
a cylinder whose chirality and the fiber
diameter are uniquely specified by the
vector:
h
1 1
2 2

c na n a

chiral angle: arctan

3n2
2n1 n2

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

47

Metallic vs. Semiconductor CNT

The 1D band on CNT is obtained by slicing
the 2D energy dispersion relation of the
graphite sheet with the periodic boundary
conditions:

chk 2 m c h K 2 m 2n1 n2 3m
Conclusion:
The armchair CNT n1 n2 are metallic
The chiral CNT with 2n1 n2 3m
are moderate band-gap semiconductors.

Metallic 1D energy bands are generally unstable under a Peierls distortion

CNT are exception since their tubular structure impedes this effects making their
metallic properties at the level of a single molecule rather unique!

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

48

CNT Band structure

PHYS 624: Electronic Band Structure of Solids

49